{ "schema_version": "1.5.0", "rubric_version": "1.2.0", "params": { "prior": 0.5, "scale": 2.0, "quality_exp": 1.0, "directness_exp": 1.0, "independence_discount": 0.5, "basis_weights": [ 1.0, 0.7, 0.4 ], "contested_pull": 1.0, "mixed_directness_min": 0.5, "side_mass_min": 0.5, "cluster_roots": "primary", "mass_min": 1.0, "verdict_thresholds": [ 0.15, 0.35, 0.65, 0.85 ], "and_leak": 0.0, "or_leak": 0.0, "max_pool_size": 25, "polarity_sample": 0.2, "queries_per_side": 2, "results_per_query": 10, "excerpt_chars": 2000, "strictness": 0.5 }, "profile": "public", "claim": { "slug": "iraq-wmd-2003", "text": "Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction in March 2003, and that justified the invasion.", "submitted_text": "Saddam had WMDs in 2003 so the war was justified", "paraphrased": true, "topic": "Iraq's weapons programmes and stockpiles, 2002-2004", "created_at": "2026-09-15T00:00:00Z" }, "tree": { "id": "root", "kind": "and", "tag": "empirical", "text": "Iraq possessed WMD in March 2003 and this justified the invasion", "reason": null, "children": [ { "id": "wmd", "kind": "or", "tag": "empirical", "text": "Iraq held usable WMD stockpiles or ran an active WMD production program in March 2003", "reason": null, "children": [ { "id": "chem", "kind": "leaf", "tag": "empirical", "text": "Iraq held militarily significant stockpiles of chemical weapons in March 2003", "reason": null, "children": [] }, { "id": "bio", "kind": "leaf", "tag": "empirical", "text": "Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active biological weapons production program in March 2003", "reason": null, "children": [] }, { "id": "nuke", "kind": "leaf", "tag": "empirical", "text": "Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003", "reason": null, "children": [] } ] }, { "id": "justified", "kind": "leaf", "tag": "values", "text": "The invasion was justified", "reason": "Whether WMD possession would justify military action is a normative question. Excluded from scoring and shown as excluded.", "children": [] } ] }, "decomposed_by": "hand", "retrieval": { "search_backend": "google+ddg", "items_by_backend": { "ddg+google": 13, "google": 19, "ddg": 23 }, "pdf_pages_fetched_ok": 12, "queries_prompt_version": "queries_v1", "results_per_query": 10, "max_pool_size": 25, "excerpt_chars": 2000, "unique_urls": 146, "search_api_calls": 0, "live_fetches": 0, "fetch_errors": { "too little text": 21, "HTTP 403": 10, "HTTP 406": 2, "body too large": 1, "HTTP 400": 2, "ReadTimeout": 3, "ConnectError": 2 }, "leaves": { "chem": { "queries": { "for": [ "Iraq chemical weapons stockpiles found 2003 ISG report", "declassified intelligence Iraq WMD stockpiles March 2003" ], "against": [ "Iraq Survey Group final report no WMD stockpiles", "UNMOVIC inspections Iraq chemical weapons 2002 2003 findings" ] }, "search_hits": 70, "candidates": 58, "fetched_ok": 47, "pool": 25 }, "bio": { "queries": { "for": [ "Iraq biological weapons stockpiles intelligence assessments March 2003", "Iraq mobile biological weapons laboratories evidence Powell UN 2003" ], "against": [ "Iraq Survey Group final report no biological weapons stockpiles", "UNMOVIC inspections Iraq 2003 found no biological weapons production" ] }, "search_hits": 74, "candidates": 64, "fetched_ok": 50, "pool": 25 }, "nuke": { "queries": { "for": [ "Colin Powell UN speech Iraq nuclear weapons program evidence", "CIA white paper Iraq reconstituted nuclear program October 2002" ], "against": [ "IAEA Hans Blix report March 2003 Iraq nuclear no evidence", "Iraq Survey Group final report nuclear program 2004" ] }, "search_hits": 66, "candidates": 65, "fetched_ok": 49, "pool": 25 } }, "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "api_calls": 0, "cache_hits": 3, "cost_usd": 0.0 }, "roots": { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "prompt_version": "roots_v1", "canon_prompt_version": "roots_canon_v1", "distinct_root_ids": 84, "groups": [ [ "charles duelfel", "charles duelfers" ], [ "colin powell un presentation 2003", "colin powell un presentation february 2003", "colin powell un security council presentation february 2003", "powell presentation february 2003", "powell un security council 2003", "powell un speech 2003" ], [ "cia", "cia announcement january 2004", "cia paper april 3 2003", "cia white paper iraqs weapons of mass destruction" ], [ "iraq survey group", "iraq survey group final report", "iraq survey group interim report 2003" ], [ "un security council", "united nations security council" ], [ "un security council resolution 1441", "united nations security council resolution 1441" ], [ "un security council resolution 687", "united nations security council resolution 687" ], [ "unmovic", "unmovic 12th quarterly report", "unmovic march 2003 report" ], [ "us department of state february 2003", "us state department 2003" ], [ "us intelligence community", "intelligence community" ], [ "curveball", "iraqi defector curveball" ], [ "david kay", "david kay new york times interview 2004", "david kay senate testimony 2004", "david kay statements 2004" ], [ "senate armed services committee 2004", "senate armed services committee hearing 2004" ], [ "united nations", "un news" ], [ "bush administration", "bush administration statements" ] ], "aliases": { "charles duelfel": "charles duelfel", "charles duelfers": "charles duelfel", "colin powell un presentation 2003": "colin powell un presentation 2003", "colin powell un presentation february 2003": "colin powell un presentation 2003", "colin powell un security council presentation february 2003": "colin powell un presentation 2003", "powell presentation february 2003": "colin powell un presentation 2003", "powell un security council 2003": "colin powell un presentation 2003", "powell un speech 2003": "colin powell un presentation 2003", "cia": "cia", "cia announcement january 2004": "cia", "cia paper april 3 2003": "cia", "cia white paper iraqs weapons of mass destruction": "cia", "iraq survey group": "iraq survey group", "iraq survey group final report": "iraq survey group", "iraq survey group interim report 2003": "iraq survey group", "un security council": "un security council", "united nations security council": "un security council", "un security council resolution 1441": "un security council resolution 1441", "united nations security council resolution 1441": "un security council resolution 1441", "un security council resolution 687": "un security council resolution 687", "united nations security council resolution 687": "un security council resolution 687", "unmovic": "unmovic", "unmovic 12th quarterly report": "unmovic", "unmovic march 2003 report": "unmovic", "us department of state february 2003": "us state department 2003", "us state department 2003": "us state department 2003", "us intelligence community": "intelligence community", "intelligence community": "intelligence community", "curveball": "curveball", "iraqi defector curveball": "curveball", "david kay": "david kay", "david kay new york times interview 2004": "david kay", "david kay senate testimony 2004": "david kay", "david kay statements 2004": "david kay", "senate armed services committee 2004": "senate armed services committee 2004", "senate armed services committee hearing 2004": "senate armed services committee 2004", "united nations": "un news", "un news": "un news", "bush administration": "bush administration", "bush administration statements": "bush administration" }, "items_failed": 0, "api_calls": 1, "cache_hits": 55, "cost_usd": 0.002115 }, "judging": { "retrieval_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "per_model": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": { "api_calls": 215, "cache_hits": 0, "cost_usd": 0.269082, "cache_lookups": 215 }, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": { "api_calls": 215, "cache_hits": 0, "cost_usd": 0.184558, "cache_lookups": 215 }, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": { "api_calls": 215, "cache_hits": 0, "cost_usd": 0.079112, "cache_lookups": 215 }, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": { "api_calls": 215, "cache_hits": 0, "cost_usd": 0.20274, "cache_lookups": 215 }, "x-ai/grok-4.3": { "api_calls": 215, "cache_hits": 0, "cost_usd": 0.517363, "cache_lookups": 215 } }, "api_calls": 1075, "cache_hits": 0, "cache_lookups": 1134, "spent_usd": 1.252856, "budget_usd": 5.0, "budget_exceeded": false, "stopped_reason": null, "failed": [], "baseline_cost_usd": 0.005202, "rescored_to_rubric": "1.2.0", "rescored_from": "2026-09-17T02:22:44.559681+00:00" }, "pool": [ { "id": "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "url": "https://cen.acs.org/articles/82/i43/ASSESSING-IRAQS-WEAPONS.html", "title": "Assessing Iraq's Weapons", "publisher": "Chemical & Engineering News", "published_at": "2014-09-16", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:22.513930Z", "excerpt": "In the months leading up to the March 2003 invasion of Iraq, President George W. Bush and his top officials issued a litany of serious allegations about Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction (WMD) and the threat they posed to the U.S. But their prime rationale for going to war has been severely undermined by the report of the Iraq Survey Group, headed by former United Nations inspector Charles A. Duelfer.\nDuelfer’s report confirms that UN sanctions and inspections put in place after the first Gulf War in 1991, plus U.S.-U.K. enforced “no-fly zones,” had effectively contained Saddam Hussein’s capability to revive his weapons programs. Indeed, Duelfer found that Hussein’s weapons programs and knowledge base, far from being a threat to the U.S., had deteriorated and were smaller when the war began than in 1998 when UN inspectors left Iraq. Additionally, the report depicts Hussein’s interest in WMD as being driven more by his concerns about Iran and Israel than the U.S.\nIn his appearance before the Senate Armed Services Committee, Duelfer explained that his data-laden report aims “to identify the dynamics of the regime’s WMD decisions over time.” Hussein “committed the brightest minds and much national treasure to developing weapons of mass destruction [because he] saw this investment as having paid vital dividends,” Duelfer said.\nDuelfer went on to say that after nearly 16 months of searching, the survey group found no evidence that Iraq had arsenals of WMD or active programs to produce them before the 2003 invasion. In fact, Duelfer said, Iraq had destroyed its stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons in the early 1990s, and had made no attempt to restart its nuclear weapons program after the first Gulf War in 1991.\nAdditionally, the survey group found no evidence that, after 1995, Iraq had plans to resume biological weapons (BW) production or to research new bioweapons for military purposes. And the report strongly undermines the Administration’s charge that prewar", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "url": "https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna7634313", "title": "CIA’s final report: No WMD found in Iraq", "publisher": "NBC News", "published_at": "2005-04-25", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:42.634095Z", "excerpt": "In his final word, the CIA’s top weapons inspector in Iraq said Monday that the hunt for weapons of mass destruction has “gone as far as feasible” and has found nothing, closing an investigation into the purported programs of Saddam Hussein that were used to justify the 2003 invasion.\n“After more than 18 months, the WMD investigation and debriefing of the WMD-related detainees has been exhausted,” wrote Charles Duelfer, head of the Iraq Survey Group, in an addendum to the final report he issued last fall.\n“As matters now stand, the WMD investigation has gone as far as feasible.”\nIn 92 pages posted online Monday evening, Duelfer provides a final look at an investigation that occupied over 1,000 military and civilian translators, weapons specialists and other experts at its peak. His latest addenda conclude a roughly 1,500-page report released last fall.\nOn Monday, Duelfer said there is no purpose in keeping many of the detainees who are in custody because of their knowledge on Iraq’s weapons, although he did not provide any details about the current number. A U.S. official, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the ultimate decision on their release will be made by the Iraqi authorities.\nWarnings about Saddam’s experts\nThe survey group also provided warnings.\nThe addenda conclude that Saddam’s programs created a pool of experts now available to develop and produce weapons and many will be seeking work. While most will probably turn to the “benign civil sector,” the danger remains that “hostile foreign governments, terrorists or insurgents may seek Iraqi expertise.”\n“Because a single individual can advance certain WMD activities, it remains an important concern,” one addendum said.\nAnother addendum also noted that military forces in Iraq may continue to find small numbers of degraded chemical weapons — most likely misplaced or improperly destroyed before the 1991 Gulf War. In an insurgent’s hands, “the use of a single even ineffectual chemical weapon would likely ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "url": "https://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/library/report/2004/isg-final-report/isg-final-report_vol1_scope-note.htm", "title": "Iraq Survey Group Final Report", "publisher": "globalsecurity.org", "published_at": "2026-01-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:07.436189Z", "excerpt": "Iraq Survey Group Final Report\nScope Note\n \n This report relays Iraq Survey Group’s findings from its creation in June 2003 until September 2004 and provides context and analysis to ISG’s physical findings. It also attempts to place the events in their Political-Military context. For the purposes of this report, the term Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMD) refers to the definition established by the United Nations Security Council in the context of UN Security Council Resolution 687 (1991).\nThe United States’ investigation of Iraqi WMD activities began during Operation Iraqi Freedom itself. In prewar planning, it was assumed chemical and possibly biological stocks were likely to be encountered and perhaps employed. Forces were equipped with protective equipment. A military unit designated Expeditionary Task Force-75 (XTF-75) was deployed during the war to investigate suspected locations for WMD stocks. Many sites were inspected but with an aim of discovering WMD, not inspecting and developing an analytical assessment of the Iraqi programs. Wartime conditions prevailed with concern about force protection primary. The work of XTF-75 was therefore aimed at discovery of possible WMD locations (to eliminate a threat), not the compilation of evidence to build a picture of what happened to the weapons and programs.\nThis early approach, perhaps logical if the goal was simply to find hidden weapons, undermined the subsequent approach of piecing together the evidence of the Iraqi WMD programs such as they existed. In fact, combined with the chaos of the war and the widespread looting in the immediate aftermath of the conflict, it resulted in the loss of a great amount of potentially very valuable information and material for constructing a full picture of Iraqi WMD capabilities. Sites were looted. Documents were either ignored or collected haphazardly or burned by either the Regime or Coalition forces.\nTo begin a more systematic collection of evidence to bui", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WMD_conjecture_after_the_2003_invasion_of_Iraq", "title": "WMD conjecture after the 2003 invasion of Iraq - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2006-06-11", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:06.747396Z", "excerpt": "The United Nations Monitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission (UNMOVIC) and the United States-led Iraq Survey Group (ISG) failed to find any of the alleged stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq that were used as a rationale for the 2003 U.S.-led invasion.[1] The United States effectively ended the search effort for unconventional weaponry in 2005, and the Iraq Intelligence Commission concluded that the judgements of the U.S. intelligence community regarding the continued existence of weapons of mass destruction and an associated military program were mistaken. The official findings of the CIA in 2004 were that Iraqi President Saddam Hussein \"did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the U.S. invasion in March 2003 and had not begun any program to produce them.\"[1]\nDuring and immediately following these searches, many theories were proposed to explain the sudden disappearance of Iraqi WMD—assuming that any had, in fact, existed. These theories included conspiracy theories, accusations against other governments and claims of successful deception efforts by Saddam Hussein. In various theories, Russia,[2] Syria,[3] Lebanon,[4] Iran,[5] and Pakistan[6] were all alleged to be involved with moving or concealing Iraq's supposed WMD arsenal. In 2004, a theory was advanced that WMD might still remain hidden somewhere within Iraq.[7] While some remnant chemical warheads were discovered, dating to the Iran–Iraq War era, none were newer than 1991. Some of these chemical weapons were found near the Muthanna State Establishment facility northwest of Baghdad.[8][9]\nAfter much criticism of the war during the years that followed, every figure who had previously supported the claims of WMD in Iraq, with the exception of U.S. Vice President Dick Cheney, acknowledged that they had been wrong.[10] A related debate also emerged over whether the figures who had pushed for war were inadvertently misled by intelligence or had, in fact, intentionally dec", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "url": "https://citizenreviewonline.org/feb_2003/text.htm", "title": "Text of Colin Powell's Presentation to the United Nations", "publisher": "citizenreviewonline.org", "published_at": "2003-05-02", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:24.897593Z", "excerpt": "Text of Colin Powell's Presentation to the United Nations \n \n Secretary of State \n \n \n 02.05.03 - At the United Nations. \n POWELL: Thank you, Mr. President. Mr. President, Mr. Secretary General, \n distinguished colleagues, I would like to begin by expressing my thanks \n for the special effort that each of you made to be here today. \n This is important day for us all as we review the situation with \n respect to Iraq and its disarmament obligations under U.N. Security \n Council Resolution 1441. \n Last November 8, this council passed Resolution 1441 by a unanimous \n vote. The purpose of that resolution was to disarm Iraq of its weapons \n of mass destruction. Iraq had already been found guilty of material \n breach of its obligations, stretching back over 16 previous resolutions \n and 12 years. \n Resolution 1441 was not dealing with an innocent party, but a regime \n this council has repeatedly convicted over the years. Resolution 1441 \n gave Iraq one last chance, one last chance to come into compliance \n or to face serious consequences. No council member present in voting \n on that day had any allusions about the nature and intent of the resolution \n or what serious consequences meant if Iraq did not comply. \n And to assist in its disarmament, we called on Iraq to cooperate \n with returning inspectors from UNMOVIC and IAEA. \n We laid down tough standards for Iraq to meet to allow the inspectors \n to do their job. This council placed the burden on Iraq to comply \n and disarm and not on the inspectors to find that which Iraq has gone \n out of its way to conceal for so long. Inspectors are inspectors; \n they are not detectives. \n I asked for this session today for two ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "url": "https://irp.fas.org/congress/2003_cr/h072103.html", "title": "Declassified Excerpts from the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate on Iraq", "publisher": "irp.fas.org", "published_at": "2024-11-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:26.088072Z", "excerpt": "Congressional Record: July 21, 2003 (Extensions)\nPage E1545-E1546\n KEY JUDGMENTS\n ______\n HON. PETER T. KING\n of new york\n in the house of representatives\n Monday, July 21, 2003\n Mr. KING of New York. Mr. Speaker, in light of the incessant barrage\nof attacks of inaccurate and baseless charges being made against\nPresident Bush by his political opponents and their allies in the\nmedia, I thought it important to include in the Record the declassified\nportions of the National Intelligence Estimate released by the White\nHouse this past Friday. This NIE clearly states the consensus view of\nour intelligence agencies that Saddam Hussein was attempting to\nreconstitute his nuclear capacity. The first half of these documents\nare being submitted today and the second half tomorrow. I commend these\ndocuments to all willing to approach this vital issue with an open\nmind.\n [From October 2002 NIE]\n Iraq's Continuing Programs for Weapons of Mass Destruction\n We judge that Iraq has continued its weapons of mass\n destruction (WMD) programs in defiance of UN resolutions and\n restrictions. Baghdad has chemical and biological weapons as\n well as missiles with ranges in excess of UN restrictions; if\n left unchecked, it probably will have a nuclear weapon during\n this decade. (See INR alternative view at the end of these\n Key Judgments.)\n We judge that we are seeing only a portion of Iraq's WMD\n efforts, owing to Baghdad's vigorous denial and deception\n efforts. Revelations after the Gulf war starkly demonstrate\n the extensive efforts undertaken by Iraq to deny information.\n We lack specific information on many key aspects of Iraq's\n WJMD programs.\n Since inspections ended in 1998, Iraq has maintained its\n chemical weapons effort, energized i", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "url": "https://www.sipri.org/commentary/essay/2023/twenty-years-ago-iraq-ignoring-expert-weapons-inspectors-proved-be-fatal-mistake", "title": "Twenty years ago in Iraq, ignoring the expert weapons inspectors proved to be a fatal mistake", "publisher": "SIPRI", "published_at": "2023-03-09", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:41.823260Z", "excerpt": "‘Let me begin by saying, we were almost all wrong, and I certainly include myself here.’—David Kay, Head of the Iraq Survey Group, during testimony to the US Senate, 29 January 2004\nThe case for invading Iraq in March 2003 was built on three basic premises: that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction (WMD); that it was developing more of them; and that it was failing to comply with its disarmament obligations under a series of United Nations Security Council resolutions. All of these premises were based on scraps of unreliable information. None of them was true.\nDavid Kay was one of the loudest voices outside the United States government advocating a new invasion of Iraq in the years and months leading to the second Gulf War. As a former nuclear inspector who had worked in Iraq in 1991, after the first Gulf War, he became a popular TV pundit and was even called to testify before Congress, talking up dubious claims about new Iraqi WMD programmes.\nIt was not surprising, then, that Kay should be chosen to head the Iraq Survey Group (ISG)—the US Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) mission to find and disable those putative WMD programmes—once the US-led multinational coalition had toppled Iraqi President Saddam Hussein’s Ba’athist regime and turned Iraq into an occupied state.\nThe ISG found no WMD in Iraq, and returning to Congress to testify on 28 January 2004, Kay admitted ‘we were almost all wrong’. He blamed a lack of human agents inside Iraq in the months before the war, and analysts being under pressure to draw conclusions based on inadequate intelligence. True, the intelligence Kay and many others in Washington, DC, London and other capitals had chosen to listen to was inadequate and flawed. But there was plenty more information that they ignored, much of it coming from many weapons inspectors working inside Iraq—including US nuclear experts—under UN mandate for four months in 2002–2003.\nI was in Iraq in those final months before the 2003 invasion as Deputy for Analy", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "bio" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17", "url": "https://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/library/report/2004/isg-final-report/isg-final-report_vol2_nuclear-01.htm", "title": "Iraq Survey Group Final Report", "publisher": "globalsecurity.org", "published_at": "2026-01-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:24.791451Z", "excerpt": "Iraq Survey Group Final Report\nEvolution of the Nuclear Weapons Program\n\t \n\t The Regime and WMD Timeline\n\t \n\t For an overview of Iraqi WMD programs and policy choices, readers should consult the Regime Strategy and WMD Timeline chart, enclosed as a separate foldout and in tabular form at the back of Volume I. Covering the period from 1980-2003, the timeline shows specific events bearing on the Regime’s efforts in the BW, CW, delivery systems, and nuclear realms and their chronological relationship with political and military developments that had direct bearing on the Regime’s policy choices.\n\t \nReaders should also be aware that, at the conclusion of each volume of text, we have also included foldout summary charts that relate inflection points—critical turning points in the Regime’s WMD policymaking—to particular events/initiatives/decisions the Regime took with respect to specific WMD programs. Inflection points are marked in the margins of the body of the text with a gray triangle. \n \nThe Early Years: Ambition \n \n\t Saddam demonstrated his commitment to obtain a nuclear weapon over two decades. Saddam’s close association with the Iraqi Atomic Energy Commission (IAEC) stems from his service as Vice President of the Republic from 1968 until 1979 when he became President of Iraq. From 1973 to 1979, he also served as President of the IAEC and sponsored its acquisition of foreign-supplied facilities with which to support a nuclear weapons program.\n \nIn 1968, Iraq commissioned a Russian supplied IRT-2000 research reactor and commissioned a number of other facilities that could be used for radioisotope production at the Tuwaitha Nuclear Research Center, home of the IAEC. In the 1970s, through contracts with French and Italian firms, the IAEC built facilities at Tuwaitha that, if operational, could have allowed Iraq to attempt to produce plutonium for a weapons program. The Israeli destruction of the Tammuz 1 (Osirak) research re", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_and_weapons_of_mass_destruction", "title": "Iraq and weapons of mass destruction - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2002-12-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:06.750326Z", "excerpt": "Iraq actively researched weapons of mass destruction (WMD) and used chemical weapons from 1962 to 1991, after which its chemical weapons stockpile was destroyed and its nuclear weapons program and its biological weapon program halted, in accordance with the United Nations Security Council's Resolution 687.[1] The Iraqi government of Saddam Hussein was internationally condemned for its chemical attacks against Iranian and Iraqi Kurdish civilians and troops during the Iran–Iraq War. Saddam pursued extensive biological and nuclear weapons programs, but did not construct a nuclear weapon. After the Gulf War, the United Nations Special Commission located, confiscated, and destroyed large quantities of Iraqi chemical weapons and infrastructure; Iraq ceased its chemical, biological and nuclear programs.[2]\nDuring the Iran–Iraq War, known Iraqi chemical weapons attacks between 1983 and 1988 were estimated to have caused 50,000 immediate casualties to Iranian troops.[3] Civilians were also targeted; between 3,200 and 5,000 people were killed in the Halabja massacre.[4][5][6] The attacks were led by Ali Hassan al-Majid, using mustard gas and nerve agents. In the Gulf War, US bombing and post-war demolition of Iraqi chemical weapons facilities, especially containing sarin and cyclosarin, were concluded to be the primary cause of Gulf War syndrome, experienced by over 40% of US veterans of the Gulf War.[7]\nFalse assertions by the US and UK that Iraq continued researching and stockpiling WMDs played a major role in the prelude to the Iraq War. The US and UK carried out the 1998 bombing of Iraq, allegedly targeting WMD facilities. Following the September 11 attacks, the US attempted to link Iraq to alleged WMD pursuits of the perpetrating terrorist group Al-Qaeda. UN inspections resumed between November 2002 and March 2003,[8] under Resolution 1441, which demanded Iraq provide \"immediate, unconditional and active cooperation\" to UN and IAEA inspections.[9] The US argued that Iraq", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "url": "https://edition.cnn.com/2003/US/03/07/sprj.irq.un.transcript.blix/index.html", "title": "Transcript of Blix's U.N. presentation", "publisher": "CNN.com - Transcript of Blix's U.N. presentation", "published_at": "2003-03-07", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:25.974306Z", "excerpt": "Transcript of Blix's U.N. presentation\n(CNN) -- Following is a transcript of chief U.N. weapons inspector Hans Blix's March 7 presentation to the U.N. Security Council on the progress of the inspection effort in Iraq.\nBlix: Thank you, Mr. President.\nMr. President, for nearly three years, I've been coming to the Security Council presenting the quarterly reports of UNMOVIC [U.N. Monitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission]. They have described our many preparations for the resumption of inspections in Iraq.\nThe 12th quarterly report is the first that describes three months of inspection. They come after four years without inspections. The report was finalized 10 days ago, and a number of relevant events have taken place since then. Today's statement will supplement the circulated report on these points to bring the council up to date.\nInspections in Iraq resumed on the 27th of November 2002. In matters relating to process, notably prompt access to sites, we have faced relatively few difficulties, and certainly much less than those that were faced by UNSCOM [U.N. Special Commission] in the period 1991 to 1998. This may well be due to the strong outside pressure.\nSome practical matters which were not settled by the talks Dr. [Mohamed] ElBaradei and I had with Iraqi side in Vienna prior to inspections or in Resolution 1441 have been resolved at meetings, which we have had in Baghdad.\nInitial difficulties raised by the Iraqi side about helicopters and aerial surveillance planes operating in the \"no-fly\" zones were overcome.\nThis is not to say that the operation of inspections is free from frictions, but at this juncture we are able to perform professional, no-notice inspections all over Iraq and to increase aerial surveillance.\nAmerican U-2 and French Mirage surveillance aircraft already give us valuable imagery, supplementing satellite pictures, and we would expect soon to be able to add night-vision capability through an aircraft offered to us by the Russian F", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_Survey_Group", "title": "Iraq Survey Group - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2003-10-26", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:06.745830Z", "excerpt": "The Iraq Survey Group (ISG) was a fact-finding mission sent by the multinational force in Iraq to find the weapons of mass destruction alleged to be possessed by Iraq that had been the main ostensible reason for the invasion in 2003. Its final report, Comprehensive Report of the Special Advisor to the Director of Central Intelligence on Iraq WMD (commonly referred to as the Duelfer Report, named after the head of the ISG Charles A. Duelfer), was submitted to Congress and the president in 2004.[1][2] It consisted of a 1,400-member international team organized by the Pentagon and Central Intelligence Agency to hunt for the alleged stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction, including chemical and biological agents, and any supporting research programs and infrastructure that could be used to develop WMD. The report acknowledged that only small stockpiles of chemical WMDs were found, the numbers being inadequate to pose a militarily significant threat.\nThe ISG was made up of more than one thousand American, British and Australian citizens, with the United States providing the bulk of the personnel and resources for the operation. These people included civilian and military intelligence and WMD experts, as well as a large number of people working to provide armed security and support. David Kay, who had been a weapons inspector after the first Gulf War, was chosen to head the group. The agency tasked as the head U.S. government agency of the ISG was a joint venture of the CIA and the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA), a Department of Defense intelligence agency. Chosen as the senior military officer of the ISG was MG Keith Dayton, who was tasked TDY from his assignment as Deputy Director, Human Intelligence, Defense Intelligence Agency.\nThe Iraq Survey Group replaced the United Nations inspections teams (the United Nations Monitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission (UNMOVIC), led by Hans Blix) and from the International Atomic Energy Agency (led by Mohamed ElBara", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "bio", "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "url": "https://www.iaea.org/sites/default/files/publications/magazines/bulletin/bull46-1/46102096971.pdf", "title": "46102096971.pdf", "publisher": "iaea.org", "published_at": null, "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T15:01:10.881200Z", "excerpt": "June 2004 69IAEA BULLETIN 46/1\nS\npeaking on the anniver-\nsary of the United States’ \ninvasion of Iraq, origi-\nnally declared as a pre-emp-\ntive strike against a madman \nready to deploy weapons of \nmass destruction (WMD), the \nman fi rst charged with fi nd-\ning those weapons said that the \nUS government has “the same \nmind frame as the witch hunt-\ners of the past” — looking for \nevidence to support a foregone \nconclusion.\n“There were about 700 inspec-\ntions, and in no case did we fi nd \nweapons of mass destruction,” \nsaid Hans Blix, the Swedish \ndiplomat called out of retire-\nment to serve as the United Nations’ chief weapons inspec-\ntor from 2000 to 2003; from 1981 to 1997 he headed the \nInternational Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). “We went to \nsites [in Iraq] given to us by intelligence, and only in three \ncases did we fi nd something” — a stash of nuclear docu-\nments, some Vulcan boosters, and several empty warheads \nfor chemical weapons. More inspections were required to \ndetermine whether these fi ndings were the “tip of the ice-\nberg” or simply fragments remaining from that deadly ice-\nberg’s past destruction, Blix said he told the United Nations \nSecurity Council. However, his work in Iraq was cut short \nwhen the United States and the United Kingdom took disar-\nmament into their own hands in March of 2003. \nBlix accused US President George W. Bush and UK Prime \nMinister Tony Blair of acting not in bad faith, but with a \nsevere lack of “critical thinking.” The United States and \nBritain failed to examine the sources of their primary intelli-\ngence — Iraqi defectors with their own agendas for encour-\naging regime change — with a sceptical eye, he alleged. \nIn the build-up to the war, \nSaddam Hussein and the Iraqis \nwere cooperating with UN \ninspections, and in February \n2003 had provided Blix’s team \nwith the names of hundreds of \nscientists to interview, indi-\nviduals Saddam claimed had \nbeen involved in the destruc-\ntion of banned weapons. Had \nthe inspections been a", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "url": "https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/article-1529jsp/", "title": "The Iraq weapons report: a review", "publisher": "Opendemocracy", "published_at": "2003-10-08", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:41.828357Z", "excerpt": "Six months after the end of the war in Iraq, and in the eye of the political storm about whether Iraqs weapons of mass destruction (WMD) threat was exaggerated by the United States-led coalition, the interim report by the group currently heading weapons inspections in Iraq, the Iraq Survey Group (ISG), has been published.\nBoth sides of the political battle have been scanning it for arguments that shore up their political case. Those who supported the war highlight Saddams commitment to continuing chemical weapons production, and the traces of biological agent found by ISG; opponents cleave to the fact that no trace of actual chemical or biological weapons have been found.\nAt this moment I would like as a professional weapons inspector and someone deeply concerned with the complete eradication of chemical and biological weapons from the world stage, someone in short with no stake in the political battles that are raging around this issue to examine the ISG report from a dispassionate, objective position. What new information does it actually provide us about Iraqs chemical and biological weapons and their associated research and development programmes?\nNeedle in the haystack or elephant in the fridge?\nIn 1991, following the first Gulf war, I was in charge of the technical United Nations Special Commission (Unscom) team sent to Iraq to destroy Saddams chemical weapons arsenal. Between 1991 and 1994 we in Unscom undertook the tough task of scouring the country for chemical weapons, and also faced daunting piles of official documents, and the difficulties with interviewing reluctant personnel. Although we were ultimately very successful at eliminating Saddams chemical stockpile as the ISG report shows it was, nevertheless, a difficult and time-consuming task.\nIraq is a large country and the ISG has been operating there for only about three months. The ISG, with approximately 1,400 personnel, is much larger than either Unscom or the later United Nations Monitoring, V", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "url": "https://news.un.org/en/story/2003/02/58372", "title": "Powell presents US case to Security Council of Iraq's failure to disarm", "publisher": "UN News", "published_at": "2003-02-05", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:24.414532Z", "excerpt": "Powell presents US case to Security Council of Iraq's failure to disarm\n\"My colleagues, every statement I make today is backed up by sources, solid sources. These are not assertions. What we're giving you are facts and conclusions based on solid intelligence,\" Mr. Powell told the ministerial-level session of the 15-member body. Before hearing Mr. Powell's presentation, the Council members decided to grant Iraq's request to allow its representative sit at the Council table and make a statement at the end of the meeting.\nThe US Secretary of State stressed that Iraq still poses a threat and remains in \"material breach\" of Council resolutions. \"Indeed, by its failure to seize its one last opportunity to come clean and disarm, Iraq has put itself in deeper material breach and close to the day when it will face serious consequences for its continued defiance of this Council,\" he said. \"We must not fail in our duty and our responsibility to the citizens of our countries.\"\nMr. Powell stressed that Iraq's continued efforts to conceal evidence and documents from UN inspectors, the active interference by Saddam Hussein himself to prevent interviews with Iraqi individuals, and a host of other activities that demonstrated its non-compliance were all violations of the terms of Security Council Resolution 1441. That text, he emphasized, states that \"false statements and omissions\" and a failure by Iraq \"to comply with, and cooperate fully\" in the implementation of the resolution should constitute a further material breach of its obligations.\n\"This body places itself in danger of irrelevance if it allows Iraq to continue to defy its will without responding effectively and immediately,\" Mr. Powell warned. \"The issue before us is not how much more time we are willing to give the inspectors to be frustrated by Iraqi obstruction, but how much longer are we willing to put up with Iraq's non-compliance before we say: 'Enough!'\"\nReferring to the audio-visual evidence he presented to the C", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "url": "https://irp.fas.org/cia/product/iraq-wmd.html", "title": "Key Judgments: Iraq's Continuing Programs for Weapons of Mass Destruction", "publisher": "irp.fas.org", "published_at": "2003-07-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:24.168228Z", "excerpt": "Key Judgments [from October 2002 NIE]\nIraq's Continuing Programs for Weapons of Mass Destruction\nWe judge that Iraq has continued its weapons of mass destruction (WMD) programs in defiance of UN resolutions and restrictions. Baghdad has chemical and biological weapons as well as missiles with ranges in excess of UN restrictions; if left unchecked, it probably will have a nuclear weapon during this decade. (See INR alternative view at the end of these Key Judgments.)\nWe judge that we are seeing only a portion of Iraq's WMD efforts, owing to Baghdad's vigorous denial and deception efforts. Revelations after the Gulf war starkly demonstrate the extensive efforts undertaken by Iraq to deny information. We lack specific information on many key aspects of Iraq's WMD programs.\nSince inspections ended in 1998, Iraq has maintained its chemical weapons effort, energized its missile program, and invested more heavily in biological weapons; in the view of most agencies, Baghdad is reconstituting its nuclear weapons program.\nHow quickly Iraq will obtain its first nuclear weapon depends on when it acquires sufficient weapons-grade fissile material.\n- Iraq's growing ability to sell oil illicitly increases Baghdad's capabilities to finance WMD programs; annual earnings in cash and goods have more than quadrupled, from $580 million in 1998 to about $3 billion this year.\n- Iraq has largely rebuilt missile and biological weapons facilities damaged during Operation Desert Fox and has expanded its chemical and biological infrastructure under the cover of civilian production.\n- Baghdad has exceeded UN range limits of 150 km with its ballistic missiles and is working with unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), which allow for a more lethal means to deliver biological and, less likely, chemical warfare agents.\n- Although we assess that Saddam does not yet have nuclear weapons or sufficient material to make any, he remains intent on acquiring them. Most agencies assess that Baghdad started recons", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "url": "https://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/wmd/report.html", "title": "Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction", "publisher": "georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov", "published_at": "2005-03-31", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:41.819904Z", "excerpt": "ENDNOTES\n1 NIEs, produced under the auspices of the National Intelligence Council (NIC),\ncontain the coordinated judgments of the Intelligence Community and are the\nDCI's most authoritative written judgments concerning national security issues.\nCIA website, http://www.cia.gov.nic/NIC_about/html .\n2 Executive\nOrder 13328, which established this Commission,\ndid not authorize us to investigate how policymakers used the intelligence they\nreceived from the Intelligence Community on Iraq's weapons programs. As a\nresult, while we interviewed several policymakers, the purpose of those\ninterviews was to obtain information about how the Intelligence Community\nreached and communicated its judgments about Iraq's weapons programs, and not\nto review policymakers' use of intelligence information.\n3 NIC, National Intelligence Estimate,\nIraq's Continuing Programs for Weapons of Mass Destruction (NIE 2002-16HC)\n(Oct. 2002) (hereinafter \"NIE\") at pp. 5, 6. The Intelligence\nCommunity is composed of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), the Department\nof State's Bureau of Intelligence and Research (INR), the Department of Energy\n(DOE), the Department of the Treasury, the Federal Bureau of Investigation\n(FBI), the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), the National Reconnaissance\nOffice (NRO), the National Security Agency (NSA), the National\nGeospatial-Intelligence Agency (NGA), the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA),\nand Army Intelligence, Navy Intelligence, Coast Guard Intelligence, Air Force\nIntelligence, and Marine Corps Intelligence. Not all of these elements\ncoordinate on all NIEs, however. The October 2002 NIE on Iraq WMD was\ncoordinated among CIA, INR, DOE, NSA, NGA (then known as the National Imagery\nand Mapping Agency (NIMA)), DIA, and all the military intelligence components.\nNIC, How the Intelligence Community Arrived at the Judgments in the October\n2002 NIE on Iraq's WMD Programs (March 2004) (hereinafter \"DCI Statement\nfor the Record\") at Introduction, p. 1 n. 1. This was t", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "bio" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "url": "https://www.cnn.com/2003/US/02/05/sprj.irq.powell.un/", "title": "Powell: Iraq hiding weapons, aiding terrorists", "publisher": "CNN.com - Powell: Iraq hiding weapons, aiding terrorists", "published_at": "2003-02-05", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:45.416674Z", "excerpt": "Powell: Iraq hiding weapons, aiding terrorists\nAnnan: War not inevitable\nUNITED NATIONS (CNN) -- U.S. Secretary of State Colin Powell used electronic intercepts, satellite photographs and other intelligence sources Wednesday in an effort to convince skeptical members of the U.N. Security Council that Iraq is actively working to deceive U.N. weapons inspectors.\n\"I cannot tell you everything that we know,\" Powell said, with CIA Director George Tenet sitting behind him. \"But what I can share with you, when combined with what all of us have learned over the years, is deeply troubling.\" (Key points)\nWhile calling Powell's presentation strong and thorough, U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan told reporters, \"I still believe war is not inevitable.\"\nBut he urged Iraqi President Saddam Hussein and the Iraqi leadership to fully comply with U.N. Resolution 1441 to disarm \"for the sake of their own people, for the region and for world order.\"\nOne intercept, Powell said, was between a colonel and brigadier general of Iraq's elite Republican Guard discussing hiding a vehicle before U.N. inspectors arrived to search a site.\nPowell said it indicated the Iraqi officials knew inspectors were coming and what they would be looking for. In the U.S. translation, one official is heard to say, \"We have this modified vehicle. What do we say if one of them sees it?\" The other official says, \"I'll come to see you in the morning. I'm worried. You all have something left.\"\nThe other official then says, \"We evacuated everything. We don't have anything left.\"\nPowell called the recordings \"part and parcel of a policy of evasion and deception that goes back 12 years.\"\nIraqi reaction\nGen. Amir al-Saadi, the Iraqi government's science adviser, dismissed those recordings as manufactured evidence, saying \"any third-rate intelligence outfit could produce such recordings.\" (More on Iraqi reaction)\nPowell also showed satellite photos that he said indicated the presence of \"active chemical munitions bunker", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "url": "https://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/library/report/2004/isg-final-report/isg-final-report_vol1_rsi-06.htm", "title": "Iraq Survey Group Final Report", "publisher": "globalsecurity.org", "published_at": "2026-01-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:14.979952Z", "excerpt": "Iraq Survey Group Final Report\nRealizing Saddam’s Veiled WMD Intent\n\t \n\t Regime Strategy and WMD Timeline\n\t \n\t For an overview of Iraqi WMD programs and policy choices, readers should consult the Regime Strategy and WMD Timeline chart, enclosed as a separate foldout and tabular form at the back of Volume I. Covering the period from 1980 to 2003, the timeline shows specific events bearing on the Regime’s efforts in the BW, CW, delivery systems and nuclear realms and their chronological relationship with political and military developments that had direct bearing on the Regime’s policy choices.\nReaders should also be aware that, at the conclusion of each volume of text, we have also included foldout summary charts that relate inflection points—critical turning points in the Regime’s WMD policymaking—to particular events, initiatives, or decisions the Regime took with respect to specific WMD programs. Inflection points are marked in the margins of the body of the text with a gray triangle.\n\t \nIn the years following Iraq’s war with Iran and invasion of Kuwait, Saddam’s Regime sought to preserve the ability to reconstitute his WMD, while seeking sanctions relief through the appearance of cooperation with the UN Special Commission (UNSCOM) and the UN Monitoring Verification and Inspection Commission (UNMOVIC). Saddam’s initial approach under sanctions was driven by his perceived requirements for WMD and his confidence in Iraq’s ability to ride out inspections without fully cooperating. Interwoven into this basic fabric of Iraq’s interaction with the UN were equally significant domestic, international, and family events, all influenced by and reflective of Saddam’s strategic intent. These events can be divided into five phases that cover the entire period 1980 to 2003. \nAmbition (1980-1991)\n\t \n\t The 1980 to 1991 period is dominated by the Iran-Iraq war and its aftershock.\nThe war was costly in financial, human and materiel resources and led Iraq towards a pe", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "url": "https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB80/", "title": "Iraq and Weapons of Mass Destruction", "publisher": "nsarchive2.gwu.edu", "published_at": "1997-10-08", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:16.484344Z", "excerpt": "Between Iraq's invasion of Kuwait in August 1990, and the \n commencement of military action in January 1991, then President George \n H.W. Bush raised the specter of the Iraqi pursuit of nuclear weapons \n as one justification for taking decisive action against Iraq. In the \n then-classified National Security Directive 54, signed on January \n 15, 1991, authorizing the use of force to expel Iraq from Kuwait, \n he identified Iraqi use of weapons of mass destruction (WMD) against \n allied forces as an action that would lead the U.S. to seek the removal \n of Saddam Hussein from power. (Note 1) \n In the aftermath of Iraq's defeat, the U.S.-led U.N. coalition \n was able to compel Iraq to agree to an inspection and monitoring \n regime, intended to insure that Iraq dismantled its WMD programs \n and did not take actions to reconstitute them. The means of implementing \n the relevant U.N. resolutions was the Special Commission on Iraq \n (UNSCOM). That inspection regime continued until December 16, 1998 \n - although it involved interruptions, confrontations, and Iraqi \n attempts at denial and deception - when UNSCOM withdrew from Iraq \n in the face of Iraqi refusal to cooperate, and harassment.\n Subsequent to George W. Bush's assumption of the presidency in \n January 2001, the U.S. made it clear that it would not accept what \n had become the status quo with respect to Iraq - a country ruled \n by Saddam Hussein and free to attempt to reconstitute its assorted \n weapons of mass destruction programs. As part of their campaign \n against the status quo, which included the clear threat of the eventual \n use of military force against the Iraqi regime, the U.S. and Britain \n published doc", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "bio", "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_Iraqi_mobile_weapons_laboratories", "title": "Allegations of Iraqi mobile weapons laboratories - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2005-11-03", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:18.313639Z", "excerpt": "During the lead-up to the Iraq War, the United States had alleged that Iraq owned bioreactors, and other processing equipment to manufacture and process biological weapons that can be moved from location to location either by train or vehicle. Subsequent investigations failed to find any evidence of Iraq having access to a mobile weapons lab.\nIn the run up to the 2003 Invasion of Iraq, the main rationale for the Iraq War were allegations that Iraq had failed to transparently and verifiably cease their weapons of mass destruction (WMD) program. In February 2003, Secretary of State Colin Powell gave a presentation before the United Nations showing a computer image of what were purported to be mobile weapons for creating biological agents. He said Iraq had as many as 18 mobile facilities for making anthrax and botulinum toxin, stating \"they can produce enough dry, biological agent in a single month to kill thousands upon thousands of people.\" Powell based the assertion on accounts of at least four Iraqi defectors, including a chemical engineer who supervised one of the facilities and been present during production runs of a biological agent. [2] Following the invasion of Iraq two trailers were found and initially described as the alleged mobile labs.\nIn the CIA briefing days before the 2003 United Nations security council presentation Colin Powell knew that all information included in the report had to be solid. \"Powell and I were both suspicious because there were no pictures of the mobile labs,\" Wilkerson, Powell's chief of staff said.[3] Powell demanded multiple sources and the two CIA men present George Tenet, then the CIA director and John E. McLaughlin, then the CIA deputy director claimed to have multiple eye witness accounts and supporting evidence. Wilkerson claims that the two said, \"This is it, Mr. Secretary. You can't doubt this one\"[3]\nThe information behind the mobile vehicles had come from the multiple informants but the main and most important one was k", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "url": "https://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/world/iraq/cw-prewar2003.htm", "title": "Iraqi Chemical Weapons Program", "publisher": "globalsecurity.org", "published_at": "1998-02-13", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:14.438490Z", "excerpt": "Iraqi Chemical Weapons Programs\n2003 Prewar Assessments\nIn the 2002 National Intelligence Estimate (NIE), the Intelligence Community (IC) concluded with \"high confidence\" that Iraq had renewed its production of illicit Chemical Weapon (CW) agents, including mustard, sarin, GF (cyclosarin) and VX nerve agent. Although it estimated that the production would be smaller than pre-Gulf War levels, owing to much destroyed infrastructure during bombing, NIE estimated that Iraq possessed between 100 and 500 metric tons (MT) of CW agents. In addition, the NIE, concurring with previous intelligence reports, stated that the expansion of the Iraqi chemical industry was primarily undertaken in order to support CW production. The NIE's conclusions regarding Iraqi CW were:\n- Baghdad has chemical weapons.\n- The IC judged that Iraq is expanding its chemical industry primarily to support chemical weapons production.\n- The IC assessed that Baghdad has begun renewed production of mustard, sarin, GF (cyclosarin), and VX.\n- Although the IC had little specific information on Iraq's CW stockpile, Saddam probably had stocked at least 100 metric tons and possibly as much as 500 metric tons of chemical warfare agents much of it added in the last year.\n- The Iraqis had experience in manufacturing chemical bombs, artillery rockets, and projectiles.\n- Baghdad probably is hiding small scale agent production within legitimate research laboratories.\n- Baghdad has procured covertly the types and quantities of chemicals and equipment sufficient to allow limited CW production hidden within Iraq's legitimate chemical industry.\nAlthough many of these conclusions agreed with previous intelligence assessments, it went much further than previous reports on several points. First, the NIE unequivocally stated that Iraq had restarted CW production. Previous reports had stated that although Iraq retained the capability to restart its CW production at reduced levels, none found to support the conclusion made in ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "url": "https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/RL31671.html", "title": "Iraq: U.N. Inspections for Weapons of Mass Destruction", "publisher": "Congressional Research Service", "published_at": "2003-03-13", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:06.758844Z", "excerpt": "Order Code RL31671\nCRS Report for Congress\nReceived through the CRS Web\nIraq: U.N. Inspections for \n Weapons of Mass Destruction\nUpdated October 7, 2003\nSharon A. Squassoni\nSpecialist in National Defense\nForeign Affairs, Defense, and Trade Division\nCongressional Research Service ˜\n The Library of Congress\nIraq: U.N. Inspections for\n Weapons of Mass Destruction \nSummary\nFrom late November 2002 to March 2003, U.N. inspectors combed Iraq looking\nfor weapons of mass destruction (WMD). Under the threat of war from the United\nStates and a unanimous Security Council resolution (1441), Iraq was granted a final\nopportunity to disarm. Many had low expectations for successful inspections. After\n16 weeks, inspectors turned up some evidence of undeclared activities, but not\nenough to convince a majority of the Security Council members that military force\nwas necessary. Nonetheless, on March 19, 2003, U.S. and British forces attacked\nIraq to forcibly eliminate its WMD. This report, which will be updated as events\nwarrant, analyzes the inspections, their outcome, and possible future tasks.\nThe U.N. Monitoring, Verification, and Inspection Commission (UNMOVIC)\nand the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) conducted over 750 inspections\nat 550 sites. These inspections seemed to benefit from strengthened authorities under\nthe new U.N. resolution, new technologies, a better relationship between UNMOVIC\nand the IAEA, and pressure from the threat of military strikes. Nonetheless, most\nobservers agree that Iraqi compliance was superficial and oriented to facilitating the\nprocess of inspections, rather than on providing cooperation in substantive matters.\nIn addition, new practical, technical, and political challenges arose. There were\nallegations that not all actionable intelligence was shared with inspectors and that the\nthreat of war increased pressure on inspectors to produce some definitive knowledge\nand helped politicize their investigations. Many alleged that Iraq mig", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraqi_chemical_weapons_program", "title": "Iraqi chemical weapons program - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2007-01-10", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:18.328341Z", "excerpt": "The Iraqi chemical weapons program was an aspect of the country's pursuit of weapons of mass destruction until the 1990s. In violation of the Geneva Protocol, Iraq initiated three separate research and development drives for chemical weapons, the first two of which (1970–1974; 1974–1978) were unsuccessful. The last drive (1978–1991), which was spurred by Iraqi president Saddam Hussein, was successful and saw the deployment of chemical weapons during the country's military campaigns against Iran and the Kurdish people.[1]\nEfforts by Iraq to acquire chemical weapons date back to the early 1960s and were motivated by a desire to greatly strengthen the Iraqi military, especially after the 1973 Arab–Israeli War.[2] However, it was not until Saddam took power that the program experienced significant and steady progress. Though lacking stockpiles at the time of the Iraqi invasion of Iran in 1980, the country rapidly engaged in intensive research to produce and store chemical weapons, with real-time battlefield deployments serving as tests for the prowess of Iraqi forces in waging chemical warfare.\nBeginning in 1983, Iraqi chemical attacks against Iran were confirmed by the United Nations to have taken place on multiple occasions over the course of the Iran–Iraq War, including more than 30 targeted attacks against Iranian civilians. It is estimated that these chemical attacks resulted in over 100,000 Iranian casualties, of which at least 20,000 were direct deaths upon exposure. The Iraqi military also used chemical weapons against Kurdish civilians during the 1988 Anfal campaign (as evidenced by the Halabja massacre), which resulted in the deaths of as many as 100,000 people, according to Human Rights Watch.[3][4] In January 1991, during the Iraqi occupation of Kuwait, Iraq began firing missiles at civilian targets in Israel and at American troops in Saudi Arabia, raising concerns of potential chemical attacks, but all of the warheads used were conventional. However, chemic", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Senate_Report_on_Iraqi_WMD_Intelligence", "title": "Senate Report on Iraqi WMD Intelligence - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2004-07-29", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:06.752948Z", "excerpt": "The Senate Report on Iraqi WMD Intelligence (formally, the Report of the Select Committee on Intelligence on the U.S. Intelligence Community's Prewar Intelligence Assessments on Iraq) was the report by the United States Senate Select Committee on Intelligence concerning the U.S. Intelligence Community's assessments of Iraq during the time leading up to the 2003 invasion of Iraq. The report, which was released on July 9, 2004, identified numerous failures in the intelligence-gathering and -analysis process. The report found that these failures led to the creation of inaccurate materials that misled both government policy makers and the American public.\nThe Committee's nine Republicans and eight Democrats agreed on the report's major conclusions and unanimously endorsed its findings. They disagreed, though, on the impact that statements on Iraq by senior members of the Bush administration had on the intelligence process. The second phase of the investigation, addressing the way senior policymakers used the intelligence, was published on May 25, 2007. Portions of the phase II report not released at that time include the review of public statements by U.S. government leaders prior to the war, and the assessment of the activities of Douglas Feith and the Pentagon's Office of Special Plans.\nAfter the 1991 Gulf War, Iraq agreed to destroy its stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction (WMD) and dismantle its WMD programs. To verify compliance, UN inspection teams were to be given free access to the country. Over the next seven years, inspectors sometimes complained about non-cooperation and evasiveness by the Iraqi government. Iraqi officials in turn complained that some weapons inspectors were acting as spies for foreign intelligence agencies. In 1998, after a critical report on the Iraqi government's noncompliance was issued by UN weapons inspector Richard Butler, U.S. president Bill Clinton announced that he would launch airstrikes on Iraqi targets (see Operation Desert ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202", "url": "https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/colin-powell-u-n-speech-was-a-great-intelligence-failure/", "title": "Colin Powell: U.N. Speech \"Was a Great Intelligence Failure\" | FRONTLINE | PBS | Official Site | Documentary Series", "publisher": "FRONTLINE | PBS | Official Site | Documentary Series", "published_at": "2025-03-07", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:48.526295Z", "excerpt": "May 17, 2016\nShare\nColin Powell has called his 2003 speech to the United Nations, laying out the Bush administration’s rationale for war in Iraq, a “blot” on his record. The speech set out to detail Iraq’s weapons program, but as the intelligence would later confirm, that program was nonexistent.\nMore than 13 years later, the speech continues to haunt the administration — not just for what it got wrong, but for the unintended consequences it may have set in motion.\nIn one section, for example, Powell mentioned the name Abu Musab al-Zarqawi 21 times. The aim was to establish Zarqawi as the link between Al Qaeda and Iraq. The problem, according to former members of the intelligence community, is that although Zarqawi once travelled to Afghanistan hoping to meet Osama bin Laden, he was considered a poor recruit for Al Qaeda.\nPowell’s U.N. speech helped elevate Zarqawi’s status, and within months, he was rapidly gaining followers in Iraq, fomenting sectarian warfare and laying the groundwork for the organization that would become ISIS.\nToday, Powell says his speech was approved by former CIA chief George Tenet, but says he doesn’t remember the details about Zarqawi.\n“Zarqawi was not anything uppermost in my mind,” he told FRONTLINE’s Jim Gilmore in an interview for the documentary The Secret History of ISIS. “It was not a significant part of the speech for me. It was almost a passing reference.”\nIn the below transcript of that conversation, conducted Feb. 5, 2016, Powell talks about the speech, what he remembers about Zarqawi, and why he warned President Bush on Iraq, “If you break it, you own it.”\nLet’s start out in 2002. You were concerned about the consequences of what would happen after an invasion of Iraq. You were telling the president that famous phrase, “If you break it, you own it.” What were your concerns, and why were they not listened to?\nThe second part of your thing may not be accurate, and I’ll come to that. In the summer of 2002, when I returned from an ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a", "url": "https://news.un.org/en/story/2024/02/1146332", "title": "Stories from the UN Archive: The presentation that launched a war", "publisher": "UN News", "published_at": "2024-02-15", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:48.984129Z", "excerpt": "Stories from the UN Archive: The presentation that launched a war\nTwenty-one years ago in February, US Secretary of State Colin Powell held up a tiny blue-capped vial in the UN Security Council, claiming Iraq and President Saddam Hussein were producing weapons of mass destruction (WMDs).\nThis #ThrowbackThursday, we revisited the exchanges that unfolded in the Security Council.\nOn 5 February 2003, Mr. Powell addressed a packed Council Chamber, laying out the case for the US invasion of Iraq the following month.\n“Every statement I make today is backed up by solid sources,” he said. “What we’re giving you are facts and conclusions. Clearly, Saddam Hussein and his regime will stop at nothing until something stops him.”\nDuring the hour-long multimedia presentation, the Secretary of State narrated a detailed video and slideshow of satellite images, audio recordings of intercepted phone calls and illustrations showing, among other things, trucks and train cars allegedly serving as mobile production facilities for biological agents in Iraq.\nAt the heart of the US’s arguments was the claim that Mr. Hussein was determined to keep his WMDs and to make more, including anthrax, a biological agent.\nRaising a tiny vial containing a beige powder-like substance, Mr. Powell explained: “Less than a teaspoon of dry anthrax…about this amount… shut down the United States Senate in the fall of 2001.”\n“Saddam Hussein has not verifiably accounted for even one teaspoonful of this deadly material,” he went on to say, still dangling the vial with an unknown substance from his fingertips. “Iraqis have never accounted for all of the biological weapons they admitted they had. This is evidence, not conjecture.”\nThe Council did not act on what was presented, and there was no resolution authorizing military action in Iraq.\nA little more than a month after that meeting, the US invaded the Middle Eastern country.\nTwo months later, the Security Council-mandated UN Monitoring, Verification and Inspectio", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "url": "https://www.factcheck.org/2008/02/no-wmds-in-iraq/", "title": "No WMDs in Iraq - FactCheck.org", "publisher": "FactCheck.org", "published_at": "2008-02-19", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:17.705776Z", "excerpt": "Q: Were there really weapons of mass destruction in Iraq when the U.S. invaded in 2003?\nA: No. The Iraq Survey Group determined that Iraq had abandoned its quest to develop chemical, biological and nuclear weapons and that it had already destroyed all of its existing stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons.\nFULL QUESTION\nI have friends in Texas, Seattle and Tennessee who say President Bush was right that there were weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. They claim that the weapons were hidden in caves in the mountains, and are still hidden there, but we have not found them yet. Where did they get such ideas, and is there even the slightest chance they are right, and if so why wouldn’t Bush have said this? How did such a belief get started, and is there a way I can dispel them of the idea?\nFULL ANSWER\nAs for how you dispel your friends’ notions that Iraq really did have stockpiles of chemical or biological weapons when President Bush no longer makes such claims himself, we suggest ridicule. If that doesn’t work, you may be out of luck.\nAfter the invasion of Iraq in 2003, the Bush administration formed the Iraq Survey Group and tasked it with the job of locating WMD stockpiles in Iraq. The ISG was staffed with hundreds of intelligence analysts and military personnel from the United States, the United Kingdom and Australia. The group scoured Iraq, searching for deposits of weapons. But that was actually only part of the ISG’s focus.\nAccording to the ISG final report, the search for WMDs actually began during the invasion phase of Operation Iraqi Freedom. A military task force was deployed to investigate suspected WMD sites on the theory that the Iraqi military might otherwise employ those weapons against coalition troops. After the invasion, the ISG was established to conduct \"a more systematic collection of evidence to build an understanding of Iraqi WMD programs.\" In other words, the ISG did not simply look for WMDs. The group also looked at Iraq’s WMD capabiliti", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "bio", "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "url": "https://www.armscontrol.org/act/2004-06/chemical-munition-found-iraq", "title": "Chemical Munition Found in Iraq", "publisher": "armscontrol.org", "published_at": "2004-06-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:41.822459Z", "excerpt": "Chemical Munition Found in Iraq\n \n The Iraq Survey Group (ISG)—the task force charged with coordinating the U.S.-led search for Iraqi weapons of mass destruction (WMD)—has confirmed that an artillery round filled with sarin nerve agent was found in Baghdad, Brig. Gen. Mark Kimmitt told reporters May 17.\n A U.S. convoy found the shell, which was rigged as an improvised explosive device (IED), Kimmitt said, adding that a “very small” amount of nerve agent was released from the shell because it partially detonated before it could be disarmed. Two members of an explosive ordnance team sustained minor injuries as a result of exposure to the agent.\n Kimmitt added that the round—the first such weapon to be found in Iraq—was “virtually ineffective as a chemical weapon” because it was used as an IED and not an artillery shell. The people who built the device probably did not know it contained chemical agents, he said, adding that the United States believes the shell was built by Iraq’s previous government.\n Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld stated May 17 at the Heritage Foundation that the field test conducted on the shell “is not perfect” and that further tests should be conducted to identify the substance.\n Iraq produced sarin prior to the 1991 Persian Gulf War but never provided a satisfactory accounting of its postwar stockpile to UN inspectors. In a March 2003 report to the UN Security Council, the UN Monitoring, Verification, and Inspection Commission (UNMOVIC) stated that there were discrepancies in Iraq’s claims about the status of nearly 4,800 rocket warheads and 12 aerial bombs filled with sarin-type agents. UNMOVIC also reported that it w", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "url": "https://www.armscontrol.org/act/2003-07/inspectors-accomplishments-iraq-2002-2003", "title": "Inspectors' Accomplishments in Iraq, 2002-2003", "publisher": "armscontrol.org", "published_at": "2003-07-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:12.989488Z", "excerpt": "\"No one can solve this problem alone, but together we can change things for the better.\"\nInspectors' Accomplishments in Iraq, 2002-2003\nThe Iraqi government under Saddam Hussein continually stated that it had destroyed all of its prohibited weapons. However, Iraq’s UN-required declarations about its weapons programs never provided an adequate accounting of Baghdad’s weapons programs or proof that the weapons had been eliminated.