All True Fact

Claims › immigration-is-good-for-a-country-b5517f26 not on the published list

Immigration is good for a country.

Refused (values claim)

no empirical leaf in decomposition: the claim is a values question and cannot be scored

No retrieval and no judgment calls were made. This refusal is the published result: the engine will not smuggle a preference into a number and call it evidence.

Profile public · rubric 1.2.0 · parameters locked-2026-09-17 · tree by model:deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813:decompose_v1 · scored 2026-09-19 · live spend on this run $0.00 (cache hits are free) · download the dataset (JSON)

Decomposition

The claim as a tree of checkable parts. AND nodes multiply their children's probabilities, OR nodes combine them noisy-or. Parts tagged as values are excluded from scoring and shown as excluded.

NodeText
root leaf · values Immigration is good for a country.
Excluded: This is a value judgment because 'good for a country' depends on contested normative criteria and no measurable outcome, time, or place is specified.