\nThe May 30 report stated that inspections “contributed to a better understanding of previous weapons programmes,” but “the long list of…unresolved disarmament issues was not shortened either by the inspections or by Iraqi declarations and documentation.” The report added that, while Iraq “devoted much effort to providing explanations and proposing methods of inquiry” into outstanding disarmament issues, “little progress was made.”\nUN weapons inspectors began their work in Iraq November 27 and left March 18. Iraq submitted a declaration containing information about its weapons of mass destruction December 7, as required by UN Security Council Resolution 1441. Inspectors from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) conducted 237 inspections at 148 sites, including 27 sites not previously inspected. UNMOVIC inspectors conducted 731 inspections at 411 sites, including 88 sites not previously inspected. Of those inspections, 22 percent were related to chemical weapons, 28 percent to biological weapons, and 30 percent to missiles. The remaining 20 percent were multidisciplinary inspections, involving experts from each disarmament area.\nUNMOVIC carried out a total of eight aerial surveillance and monitoring missions by helicopter and 16 reconnaissance missions using U-2 and Mirage aircraft between mid-February and mid-March 2003.\nInspectors also conducted 14 private interviews with Iraqi scientists, out of 54 that they had requested, between January and March 2003. Iraq provided 31 lists of Iraqi scientists to UNMOVIC, five of which contained", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74", "url": "https://www.leadingtowar.com/claims_facts_nomobile.php", "title": "Leading To War :: a film that chronicles the path to war in Iraq", "publisher": "leadingtowar.com", "published_at": "2003-02-16", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:18.555408Z", "excerpt": "How did the U.S. government lead its people to war?\nBush Administration Claims vs. Facts\n\t\t \n\t\t\t\nNo mobile biological weapons labs were found in Iraq\n\t\t \n \n \n Pre-War Claims:  \n Senior members of the Bush administration claimed that Iraq possessed truck-mounted and train-mounted mobile biological weapons laboratories.\nFacts: \n There is no evidence of the existence of mobile bioweapons laboratories.\nThe chief source for the Bush administration’s claim was an Iraqi defector, codenamed “Curveball.” Prior to the invasion of Iraq, British intelligence, German intelligence, and analysts from the U.S. Defense Intelligence Agency and the CIA determined that Curveball was a fabricator, and was therefore completely unreliable as an intelligence source. Three other Iraqi defectors who corroborated Curveball’s claims were also found to be fabricators.\nBy May 2002, the Defense Intelligence Agency issued an official “fabrication notice” instructing other intelligence agencies to disregard the defector's information as unreliable.\nOverview:  \n Although Curveball and a former Iraqi intelligence service defector, who corroborated Curveball’s story, were both determined to be fabricators by multiple intelligence agencies before the war – and despite the fact that the Bush administration was briefed on this – Bush, Powell and other senior officials persisted in citing Curveball’s fictitious claims about the existence of mobile bioweapons labs as solid facts. \nTwo trailers found in Mosul and Irbil after the invasion were not mobile biological weapons labs\n \n [link to story and timeline] \n \n Two trailers were found in Iraq in late April 2003, five weeks after the war began, which the Bush administration contended were mobile bioweapons labs – proof of Iraq’s possession of WMD.  They held onto this position for eight months, despite the May 2003 conclusion of British, ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "url": "https://grokipedia.com/page/wmd_conjecture_after_the_2003_invasion_of_iraq", "title": "WMD conjecture after the 2003 invasion of Iraq — Grokipedia", "publisher": "Grokipedia", "published_at": "2025-12-24", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:12.526125Z", "excerpt": "The WMD conjecture after the 2003 invasion of Iraq encompasses the official investigations, empirical searches, and persistent hypotheses regarding the purported stockpiles of chemical, biological, and nuclear weapons that U.S. and allied intelligence had cited as an imminent threat justifying military action against Saddam Hussein's regime.[1][2] Despite pre-invasion assessments from agencies like the CIA asserting active programs and hidden caches, post-invasion efforts uncovered no operational stockpiles, prompting debates over intelligence accuracy, regime deception tactics, and potential pre-war destruction or concealment.[3][4]The Iraq Survey Group (ISG), a multinational team led by the CIA and including experts from the U.S., UK, and Australia, was tasked in June 2003 with systematically hunting for WMD evidence across Iraq's vast territory, interrogating officials, and analyzing documents from Saddam's fallen government.[2] Initial interim reports in 2003, under ISG head David Kay, hinted at possible hidden programs but yielded only degraded remnants, such as old chemical munitions from the 1980s Iran-Iraq War era, insufficient for current threats.[1] Kay's January 2004 resignation underscored the lack of findings, stating that pre-war intelligence had been profoundly flawed despite good-faith efforts by analysts.[5]The comprehensive Duelfer Report, released in September 2004 by ISG successor Charles Duelfer, provided the definitive assessment: Iraq had destroyed its known WMD stockpiles by 1991 under UN pressure following the Gulf War, with no evidence of reconstitution into viable programs amid ongoing sanctions, though dual-use infrastructure persisted and Saddam harbored ambitions to revive capabilities once economic constraints eased.[6][4] Biological agents were verifiably eliminated in 1991-1992, chemical production halted, and nuclear pursuits dormant without imported fissile material, contradicting earlier claims of advanced delivery systems or enri", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "url": "https://schakowsky.house.gov/media/press-releases/schakowsky-bush-administrations-misstatement-day-iraq-and-weapons-mass-1", "title": "SCHAKOWSKY: BUSH ADMINISTRATIONS MISSTATEMENT OF THE DAY IRAQ AND WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION", "publisher": "Congresswoman Jan Schakowsky", "published_at": "2003-09-25", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:45.469076Z", "excerpt": "SCHAKOWSKY: BUSH ADMINISTRATIONS MISSTATEMENT OF THE DAY IRAQ AND WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION\nJANUARY 26, 2004\nSCHAKOWSKY: BUSH ADMINISTRATION'S MISSTATEMENT OF THE DAY - \nIRAQ AND WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION\nWASHINGTON, D.C. - U.S. Representative Jan Schakowsky (D-IL) issued today's \"Bush Administration's Misstatement of the Day\" on Iraq and weapons of mass destruction.\nDr. David Kay, who resigned as head of the U.S. team in charge of locating Iraqi weapons of mass destruction, said today in a New York Times interview:\n\"I'm personally convinced that there were not large stockpiles of newly produced weapons of mass destruction. We don't find the people, the documents or the physical plants that you would expect to find if the production was going on. I think they [Iraq] gradually reduced stockpiles throughout the 1990's. Somewhere in the mid-1990's, the large chemical overhang of existing stockpiles was eliminated.\" (New York Times, 1/26/04)\n- \"We believe Saddam has, in fact, reconstituted nuclear weapons.\" - Vice President Cheney (NBC \"Meet the Press,\" 3/16/03)\n- \"There can be no doubt that Saddam Hussein has biological weapons and the capability to rapidly produce more, many more.Our conservative estimate is that Iraq today has a stockpile of between 100 and 500 tons of chemical weapons agent. That is enough agent to fill 16,000 battlefield rockets.\" - Secretary of State Colin Powell (Address before UN Security Council, 2/5/03)\n- \"Our intelligence officials estimate that Saddam Hussein had the materials to produce as much as 500 tons of sarin, mustard and VX nerve agent.\" - President Bush (State of the Union Address, 1/28/03)\n- \"Simply stated, there is no doubt that Saddam Hussein now has weapons of mass destruction. There is no doubt that he is amassing them to use against our friends, against our allies, and against us.\" -Vice President Cheney (Speech to VFW 103rd National Convention, 8/26/02)\nSchakowsky said, \"President Bush is accountable for the war in Iraq ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraqi_biological_weapons_program", "title": "Iraqi biological weapons program - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2008-11-17", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:18.451004Z", "excerpt": "Saddam Hussein (1937–2006) began an extensive biological weapons (BW) program in Iraq in the early 1980s, despite having signed (but not ratified until 1991) the Biological Weapons Convention (BWC) of 1972. Details of the BW program and a chemical weapons program surfaced after the Gulf War (1990–91) during the disarmament of Iraq under the United Nations Special Commission (UNSCOM). By the end of the war, program scientists had investigated the BW potential of five bacterial strains, one fungal strain, five types of virus, and four toxins.[1] Of these, three—anthrax, botulinum and aflatoxin—had proceeded to weaponization for deployment.[2] Because of the UN disarmament program that followed the war, more is known today about the once-secret bioweapons program in Iraq than that of any other nation.\nThe program no longer existed when the George W. Bush administration cited it as justification for its 2003 invasion of Iraq and the subsequent Iraq War.\nIn the early 1980s, five German firms supplied equipment to manufacture botulin toxin and mycotoxin to Iraq. Iraq's State Establishment for Pesticide Production (SEPP) also ordered culture media and incubators from Germany's Water Engineering Trading.[3] Strains of dual-use biological material from France also helped advance Iraq's biological warfare program.[4] From the United States, the non-profit American Type Culture Collection and the U.S. Centers for Disease Control sold or sent biological samples to Iraq up until 1989, which Iraq claimed to need for medical research. These materials included anthrax, West Nile virus and botulism, as well as Brucella melitensis, and Clostridium perfringens. Some of these materials were used for Iraq's biological weapons research program, while others were used for vaccine development.[5] In delivering these materials \"The CDC was abiding by World Health Organization guidelines that encouraged the free exchange of biological samples among medical researchers...\" according to Thomas", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "url": "https://www.armscontrol.org/factsheets/disarming-saddam-chronology-iraq-and-un-weapons-inspections-2002-2003", "title": "Disarming Saddam-A Chronology of Iraq and UN Weapons Inspections From 2002-2003", "publisher": "armscontrol.org", "published_at": "2025-04-09", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:15.758653Z", "excerpt": "Contact: Daryl Kimball, Executive Director, (202) 463-8270 x107\n \nPrior to the March 2003 U.S.-led invasion of Iraq, the UN Security Council adopted Resolution 1441 in November 2002 giving Iraq a “final opportunity” to comply with its disarmament requirements under previous Security Council resolutions. At issue was Iraq’s failure to provide an adequate accounting of its prohibited weapons programs or to convince UN inspectors that its weapons of mass destruction had been destroyed as Baghdad claimed.\nUN weapons inspectors worked in Iraq from November 27, 2002 until March 18, 2003. During that time, inspectors from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and the United Nations Monitoring, Verification, and Inspections Commission (UNMOVIC) conducted more than 900 inspections at more than 500 sites. The inspectors did not find that Iraq possessed chemical or biological weapons or that it had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\nAlthough Iraq was cooperative on what inspectors called “process”—allowing inspectors access to suspected weapons sites, for example—it was only marginally cooperative in answering the questions surrounding its weapons programs. Unable to resolve its differences with Security Council members who favored strengthening and continuing weapons inspections, the United States abandoned the inspections process and initiated the invasion of Iraq on March 19.\nFollowing is a summary of the major events of the decision to pursue, then abandon, UN weapons inspections in Iraq.\nJanuary 29, 2002: In his State of the Union address, President George W. Bush labels Iraq a member of an \"axis of evil,\" along with Iran and North Korea. The president's speech is the first of many statements by top U.S. officials on the dangers posed by Iraq. Several of these officials question the ultimate worth of arms inspections and advocate the overthrow of Iraqi President Saddam Hussein as the only way to guarantee that Iraq will not develop weapons of mass destruct", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8", "url": "https://news.un.org/en/story/2003/03/63182", "title": "Blix sees no evidence Iraq has used banned weapons", "publisher": "UN News", "published_at": "2003-03-27", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:24.610712Z", "excerpt": "Blix sees no evidence Iraq has used banned weapons\nAsked by reporters at UN Headquarters in New York about reports that Iraq had used missiles that exceeded the permitted 150-kilometre range, Mr. Blix, Executive Chairman of the UN Monitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission (UNMOVIC), said that what he had heard from the United States side was that they had not seen any Scud missiles.\nHe said his impression was the missiles used were Al Fatah with a range of around 150 kilometres or “a wee bit over.” Asked whether the use of such missiles was clearly a violation, he said: “No, but the inspectors would like to have accurate information about it.”\n“So far we have not identified or heard from the allies that anything that was proscribed would have been used,” he added.\nAsked whether he was “relieved” that there had not been any apparent use of chemical or biological weapons, which Iraq has denied having, Mr. Blix said he did not think the Iraqis would use them because then the world would say they were liars. “In the second place, it would also then change the attitude of the world towards the armed conflict,” he added. “The scepticism about the armed conflict would, I think, give way to one of greater understanding. So I didn’t think so, but I may be wrong.”\nVideo\nof Hans Blix speaking to reporters", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71", "url": "https://www.famouspictures.org/iraqi-mobile-production-facilities/", "title": "Iraqi Mobile Production Facilities", "publisher": "The Famous Pictures Collection", "published_at": "2013-05-16", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:18.351390Z", "excerpt": "Behind the camera: A computer graphic based on sketches created from the description of mobile bio labs from Iraqi informant, Curveball\nWhere: Federal Government\nPhoto Summary: Iraq’s supposed mobile weapons of mass destruction vehicles\nPicture Taken: First shown February 5, 2003\n This image is in the public domain because it was taken by a federal employee\nAfter the 911 attacks, the hawks in the Bush Whitehouse pushed for the invasion and overthrow of the Saddam regime. In order to build international support to mount an invasion of Iraq the Secretary of State in the Bush administration, General Colin Luther Powell, gave a presentation on the status of Iraq’s Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMDs). The speech given at a plenary session of the United Nations Security Council on February 5, 2003, was presented with Images of Iraq’s supposed WMD program including this image of Iraqi Mobile Production Facilities for biological weapons. The image was used by media around the world making it a household image.\nThe Intelligence\nThe reports of mobile biological weapons facilities emerged from supposed defectors of the Iraqi Weapons of Mass Destruction program. The Whitehouse cited four sources that claimed the mobile units existed.\nThe first reports came from an Iraqi defector, given the codename “curveball”, who came to Germany claiming asylum because he was accused by the Iraqi government of stealing money. In Nov 1999 Curveball changed his story claiming, to German intelligence agents, that he designed laboratory equipment to convert trucks into biological weapons laboratories. This intelligence was passed to the US who at that time were looking for evidence of mobile facilities.\nEven though British intelligence and other Iraqi defectors found much of Curveball’s testimony to be false, divisions of the CIA saw his accounts of the facilities supporting descriptions of mobile labs they found on the internet and even though foreign intelligence agencies and even other division", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad", "url": "https://www.un.org/depts/unmovic/new/documents/compendium_summary/s-2006-420-English.pdf", "title": "s-2006-420-English.pdf", "publisher": "un.org", "published_at": null, "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T15:01:10.863279Z", "excerpt": "United Nations S/2006/420\n \n \nSecurity Council \n \nDistr.: General \n21 June 2006 \n \nOriginal: English \n \n \n06-39907 (E) 190706 \n*0639907* \n United Nations Monito ring, Verification and \nInspection Commission \n \n \n Note by the Secretary-General \n \n \n The Secretary-General has the honour to transmit to the Security Council the \nsummary of the compendium of Iraq’s proscribed weapons programmes in the \nchemical, biological and missile areas. It has been prepared by the United Nations \nMonitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission (UNMOVIC) and is submitted \nby its Acting Executive Chairman. \nS/2006/420 \n \n06-39907 2 \n \n Summary of the compendium of Iraq’s proscribed weapons \nprogrammes in the chemical, biological and missile areas \n \n \nJune 2006 \n \n Foreword \n \n \n The United Nations experience in the disarmament of Iraq of its weapons of \nmass destruction (WMD) and dismantlement of related programmes is unique. After \nthe conclusion of the Gulf war, in 19 91, the United Nations Security Council \nadopted a series of resolutions under Chapter VII of the Charter of the United \nNations related to the Iraq-Kuwait conflict, including the creation in April of a \nUnited Nations inspection commission as a subsidiary body of the Council. It was \nthe first time that an international inspec tion regime was authorized to destroy, \nrender harmless or remove all facets of a country’s proscribed chemical, biological \nand missile programmes and to conduct s ubsequent monitoring to deter their \nrevival. \n In carrying out its mandate, the United Nations Special Commission \n(UNSCOM) was provided with unprecedented rights of access to Iraq’s relevant \nfacilities, personnel, documents and other materials. Despite varying degrees of \ncooperation from the Iraqi authorities at the time, the United Nations inspectors \nsuccessfully oversaw the destruction, re moval or rendering harmless of Iraq’s \ndeclared WMD programmes in the chemical, biological and missile areas. The \nCommission also impl", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "url": "https://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2003/02/20030205-1.html", "title": "Secretary of State Addresses the U.N. Security Council", "publisher": "georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov", "published_at": "2003-02-05", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:26.839875Z", "excerpt": "For Immediate Release\nFebruary 5, 2003\nU.S. Secretary of State Colin Powell Addresses the U.N. Security Council\nThis transcript includes the slides that were displayed during the remarks. They are placed in the text approximately where they were displayed in the address. To view the slides, click on the graphic (a pop-up window will appear).\nPOWELL: Thank you, Mr. President.\nMr. President, Mr. Secretary General, distinguished colleagues, I would like to begin by expressing my thanks for the special effort that each of you made to be here today.\nThis is important day for us all as we review the situation with respect to Iraq and its disarmament obligations under U.N. Security Council Resolution 1441.\nLast November 8, this council passed Resolution 1441 by a unanimous vote. The purpose of that resolution was to disarm Iraq of its weapons of mass destruction. Iraq had already been found guilty of material breach of its obligations, stretching back over 16 previous resolutions and 12 years.\nPOWELL: Resolution 1441 was not dealing with an innocent party, but a regime this council has repeatedly convicted over the years. Resolution 1441 gave Iraq one last chance, one last chance to come into compliance or to face serious consequences. No council member present in voting on that day had any allusions about the nature and intent of the resolution or what serious consequences meant if Iraq did not comply.\nAnd to assist in its disarmament, we called on Iraq to cooperate with returning inspectors from UNMOVIC and IAEA.\nWe laid down tough standards for Iraq to meet to allow the inspectors to do their job.\nPOWELL: This council placed the burden on Iraq to comply and disarm and not on the inspectors to find that which Iraq has gone out of its way to conceal for so long. Inspectors are inspectors; they are not detectives.\nI asked for this session today for two purposes: First, to support the core assessments made by Dr. Blix and Dr. ElBaradei. As Dr. Blix reported to this council ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio", "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e", "url": "https://carnegieendowment.org/russia-eurasia/research/2004/01/wmd-in-iraq", "title": "WMD in Iraq", "publisher": "Carnegie Endowment for International Peace", "published_at": "2004-01-07", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:42.077150Z", "excerpt": "The Islamic State’s ideology is multifaceted and cannot be traced to one individual, movement, or period. Understanding it is crucial to defeating the group.\n- Hassan Hassan\nDrawing useful lessons from experience begins with an accurate record of what happened. It is not too soon to begin this inquiry into the Iraq experience, because public confusion is widespread and revisionism has already begun. Some pundits now claim that the war was never about WMD but was undertaken to bring democracy to Iraq or the entire Middle East. Others say it was a response to 9/11 or was the necessary answer to a composite threat posed by Saddam Hussein's domestic evils, past aggressions, defiance of the United Nations, and desire for WMD. The administration has adjusted its public expectation of what Iraq will be found to have had from actual weapons and massive stockpiles of agent, to weapons programs, to \"capabilities,\" and even to the \"capability that Iraq sought\" for weapons of mass destruction. Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz has called WMD merely \"the one reason everyone could agree on,\" chosen for \"bureaucratic reasons.\"\nThe following is taken from a new Carnegie study, WMD in Iraq: Evidence and Implications. This report attempts to summarize and clarify the complex story of WMD and the Iraq war. It examines the unclassified record of prewar intelligence, administration statements of Iraq's capabilities to produce nuclear, chemical, and biological weapons and long-range missiles, and the evidence found to date in Iraq.\nDrawing useful lessons from experience begins with an accurate record of what \n happened. It is not too soon to begin this inquiry into the Iraq experience, \n because public confusion is widespread and revisionism has already begun. Some \n pundits now claim that the war was never about WMD but was undertaken to bring \n democracy to Iraq or the entire Middle East. Others say it was a response to \n 9/11 or was the necessary answer to a composite th", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76", "url": "https://carnegieendowment.org/russia-eurasia/posts/2004/03/a-tale-of-two-intelligence-estimates", "title": "A Tale of Two Intelligence Estimates", "publisher": "Carnegie Endowment for International Peace", "published_at": "2004-03-25", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:48.732977Z", "excerpt": "- Jessica Tuchman Mathews\n{\n \"authors\": [\n \"Jessica Tuchman Mathews\"\n ],\n \"type\": \"legacyinthemedia\",\n \"centerAffiliationAll\": \"\",\n \"centers\": [\n \"Carnegie Endowment for International Peace\"\n ],\n \"collections\": [],\n \"englishNewsletterAll\": \"\",\n \"nonEnglishNewsletterAll\": \"\",\n \"primaryCenter\": \"Carnegie Endowment for International Peace\",\n \"programAffiliation\": \"\",\n \"programs\": [],\n \"projects\": [],\n \"regions\": [\n \"United States\",\n \"Iraq\"\n ],\n \"topics\": [\n \"Nuclear Policy\"\n ]\n}\nSource: Carnegie\nWMD in Iraq: Evidence and Implications details how the intelligence community and administration officials misconstrued the threat posed by Iraq’s weapon programs and outlines intelligence reforms and policy changes stemming from this incident. In this new analysis, the authors focus exclusively on differing versions of the key CIA document, the National Intelligence Estimate. A comparison suggests that before the crucial congressional vote the intelligence community itself misrepresented information in a highly significant way.\nThe failure to find weapons of mass destruction (WMD) in Iraq is frequently portrayed as the result of either intelligence failures or misrepresentation of the intelligence by others. In fact, both were involved. It appears that a third factor was involved as well: misrepresentation of intelligence by the intelligence community itself.\nOne week before lawmakers were to vote on the use of force in Iraq, the CIA released an unclassified version of its just-completed National Intelligence Estimate (NIE). As the intelligence community's definitive judgments on key issues, NIEs are always important documents on which great care is expended. However, this NIE was unusually important because it was the authoritative assessment of the Iraqi threat available to members of Congress on which to base a decision whether to support or oppose a war.\nA close comparison of the unclassified version (CIA White Paper: \"Iraq's Weapons of Mass", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "url": "https://www.cia.gov/readingroom/", "title": "Library", "publisher": "CIA FOIA (foia.cia.gov)", "published_at": "2000-01-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:06.754168Z", "excerpt": "Freedom of Information Act Electronic Reading Room\nWhat's New on the Electronic Reading Room?\nNixon and the People’s Republic of China: CIA’s Support of the Historic 1972 Presidential Trip\nThis collection marks the 50th anniversary of President Richard M. Nixon’s February 1972 trip to the People’s Republic of China (PRC) – a landmark event that preceded the establishment of diplomatic relations between the two countries. This small collection, consisting of three city guides, an atlas, and four leadership profiles, is a subset of the materials CIA produced for President Nixon and National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger in preparation for the seven-day visit.\nCity guides were produced on Peking (Beijing), Shanghai, and Hang-Chou (Hangzhou)1, as these cities were part of President Nixon’s tour of the PRC. Each guide included a brief history of the city, contemporary maps and photographs, and descriptions of geography, climates, and points of interest.\nCIA also produced an 82-page atlas of the PRC for President Nixon’s trip. The US government distributed more than 4,000 copies to government customers and non-government institutions and libraries, and sold 30,000 copies to the public for a short period after the trip for $5.25, or $35.19 in today’s dollars. This is the first time in fifty years CIA has made the atlas available to the public.\nThis collection also includes leadership profiles—assessments that CIA provides US Presidents and other policymakers to assist them in understanding their foreign counterparts. The profiles in this collection include Chinese Communist Party (CCP) Chairman Mao Tse-tung (Mao Zedong) and Premier Chou En-lai (Zhou Enlai). A profile of Lin Piao (Lin Biao), Vice Chair of the CCP, prepared for this trip is also included in this collection; however, Lin died in a plane crash five months before President Nixon’s visit.\n_____________________\n1 CIA did not begin using the non-Romanization spelling of Beijing and Hangzhou until 1979. This art", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "url": "https://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/world/iraq/bw-prewar2003.htm", "title": "Biological Weapons Program", "publisher": "globalsecurity.org", "published_at": "2002-09-24", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:18.886006Z", "excerpt": "Biological Weapons Program\n2003 Prewar Assessment\nIn the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate (NIE), the Intelligence Community (IC) judged that all key aspects - R&D, production, and weaponization - of Iraq's offensive BW program were active and that most elements were larger and more advanced than they were before the Gulf war. To support the assessment that Iraq's offensive BW program was larger and more advanced than it was before the Gulf War, and that Iraq had biological weapons, the NIE made the following assessments:\n- Baghdad had transportable facilities for producing bacterial and toxin BW agents.\n- Baghdad was able to renovate and expand its fixed dual-use BW agent production facilities.\n- IC assessed that Iraq had some BW agents and maintained the capability to produce a variety of BW agents.\n- In the absence of UN inspectors, Iraq probably intensified and expanded research and development in support of Iraq's BW program. Baghdad probably developed genetically engineered BW agents.\n- We assess that Baghdad also has increased the effectiveness of its BW arsenal by mastering the ability to produce dried agent.\n- Iraq's capability to manufacture equipment and materials . . . and to procure other necessary, dual-use materials . . . makes large-scale BW agent production easily attainable.\n- The nature and amounts of Iraq's stored BW material remain unresolved by LJNSCOM accounting.\n- We judge that we are seeing only a portion of Iraq's WMD efforts, owing to Baghdad's vigorous denial and deception efforts.\nThe October 2002 NIE, although expressing similar views to earlier intelligence regarding Iraqi BW, expressed far greater levels of certainty in its conclusions than did previous estimates. Many of the uncertainties that were expressed in all previous IC assessments about what was known about the BW program were not contained in the NIE's text. The starkest shift was the judgment that \"Baghdad has. . . biological weapons.\" All previous assessments had", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "url": "https://www.un.org/depts/unmovic/documents/2003-232.pdf", "title": "2003-232.pdf", "publisher": "un.org", "published_at": null, "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T15:01:10.827797Z", "excerpt": "United Nations S/2003/232\n \nSecurity Council Distr.: General\n28 February 2003\nOriginal: English\n03-26060 (E) 270203 270203\n*0326060*\nNote by the Secretary-General\nThe Secretary-General has the honour to transmit to the Security Council the\ntwelfth quarterly report of the Executive Chairman of the United Nations\nMonitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission (UNMOVIC), which is\nsubmitted in accordance with paragraph 12 of Security Council resolution 1284\n(1999) of 17 December 1999 (see annex).\n2\nS/2003/232\nAnnex\nTwelfth quarterly report of the Executive Chairman of the\nUnited Nations Monitoring, Verification and Inspection\nCommission in accordance with paragraph 12 of Security\nCouncil resolution 1284 (1999)\nIntroduction\n1. The present report, which is the twelfth a submitted in accordance with\nparagraph 12 of Security Council resolution 1284 (1999), covers the activities of the\nUnited Nations Monitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission (UNMOVIC)\nduring the period from 1 December 2002 to 28 February 2003.\n2. The period under review has been one of intense activity for the Commission.\nIn Iraq, inspections and monitoring were resumed on 27 November 2002, requiring a\nrapid build-up of inspection and support staff and the resolution of operational and\nlogistics issues. In New York the analysis of Iraq’s declarations and unresolved\ndisarmament issues went hand in hand with intense planning of inspections and\nadministrative activities.\nBriefings and consultations by the Executive Chairman\n3. In the period under review, the Executive Chairman of UNMOVIC briefed the\nSecurity Council informally on 19 December 2002 and 9 January 2003 on the\ndeclaration presented by Iraq on 7 December in response to paragraph 3 of Security\nCouncil resolution 1441 (2002), and on the progress of inspections in Iraq and other\nUNMOVIC activities. In accordance with paragraph 5 of the same resolution, he\nupdated the Council on 27 January on the resumption of inspection activities. He\nalso ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "url": "https://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/library/report/2004/isg-final-report/isg-final-report_vol2_nuclear-02.htm", "title": "Iraq Survey Group Final Report", "publisher": "globalsecurity.org", "published_at": "2026-01-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:25.478782Z", "excerpt": "Iraq Survey Group Final Report\nResults of ISG’s Investigation on Nuclear Issues\n\t \n\t Iraq did not possess a nuclear device, nor had it tried to reconstitute a capability to produce nuclear weapons after 1991. \n\t \nISG has uncovered no information to support allegations of Iraqi pursuit of uranium from abroad in the post-Operation Desert Storm era. \n \n- In the late 1970s and early 1980s, Iraq had an aggressive program to acquire uranium. Iraq’s known inventory of safeguarded uranium has been accounted for by the IAEA and Coalition in June 2004. These issues are described in detail in the uranium pursuits section of this paper. \nIraq did not reconstitute its indigenous ability to produce yellowcake. As a result of Desert Storm and IAEA inspection efforts, Iraq’s indigenous yellowcake production capability appears to have been eliminated. Bomb damage in 1991 destroyed the uranium extraction facility at the Al Qaim Superphosphate Fertilizer Plant. During the years of intrusive inspections, the IAEA also closed and sealed the Abu Skhair mine to curtail Iraq’s secondary pilot plant production capability for acquiring uranium. \n \n- ISG also investigated the former nuclear facility at Tarmiya but found no indicators that the processes being developed there had produced more than a few kilograms of uranium-bearing wastes as a byproduct of phosphoric acid purification. \n- These issues also are further described in the uranium pursuits section of this paper.\nPost-1991, Iraq had neither rebuilt any capability to convert uranium ore into a form suitable for enrichment nor reestablished other chemical processes related to handling fissile material for a weapons program. Prior to the 1991 war, Iraq had established uranium conversion and feed material capabilities at the Tuwaitha Nuclear Research Center—Baghdad’s premier nuclear center—as well as a feed material plant near Mosul called Al-Jazira. Iraq also was establishing chemical processes at Tarmiya, an", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9", "url": "https://www.un.org/depts/unmovic/SC7asdelivered.htm", "title": "Security Council 7 March 2003", "publisher": "un.org", "published_at": "2003-03-07", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:41.825052Z", "excerpt": "������������������� As delivered\n \n \n \nSECURITY COUNCIL 7 MARCH 2003\n \nOral introduction of the 12th quarterly report of UNMOVIC\nExecutive Chairman Dr. Hans Blix\n \n \n \n \nMr. President,\n \n \nFor nearly three years, I have been coming to the Security Council presenting the quarterly reports of UNMOVIC.� They have described our many preparations for the resumption of inspections in Iraq.� The 12th quarterly report is the first that describes three months of inspections.� They come after four years without inspections.� The report was finalized ten days ago and a number of relevant events have taken place since then.� Today�s statement will supplement the circulated report on these points to bring the Council up-to-date.\n�\n \nInspections in Iraq resumed on 27 November 2002.� In matters relating to process, notably prompt access to sites, we have faced relatively few difficulties and certainly much less than those that were faced by UNSCOM in the period 1991 to 1998.� This may well be due to the strong outside pressure.\n \nSome practical matters, which were not settled by the talks, Dr. ElBaradei and I had with the Iraqi side in Vienna prior to inspections or in resolution 1441 (2002), have been resolved at meetings, which we have had in Baghdad.� Initial difficulties raised by the Iraqi side about helicopters and aerial surveillance planes operating in the no-fly zones were overcome.� This is not to say that the operation of inspections is free from frictions, but at this juncture we are able to perform professional no-notice inspections all over Iraq and to increase aerial surveillance.\n \n \n \nAmerican U-2 and French Mirage surveillance aircraft already give us valuable imagery, supplementing satellite pictures and we would expect soon to be able to add night vision capability through an aircraft offered to us by the Russian Federation.� We also expect to add low-level, close area surveillance through drones provided by Germany.� We are grateful not only to the countries, ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d", "url": "https://www.armscontrol.org/blog/2013-03-05/cost-ignoring-un-inspectors-unnecessary-war-iraq", "title": "The Cost of Ignoring UN Inspectors: An Unnecessary War with Iraq", "publisher": "armscontrol.org", "published_at": "2013-03-05", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:47.923881Z", "excerpt": "IAEA Director General Mohamed ElBaradei (L) and UNMOVIC Executive Chairman Hans Blix (R) brief the UN Security Council on Iraq inspections March 7, 2003\nBy Greg Thielmann\nOn March 7, ten years ago, the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and the UN Special Commission on Iraq (UNMOVIC) reported to the UN Security Council on the latest results of their inspections in Iraq, monitoring enforcement of the Council's demand that Saddam Hussein eliminate his weapons of mass destruction (WMD) and related programs.\nThe IAEA's Director General, Mohamed ElBaradei, and UNMOVIC's Executive Chairman, Hans Blix, both reported progress, following the return of UN inspectors to Iraq in November 2002, in resolving critical questions about the current status of Iraq's WMD programs.\nBased on more than a hundred visits to suspect sites and private interviews with a number of individual scientists known to have been involved with WMD programs in the past, ElBaradei stated that the IAEA had \"to date found no evidence or plausible indication of the revival of a nuclear weapons programme in Iraq\" and predicted that the agency should be able to provide that Security Council with an objective and thorough assessment of Iraq's nuclear related capabilities \"in the near future.\"\nBlix reported that destruction of Iraq's al Samoud ballistic missiles, which had exhibited ranges beyond that allowed by the UN, was underway. Concerning the status of Iraq's chemical and biological weapons programs, Blix was less categorical. No stockpiles or active programs had been found, but it had not yet been possible to document destruction of all the weapons known to have been produced prior to the 1991 Gulf War. Blitz predicted that months but not years, would be needed to complete the job.\nWashington Dismisses the Inspectors' Findings\nThe Bush administration's response to the inspectors' reports was swift and negative, because their conclusions contradicted the allegations previously made by the U.S. gover", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "url": "https://www.cnn.com/2003/US/02/05/sprj.irq.powell.transcript.07/index.html", "title": "Transcript of Powell's U.N. presentation", "publisher": "CNN.com - Transcript of Powell's U.N. presentation", "published_at": "2003-02-05", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:25.640574Z", "excerpt": "Transcript of Powell's U.N. presentation\nPart 7: Nuclear weapons\nLet me turn now to nuclear weapons. We have no indication that Saddam Hussein has ever abandoned his nuclear weapons program.\nOn the contrary, we have more than a decade of proof that he remains determined to acquire nuclear weapons.\nTo fully appreciate the challenge that we face today, remember that, in 1991, the inspectors searched Iraq's primary nuclear weapons facilities for the first time. And they found nothing to conclude that Iraq had a nuclear weapons program.\nBut based on defector information in May of 1991, Saddam Hussein's lie was exposed. In truth, Saddam Hussein had a massive clandestine nuclear weapons program that covered several different techniques to enrich uranium, including electromagnetic isotope separation, gas centrifuge, and gas diffusion. We estimate that this illicit program cost the Iraqis several billion dollars.\nNonetheless, Iraq continued to tell the IAEA that it had no nuclear weapons program. If Saddam had not been stopped, Iraq could have produced a nuclear bomb by 1993, years earlier than most worse-case assessments that had been made before the war.\nIn 1995, as a result of another defector, we find out that, after his invasion of Kuwait, Saddam Hussein had initiated a crash program to build a crude nuclear weapon in violation of Iraq's U.N. obligations.\nSaddam Hussein already possesses two out of the three key components needed to build a nuclear bomb. He has a cadre of nuclear scientists with the expertise, and he has a bomb design.\nSince 1998, his efforts to reconstitute his nuclear program have been focused on acquiring the third and last component, sufficient fissile material to produce a nuclear explosion. To make the fissile material, he needs to develop an ability to enrich uranium.\nSaddam Hussein is determined to get his hands on a nuclear bomb.\nHe is so determined that he has made repeated covert attempts to acquire high-specification aluminum tubes f", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0", "url": "https://www.armscontrol.org/act/2004-03/news/kay-revives-fracas-over-us-intelligence-iraq", "title": "Kay Revives Fracas Over U.S. Intelligence on Iraq", "publisher": "Kay Revives Fracas Over U.S. Intelligence on Iraq", "published_at": "2004-03-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:41.825776Z", "excerpt": "Kay Revives Fracas Over U.S. Intelligence on Iraq\nThe Bush administration is facing a formidable diplomatic and political challenge after a key official said that he expected any weapons hunt in Iraq will prove largely futile.\n The CIA announced Jan. 23 that David Kay was stepping down as its adviser to the Iraq Survey Group (ISG), the task force charged with coordinating the U.S.-led search for Iraqi weapons of mass destruction (WMD) after the U.S.-led invasion of that country in March 2003. The same day, Kay began a series of public discussions of his results, further fueling the ongoing controversy over the failures of prewar U.S. intelligence and the Bush administration to accurately portray the status of Iraq’s weapons programs.\n Kay said that he did not expect the search to turn up any significant chemical or biological weapons stockpiles and that he believed Iraq destroyed its prohibited chemical and biological weapons produced before the 1991 Persian Gulf War, either unilaterally or under the supervision of UN weapons inspectors who worked in Iraq from 1991 until 1998. Iraq did not resume large-scale production after destroying these weapons, and there is no evidence that it reconstituted its nuclear weapons program, he said.\n Kay’s claims run counter to public speculation by President George W. Bush and administration officials that Iraq may have destroyed or moved its prohibited weapons just prior to the invasion or that the weapons remain hidden. The administration has set up an independent commission to investigate the matter, but critics question whether it will address some of the most pressing questions about the intelligence, particularly whether the president and other senior officials distorted or manipulated the information they were provided by the intelligence agencies.\n Administration officials continue to emphasize that the ISG must finish its work before any conclusions about Iraq’s weapons programs can be reached. Kay told the Senate Armed S", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "url": "https://carnegieendowment.org/russia-eurasia/research/2004/02/powell-proved-deception-but-not-imminent-threat", "title": "Powell Proved Deception, But Not Imminent Threat", "publisher": "Carnegie Endowment for International Peace", "published_at": "2004-02-03", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:45.125276Z", "excerpt": "The Islamic State’s ideology is multifaceted and cannot be traced to one individual, movement, or period. Understanding it is crucial to defeating the group.\n- Hassan Hassan\nOn the one year anniversary of secretary of State Colin Powell's presentation to the UN Security Council, we are re-posting Project Director Joseph Cirincione's analysis of the secretary's remarks at that time.\n(Originally posted February 5, 2003) Secretary of State Colin Powell calmly detailed before the United Nations Security Council US evidence of Iraq's failure to comply fully with UN disarmament orders. While the secretary focused on Iraqi deception, most nations remained fixed on the threat. They did not hear any new evidence that the danger from Iraq was urgent or severe enough to justify the extreme step of authorizing an invasion and occupation of an Arab state.Within the Arab world, the editorial opinion of the Jordan Times was typical: the speech \"did not amount to convincing evidence…that Iraq presents any real or imminent danger.\" The Times argues that the US charges \"can only be answered by allowing the UN inspectors the time, resources and support neede to carry out their mandate.\"\nOn the one year anniversary of secretary of State Colin Powell's presentation \n to the UN Security Council, we are re-posting Project Director Joseph Cirincione's \n analysis of the secretary's remarks at that time.\n \n (Originally posted February 5, 2003) Secretary of State Colin Powell calmly \n detailed before the United Nations Security Council US evidence of Iraq's failure \n to comply fully with UN disarmament orders. While the secretary focused on Iraqi \n deception, most nations remained fixed on the threat. They did not hear any \n new evidence that the danger from Iraq was urgent or severe enough to justify \n the extreme step of authorizing an invasion and occupation of an Arab state.Within \n the Arab world, the editorial opinion of the Jordan Times was typical: \n the speech \"did not amo", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "bio", "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "url": "https://www.cnn.com/2004/WORLD/meast/10/06/iraq.wmd.report/", "title": "Report: No WMD stockpiles in Iraq", "publisher": "CNN.com - Report: No WMD stockpiles in Iraq", "published_at": "2004-10-07", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:16.666823Z", "excerpt": "Report: No WMD stockpiles in Iraq\nCIA: Saddam intended to make arms if sanctions ended\nWASHINGTON (CNN) -- Saddam Hussein did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the U.S. invasion in March 2003 and had not begun any program to produce them, a CIA report concludes.\nIn fact, the long-awaited report, authored by Charles Duelfer, who advises the director of central intelligence on Iraqi weapons, says Iraq's WMD program was essentially destroyed in 1991 and Saddam ended Iraq's nuclear program after the 1991 Gulf War.\nThe Iraq Survey Group report, released Wednesday, is 1,200 to 1,500 pages long.\nThe massive report does say, however, that Iraq worked hard to cheat on United Nations-imposed sanctions and retain the capability to resume production of weapons of mass destruction at some time in the future.\n\"[Saddam] wanted to end sanctions while preserving the capability to reconstitute his weapons of mass destruction when sanctions were lifted,\" a summary of the report says.\nDuelfer, testifying at a Senate hearing on the report, said his account attempts to describe Iraq's weapons programs \"not in isolation but in the context of the aims and objectives of the regime that created and used them.\"\n\"I also have insisted that the report include as much basic data as reasonable and that it be unclassified, since the tragedy that has been Iraq has exacted such a huge cost for so many for so long,\" Duelfer said.\nThe report was released nearly two years ago to the day that President Bush strode onto a stage in Cincinnati and told the audience that Saddam Hussein's Iraq \"possesses and produces chemical and biological weapons\" and \"is seeking nuclear weapons.\"\n\"The danger is already significant and it only grows worse with time,\" Bush said in the speech delivered October 7, 2002. \"If we know Saddam Hussein has dangerous weapons today -- and we do -- does it make any sense for the world to wait to confront him as he grows even stronger and develops even more danger", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4", "url": "https://www.armscontrol.org/factsheets/chronology-bush-administration-claim-iraq-attempted-obtain-uranium-niger-2001-2003", "title": "Chronology of Bush Administration Claim that Iraq Attempted to Obtain Uranium from Niger (2001-2003)", "publisher": "armscontrol.org", "published_at": "2025-04-09", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T14:18:48.978958Z", "excerpt": "Contacts: Daryl G. Kimball, Executive Director, (202) 463-8270 x107\nOne of the chief arguments used by the Bush administration to justify the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq in March 2003 was that Saddam Hussein's Iraq was reconstituting its nuclear weapons program. For example, only three days before U.S.-led coalition forces invaded Iraq Vice President Dick Cheney claimed that Iraq had \"reconstituted nuclear weapons.\" Central to the administration's argument were erroneous claims that Iraq had recently attempted to obtain lightly-processed uranium, or \"yellowcake,\" from Africa and that it had attempted to acquire specialized aluminum tubes as part of a uranium enrichment program to produce fissile material, which is necessary for making nuclear weapons.\nThe claim regarding the uranium deal has become particularly contentious because President George W. Bush cited it in his January 28, 2003 State of the Union Address and because officials in the White House and the Office of Vice President Cheney waged a public campaign to discredit former Ambassador Joseph Wilson, who publicly challenged the uranium claim in the summer of 2003. The administration's claims regarding Iraq's pre-war capabilities are the subject of the delayed, \"second phase\" of the investigation by the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence.\nContrary to White House assertions that the \"intelligence was all wrong,\" as early as a year before the invasion U.S. intelligence assessments and senior U.S. officials disagreed about the reliability of the information supporting the main nuclear weapons-related assertions. Furthermore, International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) inspectors working on the ground in Iraq found no evidence that Baghdad had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\nThe chronology of events involving the internal intelligence assessments and international inspections clearly demonstrates that senior Bush officials overlooked intelligence assessments that cast doubt on the claim that Iraq ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "url": "https://www.armscontrol.org/act/2005-03/iraq-weapons-hunt-ends-other-investigations-continue", "title": "Iraq Weapons Hunt Ends; Other Investigations Continue", "publisher": "armscontrol.org", "published_at": "2005-03-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:19.777520Z", "excerpt": "\"No one can solve this problem alone, but together we can change things for the better.\"\nIraq Weapons Hunt Ends; Other Investigations Continue\nThe Bush administration has essentially wrapped up its investigation of Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction (WMD) programs and of the failure to find significant stockpiles of such weapons after the U.S.-led invasion of that country in March 2003. Several related investigations, however, are still ongoing.\n White House Press Secretary Scott McClellan told reporters Jan. 12 that a final report from Charles Duelfer, the head adviser to the Iraq Survey Group (ISG), is not expected to add any new information to an interim report Duelfer issued in September 2004, which said that Iraq had no WMD stockpiles. McClellan described the final report as an “addendum,” adding that the September report is “essentially the completion” of Duelfer’s work. (See ACT, November 2004.) Run by the Defense Intelligence Agency, the ISG is the task force charged with coordinating the U.S.-led WMD search. \n Before the U.S.-led invasion, Bush administration officials claimed that Iraq possessed chemical and biological weapons and had an active nuclear weapons program. The threat posed by these weapons was a key administration justification for beginning the war. UN weapons inspectors reported prior to the invasion that they had not found any evidence that Iraq either had WMD stockpiles or had reconstituted its related programs. They had, however, not been able to account for the disposition of some of Iraq’s previous chemical and biological weapons stockpiles and related materials.\n Despite the subsequent failure to find such stockpiles, administration officials have continued to argue that the invasion was necessary because deposed Iraqi President Saddam Hussein still had the capability and intent to develop such weapons. These officials frequently add that Hussein would have produced prohibited weapons if UN economic sanctions imposed after the 19", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "bio", "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg", "google" ] }, { "id": "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "url": "https://www.justice.gov/archive/osc/exhibits/0207/GX2A.pdf", "title": "GX2A.pdf", "publisher": "justice.gov", "published_at": null, "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T15:01:10.887243Z", "excerpt": "Government Exhibit 2A \nBates Numbers \n001445-001464 \n........,....,.. ..... _ .... _ ............ 9 .... .... ... ......... I.. .,.. .,. .. .. . \nDECLASSIFIED \nOFFICE .OF THE VICE PRESIDENT \nWASHINGTON \nSUBLECT: InfornatTon: CIA Paper on Purported Iraq-Niger Uranium Ded \nAttached please find a CIA paper on the Iraq-Niger deaf that was sent to tre todsy. It is \ndated April 3,2003. The paper was drafted as part ofa Congrtssional Notitication We have \nalso attached a New Yotker article by Sy Hersh on the isaue, which we are reviewing, \nSome of tbe highlights fiom the CIA paper include the following: \nOn February 14,2002, CIA wrote that \"infomation on the alleged uranium contract between \nIraq and Nigw comes exclusively &om a foreign govement service report that lacks crucial \ndetails, and we are working to clarify the information and to detenaine whether it can be \ncat.roborated.\" para 4) \nAccording to the CIA paper, the &st reaI indicatjon that the CIA bsd serious conocrns about \nthe stream ofrcp~rting on Iraq-Niger does n \nCIA paper, in tire run-up to the September 24 \nhad \"e rased concerns about the credibility \nXD Tht paper claims that \n\"the British countered CIA concems . . . by cl \nIraq sought uranium fiom Africa.\" According to the CIA, 'This aIlegt& corroborating \n*Warmtion; hwcve~+wsa8t -dured8with us.2.@ara 8) . - - ...- - \n- - \n' \nOn the day the British White Paper was released, a \"senior IC official#' told the Senate \nForeign Relations Committee '%at his analysts rejected the idea that hq could obtain \nwanitun from Niger, indicating they had concerns about the reporting.\" On 0otober 45 CIA \noficexs told the Senate Intelligence Committee that the Iraq-Niger deal was one of two \npoints on which the U.S. diffkred from the British assessment of iraq's WMD. (Para 9) \nNevezthelesS, the October lLkNIE on Iraq's \\WD stated that ''Iraq also began vigorously \ntrying to pew uranium ore and yellowcake . . , . A foreign government service reported . \nthat as of early 200", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "google" ] }, { "id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Monitoring,_Verification_and_Inspection_Commission", "title": "United Nations Monitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2002-10-04", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:06.748992Z", "excerpt": "The United Nations Monitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission (UNMOVIC) was created through the adoption of United Nations Security Council resolution 1284 of 17 December 1999 and its mission lasted until June 2007.[1]\nUNMOVIC was meant to replace the former United Nations Special Commission (UNSCOM) to carry on with the mandate to disarm Iraq of its weapons of mass destruction (WMDs), and to operate a system of ongoing monitoring and verification to check Iraq's compliance with its obligations not to reacquire the same weapons banned by the Security Council.[citation needed]\nUNSCOM was created with the adoption of United Nations Security Council Resolution 687 in April 1991.\nLack of cooperation between UNSCOM and the Iraqi government, plus Saddam Hussein's failure to provide unfettered access to UN arms inspectors, led the United States and the United Kingdom to launch air strikes during Operation Desert Fox. Along with founded suspicion of the CIA interference and infiltration in UNSCOM,[2] military intervention in Iraq in 16–18 December 1998 marked the virtual end of UNSCOM's legitimacy. Those facts led to its closing down and to, at least, one-year hiatus regarding weapon inspections in Iraq.[citation needed]\nUNMOVIC was created with the adoption of United Nations Security Council Resolution 1284 in December 1999.\nIn addition to the Office of the Chairman with executive, legal and liaison functions, UNMOVIC comprised four divisions (Planning and Operations, Analysis and Assessment, Information, Technical Support and Training) as well as an administrative service. The Commission maintained its headquarters at the United Nations in New York.[citation needed]\nIn December 1999 UNMOVIC was to take the token and even though Resolution 1284 required its inspection teams allowance to \"immediate and unconditional access to any weapons sites and facilities\", Iraq rejected the resolution. UNMOVIC could not send inspections to Iraq well into November 2002 after Reso", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "chem", "bio" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colin_Powell's_presentation_to_the_United_Nations_Security_Council", "title": "Colin Powell's presentation to the United Nations Security Council - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2023-04-15", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-16T05:42:24.055609Z", "excerpt": "On February 5, 2003, the secretary of state of the United States Colin Powell gave a PowerPoint presentation to the United Nations Security Council asserting that Iraq was in violation of UN Security Resolution 1441 and was in the process of producing chemical weapons of mass destruction. Powell stated that Iraq had repeatedly refused to work with inspectors from UNMOVIC and IAEA and citing U.S. intelligence reports, was producing WMD's and was involved with terrorism, all in violation of Resolution 1441.[1][2]\nUN secretary-general Kofi Annan called the presentation strong and thorough, urged Iraqi leadership to comply with Resolution 1441, and stated that he did not think war was inevitable.[3] The validity of the cited intelligence reports was called into question with Powell later stating his speech was a \"great intelligence failure\" and calling it a \"blot\" on his reputation.[4][5]\nOn February 5, 2003, Powell appeared before the UN to prove the urgency to engage a war with Iraq. In 2016, Powell would say, \"[A]t the time I gave the speech on Feb. 5, the president had already made this decision for military action.\" Powell was selected to deliver the speech based on his credibility, and he stated in 2016 that it had been written by the vice president's office:[6]\nThe speech supposedly had been prepared in the White House in the United States National Security Council. But when we were given what had been prepared, it was totally inadequate, and we couldn't track anything in it. When I asked Condoleezza Rice, the national security advisor, where did this come from, it turns out the vice president's office had written it.\nCIA analyst Nada Bakos has stated that the speech's language differed from what the CIA prepared for Powell and from the copies the CIA received in advance of the presentation.[7]\nMy second purpose today is ... to share with you what the United States knows about Iraq's weapons of mass destruction ... Iraq's behavior demonstrate that Saddam Hussein ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/iraq-wmd-2003/20260917T022244Z/text/fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "nuke" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] } ], "judgments": [ { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is reputable science journalism from a peer-reviewed publication (Chemical & Engineering News) that directly cites and summarizes findings from the official Iraq Survey Group report and Duelfer's Senate testimony—primary sources and official records. The sourcing is transparent and named, though the article itself is secondary reporting rather than the primary documents themselves.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate armed services committee 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is reputable science journalism from a peer-reviewed publication (Chemical & Engineering News) that directly cites and summarizes findings from the official Iraq Survey Group report and Duelfer's Senate testimony—primary sources and official records. The sourcing is transparent and named, though the article itself is secondary reporting rather than the primary documents themselves.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active biological weapons production program in March 2003, reporting the Iraq Survey Group's findings that Iraq had destroyed its biological weapons stockpiles in the early 1990s and found no evidence of active BW production programs before the 2003 invasion.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that the Iraq Survey Group, after 16 months of searching, found no evidence of WMD arsenals or active programs before the 2003 invasion, and that Iraq had destroyed its biological weapons stockpiles in the early 1990s with no plans to resume BW production after 1995.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"senate armed services committee 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3139, "completion_tokens": 1922, "total_tokens": 5061, "reasoning_tokens": 1739 }, "cost_usd": 0.01132019, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.202158Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "NBC News is a reputable news organization reporting on an official primary source (the CIA's Iraq Survey Group final report and addenda by Charles Duelfer, a named official). The article directly cites the official document and includes specific details (92 pages, 1,500-page report, 18 months of investigation), though it is secondary reporting of the primary document rather than the document itself.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"NBC News is a reputable news organization reporting on an official primary source (the CIA's Iraq Survey Group final report and addenda by Charles Duelfer, a named official). The article directly cites the official document and includes specific details (92 pages, 1,500-page report, 18 months of investigation), though it is secondary reporting of the primary document rather than the document itself.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held WMD stockpiles or active programs in March 2003 by reporting the CIA's final conclusion that the investigation found nothing, though it focuses on post-invasion findings rather than the specific March 2003 timeframe.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that after 18+ months of investigation by the CIA's Iraq Survey Group with over 1,000 experts, the WMD hunt 'has found nothing,' directly contradicting the sub-claim that Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfers\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2980, "completion_tokens": 359, "total_tokens": 3339, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00493796, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.202543Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is the Iraq Survey Group Final Report, an official U.S. government inquiry document with named institutional authorship, systematic methodology, and primary investigative findings from 2003-2004. While hosted on globalsecurity.org (a secondary source aggregator), the underlying document represents an authoritative primary record of an official investigation, though the excerpt's self-critical tone about methodological limitations slightly prevents a perfect 1.0 rating.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is the Iraq Survey Group Final Report, an official U.S. government inquiry document with named institutional authorship, systematic methodology, and primary investigative findings from 2003-2004. While hosted on globalsecurity.org (a secondary source aggregator), the underlying document represents an authoritative primary record of an official investigation, though the excerpt's self-critical tone about methodological limitations slightly prevents a perfect 1.0 rating.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the Iraq Survey Group's investigation of Iraqi WMD stockpiles as of March 2003 and their findings, though this excerpt focuses on methodology rather than specific conclusions about stockpile status.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a scope note describing the ISG's investigation methodology and does not directly address whether Iraq held chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003; it only notes that prewar planning assumed such stocks were likely to exist.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2865, "completion_tokens": 315, "total_tokens": 3180, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0046160707195, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.202700Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia article relaying findings from official sources (UNMOVIC, ISG, CIA, Iraq Intelligence Commission) with citations, but as a secondary source synthesizing others' work rather than presenting primary documents or original investigation. While the sourcing appears referenced, Wikipedia's editorial standards and potential for revision limit its authority as definitive evidence.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq intelligence commission" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia article relaying findings from official sources (UNMOVIC, ISG, CIA, Iraq Intelligence Commission) with citations, but as a secondary source synthesizing others' work rather than presenting primary documents or original investigation. While the sourcing appears referenced, Wikipedia's editorial standards and potential for revision limit its authority as definitive evidence.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held WMD stockpiles in March 2003, citing official CIA findings that explicitly state Saddam Hussein 'did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the U.S. invasion in March 2003.'\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that UNMOVIC and the ISG 'failed to find any of the alleged stockpiles' and cites the CIA's 2004 official finding that Saddam Hussein 'did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the U.S. invasion in March 2003,' directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq intelligence commission\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3090, "completion_tokens": 6904, "total_tokens": 9994, "reasoning_tokens": 6552 }, "cost_usd": 0.03778275, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.202834Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia article relaying findings from official sources (UNMOVIC, ISG, CIA, Iraq Intelligence Commission) with citations, but as a secondary source synthesizing others' work rather than presenting primary documents or original investigation. While the sourcing appears referenced, Wikipedia's editorial standards and potential for revision limit its authority as definitive evidence.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq intelligence commission" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia article relaying findings from official sources (UNMOVIC, ISG, CIA, Iraq Intelligence Commission) with citations, but as a secondary source synthesizing others' work rather than presenting primary documents or original investigation. While the sourcing appears referenced, Wikipedia's editorial standards and potential for revision limit its authority as definitive evidence.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the exact sub-claim by reporting official CIA findings that Iraq 'did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the U.S. invasion in March 2003 and had not begun any program to produce them,' and documents the failure of UNMOVIC and ISG to find alleged stockpiles.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that UNMOVIC and the ISG conducted searches and 'failed to find any of the alleged stockpiles,' and cites the CIA's 2004 official finding that Hussein 'did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the U.S. invasion in March 2003,' directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq intelligence commission\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3098, "completion_tokens": 6918, "total_tokens": 10016, "reasoning_tokens": 6552 }, "cost_usd": 0.03786075, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.202960Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a primary document—the verbatim text of an official U.S. State Department presentation to the United Nations on a specific date. While the publisher (citizenreviewonline.org) is a secondary source republishing the text, the document itself is an authoritative primary record of a major government statement directly relevant to the topic.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a primary document—the verbatim text of an official U.S. State Department presentation to the United Nations on a specific date. While the publisher (citizenreviewonline.org) is a secondary source republishing the text, the document itself is an authoritative primary record of a major government statement directly relevant to the topic.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's weapons of mass destruction and disarmament obligations broadly, but does not directly report on or test the specific claim about nuclear weapons program reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt contains only procedural statements about UN resolutions and inspection frameworks, with no content addressing whether Iraq had actually reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3038, "completion_tokens": 3333, "total_tokens": 6371, "reasoning_tokens": 3497 }, "cost_usd": 0.01673133, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.203092Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a primary document—the declassified October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate (NIE)—which represents the official consensus judgment of U.S. intelligence agencies on Iraq's WMD programs. While presented through a Congressional Record entry with political framing, the underlying source material is an authoritative government intelligence assessment, the highest-level analytical product available on this specific topic and timeframe.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a primary document—the declassified October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate (NIE)—which represents the official consensus judgment of U.S. intelligence agencies on Iraq's WMD programs. While presented through a Congressional Record entry with political framing, the underlying source material is an authoritative government intelligence assessment, the highest-level analytical product available on this specific topic and timeframe.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraq's nuclear weapons program status and reconstitution efforts as of October 2002, though it predates March 2003 and uses probabilistic language ('probably will have') rather than asserting reconstitution was complete by that specific date.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The October 2002 NIE document asserts that Iraq 'probably will have a nuclear weapon during this decade' and that Saddam Hussein was 'attempting to reconstitute his nuclear capacity,' which supports the sub-claim, though the language uses probabilistic forecasting rather than stating reconstitution as an accomplished fact by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3197, "completion_tokens": 2582, "total_tokens": 5779, "reasoning_tokens": 2245 }, "cost_usd": 0.012509179999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.203218Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "SIPRI is a reputable, peer-reviewed research institution with strong editorial standards and no apparent conflicts of interest on this topic. The piece cites named primary sources (David Kay's Senate testimony, ISG findings) and official records, though it is an opinion/analysis article rather than original research, and relies on the author's firsthand experience as a UN weapons inspector rather than systematic documentation of all available evidence.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"SIPRI is a reputable, peer-reviewed research institution with strong editorial standards and no apparent conflicts of interest on this topic. The piece cites named primary sources (David Kay's Senate testimony, ISG findings) and official records, though it is an opinion/analysis article rather than original research, and relies on the author's firsthand experience as a UN weapons inspector rather than systematic documentation of all available evidence.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held WMD stockpiles in March 2003 by reporting that the Iraq Survey Group found no WMD and that the invasion's premise about Iraqi WMD was false, though it focuses more on the broader question of whether WMD existed rather than specifically on 'militarily significant stockpiles.'\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that the premises for invasion (including that Iraq had WMD) were 'based on scraps of unreliable information' and 'none of them was true,' and that the Iraq Survey Group 'found no WMD in Iraq,' directly contradicting the sub-claim of militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay senate testimony 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3170, "completion_tokens": 4693, "total_tokens": 7863, "reasoning_tokens": 4299 }, "cost_usd": 0.0120992464, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.203345Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "SIPRI is a reputable, peer-reviewed research institution with strong editorial standards and no apparent conflicts of interest on this topic. The piece cites named primary sources (David Kay's Senate testimony, ISG findings) and official records, though it is an opinion/analysis article rather than original research, and relies on the author's firsthand experience as a UN weapons inspector rather than systematic documentation of all available evidence.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"SIPRI is a reputable, peer-reviewed research institution with strong editorial standards and no apparent conflicts of interest on this topic. The piece cites named primary sources (David Kay's Senate testimony, ISG findings) and official records, though it is an opinion/analysis article rather than original research, and relies on the author's firsthand experience as a UN weapons inspector rather than systematic documentation of all available evidence.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held WMD stockpiles or active programs in March 2003 by reporting that the Iraq Survey Group found no WMD and that the invasion premises were false, though it focuses more on the broader intelligence failure and inspection process than on the specific biological weapons component.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that the premises for invasion (Iraq had WMD, was developing more, failing to comply) were 'all based on scraps of unreliable information' and 'none of them was true,' and that the Iraq Survey Group 'found no WMD in Iraq,' directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay senate testimony 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3178, "completion_tokens": 4677, "total_tokens": 7855, "reasoning_tokens": 4299 }, "cost_usd": 0.0120272464, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.203465Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is the Iraq Survey Group Final Report, an official U.S. government inquiry conducted by weapons inspectors with direct access to Iraqi facilities, documents, and officials post-2003. It represents a primary authoritative source on Iraqi WMD programs with extensive documentation, named sources, and systematic methodology, though published here through a secondary aggregator (globalsecurity.org) rather than as an original government release.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is the Iraq Survey Group Final Report, an official U.S. government inquiry conducted by weapons inspectors with direct access to Iraqi facilities, documents, and officials post-2003. It represents a primary authoritative source on Iraqi WMD programs with extensive documentation, named sources, and systematic methodology, though published here through a secondary aggregator (globalsecurity.org) rather than as an original government release.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraq's nuclear weapons program and its evolution through 2003, including a timeline covering 1980-2003, but the excerpt provided focuses on historical background (1968-1979) rather than the specific status of reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's historical nuclear ambitions and early program development through the 1970s but does not address the specific claim about reconstitution of the program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3184, "completion_tokens": 2778, "total_tokens": 5962, "reasoning_tokens": 2474 }, "cost_usd": 0.01199696, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.203599Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources (indicated by numbered citations), relying on editorial review rather than peer review or primary research. While it has editorial standards and generally reliable sourcing practices, it is fundamentally a tertiary reference work that aggregates and interprets information rather than presenting original evidence or primary documents.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources (indicated by numbered citations), relying on editorial review rather than peer review or primary research. While it has editorial standards and generally reliable sourcing practices, it is fundamentally a tertiary reference work that aggregates and interprets information rather than presenting original evidence or primary documents.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraq's chemical weapons status and explicitly covers the March 2003 timeframe through UN inspections, though it characterizes pre-war assertions about stockpiles as 'false' rather than directly reporting on what stockpiles actually existed at that moment.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that Iraq's chemical weapons stockpile was destroyed after the Gulf War and that UN inspections found and destroyed large quantities, characterizing later US/UK claims of continued stockpiles as 'false assertions,' which directly contradicts the sub-claim of militarily significant stockpiles existing in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2976, "completion_tokens": 395, "total_tokens": 3371, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.005056169149, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.203720Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources (indicated by numbered citations), relying on editorial review rather than peer review or primary research. While it has editorial standards and generally reliable sourcing practices, it is fundamentally a tertiary reference work that aggregates and interprets information rather than presenting original evidence or primary documents.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources (indicated by numbered citations), relying on editorial review rather than peer review or primary research. While it has editorial standards and generally reliable sourcing practices, it is fundamentally a tertiary reference work that aggregates and interprets information rather than presenting original evidence or primary documents.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraq's biological weapons status and explicitly discusses the period leading up to March 2003, including UN inspections from November 2002 to March 2003, though it presents the claim that Iraq held stockpiles as a 'false assertion' rather than confirming the sub-claim itself.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that Iraq's biological weapons program 'halted' after the Gulf War and characterizes US/UK claims about continued WMD stockpiling as 'false assertions,' directly contradicting the sub-claim about active biological weapons in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2984, "completion_tokens": 392, "total_tokens": 3376, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.005049169149, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.203886Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources (indicated by numbered citations), relying on editorial review rather than peer review or primary research. While it has editorial standards and generally reliable sourcing practices, it is fundamentally a tertiary reference work that aggregates and interprets information rather than presenting original evidence or primary documents.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources (indicated by numbered citations), relying on editorial review rather than peer review or primary research. While it has editorial standards and generally reliable sourcing practices, it is fundamentally a tertiary reference work that aggregates and interprets information rather than presenting original evidence or primary documents.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraq's biological weapons status and explicitly discusses the period leading up to March 2003, including UN inspections from November 2002 to March 2003, though it presents the claim that Iraq held stockpiles as a 'false assertion' rather than confirming the sub-claim itself.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that Iraq's biological weapons program 'halted' after the Gulf War and that UN inspections found no evidence of continued WMD stockpiling or production, supporting the sub-claim that Iraq did not hold biological weapons stockpiles or run an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 882, "completion_tokens": 111, "total_tokens": 993, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001437, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.203886Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a verbatim transcript of a primary document—Hans Blix's official presentation to the U.N. Security Council on March 7, 2003—representing direct testimony from the chief U.N. weapons inspector. While published by CNN rather than an official U.N. archive, the source is clearly identified, the speaker is named and authoritative, and the content is a direct record of statements made in an official proceeding, making it a highly reliable primary source for understanding the inspection effort and findings during this period.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a verbatim transcript of a primary document—Hans Blix's official presentation to the U.N. Security Council on March 7, 2003—representing direct testimony from the chief U.N. weapons inspector. While published by CNN rather than an official U.N. archive, the source is clearly identified, the speaker is named and authoritative, and the content is a direct record of statements made in an official proceeding, making it a highly reliable primary source for understanding the inspection effort and findings during this period.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the status of Iraq's weapons programs as assessed by U.N. inspectors in March 2003, which is the exact timeframe and core question of the sub-claim, though it does not explicitly state whether nuclear weapons were 'reconstituted.'\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is Blix's March 7, 2003 report on inspection progress and procedural matters, but contains no content addressing whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by that date.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3071, "completion_tokens": 364, "total_tokens": 3435, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00475012, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.204083Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article summarizing the Iraq Survey Group, which is secondary source material relaying information about an official inquiry rather than the primary source itself. While Wikipedia cites the actual ISG/Duelfer Report and names key officials and organizations involved, the article itself is an encyclopedia entry subject to Wikipedia's editorial standards but not peer-reviewed academic work, and it synthesizes rather than presents original evidence.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia article summarizing the Iraq Survey Group, which is secondary source material relaying information about an official inquiry rather than the primary source itself. While Wikipedia cites the actual ISG/Duelfer Report and names key officials and organizations involved, the article itself is an encyclopedia entry subject to Wikipedia's editorial standards but not peer-reviewed academic work, and it synthesizes rather than presents original evidence.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses chemical weapons stockpiles in Iraq and their military significance, but reports findings from post-invasion inspections (2004) rather than the specific March 2003 timeframe of the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that the ISG's final investigation found only small stockpiles of chemical WMDs that were inadequate to pose a militarily significant threat, directly contradicting the claim of militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2963, "completion_tokens": 4152, "total_tokens": 7115, "reasoning_tokens": 3848 }, "cost_usd": 0.0215918, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.204219Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article summarizing the Iraq Survey Group, which is secondary source material relaying information about an official inquiry rather than the primary source itself. While Wikipedia cites the actual ISG/Duelfer Report and names key officials and organizations involved, the article itself is an encyclopedia entry subject to Wikipedia's editorial standards but not peer-reviewed academic work, and it synthesizes rather than presents original evidence.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia article summarizing the Iraq Survey Group, which is secondary source material relaying information about an official inquiry rather than the primary source itself. While Wikipedia cites the actual ISG/Duelfer Report and names key officials and organizations involved, the article itself is an encyclopedia entry subject to Wikipedia's editorial standards but not peer-reviewed academic work, and it synthesizes rather than presents original evidence.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the post-invasion search for Iraqi biological weapons and reports findings about WMD stockpiles, making it closely relevant to the March 2003 claim, though it focuses on what was found after the invasion rather than the pre-invasion status.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states the ISG's final report found 'only small stockpiles of chemical WMDs' with numbers 'inadequate to pose a militarily significant threat,' and makes no mention of biological weapons stockpiles or active biological production programs being found, thereby contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2971, "completion_tokens": 4173, "total_tokens": 7144, "reasoning_tokens": 3848 }, "cost_usd": 0.0217048, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.204338Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article summarizing the Iraq Survey Group, which is secondary source material relaying information about an official inquiry rather than the primary source itself. While Wikipedia cites the actual ISG/Duelfer Report and names key officials and organizations involved, the article itself is an encyclopedia entry subject to Wikipedia's editorial standards but not peer-reviewed academic work, and it synthesizes rather than presents original evidence.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia article summarizing the Iraq Survey Group, which is secondary source material relaying information about an official inquiry rather than the primary source itself. While Wikipedia cites the actual ISG/Duelfer Report and names key officials and organizations involved, the article itself is an encyclopedia entry subject to Wikipedia's editorial standards but not peer-reviewed academic work, and it synthesizes rather than presents original evidence.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the Iraq Survey Group's mission to find WMD and reports on its findings regarding chemical weapons, but does not specifically focus on or directly report findings about nuclear weapons reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the ISG's mission and findings regarding WMD stockpiles but does not directly address whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2959, "completion_tokens": 4137, "total_tokens": 7096, "reasoning_tokens": 3848 }, "cost_usd": 0.021512800000000002, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.204449Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a published article from IAEA Bulletin (official IAEA publication) featuring direct quotes from Hans Blix, a named primary source with direct authority on the topic (former IAEA director and UN chief weapons inspector 2000-2003). While it is secondary reporting rather than a primary document, it cites specific named sources and official positions, meeting the standard for reputable reporting with named primary sources.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a published article from IAEA Bulletin (official IAEA publication) featuring direct quotes from Hans Blix, a named primary source with direct authority on the topic (former IAEA director and UN chief weapons inspector 2000-2003). While it is secondary reporting rather than a primary document, it cites specific named sources and official positions, meeting the standard for reputable reporting with named primary sources.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq had reconstituted WMD/nuclear programs by March 2003 through Hans Blix's account of 700 inspections finding no WMD and only fragments from past programs, though it focuses on inspection findings rather than definitively establishing the state of Iraq's nuclear program specifically.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Hans Blix, the UN chief weapons inspector in Iraq from 2000-2003, reports that approximately 700 inspections found no weapons of mass destruction, and only three sites yielded fragments (nuclear documents, boosters, empty warheads) that appeared to be remnants from past destruction rather than evidence of reconstitution.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3578, "completion_tokens": 3642, "total_tokens": 7220, "reasoning_tokens": 3263 }, "cost_usd": 0.010625609599999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.204578Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a published article from IAEA Bulletin (official IAEA publication) featuring direct quotes from Hans Blix, a named primary source with direct authority on the topic (former IAEA director and UN chief weapons inspector 2000-2003). While it is secondary reporting rather than a primary document, it cites specific named sources and official positions, meeting the standard for reputable reporting with named primary sources.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a published article from IAEA Bulletin (official IAEA publication) featuring direct quotes from Hans Blix, a named primary source with direct authority on the topic (former IAEA director and UN chief weapons inspector 2000-2003). While it is secondary reporting rather than a primary document, it cites specific named sources and official positions, meeting the standard for reputable reporting with named primary sources.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq had reconstituted WMD/nuclear programs by March 2003 through Hans Blix's account of 700 inspections finding no WMD and only fragments from past programs, though it focuses on inspection findings rather than definitively establishing the state of Iraq's nuclear program specifically.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Hans Blix, the UN chief weapons inspector in Iraq 2000-2003, reports that approximately 700 inspections found no weapons of mass destruction, and only three sites yielded fragments (nuclear documents, boosters, empty warheads) from past programs, supporting the sub-claim that Iraq had not reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1024, "completion_tokens": 123, "total_tokens": 1147, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001639, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.204578Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is reputable reporting by a named expert (former UN weapons inspector) with direct primary experience and access to official ISG reports, published by an established editorial outlet (Opendemocracy). However, it is secondary analysis/commentary rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study, and relies on the author's interpretation of the ISG interim report rather than presenting original primary evidence.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is reputable reporting by a named expert (former UN weapons inspector) with direct primary experience and access to official ISG reports, published by an established editorial outlet (Opendemocracy). However, it is secondary analysis/commentary rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study, and relies on the author's interpretation of the ISG interim report rather than presenting original primary evidence.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the ISG report's findings about Iraq's WMD programs and mentions that no actual chemical or biological weapons were found, but does not directly address whether Iraq held militarily significant stockpiles specifically in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that the ISG interim report found 'no trace of actual chemical or biological weapons' and that Unscom 'ultimately very successful at eliminating Saddam's chemical stockpile,' directly contradicting the claim of militarily significant stockpiles existing in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq survey group interim report 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2969, "completion_tokens": 8459, "total_tokens": 11428, "reasoning_tokens": 8120 }, "cost_usd": 0.02030689152, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.204763Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a news report from a reputable UN source relaying a government official's public statement and claims, but it reports Powell's assertions rather than providing independent verification, primary intelligence documents, or peer-reviewed analysis. While UN News has editorial standards and the source is named, the document transmits advocacy rhetoric without the sourcing or documentation needed for higher quality evidence on weapons programs.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a news report from a reputable UN source relaying a government official's public statement and claims, but it reports Powell's assertions rather than providing independent verification, primary intelligence documents, or peer-reviewed analysis. While UN News has editorial standards and the source is named, the document transmits advocacy rhetoric without the sourcing or documentation needed for higher quality evidence on weapons programs.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's failure to disarm and non-compliance with inspections as of February 2003, which is adjacent to but not directly about nuclear weapons program reconstitution specifically.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports Powell's assertions about Iraq's non-compliance and material breach of disarmament resolutions, but does not directly address whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program specifically by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"powell presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un news\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2934, "completion_tokens": 3101, "total_tokens": 6035, "reasoning_tokens": 2798 }, "cost_usd": 0.012649939999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.204895Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a primary document—the Key Judgments section of the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate (NIE), an official U.S. intelligence assessment representing consensus judgments from multiple agencies. NIEs are authoritative primary sources with rigorous internal review processes, though they represent intelligence assessments rather than independently verified facts and later proved significantly inaccurate on key claims.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a primary document—the Key Judgments section of the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate (NIE), an official U.S. intelligence assessment representing consensus judgments from multiple agencies. NIEs are authoritative primary sources with rigorous internal review processes, though they represent intelligence assessments rather than independently verified facts and later proved significantly inaccurate on key claims.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the exact sub-claim by stating 'in the view of most agencies, Baghdad is reconstituting its nuclear weapons program' as of the October 2002 NIE assessment.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly states 'in the view of most agencies, Baghdad is reconstituting its nuclear weapons program' as an intelligence assessment, which directly supports the sub-claim, though it characterizes this as an ongoing process rather than completed reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2882, "completion_tokens": 316, "total_tokens": 3198, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.004630697536, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.205017Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official government inquiry document (the Robb-Silberman Commission) with extensive primary sourcing, named references to intelligence documents, and systematic methodology. It represents an authoritative official investigation with access to classified materials and direct interviews, though it is a secondary analysis rather than a pure primary record.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official government inquiry document (the Robb-Silberman Commission) with extensive primary sourcing, named references to intelligence documents, and systematic methodology. It represents an authoritative official investigation with access to classified materials and direct interviews, though it is a secondary analysis rather than a pure primary record.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an endnote section from a WMD commission report that references the October 2002 NIE on Iraq's weapons programs but does not itself present evidence or findings about Iraq's actual chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt contains only endnotes and procedural information about the Commission's scope and methodology, with no substantive content addressing whether Iraq held chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3225, "completion_tokens": 353, "total_tokens": 3578, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00511896, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.205127Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official government inquiry document (the Robb-Silberman Commission) with extensive primary sourcing, named references to intelligence documents, and systematic methodology. It represents an authoritative official investigation with access to classified materials and direct interviews, though it is a secondary analysis rather than a pure primary record.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official government inquiry document (the Robb-Silberman Commission) with extensive primary sourcing, named references to intelligence documents, and systematic methodology. It represents an authoritative official investigation with access to classified materials and direct interviews, though it is a secondary analysis rather than a pure primary record.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an endnote section from a WMD commission report that references the October 2002 NIE on Iraq's weapons programs but does not itself present evidence or findings about Iraq's actual chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt consists entirely of endnotes and procedural information about the Commission's scope and methodology, containing no substantive content addressing whether Iraq held chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 945, "completion_tokens": 82, "total_tokens": 1027, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001355, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.205127Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official government inquiry document (the Robb-Silberman Commission) with extensive primary sourcing, named references to intelligence documents, and systematic methodology. It represents an authoritative official investigation with access to classified materials and direct interviews, though it is a secondary analysis rather than a pure primary record.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official government inquiry document (the Robb-Silberman Commission) with extensive primary sourcing, named references to intelligence documents, and systematic methodology. It represents an authoritative official investigation with access to classified materials and direct interviews, though it is a secondary analysis rather than a pure primary record.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a methodological endnote explaining the Commission's scope and referencing the October 2002 NIE on Iraq WMD, but does not itself report findings or evidence about Iraq's biological weapons stockpiles or programs in March 2003.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt contains only endnotes and procedural information about the Commission's scope and methodology, with no substantive content addressing Iraq's biological weapons stockpiles or programs in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3233, "completion_tokens": 356, "total_tokens": 3589, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.005141959999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.205277Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is ordinary journalism reporting on a public speech by a government official, relaying claims about intelligence sources (intercepts, satellite photos) without independent verification or access to the underlying primary evidence. While it names the speaker and cites specific claims, it is a news account of a presentation rather than direct access to the intelligence materials themselves or peer-reviewed analysis.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us electronic intercepts" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us satellite photographs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is ordinary journalism reporting on a public speech by a government official, relaying claims about intelligence sources (intercepts, satellite photos) without independent verification or access to the underlying primary evidence. While it names the speaker and cites specific claims, it is a news account of a presentation rather than direct access to the intelligence materials themselves or peer-reviewed analysis.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq was actively concealing weapons and deceiving inspectors in early 2003, which is closely related to the claim about biological weapons stockpiles/programs, though it focuses on deception tactics and chemical weapons rather than specifically on biological weapons.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document presents Powell's allegations and intelligence assessments about Iraqi deception and evasion of inspectors, but contains no direct evidence of biological weapons stockpiles or active production programs in March 2003—only claims about hiding activities and intercepted conversations about concealment.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us electronic intercepts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us satellite photographs\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cnn\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3254, "completion_tokens": 5133, "total_tokens": 8387, "reasoning_tokens": 4789 }, "cost_usd": 0.0185844516, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.205383Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is ordinary journalism reporting on a public speech by a government official, relaying claims about intelligence sources (intercepts, satellite photos) without independent verification or access to the underlying primary evidence. While it names the speaker and cites specific claims, it is a news account of a presentation rather than direct access to the intelligence materials themselves or peer-reviewed analysis.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us electronic intercepts" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us satellite photographs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is ordinary journalism reporting on a public speech by a government official, relaying claims about intelligence sources (intercepts, satellite photos) without independent verification or access to the underlying primary evidence. While it names the speaker and cites specific claims, it is a news account of a presentation rather than direct access to the intelligence materials themselves or peer-reviewed analysis.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq was actively concealing weapons and deceiving inspectors in early 2003, which is closely related to the claim about biological weapons stockpiles/programs, though it focuses on deception tactics and chemical weapons rather than specifically on biological weapons.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.6,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Powell presents intelligence assessments (intercepts, satellite photos) as evidence that Iraq is actively deceiving inspectors and possesses weapons, which contradicts the sub-claim that Iraq did not hold stockpiles or run an active program in March 2003, though the document does not provide direct inspection findings of actual weapons.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us electronic intercepts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us satellite photographs\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cnn\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 905, "completion_tokens": 110, "total_tokens": 1015, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001455, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.205383Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is the Iraq Survey Group Final Report, an official U.S. government inquiry conducted by the CIA and Defense Department with extensive primary source access, interviews, and document review. While published on globalsecurity.org (a secondary host), the underlying source is a definitive official record with established methodology and institutional authority on this specific topic.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is the Iraq Survey Group Final Report, an official U.S. government inquiry conducted by the CIA and Defense Department with extensive primary source access, interviews, and document review. While published on globalsecurity.org (a secondary host), the underlying source is a definitive official record with established methodology and institutional authority on this specific topic.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraq's WMD programs and policy through 2003, including chemical weapons (CW), and discusses the regime's strategic intent regarding WMD preservation, making it highly relevant to assessing whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003, though this excerpt does not yet provide specific findings about stockpile status.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides strategic overview and policy context but contains no direct evidence about whether Iraq actually held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3196, "completion_tokens": 2294, "total_tokens": 5490, "reasoning_tokens": 1992 }, "cost_usd": 0.01340888, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.205589Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive is a reputable non-profit research institute at George Washington University with strong editorial standards and transparent sourcing practices. The document cites primary sources (classified directives, UN resolutions, UNSCOM records) and provides specific dates and references, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than a primary document.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The National Security Archive is a reputable non-profit research institute at George Washington University with strong editorial standards and transparent sourcing practices. The document cites primary sources (classified directives, UN resolutions, UNSCOM records) and provides specific dates and references, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than a primary document.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides historical background on Iraq's WMD programs and inspection regimes through 1998, but does not directly address the specific question of what militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles Iraq held in March 2003.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraq's WMD programs and inspection regimes in general historical context but contains no content addressing whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles specifically in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3061, "completion_tokens": 3375, "total_tokens": 6436, "reasoning_tokens": 3074 }, "cost_usd": 0.01357847, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.205706Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive is a reputable non-profit research institute at George Washington University with strong editorial standards and transparent sourcing practices. The document cites primary sources (classified directives, UN resolutions, UNSCOM records) and provides specific dates and references, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than a primary document.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The National Security Archive is a reputable non-profit research institute at George Washington University with strong editorial standards and transparent sourcing practices. The document cites primary sources (classified directives, UN resolutions, UNSCOM records) and provides specific dates and references, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than a primary document.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's WMD programs broadly and mentions post-1998 concerns about reconstitution, but does not directly report on or test the specific claim about biological weapons stockpiles or active production in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraq's WMD programs in historical context (1990-1998) and U.S. policy positions, but contains no content addressing whether Iraq actually held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program specifically in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3069, "completion_tokens": 3396, "total_tokens": 6465, "reasoning_tokens": 3074 }, "cost_usd": 0.01369147, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.205835Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive is a reputable non-profit research institute at George Washington University with strong editorial standards and transparent sourcing practices. The document cites primary sources (classified directives, UN resolutions, UNSCOM records) and provides specific dates and references, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than a primary document.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The National Security Archive is a reputable non-profit research institute at George Washington University with strong editorial standards and transparent sourcing practices. The document cites primary sources (classified directives, UN resolutions, UNSCOM records) and provides specific dates and references, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than a primary document.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's WMD programs broadly and mentions post-1998 concerns about reconstitution, but does not directly report on or test the specific claim about biological weapons stockpiles or active production in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraq's WMD programs in historical context (1990-1998) and U.S. policy positions, but contains no content addressing whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active biological weapons production program specifically in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 886, "completion_tokens": 97, "total_tokens": 983, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001371, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.205835Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive is a reputable non-profit research institute at George Washington University with strong editorial standards and transparent sourcing practices. The document cites primary sources (classified directives, UN resolutions, UNSCOM records) and provides specific dates and references, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than a primary document.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The National Security Archive is a reputable non-profit research institute at George Washington University with strong editorial standards and transparent sourcing practices. The document cites primary sources (classified directives, UN resolutions, UNSCOM records) and provides specific dates and references, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than a primary document.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's WMD programs and reconstitution concerns broadly, but focuses on the 1990-1998 period and general U.S. policy rather than directly assessing whether reconstitution had occurred by March 2003.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraq's WMD programs and inspection regimes through 1998, but contains no content addressing whether Iraq had actually reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3057, "completion_tokens": 3380, "total_tokens": 6437, "reasoning_tokens": 3074 }, "cost_usd": 0.01359947, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.206027Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive is a reputable non-profit research institute at George Washington University with strong editorial standards and transparent sourcing practices. The document cites primary sources (classified directives, UN resolutions, UNSCOM records) and provides specific dates and references, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than a primary document.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The National Security Archive is a reputable non-profit research institute at George Washington University with strong editorial standards and transparent sourcing practices. The document cites primary sources (classified directives, UN resolutions, UNSCOM records) and provides specific dates and references, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than a primary document.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's WMD programs and reconstitution concerns broadly, but focuses on the 1990-1998 period and general U.S. policy rather than directly assessing whether reconstitution had occurred by March 2003.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraq's WMD programs and inspection regimes through 1998, but contains no content addressing whether Iraq had actually reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 880, "completion_tokens": 82, "total_tokens": 962, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00129, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.206027Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources rather than presenting primary evidence or original research. While the excerpt cites specific named sources (Colin Powell, Wilkerson, Tenet, McLaughlin) and references numbered citations, Wikipedia articles lack peer review and editorial standards comparable to academic or official inquiry, and the encyclopedia's crowdsourced model creates potential reliability concerns despite its general reputation for factual accuracy on well-documented topics.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources rather than presenting primary evidence or original research. While the excerpt cites specific named sources (Colin Powell, Wilkerson, Tenet, McLaughlin) and references numbered citations, Wikipedia articles lack peer review and editorial standards comparable to academic or official inquiry, and the encyclopedia's crowdsourced model creates potential reliability concerns despite its general reputation for factual accuracy on well-documented topics.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses allegations of Iraqi biological weapons capabilities in March 2003 (the exact timeframe), specifically discussing claimed mobile biological weapons production facilities, though it focuses on one component of the broader biological weapons claim rather than comprehensive stockpiles or the full production program.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that subsequent investigations failed to find evidence of mobile weapons labs and that the U.S. allegations were based on defector accounts (assertions) rather than direct evidence, contradicting the sub-claim of actual stockpiles or active programs in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"colin powell un presentation 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2867, "completion_tokens": 402, "total_tokens": 3269, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00499084, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.206189Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source cites the 2002 National Intelligence Estimate as a primary official document with specific conclusions and reasoning, providing named sourcing and direct quotation from government records. However, it is a secondary compilation/summary of that primary source rather than the NIE itself, and globalsecurity.org, while reputable for defense policy information, is not a peer-reviewed academic publisher or official inquiry body.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "previous intelligence reports" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source cites the 2002 National Intelligence Estimate as a primary official document with specific conclusions and reasoning, providing named sourcing and direct quotation from government records. However, it is a secondary compilation/summary of that primary source rather than the NIE itself, and globalsecurity.org, while reputable for defense policy information, is not a peer-reviewed academic publisher or official inquiry body.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on prewar 2003 intelligence assessments of Iraq's chemical weapons stockpiles, including specific estimates of 100-500 metric tons of CW agents as of March 2003.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document presents the 2002 NIE's assessment that Iraq possessed 100-500 metric tons of chemical weapons agents and had renewed production, which directly supports the sub-claim, though this is an intelligence estimate rather than direct observation of actual March 2003 stockpiles.\\\"}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"previous intelligence reports\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2878, "completion_tokens": 1377, "total_tokens": 4255, "reasoning_tokens": 1242 }, "cost_usd": 0.0088274, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.206322Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Congressional Research Service is a reputable legislative branch agency with established editorial standards and institutional credibility. The report cites primary sources (U.N. inspections, Security Council resolutions, UNMOVIC and IAEA records) and names the analyst, though as a secondary analysis of inspection activities rather than a primary document itself.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Congressional Research Service is a reputable legislative branch agency with established editorial standards and institutional credibility. The report cites primary sources (U.N. inspections, Security Council resolutions, UNMOVIC and IAEA records) and names the analyst, though as a secondary analysis of inspection activities rather than a primary document itself.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses U.N. inspections in Iraq from November 2002 to March 2003 and reports on what inspectors found regarding WMD, making it closely relevant to assessing whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles at that time, though it does not provide detailed chemical weapons inventory data.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses inspection findings of 'undeclared activities' but does not directly address whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003, instead focusing on the inspection process and its limitations.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3294, "completion_tokens": 1389, "total_tokens": 4683, "reasoning_tokens": 1064 }, "cost_usd": 0.0079507322, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.206438Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Congressional Research Service is a reputable legislative branch agency with established editorial standards and institutional credibility. The report cites primary sources (U.N. inspections, Security Council resolutions, UNMOVIC and IAEA records) and names the analyst, though as a secondary analysis of inspection activities rather than a primary document itself.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Congressional Research Service is a reputable legislative branch agency with established editorial standards and institutional credibility. The report cites primary sources (U.N. inspections, Security Council resolutions, UNMOVIC and IAEA records) and names the analyst, though as a secondary analysis of inspection activities rather than a primary document itself.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses U.N. inspections in Iraq from November 2002 to March 2003 and reports on whether inspectors found evidence of WMD programs, which is the core factual basis for evaluating the sub-claim about nuclear weapons reconstitution by that date.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states inspectors found 'some evidence of undeclared activities, but not enough to convince a majority of the Security Council members that military force was necessary,' directly contradicting the claim of reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3290, "completion_tokens": 1388, "total_tokens": 4678, "reasoning_tokens": 1064 }, "cost_usd": 0.0079417322, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.206563Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources (indicated by numbered citations [1], [2], [3], [4]), relying on editorial review rather than peer review or primary documentation. While it has editorial standards and generally reliable sourcing practices, it is fundamentally a tertiary reference work that aggregates and interprets other people's findings rather than presenting primary evidence or original research.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "human rights watch" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources (indicated by numbered citations [1], [2], [3], [4]), relying on editorial review rather than peer review or primary documentation. While it has editorial standards and generally reliable sourcing practices, it is fundamentally a tertiary reference work that aggregates and interprets other people's findings rather than presenting primary evidence or original research.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's chemical weapons program broadly but focuses on historical development through the 1980s-1991 period, only tangentially touching on the specific question of biological weapons stockpiles or active production in March 2003.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's chemical weapons program through 1991 and historical deployments but does not address whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active biological weapons production program specifically in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"united nations\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"human rights watch\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3081, "completion_tokens": 9449, "total_tokens": 12530, "reasoning_tokens": 9136 }, "cost_usd": 0.0314922778, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.206677Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article summarizing an official U.S. Senate report, making it a secondary source about a primary document. While Wikipedia cites the underlying Senate Select Committee on Intelligence report (a high-quality primary source), this excerpt itself is encyclopedia-style synthesis without direct access to the original evidence, and Wikipedia's editorial standards, though reasonable, do not match peer review or official status.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia article summarizing an official U.S. Senate report, making it a secondary source about a primary document. While Wikipedia cites the underlying Senate Select Committee on Intelligence report (a high-quality primary source), this excerpt itself is encyclopedia-style synthesis without direct access to the original evidence, and Wikipedia's editorial standards, though reasonable, do not match peer review or official status.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the Senate Report on Iraqi WMD Intelligence and its findings about prewar assessments, which is closely related to evaluating whether Iraq held chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003, though it does not itself present specific evidence about the stockpiles.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the Senate Report's findings about intelligence failures and misled assessments, but does not directly address whether Iraq actually held chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence 2004\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2849, "completion_tokens": 310, "total_tokens": 3159, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00429396, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.206793Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article summarizing an official U.S. Senate report, making it a secondary source about a primary document. While Wikipedia cites the underlying Senate Select Committee on Intelligence report (a high-quality primary source), this excerpt itself is encyclopedia-style synthesis without direct access to the original evidence, and Wikipedia's editorial standards, though reasonable, do not match peer review or official status.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia article summarizing an official U.S. Senate report, making it a secondary source about a primary document. While Wikipedia cites the underlying Senate Select Committee on Intelligence report (a high-quality primary source), this excerpt itself is encyclopedia-style synthesis without direct access to the original evidence, and Wikipedia's editorial standards, though reasonable, do not match peer review or official status.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the Senate Report on Iraqi WMD Intelligence that investigated prewar assessments of Iraq's WMD capabilities including biological weapons, making it closely relevant to evaluating claims about Iraq's biological weapons status in March 2003, though the excerpt itself does not detail specific findings about biological weapons stockpiles.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the Senate Report's findings about intelligence failures and mentions Iraq's post-1991 obligations to destroy WMD, but does not directly address whether Iraq actually held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence 2004\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2857, "completion_tokens": 328, "total_tokens": 3185, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00439196, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.206903Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is reputable journalism from PBS/FRONTLINE featuring a named primary source (Colin Powell) interviewed directly by the documentary series, combined with attribution to 'former members of the intelligence community.' However, it is a secondary journalistic account of an interview rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed analysis, and the excerpt is incomplete, limiting full assessment of sourcing rigor.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "frontline pbs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell interview february 2016" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "the secret history of isis documentary" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is reputable journalism from PBS/FRONTLINE featuring a named primary source (Colin Powell) interviewed directly by the documentary series, combined with attribution to 'former members of the intelligence community.' However, it is a secondary journalistic account of an interview rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed analysis, and the excerpt is incomplete, limiting full assessment of sourcing rigor.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Powell's 2003 UN speech about Iraq's weapons program and states that 'as the intelligence would later confirm, that program was nonexistent,' which directly bears on whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly states that Powell's 2003 U.N. speech detailed Iraq's weapons program, but 'as the intelligence would later confirm, that program was nonexistent,' directly contradicting the claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"frontline pbs\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"colin powell interview february 2016\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"the secret history of isis documentary\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3280, "completion_tokens": 359, "total_tokens": 3639, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0051563, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.207019Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is secondary source journalism from a reputable UN publisher recounting a historical event (Powell's 2003 presentation) with named sources and direct quotes, but it is a retrospective narrative account rather than primary documentation or investigative reporting with independent verification of the underlying claims about Iraq's weapons programs.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council meeting february 5 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is secondary source journalism from a reputable UN publisher recounting a historical event (Powell's 2003 presentation) with named sources and direct quotes, but it is a retrospective narrative account rather than primary documentation or investigative reporting with independent verification of the underlying claims about Iraq's weapons programs.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the February 2003 US claims about Iraq's WMD programs (including nuclear weapons as part of the broader WMD argument) presented to the UN Security Council, which is the exact timeframe and claim under test, though it focuses more on the presentation of evidence than on independent verification of whether reconstitution actually occurred.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes Powell's claims about Iraqi WMDs but does not provide evidence about whether Iraq actually had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003; it only reports what was asserted in the presentation.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council meeting february 5 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3054, "completion_tokens": 2618, "total_tokens": 5672, "reasoning_tokens": 2315 }, "cost_usd": 0.0081968512, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.207137Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable fact-checking organization with editorial standards and transparency practices. The article cites the Iraq Survey Group's final report as a primary source and references official findings, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than the primary ISG report itself.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable fact-checking organization with editorial standards and transparency practices. The article cites the Iraq Survey Group's final report as a primary source and references official findings, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than the primary ISG report itself.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003, explicitly stating the Iraq Survey Group determined Iraq had destroyed all existing stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that the Iraq Survey Group determined Iraq had destroyed all existing stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons, directly contradicting the sub-claim of militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3044, "completion_tokens": 905, "total_tokens": 3949, "reasoning_tokens": 631 }, "cost_usd": 0.007127639999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.207261Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable fact-checking organization with editorial standards and transparency practices. The article cites the Iraq Survey Group's final report as a primary source and references official findings, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than the primary ISG report itself.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable fact-checking organization with editorial standards and transparency practices. The article cites the Iraq Survey Group's final report as a primary source and references official findings, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than the primary ISG report itself.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003, explicitly stating the Iraq Survey Group determined Iraq had destroyed all existing stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that the Iraq Survey Group determined Iraq had destroyed all existing stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons, which directly contradicts the sub-claim that Iraq did not hold militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 872, "completion_tokens": 93, "total_tokens": 965, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001337, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.207261Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable fact-checking organization with editorial standards and transparency practices. The article cites the Iraq Survey Group's final report as a primary source and references official findings, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than the primary ISG report itself.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable fact-checking organization with editorial standards and transparency practices. The article cites the Iraq Survey Group's final report as a primary source and references official findings, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than the primary ISG report itself.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the exact sub-claim by reporting the Iraq Survey Group's determination that Iraq had abandoned its WMD programs and destroyed all existing stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons by the time of the 2003 invasion.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that the Iraq Survey Group determined Iraq had abandoned its WMD programs and destroyed all existing stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons, directly contradicting the sub-claim that Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3052, "completion_tokens": 928, "total_tokens": 3980, "reasoning_tokens": 631 }, "cost_usd": 0.00725064, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.207422Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable fact-checking organization with editorial standards and transparency practices. The article cites the Iraq Survey Group's final report as a primary source and references official findings, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than the primary ISG report itself.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable fact-checking organization with editorial standards and transparency practices. The article cites the Iraq Survey Group's final report as a primary source and references official findings, though the excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than the primary ISG report itself.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq had reconstituted nuclear weapons by 2003, stating the Iraq Survey Group determined Iraq had abandoned its nuclear weapons quest, which directly contradicts the sub-claim but is presented as part of a broader WMD assessment rather than focusing exclusively on nuclear reconstitution.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites the Iraq Survey Group's determination that Iraq had abandoned its nuclear weapons program and destroyed existing stockpiles, which directly contradicts the claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3040, "completion_tokens": 929, "total_tokens": 3969, "reasoning_tokens": 631 }, "cost_usd": 0.00724364, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.207574Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is reputable reporting from the Arms Control Association (a credible policy organization) that directly cites named primary sources (Brig. Gen. Mark Kimmitt, Defense Secretary Rumsfeld) and official records (ISG findings, UNMOVIC reports), though it is secondary reporting rather than a primary document itself.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "kimmitt press briefing may 17 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "rumsfeld heritage foundation may 17 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is reputable reporting from the Arms Control Association (a credible policy organization) that directly cites named primary sources (Brig. Gen. Mark Kimmitt, Defense Secretary Rumsfeld) and official records (ISG findings, UNMOVIC reports), though it is secondary reporting rather than a primary document itself.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraqi chemical weapons stockpiles as of March 2003 through UNMOVIC's report citing unaccounted discrepancies in sarin-filled munitions, though it focuses on accounting gaps rather than confirming militarily significant stockpiles existed at that time.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports one sarin-filled shell found after the invasion and references pre-2003 discrepancies in Iraqi accounting, but provides no direct evidence of militarily significant stockpiles existing in March 2003, nor does it clearly contradict the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"kimmitt press briefing may 17 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"rumsfeld heritage foundation may 17 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic march 2003 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2965, "completion_tokens": 4591, "total_tokens": 7556, "reasoning_tokens": 4218 }, "cost_usd": 0.012474120288, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.207693Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a reputable organization (Arms Control Association) citing named primary sources (UN inspection reports, IAEA, UNMOVIC) with specific data and dates, though it is a secondary compilation rather than a primary document itself. The sourcing is transparent and traceable to official UN records, meeting standards for reputable reporting with documented primary sources.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq declaration december 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a reputable organization (Arms Control Association) citing named primary sources (UN inspection reports, IAEA, UNMOVIC) with specific data and dates, though it is a secondary compilation rather than a primary document itself. The sourcing is transparent and traceable to official UN records, meeting standards for reputable reporting with documented primary sources.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses UN weapons inspection findings in Iraq during March 2003 regarding chemical weapons (22% of inspections), but reports on inspection activities and unresolved disarmament issues rather than definitively establishing whether militarily significant stockpiles existed at that time.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes inspection activities and Iraq's failure to account for weapons, but contains no direct evidence or findings about whether militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles actually existed in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq declaration december 2002\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3080, "completion_tokens": 8130, "total_tokens": 11210, "reasoning_tokens": 7801 }, "cost_usd": 0.034821776, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.207815Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is advocacy journalism presenting claims about pre-war intelligence as established fact, relying on secondary sourcing (references to intelligence agency determinations and defector assessments) rather than primary documents or official inquiries. While it cites specific intelligence findings and names sources like 'Curveball,' the document is from an advocacy website promoting a particular narrative about the war's justification, lacks peer review or editorial standards of major news organizations, and presents conclusions rather than balanced reporting of contested claims.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "bush administration" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "curveball" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "defense intelligence agency" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is advocacy journalism presenting claims about pre-war intelligence as established fact, relying on secondary sourcing (references to intelligence agency determinations and defector assessments) rather than primary documents or official inquiries. While it cites specific intelligence findings and names sources like 'Curveball,' the document is from an advocacy website promoting a particular narrative about the war's justification, lacks peer review or editorial standards of major news organizations, and presents conclusions rather than balanced reporting of contested claims.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq possessed biological weapons production capabilities (mobile labs) in March 2003, though it focuses specifically on mobile labs rather than all biological weapons stockpiles or programs.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.6,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document contradicts the sub-claim by asserting that no mobile bioweapons labs were found and that key evidence sources were fabricators, though it does not directly address whether Iraq held other biological weapons stockpiles or non-mobile production programs in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush administration\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi defector curveball\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"defense intelligence agency\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2983, "completion_tokens": 394, "total_tokens": 3377, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0050714, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.207944Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is secondary source journalism/encyclopedia content that relays findings from primary sources (ISG reports, Kay's statements, Duelfer Report) with numbered citations, but it is not itself a primary document, peer-reviewed study, or official inquiry. While it references authoritative sources and appears well-sourced through citations, it is a tertiary synthesis rather than direct evidence from the investigations themselves.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is secondary source journalism/encyclopedia content that relays findings from primary sources (ISG reports, Kay's statements, Duelfer Report) with numbered citations, but it is not itself a primary document, peer-reviewed study, or official inquiry. While it references authoritative sources and appears well-sourced through citations, it is a tertiary synthesis rather than direct evidence from the investigations themselves.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses post-invasion findings about chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003, reporting that no operational stockpiles were found and that the Duelfer Report concluded Iraq had destroyed its stockpiles by 1991, which bears closely on the sub-claim's factual accuracy.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that post-invasion investigations by the Iraq Survey Group found no operational stockpiles in March 2003, only degraded remnants from the 1980s, and the Duelfer Report concluded Iraq had destroyed its WMD stockpiles by 1991 with no reconstitution, directly contradicting the claim of militarily significant stockpiles at that time.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2988, "completion_tokens": 424, "total_tokens": 3412, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00487736, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.208069Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is advocacy/opinion content from a congressional office presenting a political critique by juxtaposing official statements against a primary source quote (David Kay interview). While it cites named sources and includes direct quotes from official records and news reports, it is fundamentally a political statement designed to argue a position rather than an independent investigation or analysis of the underlying evidence on Iraqi weapons programs.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cheney meet the press 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush state of the union 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is advocacy/opinion content from a congressional office presenting a political critique by juxtaposing official statements against a primary source quote (David Kay interview). While it cites named sources and includes direct quotes from official records and news reports, it is fundamentally a political statement designed to argue a position rather than an independent investigation or analysis of the underlying evidence on Iraqi weapons programs.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or had active production programs in March 2003 by quoting administration claims made around that time and contrasting them with Dr. Kay's post-invasion assessment, though it focuses primarily on evaluating the accuracy of those claims rather than independently reporting on Iraq's actual weapons status.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document presents Dr. David Kay's statement (the head of the U.S. weapons inspection team) directly contradicting the sub-claim by asserting Iraq did not have large stockpiles of newly produced WMDs in 2003 and had gradually reduced stockpiles throughout the 1990s, though the basis is Kay's assessment rather than direct physical evidence of absence.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay new york times interview 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cheney meet the press 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"powell un security council 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush state of the union 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3555, "completion_tokens": 1811, "total_tokens": 5366, "reasoning_tokens": 1494 }, "cost_usd": 0.01135308, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.208192Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia article relaying findings from secondary sources (UNSCOM reports, historical accounts) with numbered citations, but as a tertiary encyclopedia source lacks direct access to primary documents and reflects editorial consensus rather than original research or official inquiry. The sourcing appears present but is not transparently displayed in the excerpt.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "riegle report 1994" }, { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia article relaying findings from secondary sources (UNSCOM reports, historical accounts) with numbered citations, but as a tertiary encyclopedia source lacks direct access to primary documents and reflects editorial consensus rather than original research or official inquiry. The sourcing appears present but is not transparently displayed in the excerpt.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraq's biological weapons program and explicitly states 'The program no longer existed when the George W. Bush administration cited it as justification for its 2003 invasion,' which directly bears on whether Iraq held BW stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly states 'The program no longer existed when the George W. Bush administration cited it as justification for its 2003 invasion of Iraq,' directly contradicting the claim that Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"riegle report 1994\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3096, "completion_tokens": 6901, "total_tokens": 9997, "reasoning_tokens": 6573 }, "cost_usd": 0.0327213, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.208320Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The Arms Control Association is a reputable nonprofit with established editorial standards and named sourcing (Executive Director contact provided). The document cites official primary sources (UN Security Council resolutions, IAEA and UNMOVIC inspection records) and presents a factual chronology of documented events, though it is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document itself.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Arms Control Association is a reputable nonprofit with established editorial standards and named sourcing (Executive Director contact provided). The document cites official primary sources (UN Security Council resolutions, IAEA and UNMOVIC inspection records) and presents a factual chronology of documented events, though it is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document itself.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq possessed chemical weapons in March 2003 by reporting that UN inspectors found no evidence of chemical weapons during inspections through March 18, 2003, which is the exact timeframe in question, though it does not specifically characterize the scale or military significance of any stockpiles.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that UN weapons inspectors conducted over 900 inspections at over 500 sites from November 2002 to March 2003 and 'did not find that Iraq possessed chemical or biological weapons,' which directly contradicts the claim of militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush state of the union 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3028, "completion_tokens": 384, "total_tokens": 3412, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0049689999999999995, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.208439Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The Arms Control Association is a reputable nonprofit with established editorial standards and named sourcing (Executive Director contact provided). The document cites official primary sources (UN Security Council resolutions, IAEA and UNMOVIC inspection records) and presents a factual chronology of documented events, though it is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document itself.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Arms Control Association is a reputable nonprofit with established editorial standards and named sourcing (Executive Director contact provided). The document cites official primary sources (UN Security Council resolutions, IAEA and UNMOVIC inspection records) and presents a factual chronology of documented events, though it is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document itself.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraq's biological weapons status in March 2003 by reporting that UN inspectors found no evidence Iraq possessed biological weapons during their inspections through March 18, 2003, which directly bears on the sub-claim's core proposition.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that UN weapons inspectors conducted over 900 inspections at over 500 sites from November 2002 to March 2003 and 'did not find that Iraq possessed chemical or biological weapons,' directly contradicting the sub-claim of biological weapons stockpiles or active production in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush state of the union 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3036, "completion_tokens": 372, "total_tokens": 3408, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.004917, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.208570Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a direct report of statements by Hans Blix, the head of UNMOVIC (a primary official source with direct access to inspection data), published by UN News (an official UN outlet with editorial standards). However, it is secondary reporting of his remarks rather than a primary document, and relies on paraphrasing and selective quotation rather than complete primary records.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a direct report of statements by Hans Blix, the head of UNMOVIC (a primary official source with direct access to inspection data), published by UN News (an official UN outlet with editorial standards). However, it is secondary reporting of his remarks rather than a primary document, and relies on paraphrasing and selective quotation rather than complete primary records.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Blix's observations about Iraq's use of weapons during the conflict in March 2003, which is tangential background context but does not directly address whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by that date.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses whether Iraq used banned weapons during the conflict, not whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un news\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2491, "completion_tokens": 3564, "total_tokens": 6055, "reasoning_tokens": 3269 }, "cost_usd": 0.01707852, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.208684Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is secondary source journalism/archival commentary that relays historical facts about a famous image and its origins, citing named sources (Curveball, Colin Powell, German intelligence) and providing contextual narrative. However, it lacks primary documentation, peer review, and official investigative rigor; it functions as explanatory reporting about a historical event rather than as authoritative evidence on the actual state of Iraqi weapons programs.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "curveball" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "german intelligence" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is secondary source journalism/archival commentary that relays historical facts about a famous image and its origins, citing named sources (Curveball, Colin Powell, German intelligence) and providing contextual narrative. However, it lacks primary documentation, peer review, and official investigative rigor; it functions as explanatory reporting about a historical event rather than as authoritative evidence on the actual state of Iraqi weapons programs.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses claims about Iraqi biological weapons production capabilities (specifically mobile facilities) as of early 2003, though it focuses on the intelligence sources and presentation of these claims rather than independent verification of whether stockpiles or active programs actually existed.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the mobile biological weapons facilities as 'supposed' and 'Iraq's supposed mobile weapons,' and explicitly states that British intelligence and other defectors found much of the key source's testimony to be false, thereby contradicting the sub-claim that Iraq held active biological weapons programs in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"curveball\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"german intelligence\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cia\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"powell un speech 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2807, "completion_tokens": 2496, "total_tokens": 5303, "reasoning_tokens": 2140 }, "cost_usd": 0.01321852, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.208798Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official UN Security Council document (S/2006/420) prepared by UNMOVIC, the authorized international inspection body with direct access to Iraqi facilities and records. It represents a primary institutional record from the organization mandated to verify Iraq's weapons programs, with named authorship through the Secretary-General and Acting Executive Chairman, though the specific date of preparation is not visible in the excerpt.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official UN Security Council document (S/2006/420) prepared by UNMOVIC, the authorized international inspection body with direct access to Iraqi facilities and records. It represents a primary institutional record from the organization mandated to verify Iraq's weapons programs, with named authorship through the Secretary-General and Acting Executive Chairman, though the specific date of preparation is not visible in the excerpt.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraq's biological weapons programs and UNMOVIC's inspection mandate, but focuses on the post-1991 disarmament process and historical overview rather than specifically reporting on the status of biological weapons stockpiles or active production in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes UNMOVIC's historical mandate and general background about UN inspections in Iraq but contains no specific content addressing whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3416, "completion_tokens": 2150, "total_tokens": 5566, "reasoning_tokens": 1843 }, "cost_usd": 0.0101538232, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.208921Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a primary document—an official transcript of a high-ranking government official's statement to the UN Security Council, archived by the U.S. government. It represents a direct historical record of a key policy statement on the topic, though it is advocacy rather than neutral analysis and should be evaluated alongside other primary sources and independent assessments.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a primary document—an official transcript of a high-ranking government official's statement to the UN Security Council, archived by the U.S. government. It represents a direct historical record of a key policy statement on the topic, though it is advocacy rather than neutral analysis and should be evaluated alongside other primary sources and independent assessments.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraq's weapons of mass destruction obligations and compliance status as of February 2003, which is the exact timeframe of the sub-claim, though it focuses on Iraq's legal obligations and inspector cooperation rather than specifically asserting whether stockpiles or active production existed.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.6,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Powell asserts that Iraq had WMD obligations, was found guilty of material breach, and concealed weapons, supporting the sub-claim through official allegations and characterizations rather than direct evidence of March 2003 stockpiles or active programs.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us state department 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3080, "completion_tokens": 352, "total_tokens": 3432, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.004993839999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.209038Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a primary document—an official transcript of a high-ranking government official's statement to the UN Security Council, archived by the U.S. government. It represents a direct historical record of a key policy statement on the topic, though it is advocacy rather than neutral analysis and should be evaluated alongside other primary sources and independent assessments.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a primary document—an official transcript of a high-ranking government official's statement to the UN Security Council, archived by the U.S. government. It represents a direct historical record of a key policy statement on the topic, though it is advocacy rather than neutral analysis and should be evaluated alongside other primary sources and independent assessments.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraq's weapons of mass destruction status and disarmament obligations as of February 2003, which is the exact timeframe of the sub-claim, though it focuses on Iraq's non-compliance and concealment rather than specifically on nuclear weapons program reconstitution.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document presents Powell's arguments about Iraq's past non-compliance and current obligations under Resolution 1441, but does not directly address whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003; the excerpt ends before presenting specific evidence about nuclear weapons reconstitution.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us state department 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3068, "completion_tokens": 356, "total_tokens": 3424, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0050018400000000005, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.209156Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Carnegie Endowment is a reputable think tank with established editorial standards and institutional credibility. The document cites unclassified prewar intelligence records, administration statements, and post-invasion evidence as sources, though this excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than primary documentation, and the full methodological rigor cannot be fully assessed from the excerpt alone.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, { "type": "study", "id": "wmd in iraq evidence and implications" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Carnegie Endowment is a reputable think tank with established editorial standards and institutional credibility. The document cites unclassified prewar intelligence records, administration statements, and post-invasion evidence as sources, though this excerpt itself is secondary analysis rather than primary documentation, and the full methodological rigor cannot be fully assessed from the excerpt alone.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's WMD capabilities and prewar intelligence claims broadly, but this excerpt focuses on historiographical debate and methodology rather than directly reporting on whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses prewar intelligence claims and administration statements about Iraqi WMD capabilities but does not directly address whether Iraq actually held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003, instead noting the administration shifted its claims from 'actual weapons and massive stockpiles' to 'capabilities' and 'capability that Iraq sought.'\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"carnegie endowment for international peace\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wmd in iraq evidence and implications\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2933, "completion_tokens": 349, "total_tokens": 3282, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00483616, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.209274Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is reputable analysis from an established think tank (Carnegie Endowment) by a named author (Jessica Tuchman Mathews, a recognized expert), examining primary government documents (the National Intelligence Estimate). However, it is secondary analysis and commentary rather than a primary document itself, and lacks peer review, though it demonstrates careful sourcing of official records.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is reputable analysis from an established think tank (Carnegie Endowment) by a named author (Jessica Tuchman Mathews, a recognized expert), examining primary government documents (the National Intelligence Estimate). However, it is secondary analysis and commentary rather than a primary document itself, and lacks peer review, though it demonstrates careful sourcing of official records.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraq's WMD programs and the intelligence assessments about them as of March 2003, though it focuses on intelligence misrepresentation rather than definitively reporting whether reconstitution actually occurred.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses misrepresentation of intelligence assessments and failures to find WMD, but does not directly address whether Iraq had actually reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"carnegie endowment for international peace\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia white paper iraqs weapons of mass destruction\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3106, "completion_tokens": 348, "total_tokens": 3454, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00472716, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.209395Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.0, "quality_rationale": "This document is a finding aid/index page describing CIA FOIA holdings about Nixon's 1972 China trip, not a substantive source document on Iraq's weapons programs. It contains no evidence, analysis, or information relevant to the stated topic and appears to be a metadata/catalog entry rather than source material.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is a finding aid/index page describing CIA FOIA holdings about Nixon's 1972 China trip, not a substantive source document on Iraq's weapons programs. It contains no evidence, analysis, or information relevant to the stated topic and appears to be a metadata/catalog entry rather than source material.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is a CIA FOIA reading room index describing materials related to Nixon's 1972 trip to China and contains no information whatsoever about Iraq's chemical weapons stockpiles in 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a CIA FOIA reading room index describing materials about Nixon's 1972 China trip and contains no content whatsoever addressing Iraqi chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3188, "completion_tokens": 768, "total_tokens": 3956, "reasoning_tokens": 498 }, "cost_usd": 0.0061289759999999995, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.209521Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.0, "quality_rationale": "This document is a finding aid/index page describing CIA FOIA holdings about Nixon's 1972 China trip, not a substantive source document on Iraq's weapons programs. It contains no evidence, analysis, or information relevant to the stated topic and appears to be a metadata/catalog entry rather than source material.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is a finding aid/index page describing CIA FOIA holdings about Nixon's 1972 China trip, not a substantive source document on Iraq's weapons programs. It contains no evidence, analysis, or information relevant to the stated topic and appears to be a metadata/catalog entry rather than source material.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is a CIA FOIA reading room index describing materials about Nixon's 1972 trip to China and contains no information whatsoever about Iraq's nuclear weapons program or its status in 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a CIA FOIA reading room index describing materials about Nixon's 1972 China trip and contains no information whatsoever about Iraq's nuclear weapons program or its status in 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3184, "completion_tokens": 769, "total_tokens": 3953, "reasoning_tokens": 498 }, "cost_usd": 0.006129976, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.209627Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The document cites the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate as a primary source and directly quotes official U.S. Intelligence Community assessments, providing named sourcing and official records. However, it is a secondary compilation/summary of those primary documents rather than the primary document itself, and globalsecurity.org, while reputable for archival purposes, is not a peer-reviewed publisher or official inquiry body.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate as a primary source and directly quotes official U.S. Intelligence Community assessments, providing named sourcing and official records. However, it is a secondary compilation/summary of those primary documents rather than the primary document itself, and globalsecurity.org, while reputable for archival purposes, is not a peer-reviewed publisher or official inquiry body.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on prewar 2003 intelligence assessments of Iraq's biological weapons stockpiles and active production program, including specific judgments about weapons possession and program status.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document presents the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate's assessments that Iraq's offensive BW program was active with stockpiles and production capabilities as of the prewar 2003 period, though these are intelligence judgments rather than direct observations.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3103, "completion_tokens": 1238, "total_tokens": 4341, "reasoning_tokens": 937 }, "cost_usd": 0.0073130654, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.209734Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official UN Security Council document (S/2003/232) containing a primary report from UNMOVIC's Executive Chairman submitted under formal mandate. It represents an authoritative institutional record with clear provenance, official distribution protocols, and direct accountability to the Security Council, though it is a secondary compilation of inspection activities rather than raw inspection data itself.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official UN Security Council document (S/2003/232) containing a primary report from UNMOVIC's Executive Chairman submitted under formal mandate. It represents an authoritative institutional record with clear provenance, official distribution protocols, and direct accountability to the Security Council, though it is a secondary compilation of inspection activities rather than raw inspection data itself.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a quarterly report on UNMOVIC inspection activities during December 2002-February 2003 that addresses Iraq's declarations and disarmament issues, but the excerpt provided does not directly report findings about chemical weapons stockpiles or their military significance as of March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document excerpt is a procedural cover note and introduction to a quarterly report on UNMOVIC inspection activities; it does not contain substantive findings or assertions about whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3248, "completion_tokens": 798, "total_tokens": 4046, "reasoning_tokens": 555 }, "cost_usd": 0.00695348, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.209850Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a primary document from the Iraq Survey Group, an official U.S.-led inspection body with direct access to Iraqi facilities and records post-2003. The ISG Final Report represents the definitive official inquiry into Iraqi weapons programs with named sources (IAEA, Coalition records, facility inspections) and represents the authoritative primary record on this topic, though the 2026 publication date on globalsecurity.org suggests this is a republication of the original 2004 report rather than a new primary source.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a primary document from the Iraq Survey Group, an official U.S.-led inspection body with direct access to Iraqi facilities and records post-2003. The ISG Final Report represents the definitive official inquiry into Iraqi weapons programs with named sources (IAEA, Coalition records, facility inspections) and represents the authoritative primary record on this topic, though the 2026 publication date on globalsecurity.org suggests this is a republication of the original 2004 report rather than a new primary source.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the exact sub-claim by explicitly stating 'Iraq did not possess a nuclear device, nor had it tried to reconstitute a capability to produce nuclear weapons after 1991' and providing detailed findings about Iraq's failure to reconstitute nuclear weapons capabilities by 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.95,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The ISG Final Report directly states as a finding from investigation that 'Iraq did not possess a nuclear device, nor had it tried to reconstitute a capability to produce nuclear weapons after 1991,' explicitly contradicting the sub-claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2983, "completion_tokens": 368, "total_tokens": 3351, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0047275600000000004, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.209966Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official UN Security Council document presenting the oral testimony of UNMOVIC's Executive Chairman on weapons inspections in Iraq, representing a primary source from an authoritative international body with direct access to inspection data and findings. The source carries institutional credibility and represents contemporaneous official records from the relevant UN inspection regime.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official UN Security Council document presenting the oral testimony of UNMOVIC's Executive Chairman on weapons inspections in Iraq, representing a primary source from an authoritative international body with direct access to inspection data and findings. The source carries institutional credibility and represents contemporaneous official records from the relevant UN inspection regime.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses UNMOVIC inspections in Iraq as of March 2003 and discusses inspection capabilities and access, which is closely related to assessing chemical weapons stockpiles, though it does not explicitly report findings about the presence or absence of such stockpiles.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes inspection procedures and access logistics as of March 7, 2003, but contains no content addressing whether Iraq actually held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles at that time.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic 12th quarterly report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3112, "completion_tokens": 2859, "total_tokens": 5971, "reasoning_tokens": 2555 }, "cost_usd": 0.0086086832, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.210085Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source cites primary documents and direct statements from named UN officials (ElBaradei and Blix) with specific dates and findings, published by a reputable arms control organization with editorial standards. However, it is a secondary analysis/opinion piece rather than a primary document, and the excerpt shows advocacy framing ('Unnecessary War,' 'Dismisses') that suggests interpretive rather than purely factual reporting.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea march 2003 report" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source cites primary documents and direct statements from named UN officials (ElBaradei and Blix) with specific dates and findings, published by a reputable arms control organization with editorial standards. However, it is a secondary analysis/opinion piece rather than a primary document, and the excerpt shows advocacy framing ('Unnecessary War,' 'Dismisses') that suggests interpretive rather than purely factual reporting.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on the exact sub-claim by citing IAEA Director ElBaradei's March 7, 2003 statement that inspectors found 'no evidence or plausible indication of the revival of a nuclear weapons programme in Iraq,' which directly addresses whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by that date.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"ElBaradei's direct statement based on IAEA inspections found 'no evidence or plausible indication of the revival of a nuclear weapons programme in Iraq' as of March 7, 2003, directly contradicting the sub-claim of reconstitution.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea march 2003 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic march 2003 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"bush administration statements\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3114, "completion_tokens": 3963, "total_tokens": 7077, "reasoning_tokens": 4014 }, "cost_usd": 0.01938596, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.210203Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a primary document—the official transcript of Secretary of State Colin Powell's February 5, 2003 UN Security Council presentation—with clear attribution and sourcing to named intelligence assessments and defector information. However, it is an advocacy document presenting arguments for a policy position rather than an independent investigation, and subsequent assessments found many of its specific claims about Iraqi weapons programs to be inaccurate, which affects its reliability as evidence on the actual state of Iraq's weapons programs.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi defectors" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a primary document—the official transcript of Secretary of State Colin Powell's February 5, 2003 UN Security Council presentation—with clear attribution and sourcing to named intelligence assessments and defector information. However, it is an advocacy document presenting arguments for a policy position rather than an independent investigation, and subsequent assessments found many of its specific claims about Iraqi weapons programs to be inaccurate, which affects its reliability as evidence on the actual state of Iraq's weapons programs.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq reconstituted its nuclear program by discussing post-1998 efforts to reconstitute the program and claims about current capabilities as of February 2003, though it focuses more on intent and components rather than definitively establishing reconstitution status by the specific March 2003 date.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Powell states Iraq 'has ever abandoned his nuclear weapons program' and describes efforts 'to reconstitute his nuclear program' since 1998 focused on acquiring fissile material, but explicitly describes these as ongoing efforts and intentions rather than completed reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n\\\"roots\\\": [\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us intelligence community\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi defectors\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cnn\\\"}\\n]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3050, "completion_tokens": 2236, "total_tokens": 5286, "reasoning_tokens": 1841 }, "cost_usd": 0.012475360000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.210322Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is ordinary journalism reporting on statements made by David Kay and administration officials regarding Iraq's weapons programs. While it relays findings from a primary source (Kay's public statements and his role with the ISG), it is a news article summarizing and interpreting those statements rather than presenting primary documents or official records directly, and lacks the depth of sourcing or editorial rigor of investigative reporting.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate armed services committee 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is ordinary journalism reporting on statements made by David Kay and administration officials regarding Iraq's weapons programs. While it relays findings from a primary source (Kay's public statements and his role with the ISG), it is a news article summarizing and interpreting those statements rather than presenting primary documents or official records directly, and lacks the depth of sourcing or editorial rigor of investigative reporting.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003 by reporting Kay's conclusion that no significant stockpiles would be found and that Iraq destroyed its weapons before 1991, making it a closely related assessment of the exact proposition under test.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Kay asserts that Iraq destroyed its chemical and biological weapons before 1991 and did not resume large-scale production, directly contradicting the claim of militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay statements 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia announcement january 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate armed services committee hearing 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2890, "completion_tokens": 363, "total_tokens": 3253, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.004711, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.210451Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is secondary analysis/commentary by a named analyst (Joseph Cirincione) at a reputable think tank, relaying and interpreting Powell's primary UN presentation and other nations' reactions to it. While the Carnegie Endowment has credibility and the author is identified, the piece is analytical opinion about primary events rather than primary documentation or peer-reviewed research, and it explicitly frames the analysis as advocacy-oriented commentary ('analysis of the secretary's remarks').", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jordan times editorial 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is secondary analysis/commentary by a named analyst (Joseph Cirincione) at a reputable think tank, relaying and interpreting Powell's primary UN presentation and other nations' reactions to it. While the Carnegie Endowment has credibility and the author is identified, the piece is analytical opinion about primary events rather than primary documentation or peer-reviewed research, and it explicitly frames the analysis as advocacy-oriented commentary ('analysis of the secretary's remarks').\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Powell's UN presentation about Iraq's failure to comply with disarmament orders and Iraqi deception, which relates to the broader question of Iraqi WMD programs, but does not directly report on or test whether Iraq specifically held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Powell's presentation and international reactions to it, but does not directly address whether Iraq actually held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003; it only characterizes Powell's claims as focused on 'deception' and notes that other nations found the evidence unconvincing.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un security council presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"jordan times editorial 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3095, "completion_tokens": 3864, "total_tokens": 6959, "reasoning_tokens": 3499 }, "cost_usd": 0.011262455568, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.210581Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is secondary analysis/commentary by a named analyst (Joseph Cirincione) at a reputable think tank, relaying and interpreting Powell's primary UN presentation and other nations' reactions to it. While the Carnegie Endowment has credibility and the author is identified, the piece is analytical opinion about primary events rather than primary documentation or peer-reviewed research, and it explicitly frames the analysis as advocacy-oriented commentary ('analysis of the secretary's remarks').", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jordan times editorial 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is secondary analysis/commentary by a named analyst (Joseph Cirincione) at a reputable think tank, relaying and interpreting Powell's primary UN presentation and other nations' reactions to it. While the Carnegie Endowment has credibility and the author is identified, the piece is analytical opinion about primary events rather than primary documentation or peer-reviewed research, and it explicitly frames the analysis as advocacy-oriented commentary ('analysis of the secretary's remarks').\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Powell's UN presentation about Iraq's failure to comply with disarmament orders and deception, which relates to nuclear weapons programs broadly, but does not directly address whether Iraq had specifically reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.6,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document characterizes Powell's presentation as proving 'Iraqi deception' but not establishing an 'imminent threat,' and reports that international observers found no convincing evidence Iraq presented 'any real or imminent danger,' which contradicts the claim of nuclear weapons program reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un security council presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"jordan times editorial 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3083, "completion_tokens": 3851, "total_tokens": 6934, "reasoning_tokens": 3499 }, "cost_usd": 0.011185455568, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.210697Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "CNN is reporting on an official primary document (the CIA/Iraq Survey Group report by Charles Duelfer), with named sources, direct quotes from testimony, and specific details about the report's scope and findings. However, this is secondary reporting on a primary source rather than the primary document itself, and journalistic reporting has editorial standards but lacks the rigor of peer review or official inquiry status.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CNN is reporting on an official primary document (the CIA/Iraq Survey Group report by Charles Duelfer), with named sources, direct quotes from testimony, and specific details about the report's scope and findings. However, this is secondary reporting on a primary source rather than the primary document itself, and journalistic reporting has editorial standards but lacks the rigor of peer review or official inquiry status.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the exact sub-claim by reporting a CIA conclusion that Saddam Hussein did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the U.S. invasion in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports a CIA conclusion that Saddam Hussein did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the March 2003 invasion, directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfel\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3103, "completion_tokens": 340, "total_tokens": 3443, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.004709472, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.210846Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "CNN is reporting on an official primary document (the CIA/Iraq Survey Group report by Charles Duelfer), with named sources, direct quotes from testimony, and specific details about the report's scope and findings. However, this is secondary reporting on a primary source rather than the primary document itself, and journalistic reporting has editorial standards but lacks the rigor of peer review or official inquiry status.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CNN is reporting on an official primary document (the CIA/Iraq Survey Group report by Charles Duelfer), with named sources, direct quotes from testimony, and specific details about the report's scope and findings. However, this is secondary reporting on a primary source rather than the primary document itself, and journalistic reporting has editorial standards but lacks the rigor of peer review or official inquiry status.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the exact sub-claim by reporting a CIA conclusion that Saddam Hussein did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons in March 2003 and had not begun any program to produce them.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports a CIA conclusion based on the Iraq Survey Group's investigation that Saddam Hussein did not possess WMD stockpiles in March 2003 and had not begun any production program, directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfel\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3111, "completion_tokens": 349, "total_tokens": 3460, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.004762472, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.210959Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is from a reputable non-profit organization (Arms Control Association) with named contacts and editorial standards, presenting a chronology that references primary sources (State of the Union Address, IAEA inspectors, Senate committee investigations) and official records. However, it is secondary analysis and advocacy-oriented rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study, and the organization has a clear policy position on arms control issues that could constitute a conflict of interest.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "arms control association" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is from a reputable non-profit organization (Arms Control Association) with named contacts and editorial standards, presenting a chronology that references primary sources (State of the Union Address, IAEA inspectors, Senate committee investigations) and official records. However, it is secondary analysis and advocacy-oriented rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study, and the organization has a clear policy position on arms control issues that could constitute a conflict of interest.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the sub-claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003 as a central proposition being evaluated, though it focuses primarily on the uranium-from-Niger claim as evidence rather than comprehensively assessing the reconstitution claim itself.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that IAEA inspectors found no evidence Iraq reconstituted its nuclear program, and characterizes the administration's claims as 'erroneous,' directly contradicting the sub-claim, though the document itself reports assertions rather than presenting direct inspection findings.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"arms control association\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush administration\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2917, "completion_tokens": 405, "total_tokens": 3322, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0050527523695, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.211060Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is from a reputable arms control advocacy organization with editorial standards, cites named primary sources (Scott McClellan, Charles Duelfer, ISG reports), and references official records and government statements. However, it is secondary reporting on primary documents rather than a primary document itself, and the publisher has a known advocacy mission which may influence framing, though not the factual sourcing.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is from a reputable arms control advocacy organization with editorial standards, cites named primary sources (Scott McClellan, Charles Duelfer, ISG reports), and references official records and government statements. However, it is secondary reporting on primary documents rather than a primary document itself, and the publisher has a known advocacy mission which may influence framing, though not the factual sourcing.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held significant WMD stockpiles in March 2003 by reporting that the ISG investigation concluded Iraq had no WMD stockpiles, which is the exact factual claim being tested.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that the Iraq Survey Group's investigation found 'Iraq had no WMD stockpiles' and that the U.S.-led invasion failed to find significant stockpiles, directly contradicting the claim of militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2909, "completion_tokens": 357, "total_tokens": 3266, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00483832, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.211170Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is from a reputable arms control advocacy organization with editorial standards, cites named primary sources (Scott McClellan, Charles Duelfer, ISG reports), and references official records and government statements. However, it is secondary reporting on primary documents rather than a primary document itself, and the publisher has a known advocacy mission which may influence framing, though not the factual sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is from a reputable arms control advocacy organization with editorial standards, cites named primary sources (Scott McClellan, Charles Duelfer, ISG reports), and references official records and government statements. However, it is secondary reporting on primary documents rather than a primary document itself, and the publisher has a known advocacy mission which may influence framing, though not the factual sourcing.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles in March 2003 by reporting that the ISG found Iraq had no WMD stockpiles, though it does not provide detailed evidence about the specific status of biological weapons programs versus stockpiles.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that the Iraq Survey Group's investigation concluded Iraq had no WMD stockpiles, directly contradicting the sub-claim of biological weapons stockpiles or active production in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2917, "completion_tokens": 347, "total_tokens": 3264, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00479632, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.211268Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is from a reputable arms control advocacy organization with editorial standards, cites named primary sources (Scott McClellan, Charles Duelfer, ISG reports), and references official records and government statements. However, it is secondary reporting on primary documents rather than a primary document itself, and the publisher has a known advocacy mission which may influence framing, though not the factual sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is from a reputable arms control advocacy organization with editorial standards, cites named primary sources (Scott McClellan, Charles Duelfer, ISG reports), and references official records and government statements. However, it is secondary reporting on primary documents rather than a primary document itself, and the publisher has a known advocacy mission which may influence framing, though not the factual sourcing.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003, reporting that UN weapons inspectors found no evidence of reconstitution and that the ISG investigation found no WMD stockpiles, though it does not exhaustively detail the nuclear program question in isolation.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that UN weapons inspectors found no evidence Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program prior to the invasion, and the ISG's investigation found no WMD stockpiles, directly contradicting the sub-claim of reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2905, "completion_tokens": 374, "total_tokens": 3279, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00491932, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.211375Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is from a reputable arms control advocacy organization with editorial standards, cites named primary sources (Scott McClellan, Charles Duelfer, ISG reports), and references official records and government statements. However, it is secondary reporting on primary documents rather than a primary document itself, and the publisher has a known advocacy mission which may influence framing, though not the factual sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is from a reputable arms control advocacy organization with editorial standards, cites named primary sources (Scott McClellan, Charles Duelfer, ISG reports), and references official records and government statements. However, it is secondary reporting on primary documents rather than a primary document itself, and the publisher has a known advocacy mission which may influence framing, though not the factual sourcing.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003, reporting that UN weapons inspectors found no evidence of reconstitution and that the ISG investigation found no WMD stockpiles, though it does not exhaustively detail the nuclear program question in isolation.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that UN weapons inspectors found no evidence Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program before the invasion, and the ISG's investigation found no WMD stockpiles, supporting the sub-claim, though these are reported assertions rather than direct findings by the document's author.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 860, "completion_tokens": 104, "total_tokens": 964, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00138, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.211375Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a primary government document (declassified Office of the Vice President memo) with official Bates numbering and sourcing, containing direct citations to CIA papers and Congressional records from the 2002-2004 period. It represents an official record of internal government communications regarding Iraq WMD assessments, though the excerpt quality is compromised by OCR errors and redactions.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "new yorker article sy hersh" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "british white paper september 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a primary government document (declassified Office of the Vice President memo) with official Bates numbering and sourcing, containing direct citations to CIA papers and Congressional records from the 2002-2004 period. It represents an official record of internal government communications regarding Iraq WMD assessments, though the excerpt quality is compromised by OCR errors and redactions.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's alleged uranium procurement efforts, which is part of the broader nuclear weapons program question, but focuses specifically on the Niger uranium deal controversy rather than directly assessing whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses disputed intelligence assessments about Iraq seeking uranium from Niger, but does not directly address whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia paper april 3 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"new yorker article sy hersh\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"british white paper september 2002\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3578, "completion_tokens": 380, "total_tokens": 3958, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0056131206112499995, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.211559Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article summarizing institutional history and publicly available UN resolutions rather than original research or primary documentation. While it references official UN Security Council resolutions as sources, it is a secondary encyclopedia entry with editorial standards but lacks the depth, primary sourcing, and verification rigor of peer-reviewed scholarship or official inquiries into the specific question of Iraq's weapons programs and stockpiles.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia article summarizing institutional history and publicly available UN resolutions rather than original research or primary documentation. While it references official UN Security Council resolutions as sources, it is a secondary encyclopedia entry with editorial standards but lacks the depth, primary sourcing, and verification rigor of peer-reviewed scholarship or official inquiries into the specific question of Iraq's weapons programs and stockpiles.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the institutional framework and timeline of weapons inspections in Iraq but does not directly report on or test whether Iraq actually held chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes UNMOVIC's mandate and history but contains no content addressing whether Iraq actually held chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3152, "completion_tokens": 2080, "total_tokens": 5232, "reasoning_tokens": 1770 }, "cost_usd": 0.010241336, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.211680Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article summarizing institutional history and publicly available UN resolutions rather than original research or primary documentation. While it references official UN Security Council resolutions as sources, it is a secondary encyclopedia entry with editorial standards but lacks the depth, primary sourcing, and verification rigor of peer-reviewed scholarship or official inquiries into the specific question of Iraq's weapons programs and stockpiles.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia article summarizing institutional history and publicly available UN resolutions rather than original research or primary documentation. While it references official UN Security Council resolutions as sources, it is a secondary encyclopedia entry with editorial standards but lacks the depth, primary sourcing, and verification rigor of peer-reviewed scholarship or official inquiries into the specific question of Iraq's weapons programs and stockpiles.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides background on UNMOVIC's mandate to verify Iraqi WMD disarmament and notes Iraq's non-cooperation with inspections, but does not directly report on whether Iraq actually held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes UNMOVIC's mandate and history but contains no content addressing whether Iraq actually held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3160, "completion_tokens": 2104, "total_tokens": 5264, "reasoning_tokens": 1770 }, "cost_usd": 0.010369336, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.211793Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article summarizing institutional history and publicly available UN resolutions rather than original research or primary documentation. While it references official UN Security Council resolutions as sources, it is a secondary encyclopedia entry with editorial standards but lacks the depth, primary sourcing, and verification rigor of peer-reviewed scholarship or official inquiries into the specific question of Iraq's weapons programs and stockpiles.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia article summarizing institutional history and publicly available UN resolutions rather than original research or primary documentation. While it references official UN Security Council resolutions as sources, it is a secondary encyclopedia entry with editorial standards but lacks the depth, primary sourcing, and verification rigor of peer-reviewed scholarship or official inquiries into the specific question of Iraq's weapons programs and stockpiles.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides background on UNMOVIC's mandate to verify Iraqi WMD disarmament and notes Iraq's non-cooperation with inspections, but does not directly report on whether Iraq actually held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes UNMOVIC's mandate and history but contains no content addressing whether Iraq actually held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 881, "completion_tokens": 80, "total_tokens": 961, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001281, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.211793Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article summarizing a historical event (Powell's UN presentation) rather than primary source material or original reporting. While it cites multiple sources and includes relevant context about the speech's disputed accuracy, it is a secondary source that relays and synthesizes information from other sources, including Powell's own later statements and CIA analyst commentary.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "office of the vice president" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia article summarizing a historical event (Powell's UN presentation) rather than primary source material or original reporting. While it cites multiple sources and includes relevant context about the speech's disputed accuracy, it is a secondary source that relays and synthesizes information from other sources, including Powell's own later statements and CIA analyst commentary.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Powell's February 2003 claims about Iraq's WMD programs, which is closely related to the nuclear weapons reconstitution claim, though it focuses more broadly on WMDs generally rather than specifically on nuclear weapons reconstitution.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes Powell's assertions about Iraq's WMD production but does not address nuclear weapons specifically, and explicitly notes the intelligence was later discredited as a 'great intelligence failure.'\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of state february 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"office of the vice president\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2998, "completion_tokens": 335, "total_tokens": 3333, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00482092, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.211987Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article summarizing a historical event (Powell's UN presentation) rather than primary source material or original reporting. While it cites multiple sources and includes relevant context about the speech's disputed accuracy, it is a secondary source that relays and synthesizes information from other sources, including Powell's own later statements and CIA analyst commentary.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "office of the vice president" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia article summarizing a historical event (Powell's UN presentation) rather than primary source material or original reporting. While it cites multiple sources and includes relevant context about the speech's disputed accuracy, it is a secondary source that relays and synthesizes information from other sources, including Powell's own later statements and CIA analyst commentary.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Powell's February 2003 claims about Iraq's WMD programs, which is closely related to the nuclear weapons reconstitution claim, though it focuses more broadly on WMDs generally rather than specifically on nuclear weapons reconstitution.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.6,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes Powell's February 2003 presentation asserting Iraq was producing WMDs and violating UN resolutions, which contradicts the sub-claim that Iraq had not reconstituted its nuclear program; however, the document also notes Powell later called it a 'great intelligence failure,' undermining the credibility of those assertions.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of state february 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"office of the vice president\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 883, "completion_tokens": 114, "total_tokens": 997, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001453, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.211987Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Chemical & Engineering News is a long-running professional trade publication with editorial standards, but this is still secondary reporting rather than a primary or peer-reviewed source. The excerpt relies mainly on the Iraq Survey Group/Duelfer report and congressional testimony, which strengthens sourcing, though the article itself is not an official inquiry.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate armed services committee 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Chemical & Engineering News is a long-running professional trade publication with editorial standards, but this is still secondary reporting rather than a primary or peer-reviewed source. The excerpt relies mainly on the Iraq Survey Group/Duelfer report and congressional testimony, which strengthens sourcing, though the article itself is not an official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses the Iraq Survey Group’s findings on whether Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active BW production program before the 2003 invasion, which closely matches the sub-claim, though it is framed as a broader assessment of Iraq’s WMD programs.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.95,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says the Iraq Survey Group found no evidence of biological weapons stockpiles or active production programs before the 2003 invasion and that Iraq had destroyed its biological weapons stockpiles in the early 1990s.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"senate armed services committee 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2964, "completion_tokens": 1840, "total_tokens": 4804, "reasoning_tokens": 1739 }, "cost_usd": 0.01008394, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.212150Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "NBC News is a mainstream outlet with normal editorial standards, but this is a news report summarizing Duelfer’s official findings rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study. Its evidentiary value rests largely on relaying official investigation results and anonymous official comment, with limited direct sourcing in the excerpt.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"NBC News is a mainstream outlet with normal editorial standards, but this is a news report summarizing Duelfer’s official findings rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study. Its evidentiary value rests largely on relaying official investigation results and anonymous official comment, with limited direct sourcing in the excerpt.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The article discusses the CIA/ISG final findings on Iraq’s WMD investigation, which is closely related to whether Iraq still had biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons program in March 2003, but it does not specifically focus on that exact biological-weapons claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.95,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says the Iraq Survey Group’s investigation was exhausted and had found nothing, which directly contradicts the claim that Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or had an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfers\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2780, "completion_tokens": 281, "total_tokens": 3061, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0037119600000000003, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.212270Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a published report summarizing the Iraq Survey Group’s findings, drawing on investigation and physical evidence rather than merely opinion. As hosted by GlobalSecurity.org, it is a secondary presentation of an official report with unclear editorial review, so it is reliable but not a primary record or peer-reviewed source.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a published report summarizing the Iraq Survey Group’s findings, drawing on investigation and physical evidence rather than merely opinion. As hosted by GlobalSecurity.org, it is a secondary presentation of an official report with unclear editorial review, so it is reliable but not a primary record or peer-reviewed source.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses the Iraq Survey Group’s investigation of suspected chemical and biological stockpiles and the effort to determine what happened to Iraqi WMD programs, which is closely related to whether Iraq had significant chemical weapon stockpiles in March 2003, but it does not directly state that proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says prewar planning assumed chemical stocks were likely and that sites were inspected for possible WMD, but it does not report a finding that Iraq actually held militarily significant chemical weapon stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2696, "completion_tokens": 259, "total_tokens": 2955, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0035470707194999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.212376Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary source with community-edited content and variable editorial oversight, so it is not a primary or peer-reviewed record. It can summarize official reports and other sources well, but its provenance and reliability depend on the specific citations and article quality rather than on a formal publishing standard.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq intelligence commission" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary source with community-edited content and variable editorial oversight, so it is not a primary or peer-reviewed record. It can summarize official reports and other sources well, but its provenance and reliability depend on the specific citations and article quality rather than on a formal publishing standard.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly discusses whether Iraq possessed stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the March 2003 invasion, but it is framed as a postwar assessment and broader WMD controversy rather than a focused report on chemical weapons stockpiles specifically.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"mixed\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says the CIA found Saddam Hussein did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the March 2003 invasion and that UNMOVIC/ISG failed to find the alleged stockpiles, which directly contradicts the claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq intelligence commission\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2896, "completion_tokens": 6836, "total_tokens": 9732, "reasoning_tokens": 6552 }, "cost_usd": 0.03660375, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.212504Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary source with community-edited content and variable editorial oversight, so it is not a primary or peer-reviewed record. It can summarize official reports and other sources well, but its provenance and reliability depend on the specific citations and article quality rather than on a formal publishing standard.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq intelligence commission" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary source with community-edited content and variable editorial oversight, so it is not a primary or peer-reviewed record. It can summarize official reports and other sources well, but its provenance and reliability depend on the specific citations and article quality rather than on a formal publishing standard.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":1.0,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly states the CIA finding that Iraq did not possess stockpiles or have a program to produce them at the time of the U.S. invasion in March 2003, which is exactly the sub-claim at issue.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.95,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"mixed\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says UNMOVIC and the Iraq Survey Group failed to find Iraqi WMD stockpiles, and cites CIA findings that Iraq did not possess stockpiles or an active production program in March 2003, directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq intelligence commission\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2904, "completion_tokens": 6833, "total_tokens": 9737, "reasoning_tokens": 6552 }, "cost_usd": 0.03659625, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.212612Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a reposting of a named U.S. government official’s UN speech, so the underlying content is a primary source with strong documentary value. The host site appears to be an ordinary third-party publisher, so the source quality is good but not as strong as an official archive or direct UN transcript.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a reposting of a named U.S. government official’s UN speech, so the underlying content is a primary source with strong documentary value. The host site appears to be an ordinary third-party publisher, so the source quality is good but not as strong as an official archive or direct UN transcript.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's alleged WMD disarmament violations and concealment in early 2003, which is adjacent to nuclear reconstitution but does not directly address whether the nuclear weapons program had been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.2,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt asserts that Iraq had concealed prohibited weapons-related activity and needed disarmament, which weakly supports the idea of a revived nuclear program, but it does not directly state that a nuclear weapons program had been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2817, "completion_tokens": 3311, "total_tokens": 6128, "reasoning_tokens": 3497 }, "cost_usd": 0.01577533, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.212723Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a declassified excerpt from a U.S. National Intelligence Estimate reproduced in the Congressional Record, which makes it a primary government document with strong provenance and official sourcing. The IRP/FAS page is just a repository for the document, not the substantive source, so the underlying material is high-quality evidence despite being an excerpt rather than the full record.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a declassified excerpt from a U.S. National Intelligence Estimate reproduced in the Congressional Record, which makes it a primary government document with strong provenance and official sourcing. The IRP/FAS page is just a repository for the document, not the substantive source, so the underlying material is high-quality evidence despite being an excerpt rather than the full record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses the October 2002 NIE’s judgment that Iraq was attempting to reconstitute its nuclear capacity and lacking specific information on key aspects of its WMD programs, which is closely related to whether the nuclear weapons program had been reconstituted by March 2003, though it does not directly address that exact date.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.7,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt states that intelligence agencies judged Iraq was \\\\\\\"attempting to reconstitute its nuclear capacity\\\\\\\" and that, if left unchecked, it probably would have a nuclear weapon during the decade, which supports the claim that the program had been reconstituted by March 2003, though only as an assessment rather than direct proof.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2976, "completion_tokens": 2535, "total_tokens": 5511, "reasoning_tokens": 2245 }, "cost_usd": 0.01139718, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.212864Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "SIPRI is a highly reputable research institute with strong editorial standards, and this is a signed analytical article rather than anonymous commentary. It is secondary-source synthesis drawing on inspectors, official testimony, and prior reporting rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"SIPRI is a highly reputable research institute with strong editorial standards, and this is a signed analytical article rather than anonymous commentary. It is secondary-source synthesis drawing on inspectors, official testimony, and prior reporting rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt addresses Iraq’s alleged WMD and the 2003 invasion case broadly, but it does not directly report on whether militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles existed in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.8,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt states that the case for the invasion rested on premises that were not true and that the ISG found no WMD in Iraq, which contradicts the claim that Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay senate testimony 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3007, "completion_tokens": 4570, "total_tokens": 7577, "reasoning_tokens": 4299 }, "cost_usd": 0.0106657464, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.212970Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "SIPRI is a highly reputable research institute with strong editorial standards, and this is a signed analytical article rather than anonymous commentary. It is secondary-source synthesis drawing on inspectors, official testimony, and prior reporting rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"SIPRI is a highly reputable research institute with strong editorial standards, and this is a signed analytical article rather than anonymous commentary. It is secondary-source synthesis drawing on inspectors, official testimony, and prior reporting rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt addresses whether Iraq had WMD or was developing such programs in the period leading up to March 2003, which closely overlaps with the specific claim about biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program, though it is framed more broadly.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt explicitly says the invasion case was based on unreliable scraps of information and that 'None of them was true,' while noting the ISG found no WMD in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay senate testimony 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3015, "completion_tokens": 4567, "total_tokens": 7582, "reasoning_tokens": 4299 }, "cost_usd": 0.0106582464, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.213069Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a report attributed to the Iraq Survey Group, a U.S.-led official investigative body, which gives it substantial evidentiary weight and strong sourcing compared with ordinary journalism. However, the document is hosted by a secondary publisher rather than being the primary archival record itself, so it is not at the highest end of source quality.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a report attributed to the Iraq Survey Group, a U.S.-led official investigative body, which gives it substantial evidentiary weight and strong sourcing compared with ordinary journalism. However, the document is hosted by a secondary publisher rather than being the primary archival record itself, so it is not at the highest end of source quality.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The report is specifically about Iraq’s nuclear weapons program and its evolution through 2003, so it closely addresses whether that program had been reconstituted by March 2003, though not necessarily in that exact phrasing.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s historical nuclear ambitions and facilities, but it does not state that the nuclear weapons program had been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2953, "completion_tokens": 2703, "total_tokens": 5656, "reasoning_tokens": 2474 }, "cost_usd": 0.010752959999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.213167Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article, so it is a secondary, collaboratively edited source rather than a primary or peer-reviewed record. Its value depends on the quality of the cited references and editorial maintenance, which can be uneven despite Wikimedia’s general openness and citation norms.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article, so it is a secondary, collaboratively edited source rather than a primary or peer-reviewed record. Its value depends on the quality of the cited references and editorial maintenance, which can be uneven despite Wikimedia’s general openness and citation norms.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s past chemical weapons stockpiles, their destruction, and the resumption of inspections in late 2002 to March 2003, which is adjacent background but does not directly report on whether militarily significant stockpiles existed in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.7,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says Iraq's chemical weapons stockpile had been destroyed after the Gulf War and that Iraq ceased its chemical program, which cuts against the claim that it still held militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2809, "completion_tokens": 323, "total_tokens": 3132, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0038919191489999996, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.213269Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article, so it is a secondary, collaboratively edited source rather than a primary or peer-reviewed record. Its value depends on the quality of the cited references and editorial maintenance, which can be uneven despite Wikimedia’s general openness and citation norms.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article, so it is a secondary, collaboratively edited source rather than a primary or peer-reviewed record. Its value depends on the quality of the cited references and editorial maintenance, which can be uneven despite Wikimedia’s general openness and citation norms.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s biological weapons program and mentions UN inspections through March 2003, so it is closely related to whether Iraq still had biological stockpiles or an active program at that time, though it does not directly answer the exact March 2003 status.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.7,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says Iraq’s biological weapons program had been halted after 1991 and that claims of continued WMD stockpiling were false, which contradicts the claim of an active biological weapons program or stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2817, "completion_tokens": 325, "total_tokens": 3142, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.003906919149, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.213375Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article, so it is a secondary, collaboratively edited source rather than a primary or peer-reviewed record. Its value depends on the quality of the cited references and editorial maintenance, which can be uneven despite Wikimedia’s general openness and citation norms.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article, so it is a secondary, collaboratively edited source rather than a primary or peer-reviewed record. Its value depends on the quality of the cited references and editorial maintenance, which can be uneven despite Wikimedia’s general openness and citation norms.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s biological weapons program and mentions UN inspections through March 2003, so it is closely related to whether Iraq still had biological stockpiles or an active program at that time, though it does not directly answer the exact March 2003 status.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.7,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says Iraq’s biological weapons program had been halted and that its chemical, biological, and nuclear programs had ceased, which supports the claim that Iraq was not running an active biological weapons program in March 2003 and implies no stockpiles, though it is framed as historical assertion rather than direct inspection in this excerpt.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 818, "completion_tokens": 92, "total_tokens": 910, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0010275, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.213375Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a CNN-hosted transcript of an official UN weapons inspector’s presentation to the Security Council, so it is a primary-source record of a formal public statement. CNN is only transcribing/reproducing the speech rather than independently analyzing it, but the underlying source is an official document with strong editorial provenance.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a CNN-hosted transcript of an official UN weapons inspector’s presentation to the Security Council, so it is a primary-source record of a formal public statement. CNN is only transcribing/reproducing the speech rather than independently analyzing it, but the underlying source is an official document with strong editorial provenance.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The transcript concerns UN inspections in Iraq and the state of compliance/access in early 2003, which is only tangential background to whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses inspection progress and access in Iraq, but it does not state that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2864, "completion_tokens": 250, "total_tokens": 3114, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00333687, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.213568Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article published by Wikimedia, so it is a secondary source with editorial oversight but not a peer-reviewed or official record. Its quality depends on the cited references and general article maintenance rather than direct primary evidence.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.86, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article published by Wikimedia, so it is a secondary source with editorial oversight but not a peer-reviewed or official record. Its quality depends on the cited references and general article maintenance rather than direct primary evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses the Iraq Survey Group’s findings about Iraqi chemical weapons stockpiles and whether they were militarily significant, which is closely related to the March 2003 stockpiles claim, though it does not directly address that specific date.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.86,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says the ISG’s report found only small stockpiles of chemical WMDs and that they were inadequate to pose a militarily significant threat, which contradicts the claim of militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2816, "completion_tokens": 4077, "total_tokens": 6893, "reasoning_tokens": 3848 }, "cost_usd": 0.0204543, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.213684Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article published by Wikimedia, so it is a secondary source with editorial oversight but not a peer-reviewed or official record. Its quality depends on the cited references and general article maintenance rather than direct primary evidence.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article published by Wikimedia, so it is a secondary source with editorial oversight but not a peer-reviewed or official record. Its quality depends on the cited references and general article maintenance rather than direct primary evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses the post-invasion Iraq Survey Group’s mission to investigate alleged biological and other WMD stockpiles and production programs, which is closely related to the exact March 2003 biological-weapons claim, though it does not itself directly report Iraq’s status at that date.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt only describes the ISG as a fact-finding mission sent to look for alleged WMD stockpiles and programs; it does not report any actual finding that Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2824, "completion_tokens": 4085, "total_tokens": 6909, "reasoning_tokens": 3848 }, "cost_usd": 0.020496300000000002, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.213795Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article published by Wikimedia, so it is a secondary source with editorial oversight but not a peer-reviewed or official record. Its quality depends on the cited references and general article maintenance rather than direct primary evidence.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article published by Wikimedia, so it is a secondary source with editorial oversight but not a peer-reviewed or official record. Its quality depends on the cited references and general article maintenance rather than direct primary evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document concerns the ISG's investigation into whether Iraq possessed or was developing WMD, including supporting research programs, but it does not directly address the specific claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt only describes the ISG as a fact-finding mission and summarizes its report, but it does not state that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2812, "completion_tokens": 4063, "total_tokens": 6875, "reasoning_tokens": 3848 }, "cost_usd": 0.0203883, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.213913Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a publication of the IAEA, a highly reputable international agency, and the excerpt is a published bulletin article drawing on named official sources (Hans Blix, UN inspections). It is still a secondary account rather than a primary record or formal inquiry report, so it falls below 0.9.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a publication of the IAEA, a highly reputable international agency, and the excerpt is a published bulletin article drawing on named official sources (Hans Blix, UN inspections). It is still a secondary account rather than a primary record or formal inquiry report, so it falls below 0.9.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq inspections, alleged WMD evidence, and the March 2003 invasion, but it does not directly assess whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by that date.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.7,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says UN/IAEA inspections found no weapons of mass destruction in about 700 inspections and only a few leftover items, which undermines the claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3238, "completion_tokens": 3526, "total_tokens": 6764, "reasoning_tokens": 3263 }, "cost_usd": 0.009007359599999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.214010Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a publication of the IAEA, a highly reputable international agency, and the excerpt is a published bulletin article drawing on named official sources (Hans Blix, UN inspections). It is still a secondary account rather than a primary record or formal inquiry report, so it falls below 0.9.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a publication of the IAEA, a highly reputable international agency, and the excerpt is a published bulletin article drawing on named official sources (Hans Blix, UN inspections). It is still a secondary account rather than a primary record or formal inquiry report, so it falls below 0.9.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq inspections, alleged WMD evidence, and the March 2003 invasion, but it does not directly assess whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by that date.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.85,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"mixed\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says Blix and inspectors found no weapons of mass destruction in hundreds of inspections and suggests inspections were cut short before any such finding, which supports the claim that Iraq had not reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 903, "completion_tokens": 75, "total_tokens": 978, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00101475, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.214010Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is an opinion/review article on Opendemocracy by a named former UN weapons inspector, not a primary document or peer-reviewed study. It draws on the ISG report and the author's experience, but the sourcing is limited and the publisher is a commentary platform rather than a formal editorial or research outlet.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an opinion/review article on Opendemocracy by a named former UN weapons inspector, not a primary document or peer-reviewed study. It draws on the ISG report and the author's experience, but the sourcing is limited and the publisher is a commentary platform rather than a formal editorial or research outlet.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's chemical weapons stockpile and inspection findings, but it focuses on postwar reporting and historical disarmament rather than directly establishing whether militarily significant stockpiles existed specifically in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses prior destruction of Iraq's chemical stockpile and the lack of found weapons in 2003, but it does not directly state that militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles existed in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq survey group interim report 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2791, "completion_tokens": 8379, "total_tokens": 11170, "reasoning_tokens": 8120 }, "cost_usd": 0.01911589152, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.214158Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "UN News is an official UN publisher with editorial standards, and this piece reports a live Security Council presentation with direct quotations and references to UN resolutions. However, it is still a news report relaying the claims of a political actor rather than a primary technical record or independent investigation.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"UN News is an official UN publisher with editorial standards, and this piece reports a live Security Council presentation with direct quotations and references to UN resolutions. However, it is still a news report relaying the claims of a political actor rather than a primary technical record or independent investigation.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses Iraq’s alleged failure to disarm and non-compliance with inspections, which is adjacent to nuclear reconstitution, but it does not directly address whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt argues that Iraq was still obstructing disarmament and in material breach, but it does not directly state or establish that Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"powell presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un news\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2808, "completion_tokens": 3053, "total_tokens": 5861, "reasoning_tokens": 2798 }, "cost_usd": 0.01166994, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.214257Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a reposting by the Federation of American Scientists of the October 2002 U.S. intelligence National Intelligence Estimate key judgments, a major official source with named governmental authorship and high editorial credibility. It is still a secondary presentation rather than the original classified document or primary evidence record, so it falls short of a primary/official inquiry document.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.92, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a reposting by the Federation of American Scientists of the October 2002 U.S. intelligence National Intelligence Estimate key judgments, a major official source with named governmental authorship and high editorial credibility. It is still a secondary presentation rather than the original classified document or primary evidence record, so it falls short of a primary/official inquiry document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly discusses Iraq's alleged reconstitution of its nuclear weapons program, but it is a 2002 intelligence assessment rather than a specific determination about whether this had بالفعل occurred by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.92,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt explicitly states that, in the view of most agencies, Baghdad was reconstituting its nuclear weapons program by the time of the October 2002 NIE, which if believed supports the claim that it had reconstituted it by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2691, "completion_tokens": 269, "total_tokens": 2960, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.003580447536, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.214360Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official U.S. government commission report hosted on the White House archives, with extensive endnotes and direct reliance on primary intelligence products and interviews. It has strong editorial and institutional credibility, though it is still a secondary analytical report rather than the original intelligence record.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an official U.S. government commission report hosted on the White House archives, with extensive endnotes and direct reliance on primary intelligence products and interviews. It has strong editorial and institutional credibility, though it is still a secondary analytical report rather than the original intelligence record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is a commission report about U.S. intelligence judgments on Iraq’s WMD programs, so it addresses the broader issue of whether Iraq had chemical weapons, but not specifically the March 2003 stockpile question.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt only describes the Intelligence Community and cites the October 2002 NIE; it does not itself state whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2983, "completion_tokens": 302, "total_tokens": 3285, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00396246, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.214464Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official U.S. government commission report hosted on the White House archives, with extensive endnotes and direct reliance on primary intelligence products and interviews. It has strong editorial and institutional credibility, though it is still a secondary analytical report rather than the original intelligence record.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an official U.S. government commission report hosted on the White House archives, with extensive endnotes and direct reliance on primary intelligence products and interviews. It has strong editorial and institutional credibility, though it is still a secondary analytical report rather than the original intelligence record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is a commission report about U.S. intelligence judgments on Iraq’s WMD programs, so it addresses the broader issue of whether Iraq had chemical weapons, but not specifically the March 2003 stockpile question.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is only endnotes and source descriptions about intelligence estimates and commission scope; it does not state whether Iraq had militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 856, "completion_tokens": 62, "total_tokens": 918, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.000921, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.214464Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official U.S. government commission report hosted on the White House archives, with extensive endnotes and direct reliance on primary intelligence products and interviews. It has strong editorial and institutional credibility, though it is still a secondary analytical report rather than the original intelligence record.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an official U.S. government commission report hosted on the White House archives, with extensive endnotes and direct reliance on primary intelligence products and interviews. It has strong editorial and institutional credibility, though it is still a secondary analytical report rather than the original intelligence record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a broad postwar report on intelligence judgments about Iraq’s WMD programs, with only indirect historical reference to the March 2003 biological-weapons question rather than directly testing that specific claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt only discusses the intelligence process and cites the October 2002 NIE; it does not itself state that Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2991, "completion_tokens": 300, "total_tokens": 3291, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00395946, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.214647Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is mainstream CNN news reporting on a public U.N. presentation, which gives it ordinary journalistic editorial standards and some proximity to official sources. However, it mainly relays claims from government officials and intelligence references rather than providing independently verified primary evidence or detailed sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.56, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us electronic intercepts" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us satellite photographs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is mainstream CNN news reporting on a public U.N. presentation, which gives it ordinary journalistic editorial standards and some proximity to official sources. However, it mainly relays claims from government officials and intelligence references rather than providing independently verified primary evidence or detailed sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses Powell’s February 2003 presentation alleging Iraq was actively hiding weapons and includes references to biological-weapons-related claims in the broader WMD context, but it does not directly report whether Iraq had biological stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.56,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document reports Powell's intelligence-based claim that Iraq was actively deceiving inspectors and hiding weapons, including references to concealed munitions and other suspected WMD-related activity, which supports but does not directly prove a biological weapons stockpile or production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us electronic intercepts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us satellite photographs\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cnn\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3060, "completion_tokens": 5081, "total_tokens": 8141, "reasoning_tokens": 4789 }, "cost_usd": 0.0174759516, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.214762Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is mainstream CNN news reporting on a public U.N. presentation, which gives it ordinary journalistic editorial standards and some proximity to official sources. However, it mainly relays claims from government officials and intelligence references rather than providing independently verified primary evidence or detailed sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us electronic intercepts" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us satellite photographs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is mainstream CNN news reporting on a public U.N. presentation, which gives it ordinary journalistic editorial standards and some proximity to official sources. However, it mainly relays claims from government officials and intelligence references rather than providing independently verified primary evidence or detailed sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses Powell’s February 2003 presentation alleging Iraq was actively hiding weapons and includes references to biological-weapons-related claims in the broader WMD context, but it does not directly report whether Iraq had biological stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.8,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document reports Powell's intelligence-based claim that Iraq was actively deceiving inspectors and hiding weapons, which points against the sub-claim, but it does not provide direct proof of biological stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us electronic intercepts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us satellite photographs\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cnn\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 832, "completion_tokens": 75, "total_tokens": 907, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0009615, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.214762Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official government investigative report (the Iraq Survey Group Final Report), based on direct postwar inspection and intelligence work rather than secondary reporting. It has strong evidentiary standards and high relevance, though it is still a synthesized inquiry report rather than a raw primary record.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an official government investigative report (the Iraq Survey Group Final Report), based on direct postwar inspection and intelligence work rather than secondary reporting. It has strong evidentiary standards and high relevance, though it is still a synthesized inquiry report rather than a raw primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt concerns Iraq’s overall WMD programs and timeline from 1980 to 2003, which is adjacent to the question of chemical weapon stockpiles in March 2003 but does not directly report on that specific stockpile claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s WMD strategy and intent to preserve reconstitution capability, but it does not provide direct evidence that militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles actually existed in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2936, "completion_tokens": 2224, "total_tokens": 5160, "reasoning_tokens": 1992 }, "cost_usd": 0.01216588, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.214936Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive at George Washington University is a reputable research repository that typically compiles declassified documents and cites primary records. This piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document, but it rests on official sources and strong editorial standards, with low apparent conflict of interest.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The National Security Archive at George Washington University is a reputable research repository that typically compiles declassified documents and cites primary records. This piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document, but it rests on official sources and strong editorial standards, with low apparent conflict of interest.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's WMD programs and inspection history in the 1990s, which is only indirect background to whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's WMD programs, inspections, and the possibility of reconstitution, but it does not state that Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2829, "completion_tokens": 3326, "total_tokens": 6155, "reasoning_tokens": 3074 }, "cost_usd": 0.01248747, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.215049Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive at George Washington University is a reputable research repository that typically compiles declassified documents and cites primary records. This piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document, but it rests on official sources and strong editorial standards, with low apparent conflict of interest.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The National Security Archive at George Washington University is a reputable research repository that typically compiles declassified documents and cites primary records. This piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document, but it rests on official sources and strong editorial standards, with low apparent conflict of interest.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s WMD programs and efforts to reconstitute them, providing broad background on Iraqi biological weapons issues, but it does not specifically address March 2003 stockpiles or an active biological production program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses past Iraqi WMD programs and the possibility of reconstitution, but it does not provide direct evidence about whether Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2837, "completion_tokens": 3334, "total_tokens": 6171, "reasoning_tokens": 3074 }, "cost_usd": 0.01252947, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.215156Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive at George Washington University is a reputable research repository that typically compiles declassified documents and cites primary records. This piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document, but it rests on official sources and strong editorial standards, with low apparent conflict of interest.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The National Security Archive at George Washington University is a reputable research repository that typically compiles declassified documents and cites primary records. This piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document, but it rests on official sources and strong editorial standards, with low apparent conflict of interest.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s WMD programs and efforts to reconstitute them, providing broad background on Iraqi biological weapons issues, but it does not specifically address March 2003 stockpiles or an active biological production program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's past WMD programs and the possibility of reconstituting them, but it does not directly address whether Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 800, "completion_tokens": 70, "total_tokens": 870, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.000915, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.215156Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive at George Washington University is a reputable research repository that typically compiles declassified documents and cites primary records. This piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document, but it rests on official sources and strong editorial standards, with low apparent conflict of interest.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The National Security Archive at George Washington University is a reputable research repository that typically compiles declassified documents and cites primary records. This piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document, but it rests on official sources and strong editorial standards, with low apparent conflict of interest.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s potential to reconstitute WMD programs after 1991 and by the early 2000s, but it does not directly assess whether the nuclear program had in fact been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says Iraq was free to attempt to reconstitute its WMD programs and discusses policy concerns, but it does not provide evidence that the nuclear weapons program had actually been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2825, "completion_tokens": 3338, "total_tokens": 6163, "reasoning_tokens": 3074 }, "cost_usd": 0.01253847, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.215343Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive at George Washington University is a reputable research repository that typically compiles declassified documents and cites primary records. This piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document, but it rests on official sources and strong editorial standards, with low apparent conflict of interest.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.3, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The National Security Archive at George Washington University is a reputable research repository that typically compiles declassified documents and cites primary records. This piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document, but it rests on official sources and strong editorial standards, with low apparent conflict of interest.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s potential to reconstitute WMD programs after 1991 and by the early 2000s, but it does not directly assess whether the nuclear program had in fact been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.3,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says the U.S. believed Iraq was free to attempt to reconstitute WMD programs, which is consistent with not having reconstituted a nuclear program by March 2003, but it does not directly make or evidence that finding.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 794, "completion_tokens": 77, "total_tokens": 871, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.000942, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.215343Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary, collaboratively edited source with variable editorial control and no guaranteed expert review. It may summarize cited reporting or documents, but it is not a primary record and its reliability depends on the quality of the underlying references.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.3,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a secondary, collaboratively edited source with variable editorial control and no guaranteed expert review. It may summarize cited reporting or documents, but it is not a primary record and its reliability depends on the quality of the underlying references.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is about alleged Iraqi mobile biological weapons labs in the lead-up to March 2003, which is closely related to whether Iraq had active biological weapons production capabilities then, but it does not directly address broader stockpiles or a general production program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses U.S. allegations and later investigations about mobile biological weapons labs, but it does not provide direct evidence that Iraq actually held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"colin powell un presentation 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2742, "completion_tokens": 301, "total_tokens": 3043, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00374109, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.215518Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "GlobalSecurity.org is a secondary website that aggregates and summarizes defense and intelligence material rather than providing original primary evidence. It has some subject-matter credibility and usually cites official documents, but it is not peer reviewed and its editorial standards and sourcing are less robust than official records or major vetted journalism.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "previous intelligence reports" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"GlobalSecurity.org is a secondary website that aggregates and summarizes defense and intelligence material rather than providing original primary evidence. It has some subject-matter credibility and usually cites official documents, but it is not peer reviewed and its editorial standards and sourcing are less robust than official records or major vetted journalism.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses 2002 prewar intelligence estimates about Iraq possessing 100–500 metric tons of chemical agents and renewed CW production, which is closely related to whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical stockpiles in March 2003, but it does not directly state the stockpile status at that specific date.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt explicitly states that the 2002 NIE assessed Iraq possessed 100-500 metric tons of chemical weapons agents and had renewed production, which supports the claim that Iraq held militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"previous intelligence reports\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2655, "completion_tokens": 1335, "total_tokens": 3990, "reasoning_tokens": 1242 }, "cost_usd": 0.0077799, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.215631Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Congressional Research Service reports are high-quality, nonpartisan policy research products with named authors and professional editorial standards. This is a secondary analytical source rather than a primary record, but it is generally well-sourced and authoritative for background on U.N. inspections and Iraq's WMD programs.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Congressional Research Service reports are high-quality, nonpartisan policy research products with named authors and professional editorial standards. This is a secondary analytical source rather than a primary record, but it is generally well-sourced and authoritative for background on U.N. inspections and Iraq's WMD programs.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The report is about UN inspections for WMD in Iraq in the months leading up to March 2003, so it bears on the broader question of whether Iraq had WMD-related stockpiles then, but it does not directly state or test the specific claim about militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses inspections, compliance, and allegations about intelligence and politicization, but it does not state that Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3085, "completion_tokens": 1328, "total_tokens": 4413, "reasoning_tokens": 1064 }, "cost_usd": 0.0067824821999999995, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.215746Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Congressional Research Service reports are high-quality, nonpartisan policy research products with named authors and professional editorial standards. This is a secondary analytical source rather than a primary record, but it is generally well-sourced and authoritative for background on U.N. inspections and Iraq's WMD programs.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Congressional Research Service reports are high-quality, nonpartisan policy research products with named authors and professional editorial standards. This is a secondary analytical source rather than a primary record, but it is generally well-sourced and authoritative for background on U.N. inspections and Iraq's WMD programs.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The report concerns U.N. inspections in Iraq for WMD in the period leading up to March 2003, which is adjacent to whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear program, but the excerpt does not directly address that specific proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses inspections, Iraqi compliance, and allegations about WMD activities, but it does not directly state that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3081, "completion_tokens": 1314, "total_tokens": 4395, "reasoning_tokens": 1064 }, "cost_usd": 0.0067164822, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.215863Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary source with mixed editorial oversight, not a primary record or peer-reviewed study. It can summarize and cite other materials, but its reliability depends on the quality of the underlying references and article maintenance.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "human rights watch" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary source with mixed editorial oversight, not a primary record or peer-reviewed study. It can summarize and cite other materials, but its reliability depends on the quality of the underlying references and article maintenance.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is about Iraq’s chemical weapons program and only mentions weapons of mass destruction in a broad historical context, not biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's chemical weapons program and past use, but it does not address biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"united nations\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"human rights watch\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2954, "completion_tokens": 9360, "total_tokens": 12314, "reasoning_tokens": 9136 }, "cost_usd": 0.0303107778, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.215957Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article from the Wikimedia Foundation, so it is a secondary source with ordinary editorial standards rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study. It summarizes a U.S. Senate report, which is a strong underlying source, but the document itself is not the official report.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article from the Wikimedia Foundation, so it is a secondary source with ordinary editorial standards rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study. It summarizes a U.S. Senate report, which is a strong underlying source, but the document itself is not the official report.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document concerns the Senate’s review of prewar Iraqi WMD intelligence and the broader question of Iraq’s WMD stockpiles and programs, but it does not directly address whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses the Senate report and general prewar WMD intelligence issues, but it does not provide direct content about Iraq actually holding militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence 2004\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2691, "completion_tokens": 247, "total_tokens": 2938, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00320946, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.216056Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article from the Wikimedia Foundation, so it is a secondary source with ordinary editorial standards rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study. It summarizes a U.S. Senate report, which is a strong underlying source, but the document itself is not the official report.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article from the Wikimedia Foundation, so it is a secondary source with ordinary editorial standards rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study. It summarizes a U.S. Senate report, which is a strong underlying source, but the document itself is not the official report.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is about prewar intelligence on Iraqi WMD, which is adjacent to the March 2003 biological-weapons stockpile/program question, but it does not itself directly report whether Iraq had biological weapons or an active program at that time.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses prewar intelligence assessments, inspection history, and later report findings about intelligence failures, but it does not directly state that Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence 2004\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2699, "completion_tokens": 250, "total_tokens": 2949, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00322896, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.216151Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FRONTLINE/PBS is a reputable, edited documentary outlet with a strong track record, and this piece uses a named interview with Colin Powell plus references to former intelligence community members. However, it is a secondary journalistic/documentary source rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed inquiry.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "frontline pbs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell interview february 2016" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "the secret history of isis documentary" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"FRONTLINE/PBS is a reputable, edited documentary outlet with a strong track record, and this piece uses a named interview with Colin Powell plus references to former intelligence community members. However, it is a secondary journalistic/documentary source rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses the 2003 U.N. speech about Iraq's weapons program and states that the intelligence later confirmed the program was nonexistent, which is adjacent to the reconstitution claim but does not directly assess whether it had been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.85,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt explicitly says that the Iraq weapons program 'was nonexistent' and that the intelligence later confirmed this, which contradicts the claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"frontline pbs\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"colin powell interview february 2016\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"the secret history of isis documentary\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3101, "completion_tokens": 282, "total_tokens": 3383, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0039038, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.216248Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "UN News is an official UN publisher with established editorial standards, and this piece is a retrospective news/article drawing on the UN Security Council presentation and archived UN records rather than anonymous claims. It is secondary reporting, but it cites and describes named primary-source material from an official forum.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council meeting february 5 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"UN News is an official UN publisher with established editorial standards, and this piece is a retrospective news/article drawing on the UN Security Council presentation and archived UN records rather than anonymous claims. It is secondary reporting, but it cites and describes named primary-source material from an official forum.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses U.S. claims in early 2003 that Iraq possessed and was producing WMDs, which is adjacent to but not specifically the question of whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt describes Powell's 2003 allegations about Iraqi WMDs in general, but it does not specifically state that Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council meeting february 5 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2844, "completion_tokens": 2545, "total_tokens": 5389, "reasoning_tokens": 2315 }, "cost_usd": 0.0070003512, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.216349Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable editorially reviewed journalism/fact-checking outlet, but this piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document. It relies on named official sources like the Iraq Survey Group final report, giving it solid but not top-tier evidentiary value.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable editorially reviewed journalism/fact-checking outlet, but this piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document. It relies on named official sources like the Iraq Survey Group final report, giving it solid but not top-tier evidentiary value.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses whether Iraq had chemical weapons stockpiles around the 2003 invasion and explicitly mentions the invasion phase, which closely overlaps with March 2003, but it does not specifically isolate that exact date or military significance.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document says the Iraq Survey Group determined Iraq had already destroyed all of its existing stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons, which directly contradicts the claim that Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2909, "completion_tokens": 878, "total_tokens": 3787, "reasoning_tokens": 631 }, "cost_usd": 0.00621939, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.216448Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable editorially reviewed journalism/fact-checking outlet, but this piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document. It relies on named official sources like the Iraq Survey Group final report, giving it solid but not top-tier evidentiary value.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable editorially reviewed journalism/fact-checking outlet, but this piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document. It relies on named official sources like the Iraq Survey Group final report, giving it solid but not top-tier evidentiary value.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses whether Iraq had chemical weapons stockpiles around the 2003 invasion and explicitly mentions the invasion phase, which closely overlaps with March 2003, but it does not specifically isolate that exact date or military significance.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document states that the Iraq Survey Group found Iraq had already destroyed all existing stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons, directly supporting that Iraq did not hold militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 819, "completion_tokens": 72, "total_tokens": 891, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00093825, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.216448Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable editorially reviewed journalism/fact-checking outlet, but this piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document. It relies on named official sources like the Iraq Survey Group final report, giving it solid but not top-tier evidentiary value.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.86, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable editorially reviewed journalism/fact-checking outlet, but this piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document. It relies on named official sources like the Iraq Survey Group final report, giving it solid but not top-tier evidentiary value.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses whether Iraq had existing chemical or biological weapons stockpiles and an Iraqi WMD program around the 2003 invasion, which closely overlaps with the biological-weapons sub-claim, though it is not limited specifically to March 2003 or biological weapons alone.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.86,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says the Iraq Survey Group determined Iraq had abandoned its weapons programs and had already destroyed all existing chemical and biological stockpiles, which directly contradicts the claim of stockpiles or an active biological weapons program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2917, "completion_tokens": 888, "total_tokens": 3805, "reasoning_tokens": 631 }, "cost_usd": 0.00627039, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.217951Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable editorially reviewed journalism/fact-checking outlet, but this piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document. It relies on named official sources like the Iraq Survey Group final report, giving it solid but not top-tier evidentiary value.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable editorially reviewed journalism/fact-checking outlet, but this piece is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document. It relies on named official sources like the Iraq Survey Group final report, giving it solid but not top-tier evidentiary value.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses the Iraq Survey Group’s finding that Iraq had abandoned its chemical, biological, and nuclear weapons programs, which closely bears on whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003, though it does not address that exact date or proposition directly.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.8,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says the Iraq Survey Group determined Iraq had abandoned its quest to develop nuclear weapons, which directly contradicts the claim that the nuclear program had been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2905, "completion_tokens": 879, "total_tokens": 3784, "reasoning_tokens": 631 }, "cost_usd": 0.00622089, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.218076Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a trade association/news-style report from Arms Control Association summarizing statements by U.S. military officials and UNMOVIC records, so it relies on named official sources rather than anonymous reporting. It is not a primary document or peer-reviewed study, but it has some editorial credibility and direct sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.45, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "kimmitt press briefing may 17 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "rumsfeld heritage foundation may 17 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a trade association/news-style report from Arms Control Association summarizing statements by U.S. military officials and UNMOVIC records, so it relies on named official sources rather than anonymous reporting. It is not a primary document or peer-reviewed study, but it has some editorial credibility and direct sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s prior sarin stockpiles and a March 2003 UNMOVIC report about discrepancies in declared chemical munitions, which closely relates to whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003, though it does not directly assert that exact proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.45,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says UNMOVIC reported unresolved discrepancies in Iraq’s claimed accounting for thousands of sarin-filled warheads and bombs as of March 2003, which suggests stockpiles may have existed, but it is an indirect pre-war assertion rather than direct finding of militarily significant stockpiles in Iraq at that time.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"kimmitt press briefing may 17 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"rumsfeld heritage foundation may 17 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic march 2003 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2781, "completion_tokens": 4556, "total_tokens": 7337, "reasoning_tokens": 4218 }, "cost_usd": 0.011486370288, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.218214Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a reputable advocacy/reporting piece from Arms Control Association that appears to summarize UN inspector reports and inspection statistics rather than present original primary documentation. It has named institutional sources and editorial oversight, but it is still a secondary source from an issue-focused organization, not a peer-reviewed study or official inquiry.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq declaration december 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a reputable advocacy/reporting piece from Arms Control Association that appears to summarize UN inspector reports and inspection statistics rather than present original primary documentation. It has named institutional sources and editorial oversight, but it is still a secondary source from an issue-focused organization, not a peer-reviewed study or official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses UN inspections in Iraq during late 2002 to March 2003 and unresolved chemical-weapons disarmament issues, but it does not directly report whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says inspectors conducted many inspections and notes unresolved disarmament issues, but it does not directly state that Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq declaration december 2002\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2865, "completion_tokens": 8073, "total_tokens": 10938, "reasoning_tokens": 7801 }, "cost_usd": 0.033697776, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.218343Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "This appears to be an advocacy/issue-site produced to argue a political case rather than an independent, editorially controlled or peer-reviewed source. It cites some specific intelligence claims and official findings, but the publication itself has no evident professional standards or neutral track record, so the evidentiary value is limited.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "bush administration" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "curveball" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "defense intelligence agency" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.3,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This appears to be an advocacy/issue-site produced to argue a political case rather than an independent, editorially controlled or peer-reviewed source. It cites some specific intelligence claims and official findings, but the publication itself has no evident professional standards or neutral track record, so the evidentiary value is limited.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly discusses allegations and evidence about Iraq’s biological weapons capabilities, but it focuses specifically on mobile biological weapons labs and related prewar claims rather than the exact question of stockpiles or an active production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.7,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt denies that pre-war claims about Iraqi mobile biological weapons labs were supported and says no evidence of such labs existed, which contradicts the claim of an active biological weapons production program, though it does not directly address March 2003 stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush administration\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi defector curveball\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"defense intelligence agency\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2741, "completion_tokens": 321, "total_tokens": 3062, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00383715, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.218459Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a recent encyclopedia-style secondary summary, not a primary document, but it appears to rely on named official sources and investigative records such as the Iraq Survey Group, Kay interim reporting, and the Duelfer Report. Publisher quality is uncertain compared with established reference works, so it rates as moderately strong but not definitive evidence.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a recent encyclopedia-style secondary summary, not a primary document, but it appears to rely on named official sources and investigative records such as the Iraq Survey Group, Kay interim reporting, and the Duelfer Report. Publisher quality is uncertain compared with established reference works, so it rates as moderately strong but not definitive evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s alleged pre-war chemical weapon stockpiles and post-invasion searches for them, which is closely related to whether such militarily significant stockpiles existed in March 2003, but it does not directly assess that exact date-specific proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt states that post-invasion investigations found no operational stockpiles and that Iraq had destroyed its known WMD stockpiles by 1991, which directly contradicts the claim of militarily significant chemical weapon stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2752, "completion_tokens": 342, "total_tokens": 3094, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0035898600000000003, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.218593Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "This is a congressional press release/opinion piece from an elected politician, not a neutral research publication. It quotes and cites other sources, but it is advocacy-oriented and does not present original primary documentation or systematic sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cheney meet the press 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush state of the union 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.3,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a congressional press release/opinion piece from an elected politician, not a neutral research publication. It quotes and cites other sources, but it is advocacy-oriented and does not present original primary documentation or systematic sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses Iraq’s alleged biological weapons and capacity to rapidly produce more, but it does so in the context of political statements and later assessments rather than directly testing the specific March 2003 stockpile/production claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt only reports political quotations and arguments about what Iraq supposedly had or could produce, not direct evidence that Iraq actually held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay new york times interview 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cheney meet the press 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"powell un security council 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush state of the union 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3354, "completion_tokens": 1676, "total_tokens": 5030, "reasoning_tokens": 1494 }, "cost_usd": 0.00977358, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.218716Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary, collaboratively edited source with variable reliability and no formal peer review, so it is only ordinary reference-quality evidence. It may summarize named sources and official findings, but the page itself is not a primary document or independently vetted scholarly work.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "riegle report 1994" }, { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a secondary, collaboratively edited source with variable reliability and no formal peer review, so it is only ordinary reference-quality evidence. It may summarize named sources and official findings, but the page itself is not a primary document or independently vetted scholarly work.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s biological weapons program and notes it no longer existed by the time of the 2003 invasion, which bears closely on whether Iraq still had BW stockpiles or an active production program in March 2003, but it does not directly test that exact March 2003 condition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.7,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt states that Iraq had an extensive biological weapons program and that it no longer existed by 2003, which supports prior capability/history but does not directly prove March 2003 stockpiles or active production.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"riegle report 1994\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2929, "completion_tokens": 6838, "total_tokens": 9767, "reasoning_tokens": 6573 }, "cost_usd": 0.03159555, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.218861Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a reputable advocacy/research organization publication with a named executive director and a chronology grounded in official UN/IAEA/UNMOVIC records, rather than anonymous or uncited claims. It is still a secondary summary produced by a policy organization, not a peer-reviewed study or primary document.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a reputable advocacy/research organization publication with a named executive director and a chronology grounded in official UN/IAEA/UNMOVIC records, rather than anonymous or uncited claims. It is still a secondary summary produced by a policy organization, not a peer-reviewed study or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses Iraq’s alleged chemical/biological weapons status and UN inspections immediately before the March 2003 invasion, which is closely related to whether Iraq held chemical weapons stockpiles at that time, though it does not directly test that exact proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.8,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says UN inspectors conducted over 900 inspections through March 18, 2003 and did not find that Iraq possessed chemical or biological weapons, which directly contradicts the claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush state of the union 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2804, "completion_tokens": 289, "total_tokens": 3093, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.003637, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.218989Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a reputable advocacy/research organization publication with a named executive director and a chronology grounded in official UN/IAEA/UNMOVIC records, rather than anonymous or uncited claims. It is still a secondary summary produced by a policy organization, not a peer-reviewed study or primary document.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a reputable advocacy/research organization publication with a named executive director and a chronology grounded in official UN/IAEA/UNMOVIC records, rather than anonymous or uncited claims. It is still a secondary summary produced by a policy organization, not a peer-reviewed study or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses whether Iraq possessed biological weapons or had reconstituted a biological weapons program in the run-up to March 2003, which is closely related to the exact sub-claim, though it does not independently establish the underlying factual proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt states that UN inspectors conducted over 900 inspections in Iraq and did not find that Iraq possessed chemical or biological weapons or had reconstituted such programs, which directly contradicts the claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush state of the union 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2812, "completion_tokens": 289, "total_tokens": 3101, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.003643, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.219127Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "UN News is a reputable institutional news outlet with editorial standards, and this item directly quotes Hans Blix, the head of UNMOVIC, a primary official source on Iraq inspections. It is still a news report rather than the underlying inspection record, so it is strong but not definitive primary evidence.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"UN News is a reputable institutional news outlet with editorial standards, and this item directly quotes Hans Blix, the head of UNMOVIC, a primary official source on Iraq inspections. It is still a news report rather than the underlying inspection record, so it is strong but not definitive primary evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.0,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The article concerns alleged use of banned missiles and possible chemical/biological weapons in March 2003, not whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses whether Iraq had used banned missiles or chemical/biological weapons, not whether its nuclear weapons program had been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un news\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2362, "completion_tokens": 3493, "total_tokens": 5855, "reasoning_tokens": 3269 }, "cost_usd": 0.01607127, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.219235Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary, highly editorialized web piece from an obscure publisher rather than a primary document or reputable journalistic source. It appears to summarize and interpret claims from other reports, with no clear editorial standards, peer review, or substantive sourcing beyond narrative description.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.65, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "curveball" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "german intelligence" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.3,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a secondary, highly editorialized web piece from an obscure publisher rather than a primary document or reputable journalistic source. It appears to summarize and interpret claims from other reports, with no clear editorial standards, peer review, or substantive sourcing beyond narrative description.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is about alleged Iraqi mobile biological weapons production facilities and related intelligence in early 2003, which is closely related to whether Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active production program in March 2003, but it does not directly establish that exact fact.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.65,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt describes intelligence claims and a U.S. presentation alleging Iraqi mobile biological weapons labs and production facilities in early 2003, which supports the sub-claim only as an allegation, not as direct proof.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"curveball\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"german intelligence\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cia\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"powell un speech 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2668, "completion_tokens": 2408, "total_tokens": 5076, "reasoning_tokens": 2140 }, "cost_usd": 0.012034769999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.219340Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official United Nations/UNMOVIC document produced for the Security Council, giving it very high institutional credibility and editorial oversight. It is a primary official summary based on inspection records and commission work, though it is still a synthesized report rather than the raw underlying records.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.43, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an official United Nations/UNMOVIC document produced for the Security Council, giving it very high institutional credibility and editorial oversight. It is a primary official summary based on inspection records and commission work, though it is still a synthesized report rather than the raw underlying records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is a 2006 UNMOVIC summary about Iraq’s biological and other proscribed weapons programs, so it is adjacent background on the issue, but it does not directly address whether Iraq held biological stockpiles or ran an active production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.43,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says UN inspectors oversaw destruction, removal, or rendering harmless of Iraq's declared biological weapons programme, which implies Iraq had such a programme before 2003, but it does not directly establish March 2003 stockpiles or active production.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3064, "completion_tokens": 2098, "total_tokens": 5162, "reasoning_tokens": 1843 }, "cost_usd": 0.0088898232, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.219448Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official U.S. government primary-source transcript of Secretary Powell’s UN Security Council presentation, published on the White House archives with clear dating and attribution. It has strong provenance and editorial reliability as a contemporaneous official record, though it is still a political speech rather than an independent inquiry.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an official U.S. government primary-source transcript of Secretary Powell’s UN Security Council presentation, published on the White House archives with clear dating and attribution. It has strong provenance and editorial reliability as a contemporaneous official record, though it is still a political speech rather than an independent inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is a speech about Iraq’s alleged WMD disarmament issues in early 2003 and is closely related to claims about biological weapons stockpiles or production, though it does not directly and specifically test the biological-weapon sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.6,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The transcript asserts Iraq was a regime this council had long been trying to disarm of weapons of mass destruction and that Iraq had concealed such weapons, which supports the claim, but it does not provide direct findings about biological stockpiles or an active biological production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us state department 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2907, "completion_tokens": 305, "total_tokens": 3212, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00392259, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.219586Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official U.S. government primary-source transcript of Secretary Powell’s UN Security Council presentation, published on the White House archives with clear dating and attribution. It has strong provenance and editorial reliability as a contemporaneous official record, though it is still a political speech rather than an independent inquiry.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.55, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an official U.S. government primary-source transcript of Secretary Powell’s UN Security Council presentation, published on the White House archives with clear dating and attribution. It has strong provenance and editorial reliability as a contemporaneous official record, though it is still a political speech rather than an independent inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document addresses Iraq's alleged WMD/disarmament status in early 2003, but it does not directly test or report specifically on whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.55,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Powell asserts that Iraq had not complied with disarmament and that inspectors were meant to uncover what Iraq had concealed, which supports the claim that a nuclear weapons program had been reconstituted, though it is an allegation rather than direct evidence and does not specifically document nuclear reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us state department 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2895, "completion_tokens": 302, "total_tokens": 3197, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0039000899999999997, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.219697Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Carnegie Endowment for International Peace is a reputable, nonpartisan policy research institution with editorial standards, and the piece explicitly says it draws on the unclassified record, prewar intelligence, administration statements, and evidence found in Iraq. It is still a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed inquiry, so it merits strong but not top-tier source quality.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, { "type": "study", "id": "wmd in iraq evidence and implications" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Carnegie Endowment for International Peace is a reputable, nonpartisan policy research institution with editorial standards, and the piece explicitly says it draws on the unclassified record, prewar intelligence, administration statements, and evidence found in Iraq. It is still a secondary synthesis rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed inquiry, so it merits strong but not top-tier source quality.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is a study specifically about WMD in Iraq and discusses prewar intelligence and evidence found in Iraq, so it closely bears on whether Iraq held chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003, though the excerpt does not address that exact claim directly.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses prewar intelligence, administration statements, and evidence in general, but it does not itself state that Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"carnegie endowment for international peace\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wmd in iraq evidence and implications\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2782, "completion_tokens": 286, "total_tokens": 3068, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00373266, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.219840Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a Carnegie Endowment analysis by a named expert from a reputable policy research institution with editorial standards, but it is still a secondary interpretive piece rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study. Its value as evidence comes from cited intelligence documents and institutional research, not independent original records.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Carnegie Endowment analysis by a named expert from a reputable policy research institution with editorial standards, but it is still a secondary interpretive piece rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study. Its value as evidence comes from cited intelligence documents and institutional research, not independent original records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt focuses on CIA/NIE assessments of Iraq’s WMD threat and intelligence claims about Iraqi weapon programs, which closely relates to whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear program by March 2003, though it does not directly make that exact finding.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.8,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says the intelligence community and administration misconstrued and misrepresented the threat, and that the failure to find WMD in Iraq showed those judgments were wrong, which undermines the claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"carnegie endowment for international peace\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia white paper iraqs weapons of mass destruction\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2844, "completion_tokens": 314, "total_tokens": 3158, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00365166, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.220006Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a CIA Freedom of Information Act electronic reading room page, which is an official government repository for primary documents and archival material. As a source type it has strong editorial/archival standards and is highly reliable for evidence about what CIA documents exist and contain, though the page itself is a descriptive collection notice rather than the original primary record.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a CIA Freedom of Information Act electronic reading room page, which is an official government repository for primary documents and archival material. As a source type it has strong editorial/archival standards and is highly reliable for evidence about what CIA documents exist and contain, though the page itself is a descriptive collection notice rather than the original primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.0,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is about CIA FOIA reading-room materials on Nixon’s 1972 China trip and related historical documents, with no mention of Iraq, chemical weapons, or stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is only a CIA Reading Room overview of unrelated China travel materials and contains no information about Iraq's chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3002, "completion_tokens": 722, "total_tokens": 3724, "reasoning_tokens": 498 }, "cost_usd": 0.005083476, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.220125Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a CIA Freedom of Information Act electronic reading room page, which is an official government repository for primary documents and archival material. As a source type it has strong editorial/archival standards and is highly reliable for evidence about what CIA documents exist and contain, though the page itself is a descriptive collection notice rather than the original primary record.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a CIA Freedom of Information Act electronic reading room page, which is an official government repository for primary documents and archival material. As a source type it has strong editorial/archival standards and is highly reliable for evidence about what CIA documents exist and contain, though the page itself is a descriptive collection notice rather than the original primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is a general CIA Reading Room page about Nixon-era China materials and contains no information about Iraq or its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is a general CIA Reading Room page about Nixon-era China materials and does not mention Iraq or any nuclear weapons program, so it neither supports nor contradicts the claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2998, "completion_tokens": 712, "total_tokens": 3710, "reasoning_tokens": 498 }, "cost_usd": 0.005035476, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.220231Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Globalsecurity.org is a specialized defense/arms-analysis publisher, but this excerpt is a secondary summary of the 2002 NIE rather than a primary document. It cites an official intelligence estimate and appears edited and curated, yet it is not peer-reviewed and has no clear formal editorial standard like a journal or government record.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.76, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Globalsecurity.org is a specialized defense/arms-analysis publisher, but this excerpt is a secondary summary of the 2002 NIE rather than a primary document. It cites an official intelligence estimate and appears edited and curated, yet it is not peer-reviewed and has no clear formal editorial standard like a journal or government record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq’s biological weapons program, including active production, stockpiles, and assessments around the prewar period, but it is a broader intelligence-summary document rather than a direct report specifically confirming the March 2003 status.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.76,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt explicitly reports October 2002 intelligence judgments that Iraq had biological weapons and that key aspects of its offensive BW program were active in the prewar period, which supports the March 2003 sub-claim if believed.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2853, "completion_tokens": 1179, "total_tokens": 4032, "reasoning_tokens": 937 }, "cost_usd": 0.0061583154, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.220335Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official United Nations Security Council document transmitting a UNMOVIC quarterly report, an authoritative primary or near-primary record from an official inspection body. It has strong institutional editorial standards and minimal conflict of interest, though it is still a report rather than the underlying raw inspection records.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an official United Nations Security Council document transmitting a UNMOVIC quarterly report, an authoritative primary or near-primary record from an official inspection body. It has strong institutional editorial standards and minimal conflict of interest, though it is still a report rather than the underlying raw inspection records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This UNMOVIC quarterly report concerns Iraq’s weapons inspections and unresolved disarmament issues in the period immediately before March 2003, so it is adjacent to the claim about chemical weapons stockpiles but does not directly report whether militarily significant stockpiles existed.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt only says UNMOVIC was analyzing Iraq’s declarations and unresolved disarmament issues and gives no direct content about whether Iraq actually held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3011, "completion_tokens": 732, "total_tokens": 3743, "reasoning_tokens": 555 }, "cost_usd": 0.00573173, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.220448Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official Iraq Survey Group final report excerpt, i.e., a primary government investigation with direct access to records, inspections, and interviews. The copy hosted by globalsecurity.org is a secondary mirror, but the underlying document is a high-quality official inquiry rather than journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an official Iraq Survey Group final report excerpt, i.e., a primary government investigation with direct access to records, inspections, and interviews. The copy hosted by globalsecurity.org is a secondary mirror, but the underlying document is a high-quality official inquiry rather than journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":1.0,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt explicitly addresses whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program after 1991, which directly bears on the claim about reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":1,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The report states that ISG found Iraq did not try to reconstitute a capability to produce nuclear weapons after 1991 and had not rebuilt key uranium-processing capabilities, directly contradicting the claim that the program had been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2767, "completion_tokens": 239, "total_tokens": 3006, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00324381, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.220589Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official UN document from the UN Security Council, delivered by the head of UNMOVIC, using direct institutional reporting based on inspections and official records. It has very strong editorial and evidentiary standards, though it is not itself a raw primary record of Iraqi weapons stockpiles.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an official UN document from the UN Security Council, delivered by the head of UNMOVIC, using direct institutional reporting based on inspections and official records. It has very strong editorial and evidentiary standards, though it is not itself a raw primary record of Iraqi weapons stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is about UNMOVIC inspections and Iraq's WMD disarmament process in March 2003, but it does not directly address whether Iraq then held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses the resumption and conduct of inspections in Iraq, but it does not state that Iraq had militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic 12th quarterly report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2950, "completion_tokens": 2799, "total_tokens": 5749, "reasoning_tokens": 2555 }, "cost_usd": 0.0075041832, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.220704Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "ArmsControl.org is a reputable advocacy/news publication with editorial standards, but it is not a primary source or peer-reviewed work. The article mainly synthesizes and interprets official UN/IAEA/UNMOVIC findings rather than presenting new primary evidence.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea march 2003 report" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"ArmsControl.org is a reputable advocacy/news publication with editorial standards, but it is not a primary source or peer-reviewed work. The article mainly synthesizes and interprets official UN/IAEA/UNMOVIC findings rather than presenting new primary evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly discusses Iraq’s nuclear weapons program status in March 2003 and reports inspectors found no evidence of its revival, which closely bears on whether it had been reconstituted by then.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.95,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document reports that after more than a hundred site visits and interviews, the IAEA found “no evidence or plausible indication” that Iraq had revived a nuclear weapons program, directly contradicting the claim that it had been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea march 2003 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic march 2003 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"bush administration statements\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2923, "completion_tokens": 3854, "total_tokens": 6777, "reasoning_tokens": 4014 }, "cost_usd": 0.01801221, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.220829Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a CNN transcript of a public UN presentation by a senior US official, so it is a reputable contemporaneous report with a clear primary source for the speech itself. However, it is still a transcript of advocacy by a government speaker rather than an independent primary record or peer-reviewed/official inquiry, and the excerpt provides limited direct sourcing beyond the speaker’s claims.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi defectors" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a CNN transcript of a public UN presentation by a senior US official, so it is a reputable contemporaneous report with a clear primary source for the speech itself. However, it is still a transcript of advocacy by a government speaker rather than an independent primary record or peer-reviewed/official inquiry, and the excerpt provides limited direct sourcing beyond the speaker’s claims.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The transcript directly discusses Iraq’s efforts to reconstitute its nuclear program up to early 2003, though it is framed as a presentation of evidence and assessment rather than a direct finding that reconstitution had been completed by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Powell explicitly states that since 1998 Iraq's efforts to reconstitute its nuclear program were focused on acquiring fissile material, implying the program had been reconstituted by March 2003, though this is presented as an intelligence assertion rather than direct finding.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n\\\"roots\\\": [\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us intelligence community\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi defectors\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cnn\\\"}\\n]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2844, "completion_tokens": 2155, "total_tokens": 4999, "reasoning_tokens": 1841 }, "cost_usd": 0.011210610000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.220950Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a mainstream news report, which generally has editorial standards, but it is a secondary account that mainly relays statements from officials rather than presenting primary documents or original investigative evidence. Its sourcing appears limited to named public figures and government bodies, so it is useful but not high-grade evidence on the underlying weapons programmes and stockpiles.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate armed services committee 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a mainstream news report, which generally has editorial standards, but it is a secondary account that mainly relays statements from officials rather than presenting primary documents or original investigative evidence. Its sourcing appears limited to named public figures and government bodies, so it is useful but not high-grade evidence on the underlying weapons programmes and stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses whether Iraq had any significant chemical weapons stockpiles around the time of the 2003 invasion and whether such stockpiles would be found, which closely relates to the exact March 2003 stockpiles claim even though it is not a direct report of stockpile status on that date.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.7,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says Kay expected the search to find no significant chemical weapons stockpiles and believed Iraq had destroyed its prohibited chemical weapons before 2003, which argues against the claim that such stockpiles existed in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay statements 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia announcement january 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate armed services committee hearing 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2718, "completion_tokens": 323, "total_tokens": 3041, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0037080000000000004, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.221075Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "This is a think-tank commentary reposted by the Carnegie Endowment, not a primary document or peer-reviewed study. It appears to rely largely on public statements and editorial opinion rather than original evidence, and its sourcing is limited for a forensic question about Iraq’s weapons programmes and stockpiles.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jordan times editorial 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.3,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a think-tank commentary reposted by the Carnegie Endowment, not a primary document or peer-reviewed study. It appears to rely largely on public statements and editorial opinion rather than original evidence, and its sourcing is limited for a forensic question about Iraq’s weapons programmes and stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses U.S. claims about Iraq’s disarmament violations and deception in early 2003, but only broadly touches on weapons-related issues rather than directly addressing biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Powell's presentation and Iraq's failure to comply with disarmament orders, but it does not state that Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un security council presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"jordan times editorial 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2934, "completion_tokens": 3756, "total_tokens": 6690, "reasoning_tokens": 3499 }, "cost_usd": 0.009921455568, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.221180Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "This is a think-tank commentary reposted by the Carnegie Endowment, not a primary document or peer-reviewed study. It appears to rely largely on public statements and editorial opinion rather than original evidence, and its sourcing is limited for a forensic question about Iraq’s weapons programmes and stockpiles.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jordan times editorial 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.3,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a think-tank commentary reposted by the Carnegie Endowment, not a primary document or peer-reviewed study. It appears to rely largely on public statements and editorial opinion rather than original evidence, and its sourcing is limited for a forensic question about Iraq’s weapons programmes and stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses Iraq’s alleged noncompliance and perceived threat in the context of disarmament, but it does not directly address whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's failure to comply with disarmament orders and the perceived threat level, but it does not state that Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un security council presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"jordan times editorial 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2922, "completion_tokens": 3747, "total_tokens": 6669, "reasoning_tokens": 3499 }, "cost_usd": 0.009871955568, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.221281Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a mainstream CNN news report summarizing a named official source, the CIA/Iraq Survey Group report by Charles Duelfer, and includes direct quotes from the author. It is secondary journalism rather than the primary document itself, but it has reasonable editorial standards and substantial primary-source grounding.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a mainstream CNN news report summarizing a named official source, the CIA/Iraq Survey Group report by Charles Duelfer, and includes direct quotes from the author. It is secondary journalism rather than the primary document itself, but it has reasonable editorial standards and substantial primary-source grounding.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly discusses whether Iraq possessed WMD stockpiles at the time of the March 2003 invasion, which closely bears on the specific claim about militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in that period.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.95,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The article reports the Iraq Survey Group/CIA conclusion that Saddam did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the March 2003 invasion, directly contradicting the claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfel\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2898, "completion_tokens": 276, "total_tokens": 3174, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.003537972, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.221393Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a mainstream CNN news report summarizing a named official source, the CIA/Iraq Survey Group report by Charles Duelfer, and includes direct quotes from the author. It is secondary journalism rather than the primary document itself, but it has reasonable editorial standards and substantial primary-source grounding.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a mainstream CNN news report summarizing a named official source, the CIA/Iraq Survey Group report by Charles Duelfer, and includes direct quotes from the author. It is secondary journalism rather than the primary document itself, but it has reasonable editorial standards and substantial primary-source grounding.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly discusses whether Iraq had WMD stockpiles or had begun production by March 2003, including biological weapons, though it frames this within a broader WMD report rather than focusing solely on biological weapons.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.95,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document reports the CIA/Duelfer Iraq Survey Group finding that Saddam did not possess WMD stockpiles in March 2003 and had not begun a program to produce them, directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfel\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2906, "completion_tokens": 285, "total_tokens": 3191, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.003584472, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.221519Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Arms Control Association is a reputable policy organization with editorial standards and named authorship, but this is a secondary, advocacy-oriented chronology rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study. Its value as evidence depends on the underlying cited public records and reporting, which are not fully visible in the excerpt.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "arms control association" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Arms Control Association is a reputable policy organization with editorial standards and named authorship, but this is a secondary, advocacy-oriented chronology rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study. Its value as evidence depends on the underlying cited public records and reporting, which are not fully visible in the excerpt.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document focuses on the Bush administration's claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear program, but it does so in the context of the broader uranium/Niger controversy rather than directly evaluating that exact sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"mixed\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says IAEA inspectors found no evidence that Baghdad had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program and notes that U.S. intelligence assessments cast doubt on the claim, which directly contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"arms control association\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush administration\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2728, "completion_tokens": 304, "total_tokens": 3032, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0037422523695, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.221633Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a trade-publication/news brief from Arms Control Today/armscontrol.org with named references to official statements, UN inspectors, and the Iraq Survey Group, so it is more than simple opinion and has some factual sourcing. It is still secondary reporting rather than a primary or peer-reviewed document, and its authority depends on the quality of the cited official records and journalism standards.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a trade-publication/news brief from Arms Control Today/armscontrol.org with named references to official statements, UN inspectors, and the Iraq Survey Group, so it is more than simple opinion and has some factual sourcing. It is still secondary reporting rather than a primary or peer-reviewed document, and its authority depends on the quality of the cited official records and journalism standards.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly discusses the failure to find significant Iraqi WMD stockpiles after the March 2003 invasion and references prior assessments of chemical weapon stockpiles, which is closely related to whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles at that time.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says the invasion found no WMD stockpiles and notes prior claims and unresolved accounting of past materials, but it does not provide direct content that Iraq held militarily significant chemical stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2775, "completion_tokens": 308, "total_tokens": 3083, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00381882, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.221758Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a trade-publication/news brief from Arms Control Today/armscontrol.org with named references to official statements, UN inspectors, and the Iraq Survey Group, so it is more than simple opinion and has some factual sourcing. It is still secondary reporting rather than a primary or peer-reviewed document, and its authority depends on the quality of the cited official records and journalism standards.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a trade-publication/news brief from Arms Control Today/armscontrol.org with named references to official statements, UN inspectors, and the Iraq Survey Group, so it is more than simple opinion and has some factual sourcing. It is still secondary reporting rather than a primary or peer-reviewed document, and its authority depends on the quality of the cited official records and journalism standards.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses whether Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons program around the 2003 invasion, but it does so as part of a broader WMD investigation rather than focusing solely on that exact biological-weapons sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt reports that U.S. officials had claimed Iraq possessed biological weapons and notes UN inspectors had not found evidence of stockpiles or reconstituted programs, but it does not itself establish that Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2783, "completion_tokens": 316, "total_tokens": 3099, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00386082, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.221877Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a trade-publication/news brief from Arms Control Today/armscontrol.org with named references to official statements, UN inspectors, and the Iraq Survey Group, so it is more than simple opinion and has some factual sourcing. It is still secondary reporting rather than a primary or peer-reviewed document, and its authority depends on the quality of the cited official records and journalism standards.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a trade-publication/news brief from Arms Control Today/armscontrol.org with named references to official statements, UN inspectors, and the Iraq Survey Group, so it is more than simple opinion and has some factual sourcing. It is still secondary reporting rather than a primary or peer-reviewed document, and its authority depends on the quality of the cited official records and journalism standards.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt explicitly mentions the pre-invasion question of whether Iraq had an active nuclear weapons program and notes that UN inspectors had not found evidence that Iraq had reconstituted its related programs, which is closely related to the exact March 2003 reconstitution claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.8,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says UN weapons inspectors reported before the invasion that they had not found any evidence Iraq had reconstituted its related programs, which directly contradicts the claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2771, "completion_tokens": 297, "total_tokens": 3068, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00376632, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.221975Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a trade-publication/news brief from Arms Control Today/armscontrol.org with named references to official statements, UN inspectors, and the Iraq Survey Group, so it is more than simple opinion and has some factual sourcing. It is still secondary reporting rather than a primary or peer-reviewed document, and its authority depends on the quality of the cited official records and journalism standards.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a trade-publication/news brief from Arms Control Today/armscontrol.org with named references to official statements, UN inspectors, and the Iraq Survey Group, so it is more than simple opinion and has some factual sourcing. It is still secondary reporting rather than a primary or peer-reviewed document, and its authority depends on the quality of the cited official records and journalism standards.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt explicitly mentions the pre-invasion question of whether Iraq had an active nuclear weapons program and notes that UN inspectors had not found evidence that Iraq had reconstituted its related programs, which is closely related to the exact March 2003 reconstitution claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.8,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says UN weapons inspectors reported before the invasion that they had not found evidence Iraq had reconstituted its related programs, which supports the claim that Iraq had not reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 808, "completion_tokens": 73, "total_tokens": 881, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0009345, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.221975Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a declassified U.S. government exhibit from the Department of Justice, preserving an official document with internal dates and quoted CIA material. It is a primary record with strong provenance and no obvious editorial or commercial conflict, though it is still an excerpted exhibit rather than the underlying full archival file.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "new yorker article sy hersh" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "british white paper september 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a declassified U.S. government exhibit from the Department of Justice, preserving an official document with internal dates and quoted CIA material. It is a primary record with strong provenance and no obvious editorial or commercial conflict, though it is still an excerpted exhibit rather than the underlying full archival file.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is about the Iraq-Niger uranium allegation and broader WMD reporting, which is only tangentially related to whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.2,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says the October 2002 NIE stated that Iraq was “vigorously trying to procure uranium ore and yellowcake,” which is indirect support for nuclear reconstitution, but it is an intelligence assertion about procurement efforts rather than direct evidence that the program had been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia paper april 3 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"new yorker article sy hersh\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"british white paper september 2002\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3275, "completion_tokens": 347, "total_tokens": 3622, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00441537061125, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.222120Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article from 2002, which is a tertiary crowd-edited source rather than a primary record or vetted expert study. It may summarize generally reliable material, but its sourcing is incomplete in the excerpt and it has no strong editorial or peer-review guarantees.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.3,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article from 2002, which is a tertiary crowd-edited source rather than a primary record or vetted expert study. It may summarize generally reliable material, but its sourcing is incomplete in the excerpt and it has no strong editorial or peer-review guarantees.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is mainly about UNMOVIC/UNSCOM and Iraq weapons inspections, providing background on monitoring Iraq’s WMD compliance rather than directly reporting whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses UNMOVIC's creation and inspection history, but it does not provide any direct evidence about whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2954, "completion_tokens": 2035, "total_tokens": 4989, "reasoning_tokens": 1770 }, "cost_usd": 0.009199086, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.222226Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article from 2002, which is a tertiary crowd-edited source rather than a primary record or vetted expert study. It may summarize generally reliable material, but its sourcing is incomplete in the excerpt and it has no strong editorial or peer-review guarantees.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.3,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article from 2002, which is a tertiary crowd-edited source rather than a primary record or vetted expert study. It may summarize generally reliable material, but its sourcing is incomplete in the excerpt and it has no strong editorial or peer-review guarantees.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The article is general background on UNMOVIC and Iraq weapons inspections, only indirectly touching on Iraq's biological weapons status rather than reporting on biological stockpiles or an active production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt only describes UNMOVIC’s mandate, Iraq’s lack of cooperation, and inspection history; it does not provide evidence that Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2962, "completion_tokens": 2038, "total_tokens": 5000, "reasoning_tokens": 1770 }, "cost_usd": 0.009218586, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.222327Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article from 2002, which is a tertiary crowd-edited source rather than a primary record or vetted expert study. It may summarize generally reliable material, but its sourcing is incomplete in the excerpt and it has no strong editorial or peer-review guarantees.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.3,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article from 2002, which is a tertiary crowd-edited source rather than a primary record or vetted expert study. It may summarize generally reliable material, but its sourcing is incomplete in the excerpt and it has no strong editorial or peer-review guarantees.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The article is general background on UNMOVIC and Iraq weapons inspections, only indirectly touching on Iraq's biological weapons status rather than reporting on biological stockpiles or an active production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses UNMOVIC's creation, mandate, and inspection history, but it does not state whether Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 806, "completion_tokens": 66, "total_tokens": 872, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0009015, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.222327Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary source with editorial oversight and citations, but it is not peer reviewed and depends on the quality of the underlying references. As a summary of a public presentation, it is usable for background but not strong evidence by itself on Iraq's weapons programmes and stockpiles.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "office of the vice president" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a secondary source with editorial oversight and citations, but it is not peer reviewed and depends on the quality of the underlying references. As a summary of a public presentation, it is usable for background but not strong evidence by itself on Iraq's weapons programmes and stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is about U.S. claims in early 2003 that Iraq possessed or was producing WMD and ignored inspectors, which is adjacent to but not a direct test of whether Iraq had specifically reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.6,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says Powell asserted Iraq was producing WMDs and violating UN resolutions, but it does not claim Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003, so it at most gestures at suspicion rather than that specific finding.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of state february 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"office of the vice president\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2852, "completion_tokens": 297, "total_tokens": 3149, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0038374200000000002, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.222496Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary source with editorial oversight and citations, but it is not peer reviewed and depends on the quality of the underlying references. As a summary of a public presentation, it is usable for background but not strong evidence by itself on Iraq's weapons programmes and stockpiles.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "office of the vice president" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a secondary source with editorial oversight and citations, but it is not peer reviewed and depends on the quality of the underlying references. As a summary of a public presentation, it is usable for background but not strong evidence by itself on Iraq's weapons programmes and stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is about U.S. claims in early 2003 that Iraq possessed or was producing WMD and ignored inspectors, which is adjacent to but not a direct test of whether Iraq had specifically reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.6,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says Powell asserted Iraq was producing WMD and was in violation of UN resolution, which implies ongoing weapons activity and weakly contradicts the claim that Iraq had not reconstituted its nuclear program by March 2003, but it does not directly address nuclear reconstitution.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of state february 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"office of the vice president\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 827, "completion_tokens": 84, "total_tokens": 911, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00099825, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.222496Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Published in a reputable professional magazine (Chemical & Engineering News) and based primarily on official government and inquiry records such as the Iraq Survey Group report and congressional testimony.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate armed services committee 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published in a reputable professional magazine (Chemical & Engineering News) and based primarily on official government and inquiry records such as the Iraq Survey Group report and congressional testimony.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses and reports on whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran active production programs in March 2003 based on the findings of the Iraq Survey Group.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that the Iraq Survey Group found no evidence of WMD arsenals or active production programs, and that biological weapon stockpiles were destroyed in the early 1990s.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"senate armed services committee 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3042, "completion_tokens": 1783, "total_tokens": 4825, "reasoning_tokens": 1739 }, "cost_usd": 0.00854509, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.222660Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is reputable reporting by a major news organization relaying official findings and statements directly from the head of the Iraq Survey Group and primary government documents.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is reputable reporting by a major news organization relaying official findings and statements directly from the head of the Iraq Survey Group and primary government documents.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports on the CIA's final investigation findings regarding whether Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction or active programs in 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that the CIA's top weapons inspector concluded the investigation found no weapons of mass destruction, contradicting the claim that Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active production program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfers\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2869, "completion_tokens": 224, "total_tokens": 3093, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0022027600000000002, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.222768Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The source is an official government/military inquiry report (the Iraq Survey Group Final Report), which constitutes a primary official document on the topic.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an official government/military inquiry report (the Iraq Survey Group Final Report), which constitutes a primary official document on the topic.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the Iraq Survey Group's investigation into Iraqi WMD activities and prewar assumptions about chemical stocks, which is closely related to the question of whether Iraq held such stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses the Iraq Survey Group's findings and the subsequent realization that post-invasion investigations failed to discover any hidden WMD stockpiles, despite pre-war assumptions.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2766, "completion_tokens": 217, "total_tokens": 2983, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0020973707195, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.222934Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents tertiary literature summarizing secondary reporting and official inquiries rather than providing primary research or direct peer-reviewed analysis.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq intelligence commission" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents tertiary literature summarizing secondary reporting and official inquiries rather than providing primary research or direct peer-reviewed analysis.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly discusses whether Iraq possessed stockpiles of chemical and other weapons of mass destruction at the time of the March 2003 invasion.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that official findings and inspections by the ISG and CIA concluded that Iraq did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the invasion in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq intelligence commission\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2962, "completion_tokens": 6770, "total_tokens": 9732, "reasoning_tokens": 6552 }, "cost_usd": 0.03504565, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.223044Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents tertiary literature summarizing secondary reporting and official inquiries rather than providing primary research or direct peer-reviewed analysis.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq intelligence commission" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents tertiary literature summarizing secondary reporting and official inquiries rather than providing primary research or direct peer-reviewed analysis.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active production program in March 2003 through its discussion of official findings and search results regarding Iraqi WMD.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites official findings by the Iraq Survey Group, CIA, and Iraq Intelligence Commission concluding that Iraq did not possess WMD stockpiles or active production programs in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq intelligence commission\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2970, "completion_tokens": 6774, "total_tokens": 9744, "reasoning_tokens": 6552 }, "cost_usd": 0.03505805, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.223147Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is a primary official record (the text of a presentation by the U.S. Secretary of State to the United Nations), which serves as direct evidence regarding official claims about Iraq's weapons programmes.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a primary official record (the text of a presentation by the U.S. Secretary of State to the United Nations), which serves as direct evidence regarding official claims about Iraq's weapons programmes.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is the text of Colin Powell's presentation to the UN, which directly addressed the status of Iraq's weapons programs, including nuclear weapons, around the time in question.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt introduces the topic of Iraq's disarmament obligations and Resolution 1441 but cuts off before addressing whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2958, "completion_tokens": 3262, "total_tokens": 6220, "reasoning_tokens": 3497 }, "cost_usd": 0.014322630000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.223253Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is an official primary record consisting of declassified excerpts from a National Intelligence Estimate (NIE), published in the Congressional Record.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an official primary record consisting of declassified excerpts from a National Intelligence Estimate (NIE), published in the Congressional Record.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document contains the key judgments of the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate, which directly reports on whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that Iraq has continued its WMD programs and judges that it will likely have a nuclear weapon during the decade, supporting the sub-claim that the program was reconstituted.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3075, "completion_tokens": 2432, "total_tokens": 5507, "reasoning_tokens": 2245 }, "cost_usd": 0.00969488, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.223360Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The source is published by SIPRI, an authoritative research institute, and authored by a primary participant (the Deputy for Analysis for UN weapons inspectors in Iraq), providing an official-level retrospective evaluation based on direct experience and primary inquiry records.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is published by SIPRI, an authoritative research institute, and authored by a primary participant (the Deputy for Analysis for UN weapons inspectors in Iraq), providing an official-level retrospective evaluation based on direct experience and primary inquiry records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly discusses whether Iraq held weapons of mass destruction, specifically chemical weapons stockpiles, in March 2003 and evaluates the truth of that premise.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that the Iraq Survey Group searched for and found no weapons of mass destruction in Iraq after the 2003 invasion.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay senate testimony 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3080, "completion_tokens": 4527, "total_tokens": 7607, "reasoning_tokens": 4299 }, "cost_usd": 0.0091670464, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.223465Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The source is published by SIPRI, an authoritative research institute, and authored by a primary participant (the Deputy for Analysis for UN weapons inspectors in Iraq), providing an official-level retrospective evaluation based on direct experience and primary inquiry records.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is published by SIPRI, an authoritative research institute, and authored by a primary participant (the Deputy for Analysis for UN weapons inspectors in Iraq), providing an official-level retrospective evaluation based on direct experience and primary inquiry records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held weapons of mass destruction, which encompasses biological weapons stockpiles and production programs in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly states that the ISG found no weapons of mass destruction in Iraq and that the premise of active WMD programs was not true.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay senate testimony 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3088, "completion_tokens": 4524, "total_tokens": 7612, "reasoning_tokens": 4299 }, "cost_usd": 0.009161946399999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.223581Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is an excerpt from the Iraq Survey Group Final Report, which serves as an official governmental inquiry and primary investigative record into Iraq's weapons programs.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an excerpt from the Iraq Survey Group Final Report, which serves as an official governmental inquiry and primary investigative record into Iraq's weapons programs.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is from the Iraq Survey Group Final Report on the evolution of Iraq's nuclear weapons program up to 2003, which directly tests whether the program had been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses historical background regarding Iraq's nuclear ambitions from the 1960s to the 1970s and does not address whether the program was reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3073, "completion_tokens": 2676, "total_tokens": 5749, "reasoning_tokens": 2474 }, "cost_usd": 0.00934646, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.223688Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is Wikipedia, an encyclopedia that aggregates secondary reporting and official documents, fitting the profile of ordinary journalism relaying findings.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is Wikipedia, an encyclopedia that aggregates secondary reporting and official documents, fitting the profile of ordinary journalism relaying findings.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the status of Iraq's chemical weapons stockpiles and UN inspections leading up to March 2003, which tests the sub-claim about whether such stockpiles existed at that time.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The text states that Iraq's chemical weapons stockpile was destroyed after 1991 in accordance with UN resolutions, directly contradicting the claim that it held militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2900, "completion_tokens": 289, "total_tokens": 3189, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.002448469149, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.223794Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is Wikipedia, an encyclopedia that aggregates secondary reporting and official documents, fitting the profile of ordinary journalism relaying findings.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is Wikipedia, an encyclopedia that aggregates secondary reporting and official documents, fitting the profile of ordinary journalism relaying findings.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly discusses whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran active biological weapons programs in the context leading up to March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt explicitly describes claims that Iraq continued researching and stockpiling WMDs as 'False assertions by the US and UK'.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2908, "completion_tokens": 253, "total_tokens": 3161, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.002360869149, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.223904Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is Wikipedia, an encyclopedia that aggregates secondary reporting and official documents, fitting the profile of ordinary journalism relaying findings.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is Wikipedia, an encyclopedia that aggregates secondary reporting and official documents, fitting the profile of ordinary journalism relaying findings.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly discusses whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran active biological weapons programs in the context leading up to March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The text states that Iraq's biological weapon program was halted and that claims of ongoing WMD research and stockpiling were false assertions by the US and UK.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 852, "completion_tokens": 58, "total_tokens": 910, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004006, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.223904Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This document is a direct, primary transcript of an official presentation to the U.N. Security Council by the chief weapons inspector, representing an authoritative first-hand record.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is a direct, primary transcript of an official presentation to the U.N. Security Council by the chief weapons inspector, representing an authoritative first-hand record.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a direct transcript of chief U.N. weapons inspector Hans Blix reporting on the status of inspections in Iraq in March 2003, which directly tests the proposition regarding Iraq's nuclear and weapons programs.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses the logistics and progress of U.N. weapons inspections in Iraq up to March 2003, but it does not provide findings or assertions regarding whether Iraq had actually reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2987, "completion_tokens": 249, "total_tokens": 3236, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00200932, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.224084Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents ordinary secondary reporting that summarizes official findings and investigations regarding Iraq's weapons programmes.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents ordinary secondary reporting that summarizes official findings and investigations regarding Iraq's weapons programmes.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt explicitly discusses the Iraq Survey Group's findings regarding whether Iraq held militarily significant stockpiles of chemical weapons in 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly states that the ISG found only small stockpiles of chemical weapons that were inadequate to pose a militarily significant threat.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2845, "completion_tokens": 4007, "total_tokens": 6852, "reasoning_tokens": 3848 }, "cost_usd": 0.0189524, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.224220Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents ordinary secondary reporting that summarizes official findings and investigations regarding Iraq's weapons programmes.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents ordinary secondary reporting that summarizes official findings and investigations regarding Iraq's weapons programmes.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the Iraq Survey Group and its mission to investigate Iraq's alleged weapons of mass destruction, including biological weapons and production programs, which closely relates to the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt notes that the Iraq Survey Group's final report acknowledged that only small stockpiles of chemical WMDs were found and does not report the discovery of biological weapons stockpiles or active production programs in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2853, "completion_tokens": 4041, "total_tokens": 6894, "reasoning_tokens": 3848 }, "cost_usd": 0.0190398, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.224322Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents ordinary secondary reporting that summarizes official findings and investigations regarding Iraq's weapons programmes.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents ordinary secondary reporting that summarizes official findings and investigations regarding Iraq's weapons programmes.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses the Iraq Survey Group's mission to investigate Iraq's alleged weapons of mass destruction, which broadly covers the nuclear program sub-claim without specifically detailing its reconstitution status by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt notes that the ISG's final report concluded only small, militarily insignificant stockpiles of chemical WMDs were found, undermining the claim that a nuclear program had been reconstituted.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2839, "completion_tokens": 4033, "total_tokens": 6872, "reasoning_tokens": 3848 }, "cost_usd": 0.0190156, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.224425Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is published by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) in its official bulletin and directly cites Hans Blix, the former chief UN weapons inspector, representing a primary-source-adjacent official record.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is published by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) in its official bulletin and directly cites Hans Blix, the former chief UN weapons inspector, representing a primary-source-adjacent official record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses UN weapons inspections and the findings regarding Iraq's weapons of mass destruction up to March 2003, which closely relates to the sub-claim about a reconstituted nuclear program.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that weapons inspectors conducted about 700 inspections and found no weapons of mass destruction.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3451, "completion_tokens": 3489, "total_tokens": 6940, "reasoning_tokens": 3263 }, "cost_usd": 0.007489809599999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.224544Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is published by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) in its official bulletin and directly cites Hans Blix, the former chief UN weapons inspector, representing a primary-source-adjacent official record.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is published by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) in its official bulletin and directly cites Hans Blix, the former chief UN weapons inspector, representing a primary-source-adjacent official record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses UN weapons inspections and the findings regarding Iraq's weapons of mass destruction up to March 2003, which closely relates to the sub-claim about a reconstituted nuclear program.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites the chief weapons inspector stating that hundreds of inspections found no weapons of mass destruction, supporting the claim that Iraq had not reconstituted its nuclear program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 980, "completion_tokens": 74, "total_tokens": 1054, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.000479, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.224544Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is an analytical review published on a reputable commentary platform by an author who is a former professional weapons inspector with direct firsthand expertise, providing informed commentary on official government and inspection findings.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an analytical review published on a reputable commentary platform by an author who is a former professional weapons inspector with direct firsthand expertise, providing informed commentary on official government and inspection findings.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly discusses findings from the Iraq Survey Group report regarding whether actual chemical weapons were found in Iraq following the 2003 invasion.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document notes that opponents highlight the fact that no trace of actual chemical or biological weapons has been found by the ISG.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq survey group interim report 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2841, "completion_tokens": 8323, "total_tokens": 11164, "reasoning_tokens": 8120 }, "cost_usd": 0.01765429152, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.224701Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The document is reputable reporting by UN News covering an official address by the US Secretary of State to the Security Council, citing named primary officials and official records.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is reputable reporting by UN News covering an official address by the US Secretary of State to the Security Council, citing named primary officials and official records.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports on Powell's presentation of the US case regarding Iraq's weapons programs and disarmament failures, which directly bears on whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports on US Secretary of State Colin Powell's presentation to the UN Security Council alleging that Iraq maintained active weapons programs and remained in material breach of disarmament resolutions.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"powell presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un news\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2877, "completion_tokens": 3009, "total_tokens": 5886, "reasoning_tokens": 2798 }, "cost_usd": 0.010249939999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.224811Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is an official U.S. government intelligence community publication (the National Intelligence Estimate), representing a primary official record for assessing the topic of Iraq's weapons programs.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an official U.S. government intelligence community publication (the National Intelligence Estimate), representing a primary official record for assessing the topic of Iraq's weapons programs.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly evaluates whether Iraq was reconstituting its nuclear weapons program, directly addressing the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly asserts that most intelligence agencies assessed Baghdad was reconstituting its nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2766, "completion_tokens": 171, "total_tokens": 2937, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001977997536, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.224920Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This document is an official government commission report (The Robb-Silberman Commission), which functions as an official inquiry into intelligence capabilities regarding WMDs, supported by extensive primary source citations.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is an official government commission report (The Robb-Silberman Commission), which functions as an official inquiry into intelligence capabilities regarding WMDs, supported by extensive primary source citations.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only provides endnotes defining intelligence agencies and reports without directly discussing Iraq's chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only discusses endnotes regarding intelligence assessments and the mandate of the Commission, without providing any content about whether Iraq actually held chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3050, "completion_tokens": 266, "total_tokens": 3316, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00248766, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.225028Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This document is an official government commission report (The Robb-Silberman Commission), which functions as an official inquiry into intelligence capabilities regarding WMDs, supported by extensive primary source citations.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is an official government commission report (The Robb-Silberman Commission), which functions as an official inquiry into intelligence capabilities regarding WMDs, supported by extensive primary source citations.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only provides endnotes defining intelligence agencies and reports without directly discussing Iraq's chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only discusses the administrative background, definitions, and sources of National Intelligence Estimates regarding Iraq's WMD programs, without providing any factual content or assessment about actual stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 882, "completion_tokens": 69, "total_tokens": 951, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004371, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.225028Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This document is an official government commission report (The Robb-Silberman Commission), which functions as an official inquiry into intelligence capabilities regarding WMDs, supported by extensive primary source citations.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is an official government commission report (The Robb-Silberman Commission), which functions as an official inquiry into intelligence capabilities regarding WMDs, supported by extensive primary source citations.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses the Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities and references the National Intelligence Estimate on Iraq's WMD programs, which addresses the broader topic of Iraq's weapons of mass destruction.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only mentions endnotes and citations regarding intelligence reports and the structure of the Intelligence Community without providing content that supports or contradicts the claim about Iraq's biological weapons.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3058, "completion_tokens": 289, "total_tokens": 3347, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00254756, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.225186Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is reputable journalism reporting directly on an official presentation (Secretary of State Colin Powell's address to the U.N. Security Council), citing named primary figures and official intelligence records.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us electronic intercepts" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us satellite photographs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is reputable journalism reporting directly on an official presentation (Secretary of State Colin Powell's address to the U.N. Security Council), citing named primary figures and official intelligence records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses U.S. allegations presented by Colin Powell regarding Iraqi concealment of weapons of mass destruction, which is closely related to the sub-claim about biological weapons stockpiles or production programs.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document presents U.S. officials asserting that Iraq is hiding weapons and actively evading inspectors, which supports the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us electronic intercepts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us satellite photographs\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cnn\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3156, "completion_tokens": 5010, "total_tokens": 8166, "reasoning_tokens": 4789 }, "cost_usd": 0.0158961516, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.225296Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is reputable journalism reporting directly on an official presentation (Secretary of State Colin Powell's address to the U.N. Security Council), citing named primary figures and official intelligence records.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us electronic intercepts" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us satellite photographs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is reputable journalism reporting directly on an official presentation (Secretary of State Colin Powell's address to the U.N. Security Council), citing named primary figures and official intelligence records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses U.S. allegations presented by Colin Powell regarding Iraqi concealment of weapons of mass destruction, which is closely related to the sub-claim about biological weapons stockpiles or production programs.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts through Powell's presentation that Iraq is hiding weapons and deceiving inspectors, which contradicts the claim that Iraq did not have biological weapons or active programs.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us electronic intercepts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us satellite photographs\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cnn\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 869, "completion_tokens": 58, "total_tokens": 927, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004057, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.225296Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is an excerpt from the official Iraq Survey Group Final Report, which functions as an authoritative government inquiry and primary investigative record on Iraq's weapons programs.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an excerpt from the official Iraq Survey Group Final Report, which functions as an authoritative government inquiry and primary investigative record on Iraq's weapons programs.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the Iraq Survey Group Final Report which investigates Iraq's WMD programs and policy choices leading up to 2003, addressing the sub-claim as part of the broader evaluation of chemical weapons and regime strategy.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's regime strategy, WMD timeline, and interactions with UN inspectors up to 1991, but does not contain information about military stockpiles of chemical weapons in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3076, "completion_tokens": 2214, "total_tokens": 5290, "reasoning_tokens": 1992 }, "cost_usd": 0.010816880000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.225454Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published by the National Security Archive (George Washington University), the document relies on declassified official records and primary government directives, offering high-level academic and archival reliability.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published by the National Security Archive (George Washington University), the document relies on declassified official records and primary government directives, offering high-level academic and archival reliability.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses historical WMD programs and inspection regimes leading up to the Iraq war, which partly covers the broader context of the sub-claim about March 2003 stockpiles.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses historical events leading up to the 1991 Gulf War and subsequent UN inspections up to 1998, but does not address whether Iraq held militarily significant stockpiles of chemical weapons in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2981, "completion_tokens": 3325, "total_tokens": 6306, "reasoning_tokens": 3074 }, "cost_usd": 0.01120757, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.225573Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published by the National Security Archive (George Washington University), the document relies on declassified official records and primary government directives, offering high-level academic and archival reliability.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published by the National Security Archive (George Washington University), the document relies on declassified official records and primary government directives, offering high-level academic and archival reliability.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader historical context of Iraqi WMD programs, UNSCOM inspections, and U.S. policy regarding Iraq, which only partly covers the specific sub-claim about biological weapons stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses historical U.S. policy and inspections regarding Iraq's WMD programs up to 1998, but does not provide content that supports or contradicts whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or an active program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2989, "completion_tokens": 3340, "total_tokens": 6329, "reasoning_tokens": 3074 }, "cost_usd": 0.011247469999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.225678Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published by the National Security Archive (George Washington University), the document relies on declassified official records and primary government directives, offering high-level academic and archival reliability.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published by the National Security Archive (George Washington University), the document relies on declassified official records and primary government directives, offering high-level academic and archival reliability.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader historical context of Iraqi WMD programs, UNSCOM inspections, and U.S. policy regarding Iraq, which only partly covers the specific sub-claim about biological weapons stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses historical U.S. justifications for action against Iraq and the UNSCOM inspection regime up to 1998, but it does not provide information addressing whether Iraq actually held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 854, "completion_tokens": 89, "total_tokens": 943, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004787, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.225678Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published by the National Security Archive (George Washington University), the document relies on declassified official records and primary government directives, offering high-level academic and archival reliability.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published by the National Security Archive (George Washington University), the document relies on declassified official records and primary government directives, offering high-level academic and archival reliability.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the general issue of Iraq's WMD programs and efforts to prevent reconstitution, but it was published in 1997 and only touches upon the broader context leading up to the 2003 situation rather than specifically testing whether the program was reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses US policy and UNSCOM inspections up to 1998 but does not provide information on whether Iraq had actually reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2975, "completion_tokens": 3340, "total_tokens": 6315, "reasoning_tokens": 3074 }, "cost_usd": 0.01124327, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.225831Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published by the National Security Archive (George Washington University), the document relies on declassified official records and primary government directives, offering high-level academic and archival reliability.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published by the National Security Archive (George Washington University), the document relies on declassified official records and primary government directives, offering high-level academic and archival reliability.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the general issue of Iraq's WMD programs and efforts to prevent reconstitution, but it was published in 1997 and only touches upon the broader context leading up to the 2003 situation rather than specifically testing whether the program was reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses U.S. policy and the history of weapons inspections up to 1998, but does not provide evidence or address whether Iraq had actually reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 847, "completion_tokens": 70, "total_tokens": 917, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004291, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.225831Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents ordinary journalism and tertiary synthesis relaying other people's findings and official records, rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents ordinary journalism and tertiary synthesis relaying other people's findings and official records, rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses allegations and investigations regarding active biological weapons production programs and mobile laboratories in Iraq prior to March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document notes that the U.S. alleged Iraq had mobile biological weapons laboratories before the war, but subsequent investigations failed to find any evidence of them.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"colin powell un presentation 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2776, "completion_tokens": 252, "total_tokens": 3028, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00228884, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.226020Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a reputable defense information website summarizing official government records and intelligence estimates, specifically the 2002 National Intelligence Estimate, providing clear institutional attribution.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "previous intelligence reports" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a reputable defense information website summarizing official government records and intelligence estimates, specifically the 2002 National Intelligence Estimate, providing clear institutional attribution.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on pre-war intelligence assessments concerning Iraq's chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document details intelligence assessments stating that Iraq possessed between 100 and 500 metric tons of chemical weapons agents prior to the war.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"previous intelligence reports\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2728, "completion_tokens": 1268, "total_tokens": 3996, "reasoning_tokens": 1242 }, "cost_usd": 0.006273, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.226118Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The source is an official Congressional Research Service report written by a subject matter expert, utilizing primary U.N. inspection records and official government data, adhering to strict congressional research standards.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an official Congressional Research Service report written by a subject matter expert, utilizing primary U.N. inspection records and official government data, adhering to strict congressional research standards.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader subject of UN weapons inspections in Iraq during the relevant timeframe, which directly relates to the question of whether Iraq held WMD stockpiles like chemical weapons.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that U.N. inspectors combed Iraq for 16 weeks and turned up some evidence of undeclared activities, but not enough to prove the existence of militarily significant stockpiles of chemical weapons.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3152, "completion_tokens": 1289, "total_tokens": 4441, "reasoning_tokens": 1064 }, "cost_usd": 0.0052865322, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.226249Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The source is an official Congressional Research Service report written by a subject matter expert, utilizing primary U.N. inspection records and official government data, adhering to strict congressional research standards.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an official Congressional Research Service report written by a subject matter expert, utilizing primary U.N. inspection records and official government data, adhering to strict congressional research standards.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses UN inspections for WMDs in Iraq up to March 2003, which closely relates to the question of whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program at that time.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses U.N. inspections and allegations of superficial compliance but does not provide content that directly supports or contradicts the specific claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3146, "completion_tokens": 1279, "total_tokens": 4425, "reasoning_tokens": 1064 }, "cost_usd": 0.0052597322, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.226348Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents tertiary-to-secondary journalism and general reference material relaying findings from other sources rather than an official inquiry or primary document.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "human rights watch" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents tertiary-to-secondary journalism and general reference material relaying findings from other sources rather than an official inquiry or primary document.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraq's chemical weapons program, which addresses the broader topic of Iraqi weapons of mass destruction but only partly covers the specific sub-claim regarding biological weapons.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraq's chemical weapons program rather than biological weapons stockpiles or production.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"united nations\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"human rights watch\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3096, "completion_tokens": 9332, "total_tokens": 12428, "reasoning_tokens": 9136 }, "cost_usd": 0.0289893778, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.226468Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article summarizing an official government report, functioning as ordinary secondary journalism or reference compilation relaying other people's findings.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article summarizing an official government report, functioning as ordinary secondary journalism or reference compilation relaying other people's findings.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses a Senate report evaluating pre-war intelligence regarding Iraq's weapons of mass destruction, which is closely related to the question of whether significant chemical weapons stockpiles existed in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses a Senate report on prewar intelligence failures regarding Iraqi WMDs and historical UN inspections, but it does not provide content that directly supports or contradicts whether Iraq actually held significant chemical stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence 2004\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2769, "completion_tokens": 231, "total_tokens": 3000, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00186116, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.226584Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article summarizing an official government report, functioning as ordinary secondary journalism or reference compilation relaying other people's findings.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article summarizing an official government report, functioning as ordinary secondary journalism or reference compilation relaying other people's findings.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses a Senate report evaluating pre-war intelligence assessments regarding Iraq's weapons of mass destruction, which is closely related to the sub-claim about biological weapons stockpiles or programs in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses a Senate report on intelligence failures regarding Iraq's WMDs but does not provide direct evidence or take a definitive stance on whether Iraq actually held biological weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence 2004\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2777, "completion_tokens": 219, "total_tokens": 2996, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0018335600000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.226687Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The source is an interview transcript published by PBS Frontline featuring direct primary evidence from Colin Powell discussing his intelligence briefings and U.N. speech.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "frontline pbs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell interview february 2016" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "the secret history of isis documentary" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an interview transcript published by PBS Frontline featuring direct primary evidence from Colin Powell discussing his intelligence briefings and U.N. speech.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly discusses Colin Powell's 2003 UN speech regarding Iraq's weapons program and notes that the intelligence later confirmed the program was nonexistent, which directly tests the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that subsequent intelligence confirmed Iraq's weapons program was nonexistent, directly contradicting the claim that the program had been reconstituted.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"frontline pbs\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"colin powell interview february 2016\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"the secret history of isis documentary\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3214, "completion_tokens": 231, "total_tokens": 3445, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0023311, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.226790Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is reputable reporting from the UN's official news service, drawing directly on historical UN archives and official proceedings regarding Iraq's weapons programmes.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council meeting february 5 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is reputable reporting from the UN's official news service, drawing directly on historical UN archives and official proceedings regarding Iraq's weapons programmes.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Colin Powell's 2003 UN presentation concerning Iraqi weapons of mass destruction, which is closely related to the specific sub-claim about Iraq's nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document recounts Colin Powell's 2003 presentation asserting that Iraq was actively producing weapons of mass destruction, which aligns with the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council meeting february 5 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2909, "completion_tokens": 2507, "total_tokens": 5416, "reasoning_tokens": 2315 }, "cost_usd": 0.0055817511999999994, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.226898Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable, non-partisan organization that relies on official documentation and primary records such as the Iraq Survey Group report, though it is a secondary fact-checking piece rather than an official inquiry or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable, non-partisan organization that relies on official documentation and primary records such as the Iraq Survey Group report, though it is a secondary fact-checking piece rather than an official inquiry or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on whether Iraq held stockpiles of chemical weapons at the time of the 2003 invasion.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites the Iraq Survey Group's findings that Iraq had already destroyed all of its existing chemical weapons stockpiles by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2966, "completion_tokens": 830, "total_tokens": 3796, "reasoning_tokens": 631 }, "cost_usd": 0.00473334, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.227024Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable, non-partisan organization that relies on official documentation and primary records such as the Iraq Survey Group report, though it is a secondary fact-checking piece rather than an official inquiry or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable, non-partisan organization that relies on official documentation and primary records such as the Iraq Survey Group report, though it is a secondary fact-checking piece rather than an official inquiry or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on whether Iraq held stockpiles of chemical weapons at the time of the 2003 invasion.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites the Iraq Survey Group's determination that Iraq had already destroyed all of its existing chemical weapons stockpiles by March 2003, which directly supports the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 843, "completion_tokens": 75, "total_tokens": 918, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004404, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.227024Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable, non-partisan organization that relies on official documentation and primary records such as the Iraq Survey Group report, though it is a secondary fact-checking piece rather than an official inquiry or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable, non-partisan organization that relies on official documentation and primary records such as the Iraq Survey Group report, though it is a secondary fact-checking piece rather than an official inquiry or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites the Iraq Survey Group's final report to state that Iraq had abandoned its WMD programs and destroyed all existing biological weapons stockpiles by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2974, "completion_tokens": 843, "total_tokens": 3817, "reasoning_tokens": 631 }, "cost_usd": 0.00476824, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.227177Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable, non-partisan organization that relies on official documentation and primary records such as the Iraq Survey Group report, though it is a secondary fact-checking piece rather than an official inquiry or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable, non-partisan organization that relies on official documentation and primary records such as the Iraq Survey Group report, though it is a secondary fact-checking piece rather than an official inquiry or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq had a nuclear weapons program around the time of the 2003 invasion.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that the Iraq Survey Group determined Iraq had abandoned its quest to develop nuclear weapons, directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2960, "completion_tokens": 817, "total_tokens": 3777, "reasoning_tokens": 631 }, "cost_usd": 0.00469904, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.227271Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a reputable reporting organization citing official statements from military and defense officials, as well as UN reports, providing named primary sources and records.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "kimmitt press briefing may 17 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "rumsfeld heritage foundation may 17 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a reputable reporting organization citing official statements from military and defense officials, as well as UN reports, providing named primary sources and records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the discovery of a single chemical munition and past accounting discrepancies regarding sarin, which addresses a broader or adjacent question about Iraq's WMD programs rather than directly testing whether Iraq held militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document notes that the found shell was the first such weapon discovered and described it as virtually ineffective, which contradicts the claim that Iraq held militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"kimmitt press briefing may 17 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"rumsfeld heritage foundation may 17 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic march 2003 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2843, "completion_tokens": 4493, "total_tokens": 7336, "reasoning_tokens": 4218 }, "cost_usd": 0.009940720288, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.227366Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a reputable non-governmental organization specializing in arms control that relies directly on official UN and IAEA inspection reports and records for its data.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq declaration december 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a reputable non-governmental organization specializing in arms control that relies directly on official UN and IAEA inspection reports and records for its data.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports on UN inspections regarding Iraq's weapons of mass destruction, directly addressing whether stockpiles existed or were accounted for in early 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses inspection statistics and unresolved disarmament issues but does not provide evidence confirming the presence of militarily significant chemical weapon stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq declaration december 2002\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2998, "completion_tokens": 8018, "total_tokens": 11016, "reasoning_tokens": 7801 }, "cost_usd": 0.032247076, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.227495Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "The source is an advocacy website promoting a documentary film comparing pre-war claims to facts, relying on secondary reporting rather than original primary documents or peer-reviewed research.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "bush administration" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "curveball" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "defense intelligence agency" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an advocacy website promoting a documentary film comparing pre-war claims to facts, relying on secondary reporting rather than original primary documents or peer-reviewed research.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq possessed biological weapons or ran an active biological weapons production program, specifically evaluating pre-war claims regarding mobile biological weapons laboratories.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that no mobile biological weapons labs were found and that the primary intelligence supporting their existence was fabricated, contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush administration\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi defector curveball\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"defense intelligence agency\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2884, "completion_tokens": 248, "total_tokens": 3132, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0023209999999999997, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.227606Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is an encyclopedia-style entry that synthesizes official findings and historical investigations, functioning as ordinary secondary journalism or summary reference material rather than a primary document.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an encyclopedia-style entry that synthesizes official findings and historical investigations, functioning as ordinary secondary journalism or summary reference material rather than a primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held militarily significant stockpiles of chemical weapons in March 2003 by discussing post-invasion findings and official reports regarding pre-war WMD claims.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that post-invasion investigations by the Iraq Survey Group uncovered no operational stockpiles and confirmed that Iraq had destroyed its known WMD stockpiles by 1991.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2814, "completion_tokens": 259, "total_tokens": 3073, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00197566, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.227715Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The document relies on official statements, primary inquiry findings, and named journalistic sources (such as a New York Times interview with David Kay and official government speeches), representing reputable reporting of official records.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cheney meet the press 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush state of the union 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document relies on official statements, primary inquiry findings, and named journalistic sources (such as a New York Times interview with David Kay and official government speeches), representing reputable reporting of official records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly quotes official statements and inspection findings regarding whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or an active production program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites the head of the U.S. weapons search team stating that they found no people, documents, or physical plants indicating production or large stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay new york times interview 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cheney meet the press 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"powell un security council 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush state of the union 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3458, "completion_tokens": 1653, "total_tokens": 5111, "reasoning_tokens": 1494 }, "cost_usd": 0.00826978, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.227866Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents tertiary compilation and advocacy/encyclopedic summary rather than primary research or a peer-reviewed study, though it contains inline citations.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "riegle report 1994" }, { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents tertiary compilation and advocacy/encyclopedic summary rather than primary research or a peer-reviewed study, though it contains inline citations.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the history, existence, and status of Iraq's biological weapons program up to and around the 2003 invasion.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt explicitly states that the biological weapons program no longer existed by the time of the 2003 invasion.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"riegle report 1994\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3000, "completion_tokens": 6770, "total_tokens": 9770, "reasoning_tokens": 6573 }, "cost_usd": 0.0300483, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.227967Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a reputable non-governmental organization (Arms Control Association) providing a structured chronology of official UN records and public statements, qualifying as reputable reporting with named primary sources or official records.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a reputable non-governmental organization (Arms Control Association) providing a structured chronology of official UN records and public statements, qualifying as reputable reporting with named primary sources or official records.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on UN inspection findings regarding whether Iraq possessed chemical weapons prior to the March 2003 invasion.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that UN weapons inspectors conducted numerous inspections prior to the invasion and did not find that Iraq possessed chemical or biological weapons.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush state of the union 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2941, "completion_tokens": 228, "total_tokens": 3169, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0021541, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.228095Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a reputable non-governmental organization (Arms Control Association) providing a structured chronology of official UN records and public statements, qualifying as reputable reporting with named primary sources or official records.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a reputable non-governmental organization (Arms Control Association) providing a structured chronology of official UN records and public statements, qualifying as reputable reporting with named primary sources or official records.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on UN weapons inspections investigating whether Iraq possessed biological weapons or ran active production programs prior to the March 2003 invasion.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document notes that UN weapons inspectors conducted numerous inspections between November 2002 and March 2003 and did not find that Iraq possessed chemical or biological weapons.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush state of the union 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2949, "completion_tokens": 249, "total_tokens": 3198, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.002209, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.228199Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is reputable reporting from UN News relaying direct statements from Hans Blix, the Executive Chairman of UNMOVIC, serving as a named primary official source regarding weapons inspections.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is reputable reporting from UN News relaying direct statements from Hans Blix, the Executive Chairman of UNMOVIC, serving as a named primary official source regarding weapons inspections.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses UNMOVIC inspections and Iraq's weapons of mass destruction compliance generally, which partly covers the broader context of Iraq's alleged weapons programs including nuclear.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The UN chief weapons inspector states that inspectors had not identified any proscribed weapons being used, which contradicts the claim that a nuclear program had been reconstituted and active by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un news\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2410, "completion_tokens": 3480, "total_tokens": 5890, "reasoning_tokens": 3269 }, "cost_usd": 0.01490562, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.228306Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source provides an overview of the intelligence history behind the mobile biological labs based on established public records and historical reporting, acting as secondary explanatory journalism rather than an official inquiry or primary document.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "curveball" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "german intelligence" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source provides an overview of the intelligence history behind the mobile biological labs based on established public records and historical reporting, acting as secondary explanatory journalism rather than an official inquiry or primary document.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly discusses the intelligence regarding Iraqi mobile biological weapons production facilities, which specifically tests the sub-claim that Iraq ran an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes intelligence reports and official presentations asserting that Iraq ran mobile biological weapons production facilities.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"curveball\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"german intelligence\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cia\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"powell un speech 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2710, "completion_tokens": 2360, "total_tokens": 5070, "reasoning_tokens": 2140 }, "cost_usd": 0.01060562, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.228412Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is an official United Nations Security Council report prepared by UNMOVIC, representing a primary official inquiry and authoritative international inspection record.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an official United Nations Security Council report prepared by UNMOVIC, representing a primary official inquiry and authoritative international inspection record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports directly on the summary of Iraq's proscribed biological weapons programmes investigated by UNMOVIC, which bears directly on whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt introduces a summary of Iraq's proscribed weapons programmes but does not provide specific content regarding whether biological weapons stockpiles or active production existed in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3390, "completion_tokens": 2041, "total_tokens": 5431, "reasoning_tokens": 1843 }, "cost_usd": 0.0074229232, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.228534Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This document is an official transcript of a primary government presentation delivered to the UN Security Council, representing an official state record directly relevant to the topic.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is an official transcript of a primary government presentation delivered to the UN Security Council, representing an official state record directly relevant to the topic.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt introduces a speech addressing Iraq's weapons of mass destruction and UN resolutions more broadly, only partly covering the specific sub-claim about biological weapons stockpiles or production programs.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document features Colin Powell's presentation alleging that Iraq possessed biological weapons and active production programs, which supports the sub-claim through official intelligence assertions.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us state department 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2999, "completion_tokens": 235, "total_tokens": 3234, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00232614, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.228640Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This document is an official transcript of a primary government presentation delivered to the UN Security Council, representing an official state record directly relevant to the topic.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is an official transcript of a primary government presentation delivered to the UN Security Council, representing an official state record directly relevant to the topic.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is the official speech by Secretary of State Colin Powell to the U.N. Security Council detailing evidence regarding Iraq's weapons of mass destruction, which directly tests the proposition that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document contains arguments and claims presented to the U.N. Security Council alleging Iraqi non-compliance and weapons programs.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us state department 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2985, "completion_tokens": 232, "total_tokens": 3217, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00231444, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.228744Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published by the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, this document serves as a structured, institutional inquiry into prewar intelligence and official records regarding Iraq's weapons programmes.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, { "type": "study", "id": "wmd in iraq evidence and implications" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published by the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, this document serves as a structured, institutional inquiry into prewar intelligence and official records regarding Iraq's weapons programmes.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses the broader context of prewar intelligence and administration claims regarding Iraq's weapons of mass destruction rather than specifically evaluating chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses public debate, administration statements, and the framing of the war, but does not provide direct evidence or findings regarding whether Iraq actually held militarily significant stockpiles of chemical weapons in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"carnegie endowment for international peace\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wmd in iraq evidence and implications\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2824, "completion_tokens": 244, "total_tokens": 3068, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00224306, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.228852Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Published by a prominent policy institute (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) with named authorship and substantive analysis of official records like National Intelligence Estimates, representing reputable reporting and analysis.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published by a prominent policy institute (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) with named authorship and substantive analysis of official records like National Intelligence Estimates, representing reputable reporting and analysis.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the National Intelligence Estimate and intelligence misrepresentations concerning Iraq's weapons programs, which relates to the claim about a reconstituted nuclear program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that the intelligence community misconstrued and misrepresented the threat posed by Iraq's weapons programs, and that no weapons of mass destruction were found.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"carnegie endowment for international peace\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia white paper iraqs weapons of mass destruction\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2909, "completion_tokens": 253, "total_tokens": 3162, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00211066, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.228962Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.0, "quality_rationale": "The provided document is an index or landing page description from the CIA FOIA reading room concerning Nixon's 1972 trip to China, making it entirely irrelevant and unusable as evidence on Iraq's weapons programmes between 2002 and 2004.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided document is an index or landing page description from the CIA FOIA reading room concerning Nixon's 1972 trip to China, making it entirely irrelevant and unusable as evidence on Iraq's weapons programmes between 2002 and 2004.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses CIA materials related to President Nixon's 1972 trip to China, which has no relation to Iraq's chemical weapons stockpiles in 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses CIA materials related to President Nixon's 1972 trip to China and does not address Iraq or chemical weapons in 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3093, "completion_tokens": 701, "total_tokens": 3794, "reasoning_tokens": 498 }, "cost_usd": 0.003700776, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.229090Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.0, "quality_rationale": "The provided document is an index or landing page description from the CIA FOIA reading room concerning Nixon's 1972 trip to China, making it entirely irrelevant and unusable as evidence on Iraq's weapons programmes between 2002 and 2004.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided document is an index or landing page description from the CIA FOIA reading room concerning Nixon's 1972 trip to China, making it entirely irrelevant and unusable as evidence on Iraq's weapons programmes between 2002 and 2004.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses historical CIA materials related to President Nixon's 1972 trip to China, which is entirely unrelated to Iraq's nuclear weapons program in 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses historical materials related to President Nixon's 1972 trip to China and does not mention Iraq or any nuclear weapons program.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3087, "completion_tokens": 713, "total_tokens": 3800, "reasoning_tokens": 498 }, "cost_usd": 0.0037289759999999997, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.229234Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source relies on official records such as the National Intelligence Estimate, offering reputable reporting on government assessments with named institutional origin, though it functions as secondary compilation rather than a primary document.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source relies on official records such as the National Intelligence Estimate, offering reputable reporting on government assessments with named institutional origin, though it functions as secondary compilation rather than a primary document.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on intelligence assessments regarding whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles and ran an active production program prior to March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that the US Intelligence Community judged in October 2002 that Iraq had active offensive biological weapons programs and biological weapons stockpiles.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2956, "completion_tokens": 1126, "total_tokens": 4082, "reasoning_tokens": 937 }, "cost_usd": 0.0047171654, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.229340Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This document is an official United Nations Security Council report from UNMOVIC, serving as a primary administrative record detailing weapons inspections and activities in Iraq.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is an official United Nations Security Council report from UNMOVIC, serving as a primary administrative record detailing weapons inspections and activities in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports on UNMOVIC's inspections and findings in Iraq directly leading up to March 2003 regarding Iraq's weapons declarations and unresolved disarmament issues.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses UNMOVIC inspection activities and administrative matters up to February 2003, but does not provide content that supports or contradicts whether Iraq held militarily significant stockpiles of chemical weapons.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3251, "completion_tokens": 684, "total_tokens": 3935, "reasoning_tokens": 555 }, "cost_usd": 0.00426978, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.229446Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is an excerpt from the official Iraq Survey Group Final Report, which functions as an authoritative governmental inquiry and primary investigative record on the topic.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an excerpt from the official Iraq Survey Group Final Report, which functions as an authoritative governmental inquiry and primary investigative record on the topic.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly investigates and reports on whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program after 1991.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly states that Iraq had not tried to reconstitute a capability to produce nuclear weapons after 1991.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2872, "completion_tokens": 179, "total_tokens": 3051, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00177666, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.229564Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This document is an official transcript of an address to the UN Security Council by the Executive Chairman of UNMOVIC, representing a primary official record and authoritative investigative body report.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is an official transcript of an address to the UN Security Council by the Executive Chairman of UNMOVIC, representing a primary official record and authoritative investigative body report.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses UN inspections in Iraq regarding weapons of mass destruction compliance around March 2003, which broadly touches upon the subject of chemical weapons stockpiles.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses inspection access and surveillance logistics in Iraq but does not provide evidence regarding the presence or absence of chemical weapon stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic 12th quarterly report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3072, "completion_tokens": 2753, "total_tokens": 5825, "reasoning_tokens": 2555 }, "cost_usd": 0.0060514832, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.229670Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a reputable policy analysis organization providing accounts based on official UN records and named primary sources like IAEA and UNMOVIC briefings.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea march 2003 report" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a reputable policy analysis organization providing accounts based on official UN records and named primary sources like IAEA and UNMOVIC briefings.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on the IAEA findings regarding the status of Iraq's nuclear weapons program in March 2003, which is the exact proposition under test.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that IAEA Director General ElBaradei stated the agency found no evidence or plausible indication of the revival of a nuclear weapons program in Iraq as of March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea march 2003 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic march 2003 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"bush administration statements\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2978, "completion_tokens": 3813, "total_tokens": 6791, "reasoning_tokens": 4014 }, "cost_usd": 0.01655166, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.229776Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This document is a direct, official transcript of a primary government presentation given at the United Nations by the U.S. Secretary of State, serving as an authoritative primary-source record of the official claims made at the time.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi defectors" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is a direct, official transcript of a primary government presentation given at the United Nations by the U.S. Secretary of State, serving as an authoritative primary-source record of the official claims made at the time.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on allegations and intelligence regarding whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program leading up to 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that since 1998 Iraq has made efforts to reconstitute its nuclear program, specifically aiming to acquire fissile material.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n\\\"roots\\\": [\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us intelligence community\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi defectors\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cnn\\\"}\\n]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2946, "completion_tokens": 2076, "total_tokens": 5022, "reasoning_tokens": 1841 }, "cost_usd": 0.009596360000000002, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.229881Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The document is reputable reporting from a recognized publication detailing the statements of David Kay, the former chief U.S. weapons inspector, providing primary-source insights into official findings regarding Iraq's weapons programs.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate armed services committee 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is reputable reporting from a recognized publication detailing the statements of David Kay, the former chief U.S. weapons inspector, providing primary-source insights into official findings regarding Iraq's weapons programs.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on David Kay's findings regarding whether Iraq held significant chemical weapons stockpiles around the time of the March 2003 invasion.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that chief weapons inspector David Kay stated the search would not turn up significant chemical or biological stockpiles because Iraq had destroyed them prior to the invasion.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay statements 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia announcement january 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate armed services committee hearing 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2794, "completion_tokens": 252, "total_tokens": 3046, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0021524, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.229969Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Published by a reputable research institution (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) featuring expert analysis by a project director referencing official UN presentations and public records, though it functions as policy commentary rather than a primary technical inquiry.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jordan times editorial 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published by a reputable research institution (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) featuring expert analysis by a project director referencing official UN presentations and public records, though it functions as policy commentary rather than a primary technical inquiry.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Colin Powell's UN presentation regarding Iraq's compliance with disarmament orders more broadly, addressing the general threat rather than specifically isolating biological weapons stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Colin Powell's presentation and reactions to it regarding Iraqi non-compliance and deception, but does not contain content that directly supports or contradicts the specific claim about biological weapons stockpiles or active production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un security council presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"jordan times editorial 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3016, "completion_tokens": 3742, "total_tokens": 6758, "reasoning_tokens": 3499 }, "cost_usd": 0.008525855568, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.230085Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Published by a reputable research institution (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) featuring expert analysis by a project director referencing official UN presentations and public records, though it functions as policy commentary rather than a primary technical inquiry.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jordan times editorial 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published by a reputable research institution (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace) featuring expert analysis by a project director referencing official UN presentations and public records, though it functions as policy commentary rather than a primary technical inquiry.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Colin Powell's UN presentation regarding Iraq's compliance with disarmament orders, which broadly touches on Iraq's weapons programs and the threat it posed around March 2003, but does not specifically or directly evaluate the claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Colin Powell's presentation and reactions to it regarding Iraqi compliance and threats, but does not provide content that directly supports or contradicts whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un security council presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"jordan times editorial 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3002, "completion_tokens": 3763, "total_tokens": 6765, "reasoning_tokens": 3499 }, "cost_usd": 0.008574155568, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.230202Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The source reports directly on the findings of an official government inquiry (the Iraq Survey Group report authored by Charles Duelfer) and cites named primary sources such as Duelfer himself, qualifying it as high-tier official reporting.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source reports directly on the findings of an official government inquiry (the Iraq Survey Group report authored by Charles Duelfer) and cites named primary sources such as Duelfer himself, qualifying it as high-tier official reporting.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on whether Iraq possessed stockpiles of illicit weapons, including chemical weapons, at the time of the U.S. invasion in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites the Iraq Survey Group report by Charles Duelfer, which concluded that Saddam Hussein did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons at the time of the U.S. invasion in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfel\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2982, "completion_tokens": 264, "total_tokens": 3246, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.002146172, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.230317Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The source reports directly on the findings of an official government inquiry (the Iraq Survey Group report authored by Charles Duelfer) and cites named primary sources such as Duelfer himself, qualifying it as high-tier official reporting.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source reports directly on the findings of an official government inquiry (the Iraq Survey Group report authored by Charles Duelfer) and cites named primary sources such as Duelfer himself, qualifying it as high-tier official reporting.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on findings regarding whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran active production programs in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites the Iraq Survey Group report concluding that Saddam Hussein did not possess stockpiles of illicit weapons and had not begun any production program at the time of the invasion in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfel\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2990, "completion_tokens": 252, "total_tokens": 3242, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.002118572, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.230435Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a reputable non-governmental organization specializing in arms control that cites official records, government investigations, and international agency reports.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "arms control association" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a reputable non-governmental organization specializing in arms control that cites official records, government investigations, and international agency reports.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses and reports on the Bush administration's claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document notes that International Atomic Energy Agency inspectors working on the ground in Iraq found no evidence that Baghdad had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"arms control association\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush administration\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2814, "completion_tokens": 239, "total_tokens": 3053, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0022670523695, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.230558Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a reputable publication by Arms Control Association that cites official records, White House statements, and reports from the Iraq Survey Group and UN inspectors.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a reputable publication by Arms Control Association that cites official records, White House statements, and reports from the Iraq Survey Group and UN inspectors.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on the investigation into whether Iraq held significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites investigations by the Iraq Survey Group and UN inspectors showing that Iraq had no WMD stockpiles at the time of the March 2003 invasion.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2791, "completion_tokens": 219, "total_tokens": 3010, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00218862, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.230690Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a reputable publication by Arms Control Association that cites official records, White House statements, and reports from the Iraq Survey Group and UN inspectors.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a reputable publication by Arms Control Association that cites official records, White House statements, and reports from the Iraq Survey Group and UN inspectors.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active program prior to the March 2003 invasion.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that official investigations, such as the Iraq Survey Group report, concluded that Iraq had no WMD stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2799, "completion_tokens": 215, "total_tokens": 3014, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00218102, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.230797Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a reputable publication by Arms Control Association that cites official records, White House statements, and reports from the Iraq Survey Group and UN inspectors.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a reputable publication by Arms Control Association that cites official records, White House statements, and reports from the Iraq Survey Group and UN inspectors.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on claims and findings regarding whether Iraq had an active or reconstituted nuclear weapons program prior to March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that UN weapons inspectors reported prior to the invasion that they had not found any evidence that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2785, "completion_tokens": 229, "total_tokens": 3014, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0022118199999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.230905Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a reputable publication by Arms Control Association that cites official records, White House statements, and reports from the Iraq Survey Group and UN inspectors.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a reputable publication by Arms Control Association that cites official records, White House statements, and reports from the Iraq Survey Group and UN inspectors.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on claims and findings regarding whether Iraq had an active or reconstituted nuclear weapons program prior to March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document notes that UN weapons inspectors and the Iraq Survey Group found no evidence that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program or possessed WMD stockpiles, supporting the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 816, "completion_tokens": 72, "total_tokens": 888, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004248, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.230905Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is a declassified official government exhibit containing primary records and internal communications regarding intelligence assessments of Iraq's WMD programs.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "new yorker article sy hersh" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "british white paper september 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a declassified official government exhibit containing primary records and internal communications regarding intelligence assessments of Iraq's WMD programs.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader question of Iraq's alleged attempts to acquire uranium from Niger, which is an adjacent aspect of a nuclear weapons program but does not directly test whether the entire program was reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses intelligence disputes regarding purported uranium deals between Iraq and Niger rather than providing direct evidence that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia paper april 3 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"new yorker article sy hersh\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"british white paper september 2002\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3426, "completion_tokens": 284, "total_tokens": 3710, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0027344206112500003, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.231430Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is an excerpt from a Wikipedia article, which functions as tertiary/ordinary reporting that relies on secondary and primary findings rather than being an official inquiry or definitive primary record itself.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an excerpt from a Wikipedia article, which functions as tertiary/ordinary reporting that relies on secondary and primary findings rather than being an official inquiry or definitive primary record itself.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses UNMOVIC's mandate to disarm Iraq of weapons of mass destruction, which addresses the broader context of Iraq's weapons programs rather than specifically reporting on whether Iraq held militarily significant stockpiles of chemical weapons in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the creation and history of UNMOVIC and UNSCOM but does not provide any information regarding whether Iraq held militarily significant stockpiles of chemical weapons in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3070, "completion_tokens": 2029, "total_tokens": 5099, "reasoning_tokens": 1770 }, "cost_usd": 0.007883136, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.231587Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is an excerpt from a Wikipedia article, which functions as tertiary/ordinary reporting that relies on secondary and primary findings rather than being an official inquiry or definitive primary record itself.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an excerpt from a Wikipedia article, which functions as tertiary/ordinary reporting that relies on secondary and primary findings rather than being an official inquiry or definitive primary record itself.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses UNMOVIC's mandate to inspect Iraq for weapons of mass destruction, which broadly covers biological weapons but does not specifically test or report on whether Iraq held actual biological weapons stockpiles or active production programs in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the creation and history of UNMOVIC and UNSCOM without providing specific evidence or making assertions regarding whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or active production programs in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3078, "completion_tokens": 2031, "total_tokens": 5109, "reasoning_tokens": 1770 }, "cost_usd": 0.007890536, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.231707Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is an excerpt from a Wikipedia article, which functions as tertiary/ordinary reporting that relies on secondary and primary findings rather than being an official inquiry or definitive primary record itself.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an excerpt from a Wikipedia article, which functions as tertiary/ordinary reporting that relies on secondary and primary findings rather than being an official inquiry or definitive primary record itself.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses UNMOVIC's mandate to inspect Iraq for weapons of mass destruction, which broadly covers biological weapons but does not specifically test or report on whether Iraq held actual biological weapons stockpiles or active production programs in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses the creation and history of UNMOVIC and UNSCOM but does not contain information regarding whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or an active production program in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 848, "completion_tokens": 76, "total_tokens": 924, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004444, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.231707Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents secondary tertiary journalism and encyclopedia-style compilation of other people's findings and official records.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "office of the vice president" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents secondary tertiary journalism and encyclopedia-style compilation of other people's findings and official records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Colin Powell's presentation alleging Iraqi WMD programs, which is closely related to claims about Iraq's nuclear weapons program around that time.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes Colin Powell's presentation asserting that Iraq possessed and was producing weapons of mass destruction in violation of UN resolutions.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of state february 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"office of the vice president\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2948, "completion_tokens": 213, "total_tokens": 3161, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00224652, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.231892Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents secondary tertiary journalism and encyclopedia-style compilation of other people's findings and official records.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "office of the vice president" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article, which represents secondary tertiary journalism and encyclopedia-style compilation of other people's findings and official records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Colin Powell's presentation alleging Iraqi WMD programs, which is closely related to claims about Iraq's nuclear weapons program around that time.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt notes that Colin Powell asserted to the UN Security Council that Iraq was producing weapons of mass destruction and violating resolutions, which contradicts the sub-claim that Iraq had not reconstituted its nuclear/WMD program.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of state february 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"office of the vice president\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 862, "completion_tokens": 78, "total_tokens": 940, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004536, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.231892Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Reputable science news outlet reporting on the official Iraq Survey Group/Duelfer report and Senate testimony, with named primary sources, but it is a secondary news account rather than the primary inquiry document itself.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate armed services committee 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable science news outlet reporting on the official Iraq Survey Group/Duelfer report and Senate testimony, with named primary sources, but it is a secondary news account rather than the primary inquiry document itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly reports the Iraq Survey Group's findings that Iraq had destroyed its biological weapons stockpiles in the early 1990s, found no evidence of WMD arsenals or active production programs before the 2003 invasion, and had no BW production plans after 1995—directly addressing the exact sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.85, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Iraq Survey Group's 16-month inspection concluded it found no evidence Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active BW production program before the March 2003 invasion, noting Iraq destroyed its chemical and biological stockpiles in the early 1990s and had no post-1995 plans to resume BW production.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"senate armed services committee 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3087, "completion_tokens": 2173, "total_tokens": 5260, "reasoning_tokens": 2112 }, "cost_usd": 0.00880819, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.232076Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "NBC News is a reputable mainstream outlet, and the article reports directly on the official CIA/Duelfer Iraq Survey Group report, quoting its head and citing the posted addenda. It is secondary reporting on primary official records rather than the primary document itself, so it fits reputable reporting with named primary sources.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"NBC News is a reputable mainstream outlet, and the article reports directly on the official CIA/Duelfer Iraq Survey Group report, quoting its head and citing the posted addenda. It is secondary reporting on primary official records rather than the primary document itself, so it fits reputable reporting with named primary sources.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports the CIA's final WMD investigation finding no weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, directly addressing whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active biological weapons program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The CIA's final report states the WMD investigation found nothing and was exhausted, directly contradicting the claim that Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfers\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2868, "completion_tokens": 765, "total_tokens": 3633, "reasoning_tokens": 527 }, "cost_usd": 0.0025086600000000002, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.232196Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is the official Iraq Survey Group final report, a government inquiry based on primary evidence, interviews, and site inspections; GlobalSecurity.org is a reputable aggregator but not the original issuing body, so it falls short of a pure definitive primary record.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is the official Iraq Survey Group final report, a government inquiry based on primary evidence, interviews, and site inspections; GlobalSecurity.org is a reputable aggregator but not the original issuing body, so it falls short of a pure definitive primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is the scope note of the official ISG report that directly investigated Iraqi chemical weapons stockpiles, and it discusses prewar assumptions about encountering chemical stocks, but the excerpt itself does not report the specific finding on March 2003 stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt only describes prewar assumptions and the search for WMD, not any finding that Iraq actually held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2794, "completion_tokens": 4530, "total_tokens": 7324, "reasoning_tokens": 4307 }, "cost_usd": 0.0068488707194999995, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.232310Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source that relays official findings and cites references, but it is not peer-reviewed, not an official inquiry, and lacks traditional editorial accountability. Its reliability is comparable to ordinary secondary reporting rather than a primary or authoritative record.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq intelligence commission" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source that relays official findings and cites references, but it is not peer-reviewed, not an official inquiry, and lacks traditional editorial accountability. Its reliability is comparable to ordinary secondary reporting rather than a primary or authoritative record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly reports the CIA's 2004 finding that Saddam Hussein did not possess illicit weapons stockpiles at the time of the March 2003 invasion, directly addressing whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that UNMOVIC and the Iraq Survey Group found no alleged WMD stockpiles and that the CIA concluded Saddam Hussein did not possess illicit weapons stockpiles at the time of the March 2003 invasion, with only pre-1991 remnant chemical warheads discovered.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq intelligence commission\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2976, "completion_tokens": 7908, "total_tokens": 10884, "reasoning_tokens": 7723 }, "cost_usd": 0.036249335, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.232421Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source that relays official findings and cites references, but it is not peer-reviewed, not an official inquiry, and lacks traditional editorial accountability. Its reliability is comparable to ordinary secondary reporting rather than a primary or authoritative record.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq intelligence commission" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source that relays official findings and cites references, but it is not peer-reviewed, not an official inquiry, and lacks traditional editorial accountability. Its reliability is comparable to ordinary secondary reporting rather than a primary or authoritative record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader WMD stockpile/program question in March 2003 but does not specifically mention biological weapons, so it only partly covers the exact sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports UNMOVIC/ISG inspections and CIA findings that Iraq did not possess illicit weapons stockpiles and had not begun a program to produce them at the time of the March 2003 invasion, which directly contradicts the sub-claim if believed.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq intelligence commission\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2966, "completion_tokens": 8176, "total_tokens": 11142, "reasoning_tokens": 8087 }, "cost_usd": 0.03646382, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.232569Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is a verbatim primary-source transcript of Secretary of State Colin Powell's 2003 UN presentation, directly relevant to the topic. Although hosted by a non-official site, it reproduces an official public statement without apparent analytical mediation.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a verbatim primary-source transcript of Secretary of State Colin Powell's 2003 UN presentation, directly relevant to the topic. Although hosted by a non-official site, it reproduces an official public statement without apparent analytical mediation.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's broader WMD disarmament obligations and alleged noncompliance, but the excerpt does not specifically report on whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's WMD disarmament and concealment in general but does not address whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2892, "completion_tokens": 5331, "total_tokens": 8223, "reasoning_tokens": 5568 }, "cost_usd": 0.01647724, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.232684Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is an official primary source: declassified key judgments from the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate, reproduced in the Congressional Record and archived by FAS. It is not the full NIE and is presented via a political speech, but it remains a high-quality official record of intelligence assessments.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an official primary source: declassified key judgments from the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate, reproduced in the Congressional Record and archived by FAS. It is not the full NIE and is presented via a political speech, but it remains a high-quality official record of intelligence assessments.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a declassified October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate that explicitly addresses Iraq's efforts to reconstitute its nuclear capacity, directly bearing on the sub-claim about Iraq's nuclear weapons program status by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.5,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt relays the October 2002 NIE's assessment that Iraq was attempting to reconstitute its nuclear capacity, which supports a reconstitution effort but does not confirm that it had been completed by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3056, "completion_tokens": 7475, "total_tokens": 10531, "reasoning_tokens": 7306 }, "cost_usd": 0.01552758, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.232798Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "SIPRI is a reputable research institute, and the piece is an expert retrospective citing named primary testimony and official inspection findings, but it is a secondary commentary rather than a peer-reviewed study or official inquiry.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"SIPRI is a reputable research institute, and the piece is an expert retrospective citing named primary testimony and official inspection findings, but it is a secondary commentary rather than a peer-reviewed study or official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports that the Iraq Survey Group found no WMD in Iraq, which closely addresses the broader WMD-stockpile claim but does not specifically focus on chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports that the Iraq Survey Group found no WMD in Iraq and that the premise Iraq had WMD was false, directly contradicting the claim of militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay senate testimony 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3102, "completion_tokens": 6011, "total_tokens": 9113, "reasoning_tokens": 5765 }, "cost_usd": 0.0109135014, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.232942Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "SIPRI is a reputable research institute, and the piece is an expert retrospective citing named primary testimony and official inspection findings, but it is a secondary commentary rather than a peer-reviewed study or official inquiry.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"SIPRI is a reputable research institute, and the piece is an expert retrospective citing named primary testimony and official inspection findings, but it is a secondary commentary rather than a peer-reviewed study or official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq had WMD programs in March 2003, a closely related question that encompasses the biological weapons sub-claim, but it does not specifically mention biological weapons stockpiles or production.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.85, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The essay relays the Iraq Survey Group's post-war inspection finding that it found no WMD in Iraq and that the WMD premises for invasion were untrue, which directly contradicts the claim that Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or an active BW program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay senate testimony 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3111, "completion_tokens": 5370, "total_tokens": 8481, "reasoning_tokens": 5162 }, "cost_usd": 0.0099682464, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.233043Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is the official Iraq Survey Group Final Report, an official inquiry based on primary evidence and official records, though hosted by globalsecurity.org rather than the original publisher.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is the official Iraq Survey Group Final Report, an official inquiry based on primary evidence and official records, though hosted by globalsecurity.org rather than the original publisher.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The ISG Final Report's nuclear volume directly examines the evolution of Iraq's nuclear weapons program through 2003, which is the exact subject of the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only discusses Iraq's early nuclear ambitions and 1970s-era facilities, not whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3042, "completion_tokens": 3697, "total_tokens": 6739, "reasoning_tokens": 3648 }, "cost_usd": 0.01032966, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.233161Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary, crowd-edited encyclopedia with no formal peer review or named authorship, though it cites footnoted sources and relays findings from official inspections and reports. It is ordinary secondary aggregation rather than a primary or peer-reviewed record.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary, crowd-edited encyclopedia with no formal peer review or named authorship, though it cites footnoted sources and relays findings from official inspections and reports. It is ordinary secondary aggregation rather than a primary or peer-reviewed record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt directly addresses whether Iraq retained chemical weapons stockpiles after 1991 and in the 2002–2003 pre-war period, including the disputed claim of continued stockpiling before March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states Iraq's chemical weapons stockpile was destroyed after 1991 and that US/UK assertions of continued WMD stockpiling were false, directly contradicting the claim that Iraq held militarily significant chemical stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2923, "completion_tokens": 1142, "total_tokens": 4065, "reasoning_tokens": 831 }, "cost_usd": 0.003242284149, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.233276Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary, crowd-edited encyclopedia with no formal peer review or named authorship, though it cites footnoted sources and relays findings from official inspections and reports. It is ordinary secondary aggregation rather than a primary or peer-reviewed record.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary, crowd-edited encyclopedia with no formal peer review or named authorship, though it cites footnoted sources and relays findings from official inspections and reports. It is ordinary secondary aggregation rather than a primary or peer-reviewed record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on Iraq's biological weapons program being halted after 1991 and on false assertions that Iraq continued stockpiling WMDs in the pre-2003 period, which bears exactly on whether Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt states Iraq ceased its biological weapons program after 1991 and calls US/UK claims of continued WMD stockpiling 'false assertions,' directly contradicting the sub-claim, though this rests on narrative assertion rather than direct inspection findings.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2885, "completion_tokens": 965, "total_tokens": 3850, "reasoning_tokens": 641 }, "cost_usd": 0.002766109149, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.233400Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary, crowd-edited encyclopedia with no formal peer review or named authorship, though it cites footnoted sources and relays findings from official inspections and reports. It is ordinary secondary aggregation rather than a primary or peer-reviewed record.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary, crowd-edited encyclopedia with no formal peer review or named authorship, though it cites footnoted sources and relays findings from official inspections and reports. It is ordinary secondary aggregation rather than a primary or peer-reviewed record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on Iraq's biological weapons program being halted after 1991 and on false assertions that Iraq continued stockpiling WMDs in the pre-2003 period, which bears exactly on whether Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt states Iraq's biological weapons program was halted after 1991 and that Iraq ceased its biological programs, and it calls claims of continued WMD stockpiling false, which supports the sub-claim that Iraq did not hold biological stockpiles or run an active biological weapons program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 845, "completion_tokens": 697, "total_tokens": 1542, "reasoning_tokens": 689 }, "cost_usd": 0.0010899, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.233400Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a verbatim transcript of an official U.N. presentation by chief weapons inspector Hans Blix, making it a primary document from a key participant. CNN is a reputable outlet, though the transcript is not the U.N.'s own official record.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a verbatim transcript of an official U.N. presentation by chief weapons inspector Hans Blix, making it a primary document from a key participant. CNN is a reputable outlet, though the transcript is not the U.N.'s own official record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses inspection logistics and access, not nuclear findings, offering only tangential background to the claim about reconstitution of a nuclear program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses inspection process and access but does not address Iraq's nuclear weapons program, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2987, "completion_tokens": 2797, "total_tokens": 5784, "reasoning_tokens": 2579 }, "cost_usd": 0.004684815, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.233618Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source with some citations, but it is not peer-reviewed or a primary/official record; it mainly relays findings from the Iraq Survey Group and Duelfer Report.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source with some citations, but it is not peer-reviewed or a primary/official record; it mainly relays findings from the Iraq Survey Group and Duelfer Report.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports the Iraq Survey Group's findings on chemical WMD stockpiles in Iraq and whether they were militarily significant.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states the ISG report found only small chemical WMD stockpiles inadequate to pose a militarily significant threat, directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2930, "completion_tokens": 5868, "total_tokens": 8798, "reasoning_tokens": 5687 }, "cost_usd": 0.021402975, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.233736Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source with some citations, but it is not peer-reviewed or a primary/official record; it mainly relays findings from the Iraq Survey Group and Duelfer Report.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source with some citations, but it is not peer-reviewed or a primary/official record; it mainly relays findings from the Iraq Survey Group and Duelfer Report.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the Iraq Survey Group's broader hunt for Iraqi WMD, including biological agents and related production programs, but does not directly report on whether Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.2, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt relays that the ISG's post-invasion fact-finding report acknowledged only small chemical WMD stockpiles inadequate for military significance and mentions no biological weapons found or produced, indirectly undercutting the claim, though it never directly states a biological-weapons conclusion.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2939, "completion_tokens": 7357, "total_tokens": 10296, "reasoning_tokens": 7130 }, "cost_usd": 0.02304786, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.233869Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source with some citations, but it is not peer-reviewed or a primary/official record; it mainly relays findings from the Iraq Survey Group and Duelfer Report.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source with some citations, but it is not peer-reviewed or a primary/official record; it mainly relays findings from the Iraq Survey Group and Duelfer Report.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader post-invasion search for Iraq's alleged WMD programs, but the excerpt does not specifically mention nuclear weapons or a reconstituted nuclear program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses the ISG and chemical WMD stockpiles but never mentions Iraq's nuclear weapons program or its reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2881, "completion_tokens": 6380, "total_tokens": 9261, "reasoning_tokens": 6340 }, "cost_usd": 0.02190342, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.233973Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The IAEA Bulletin is a reputable official publication and the article quotes a named primary source, Hans Blix, but it is journalistic reporting of his statements rather than a formal inspection report, official inquiry, or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The IAEA Bulletin is a reputable official publication and the article quotes a named primary source, Hans Blix, but it is journalistic reporting of his statements rather than a formal inspection report, official inquiry, or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports on UN weapons inspections in Iraq through March 2003 and specifically notes that no WMD were found but a stash of nuclear documents was, addressing the closely related question of Iraq's prohibited weapons programs though not explicitly whether its nuclear weapons program had been reconstituted.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Blix reports that roughly 700 inspections found no weapons of mass destruction and only minor remnants, indicating Iraq had not reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3360, "completion_tokens": 4387, "total_tokens": 7747, "reasoning_tokens": 4139 }, "cost_usd": 0.0078344496, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.234076Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The IAEA Bulletin is a reputable official publication and the article quotes a named primary source, Hans Blix, but it is journalistic reporting of his statements rather than a formal inspection report, official inquiry, or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The IAEA Bulletin is a reputable official publication and the article quotes a named primary source, Hans Blix, but it is journalistic reporting of his statements rather than a formal inspection report, official inquiry, or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports on UN weapons inspections in Iraq through March 2003 and specifically notes that no WMD were found but a stash of nuclear documents was, addressing the closely related question of Iraq's prohibited weapons programs though not explicitly whether its nuclear weapons program had been reconstituted.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.4, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Blix reports that inspections found no WMD, which supports the view that Iraq had not reconstituted a nuclear weapons program, but he also says more inspections were needed to determine whether limited findings were remnants or a tip of an iceberg, making the support partial and indirect.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 932, "completion_tokens": 2421, "total_tokens": 3353, "reasoning_tokens": 2739 }, "cost_usd": 0.0031848, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.234076Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Expert commentary by a former UN weapons inspector, published in a reputable outlet with editorial standards and based on the official ISG report and firsthand experience. It is a secondary analysis rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary record, so it falls short of the highest evidence tiers.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Expert commentary by a former UN weapons inspector, published in a reputable outlet with editorial standards and based on the official ISG report and firsthand experience. It is a secondary analysis rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary record, so it falls short of the highest evidence tiers.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reviews the ISG report on whether Iraq had actual chemical weapons stockpiles, explicitly noting that no trace of chemical or biological weapons was found.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The article relays ISG inspection findings and the author's own Unscom experience that Iraq's chemical stockpile had been eliminated and no actual chemical weapons were found, contradicting the claim of significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq survey group interim report 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2920, "completion_tokens": 12244, "total_tokens": 15164, "reasoning_tokens": 12003 }, "cost_usd": 0.02249554152, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.234257Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "UN News is a reputable publisher, but this is a secondary news report relaying Powell's allegations and quotes rather than an independent or primary examination of Iraq's weapons programmes.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"UN News is a reputable publisher, but this is a secondary news report relaying Powell's allegations and quotes rather than an independent or primary examination of Iraq's weapons programmes.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports the US case that Iraq failed to disarm and was in material breach, a broader WMD-compliance question that only partly covers the specific claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt recounts Powell's general allegations of Iraqi non-cooperation and material breach but says nothing about a reconstituted nuclear weapons program specifically, so it neither supports nor contradicts that narrow sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"powell presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un news\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2854, "completion_tokens": 4319, "total_tokens": 7173, "reasoning_tokens": 4198 }, "cost_usd": 0.01115969, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.234384Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a declassified primary document: the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate key judgments, an official U.S. intelligence assessment issued by the intelligence community. It is an authoritative government primary source, though only an excerpt and an assessment rather than definitive physical evidence.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a declassified primary document: the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate key judgments, an official U.S. intelligence assessment issued by the intelligence community. It is an authoritative government primary source, though only an excerpt and an assessment rather than definitive physical evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document's key judgments explicitly state that Baghdad is reconstituting its nuclear weapons program, which is precisely the proposition at issue (reconstitution of Iraq's nuclear program around the 2003 timeframe).\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The NIE states that, in the view of most agencies, Baghdad was reconstituting its nuclear weapons program, which supports the claim that reconstitution had occurred by March 2003, though it is an intelligence judgment rather than direct observation and is couched as an ongoing process.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2787, "completion_tokens": 1317, "total_tokens": 4104, "reasoning_tokens": 1071 }, "cost_usd": 0.002980497536, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.234522Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is the official report of the congressionally-mandated Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction, published on the White House archive site, an official government inquiry drawing on classified primary records and interviews. It is a primary/official document with extensive endnoted sourcing, meriting near the top of the scale, though it is a government commission report rather than the underlying raw intelligence record itself.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is the official report of the congressionally-mandated Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction, published on the White House archive site, an official government inquiry drawing on classified primary records and interviews. It is a primary/official document with extensive endnoted sourcing, meriting near the top of the scale, though it is a government commission report rather than the underlying raw intelligence record itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document concerns the U.S. intelligence community's assessments of Iraq's WMD programs, not the actual existence of chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003, so it only indirectly addresses the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only references an October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate on Iraq's WMD programs and does not itself state whether Iraq actually held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3115, "completion_tokens": 1806, "total_tokens": 4921, "reasoning_tokens": 1662 }, "cost_usd": 0.00430197, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.234642Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is the official report of the congressionally-mandated Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction, published on the White House archive site, an official government inquiry drawing on classified primary records and interviews. It is a primary/official document with extensive endnoted sourcing, meriting near the top of the scale, though it is a government commission report rather than the underlying raw intelligence record itself.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is the official report of the congressionally-mandated Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction, published on the White House archive site, an official government inquiry drawing on classified primary records and interviews. It is a primary/official document with extensive endnoted sourcing, meriting near the top of the scale, though it is a government commission report rather than the underlying raw intelligence record itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document concerns the U.S. intelligence community's assessments of Iraq's WMD programs, not the actual existence of chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003, so it only indirectly addresses the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only describes the provenance and coordination of the October 2002 NIE on Iraq's WMD programs and does not state whether Iraq actually held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 888, "completion_tokens": 302, "total_tokens": 1190, "reasoning_tokens": 258 }, "cost_usd": 0.0006288, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.234642Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is the official report of the congressionally-mandated Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction, published on the White House archive site, an official government inquiry drawing on classified primary records and interviews. It is a primary/official document with extensive endnoted sourcing, meriting near the top of the scale, though it is a government commission report rather than the underlying raw intelligence record itself.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is the official report of the congressionally-mandated Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction, published on the White House archive site, an official government inquiry drawing on classified primary records and interviews. It is a primary/official document with extensive endnoted sourcing, meriting near the top of the scale, though it is a government commission report rather than the underlying raw intelligence record itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt addresses the Intelligence Community's broader assessments of Iraq's WMD programs, not specifically biological weapons stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.2, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt is bibliographic endnote material that merely cites the October 2002 NIE titled 'Iraq's Continuing Programs for Weapons of Mass Destruction,' whose title relays an intelligence estimate asserting Iraqi WMD programs (including biological) without any direct observation or mention of biological weapons specifically.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3145, "completion_tokens": 1319, "total_tokens": 4464, "reasoning_tokens": 978 }, "cost_usd": 0.0037593, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.234840Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "CNN is a reputable outlet, but this is a secondary news report relaying Colin Powell's presentation and reactions rather than an independent or primary record of Iraq's weapons programmes.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us electronic intercepts" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us satellite photographs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CNN is a reputable outlet, but this is a secondary news report relaying Colin Powell's presentation and reactions rather than an independent or primary record of Iraq's weapons programmes.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's broader WMD concealment and chemical munitions claims, but does not specifically report on biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt contains Powell's claims about Iraqi evasion and a satellite photo of a chemical munitions bunker but no content on biological weapons stockpiles or production, so it does not address the biological sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us electronic intercepts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us satellite photographs\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cnn\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3130, "completion_tokens": 6357, "total_tokens": 9487, "reasoning_tokens": 6232 }, "cost_usd": 0.0172755916, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.234967Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "CNN is a reputable outlet, but this is a secondary news report relaying Colin Powell's presentation and reactions rather than an independent or primary record of Iraq's weapons programmes.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us electronic intercepts" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us satellite photographs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CNN is a reputable outlet, but this is a secondary news report relaying Colin Powell's presentation and reactions rather than an independent or primary record of Iraq's weapons programmes.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's broader WMD concealment and chemical munitions claims, but does not specifically report on biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt does not mention biological weapons; it only relays Powell's assertions about hiding chemical munitions and deceiving inspectors, so it neither supports nor contradicts the specific claim about biological weapons in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us electronic intercepts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us satellite photographs\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cnn\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 879, "completion_tokens": 1502, "total_tokens": 2381, "reasoning_tokens": 1433 }, "cost_usd": 0.0020661, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.234967Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The excerpt reproduces the official Iraq Survey Group Final Report, a primary, government-commissioned inquiry and authoritative record of Iraq's WMD programmes. Although hosted by globalsecurity.org, the underlying content is an official primary document rather than secondary commentary or advocacy.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt reproduces the official Iraq Survey Group Final Report, a primary, government-commissioned inquiry and authoritative record of Iraq's WMD programmes. Although hosted by globalsecurity.org, the underlying content is an official primary document rather than secondary commentary or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Iraq Survey Group Final Report is the official investigation into Iraq's WMD programs, including chemical weapons, and directly assesses whether Iraq possessed militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.2, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt states Saddam sought to preserve the ability to reconstitute WMD, implying no existing stockpiles, but does not directly address March 2003 chemical weapons stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3094, "completion_tokens": 4469, "total_tokens": 7563, "reasoning_tokens": 4391 }, "cost_usd": 0.013351085, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.235137Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive is a reputable publisher with editorial standards, and the document cites official records such as National Security Directive 54, but the excerpt is a secondary analytical narrative rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The National Security Archive is a reputable publisher with editorial standards, and the document cites official records such as National Security Directive 54, but the excerpt is a secondary analytical narrative rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraq's WMD programs and inspections broadly but predates March 2003 and does not specifically address chemical weapons stockpiles at that time.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt is a 1997 policy narrative about UNSCOM inspections and U.S. threats of force, offering only general allegations of Iraqi attempts at denial and deception and no direct observation or assessment of chemical weapons stockpiles as of March 2003, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2952, "completion_tokens": 5965, "total_tokens": 8917, "reasoning_tokens": 5713 }, "cost_usd": 0.013052379, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.235256Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive is a reputable publisher with editorial standards, and the document cites official records such as National Security Directive 54, but the excerpt is a secondary analytical narrative rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The National Security Archive is a reputable publisher with editorial standards, and the document cites official records such as National Security Directive 54, but the excerpt is a secondary analytical narrative rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's broader WMD programs, inspections, and possible reconstitution, which only partly covers the specific claim about biological weapons stockpiles or active production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's general WMD programs and UNSCOM inspections through 1998, but does not address biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2916, "completion_tokens": 5492, "total_tokens": 8408, "reasoning_tokens": 5276 }, "cost_usd": 0.012672204, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.235385Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive is a reputable publisher with editorial standards, and the document cites official records such as National Security Directive 54, but the excerpt is a secondary analytical narrative rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The National Security Archive is a reputable publisher with editorial standards, and the document cites official records such as National Security Directive 54, but the excerpt is a secondary analytical narrative rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's broader WMD programs, inspections, and possible reconstitution, which only partly covers the specific claim about biological weapons stockpiles or active production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses UNSCOM and general concerns about Iraq reconstituting WMD programs but does not address biological weapons stockpiles or active production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 821, "completion_tokens": 1159, "total_tokens": 1980, "reasoning_tokens": 1098 }, "cost_usd": 0.0016371, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.235385Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive is a reputable publisher with editorial standards, and the document cites official records such as National Security Directive 54, but the excerpt is a secondary analytical narrative rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The National Security Archive is a reputable publisher with editorial standards, and the document cites official records such as National Security Directive 54, but the excerpt is a secondary analytical narrative rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraq's WMD programs and the goal of preventing their reconstitution, but it is a 1997 briefing focused on the 1990-91 Gulf War and UNSCOM inspections, not on whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt says Iraq was 'free to attempt to reconstitute' WMD programs after inspections ended, but it does not state that Iraq had actually reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2899, "completion_tokens": 5272, "total_tokens": 8171, "reasoning_tokens": 5015 }, "cost_usd": 0.012187794, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.235579Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The National Security Archive is a reputable publisher with editorial standards, and the document cites official records such as National Security Directive 54, but the excerpt is a secondary analytical narrative rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The National Security Archive is a reputable publisher with editorial standards, and the document cites official records such as National Security Directive 54, but the excerpt is a secondary analytical narrative rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraq's WMD programs and the goal of preventing their reconstitution, but it is a 1997 briefing focused on the 1990-91 Gulf War and UNSCOM inspections, not on whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's WMD programs and UNSCOM inspections through 1998 and general post-2001 policy, but does not address whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 814, "completion_tokens": 431, "total_tokens": 1245, "reasoning_tokens": 391 }, "cost_usd": 0.0007614, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.235579Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source that summarizes cited material but lacks named authorship, peer review, and definitive editorial accountability, making it comparable to ordinary secondary reporting rather than a primary or official record.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source that summarizes cited material but lacks named authorship, peer review, and definitive editorial accountability, making it comparable to ordinary secondary reporting rather than a primary or official record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on allegations that Iraq had mobile biological-weapons production facilities and the subsequent failure to find evidence, which bears exactly on whether Iraq ran an active biological weapons production program around March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports US allegations of Iraqi mobile biological weapons labs (supporting) but also states subsequent investigations found no evidence (contradicting), making the content mixed.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"colin powell un presentation 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2796, "completion_tokens": 3554, "total_tokens": 6350, "reasoning_tokens": 3283 }, "cost_usd": 0.005980476, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.235750Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Reputable security information website that directly summarizes and cites the 2002 National Intelligence Estimate and other official assessments, though it is a secondary compilation without peer review or a named author.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "previous intelligence reports" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable security information website that directly summarizes and cites the 2002 National Intelligence Estimate and other official assessments, though it is a secondary compilation without peer review or a named author.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports prewar intelligence assessments that Iraq possessed chemical weapons stockpiles of 100–500 metric tons, which is exactly the proposition under test.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document relays the 2002 NIE's high-confidence assessment that Iraq possessed 100–500 metric tons of chemical warfare agents and had renewed production, which if believed strongly supports the claim that Iraq held militarily significant chemical stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"previous intelligence reports\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2767, "completion_tokens": 3870, "total_tokens": 6637, "reasoning_tokens": 3841 }, "cost_usd": 0.00925905, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.235875Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "CRS is an official, nonpartisan congressional research service; the report is authored by a named specialist and draws on UN inspection records and official documents, though it is a secondary analytical report rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary record.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CRS is an official, nonpartisan congressional research service; the report is authored by a named specialist and draws on UN inspection records and official documents, though it is a secondary analytical report rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The report examines U.N. inspections for Iraq's WMD programs around March 2003, closely encompassing the specific sub-claim about chemical weapons stockpiles but without explicitly focusing on chemical weapons in the provided excerpt.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports UN inspections found only some evidence of undeclared activities and not enough to convince a majority of the Security Council, but it does not specifically address whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3188, "completion_tokens": 5782, "total_tokens": 8970, "reasoning_tokens": 5537 }, "cost_usd": 0.0112672272, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.236018Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "CRS is an official, nonpartisan congressional research service; the report is authored by a named specialist and draws on UN inspection records and official documents, though it is a secondary analytical report rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary record.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CRS is an official, nonpartisan congressional research service; the report is authored by a named specialist and draws on UN inspection records and official documents, though it is a secondary analytical report rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The report analyzes U.N. inspections for Iraq's WMD programs in the period up to March 2003, which closely addresses whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program, though it focuses on inspections and disarmament rather than directly testing that specific proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports U.N. inspections and some undeclared WMD-related activities but does not address whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3158, "completion_tokens": 2686, "total_tokens": 5844, "reasoning_tokens": 2453 }, "cost_usd": 0.0068600022, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.236131Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a collaborative tertiary source with some citations, but it lacks named authorship, peer review, or strong editorial accountability. It relays findings from other sources rather than presenting primary records, so it fits the mid-range of ordinary secondary sourcing.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "human rights watch" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a collaborative tertiary source with some citations, but it lacks named authorship, peer review, or strong editorial accountability. It relays findings from other sources rather than presenting primary records, so it fits the mid-range of ordinary secondary sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document concerns Iraq's chemical weapons program, not biological weapons, so it provides only tangential background on Iraqi WMD programs without addressing the specific biological weapons claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt exclusively discusses Iraq's chemical weapons program and contains no information about biological weapons stockpiles or production in March 2003, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"united nations\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"human rights watch\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3047, "completion_tokens": 10452, "total_tokens": 13499, "reasoning_tokens": 10269 }, "cost_usd": 0.030160693800000003, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.236251Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary, crowd-edited source with no formal peer review or named author accountability, though it has editorial standards and cites primary documents like the Senate report. It relays and summarizes the findings of the official Senate Select Committee on Intelligence report rather than being a primary record itself.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary, crowd-edited source with no formal peer review or named author accountability, though it has editorial standards and cites primary documents like the Senate report. It relays and summarizes the findings of the official Senate Select Committee on Intelligence report rather than being a primary record itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the Senate report on prewar Iraqi WMD intelligence broadly, but does not specifically address chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses intelligence failures and past WMD disarmament obligations but does not state whether Iraq actually possessed militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence 2004\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2808, "completion_tokens": 1570, "total_tokens": 4378, "reasoning_tokens": 1461 }, "cost_usd": 0.003337515, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.236371Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary, crowd-edited source with no formal peer review or named author accountability, though it has editorial standards and cites primary documents like the Senate report. It relays and summarizes the findings of the official Senate Select Committee on Intelligence report rather than being a primary record itself.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary, crowd-edited source with no formal peer review or named author accountability, though it has editorial standards and cites primary documents like the Senate report. It relays and summarizes the findings of the official Senate Select Committee on Intelligence report rather than being a primary record itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader question of Iraqi WMD intelligence and prewar assessments, but does not specifically mention biological weapons stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses WMD intelligence failures and inspections generally but does not state whether Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence 2004\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2795, "completion_tokens": 1174, "total_tokens": 3969, "reasoning_tokens": 1016 }, "cost_usd": 0.002629321, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.236512Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "FRONTLINE/PBS is a reputable documentary publisher, and the document is a direct interview transcript with Colin Powell, a named primary participant, providing firsthand testimony. It is not peer-reviewed or an official inquiry, but it is a primary-source document with clear editorial provenance.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "frontline pbs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell interview february 2016" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "the secret history of isis documentary" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FRONTLINE/PBS is a reputable documentary publisher, and the document is a direct interview transcript with Colin Powell, a named primary participant, providing firsthand testimony. It is not peer-reviewed or an official inquiry, but it is a primary-source document with clear editorial provenance.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's broader WMD/weapons program being nonexistent after Powell's 2003 U.N. speech, which only partly covers the specific claim about a reconstituted nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The article states that post-war intelligence confirmed Iraq's weapons program 'was nonexistent,' directly contradicting the claim that Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003, though the statement speaks to the WMD program generally rather than nuclear efforts specifically.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"frontline pbs\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"colin powell interview february 2016\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"the secret history of isis documentary\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3264, "completion_tokens": 1471, "total_tokens": 4735, "reasoning_tokens": 1193 }, "cost_usd": 0.0035496446, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.236641Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a UN News archival retrospective that directly quotes and describes the primary Security Council presentation and official proceedings, giving it strong institutional sourcing and access to primary records, though it remains secondary reporting rather than the underlying documents themselves.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council meeting february 5 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a UN News archival retrospective that directly quotes and describes the primary Security Council presentation and official proceedings, giving it strong institutional sourcing and access to primary records, though it remains secondary reporting rather than the underlying documents themselves.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader March 2003 WMD claims against Iraq, but focuses on biological agents rather than the specific nuclear-weapons-reconstitution proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt recounts Powell's 2003 allegations about Iraqi WMDs, focused on biological agents (anthrax, mobile bio-production labs) rather than any nuclear weapons program, so it does not directly address whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council meeting february 5 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2970, "completion_tokens": 4517, "total_tokens": 7487, "reasoning_tokens": 4302 }, "cost_usd": 0.0075003857999999994, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.236780Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable, editorially reviewed fact-checking outlet, and the article relies on the official Iraq Survey Group final report, a named primary source. However, it is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or the primary document itself.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable, editorially reviewed fact-checking outlet, and the article relies on the official Iraq Survey Group final report, a named primary source. However, it is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or the primary document itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document's core question and answer directly address whether Iraq had chemical, biological and nuclear weapon stockpiles at the time of the March 2003 invasion, reporting the Iraq Survey Group's finding that all such stockpiles had been destroyed.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The article relays the Iraq Survey Group's post-invasion inspection findings that Iraq had abandoned its chemical weapons program and destroyed all existing stockpiles, which directly contradicts the claim that militarily significant chemical stockpiles existed in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3040, "completion_tokens": 1223, "total_tokens": 4263, "reasoning_tokens": 979 }, "cost_usd": 0.0049505796, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.236920Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable, editorially reviewed fact-checking outlet, and the article relies on the official Iraq Survey Group final report, a named primary source. However, it is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or the primary document itself.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable, editorially reviewed fact-checking outlet, and the article relies on the official Iraq Survey Group final report, a named primary source. However, it is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or the primary document itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document's core question and answer directly address whether Iraq had chemical, biological and nuclear weapon stockpiles at the time of the March 2003 invasion, reporting the Iraq Survey Group's finding that all such stockpiles had been destroyed.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that the Iraq Survey Group determined Iraq had destroyed all existing chemical and biological weapons stockpiles and had no WMDs when the U.S. invaded in 2003, directly supporting the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 850, "completion_tokens": 619, "total_tokens": 1469, "reasoning_tokens": 611 }, "cost_usd": 0.0009978, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.236920Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable, editorially reviewed fact-checking outlet, and the article relies on the official Iraq Survey Group final report, a named primary source. However, it is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or the primary document itself.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable, editorially reviewed fact-checking outlet, and the article relies on the official Iraq Survey Group final report, a named primary source. However, it is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or the primary document itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports the Iraq Survey Group's finding that Iraq had abandoned its biological weapons program and destroyed its biological stockpiles, which is exactly the proposition under test.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that the Iraq Survey Group determined Iraq had abandoned its biological weapons program and destroyed all existing biological stockpiles, directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3026, "completion_tokens": 1391, "total_tokens": 4417, "reasoning_tokens": 1178 }, "cost_usd": 0.005119521, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.237098Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable, editorially reviewed fact-checking outlet, and the article relies on the official Iraq Survey Group final report, a named primary source. However, it is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or the primary document itself.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable, editorially reviewed fact-checking outlet, and the article relies on the official Iraq Survey Group final report, a named primary source. However, it is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or the primary document itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly reports the Iraq Survey Group's finding that Iraq had abandoned its nuclear weapons development quest by the time of the 2003 invasion, directly addressing the status of Iraq's nuclear program at that time.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.85, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Iraq Survey Group's own investigation concluded Iraq had abandoned its quest to develop nuclear, chemical and biological weapons, directly contradicting the claim that a nuclear program had been reconstituted by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3012, "completion_tokens": 2338, "total_tokens": 5350, "reasoning_tokens": 2110 }, "cost_usd": 0.0065364246, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.237209Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The article is a secondary news report from a reputable arms-control organization, but it relies on named official sources such as Brig. Gen. Kimmitt, Donald Rumsfeld, and UNMOVIC records rather than original primary research. It is not peer-reviewed or a primary document, but its sourcing and publisher track record make it reasonably reliable evidence.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "kimmitt press briefing may 17 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "rumsfeld heritage foundation may 17 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The article is a secondary news report from a reputable arms-control organization, but it relies on named official sources such as Brig. Gen. Kimmitt, Donald Rumsfeld, and UNMOVIC records rather than original primary research. It is not peer-reviewed or a primary document, but its sourcing and publisher track record make it reasonably reliable evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports a single sarin-filled munition and UNMOVIC accounting discrepancies, which relates to Iraq's chemical weapons existence but not directly to whether Iraq held militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports a single sarin-filled artillery round found in Iraq but describes it as virtually ineffective and the first such find, while also noting UNMOVIC accounting discrepancies, so it neither confirms nor denies militarily significant stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"kimmitt press briefing may 17 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"rumsfeld heritage foundation may 17 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic march 2003 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2860, "completion_tokens": 8641, "total_tokens": 11501, "reasoning_tokens": 8327 }, "cost_usd": 0.012092820288, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.237330Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary compilation by the Arms Control Association, a reputable arms-control NGO with editorial standards, but it is not peer-reviewed or a primary official document. It draws on named UNMOVIC/IAEA reports and inspection data, making it credible reporting with identifiable official sources.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq declaration december 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary compilation by the Arms Control Association, a reputable arms-control NGO with editorial standards, but it is not peer-reviewed or a primary official document. It draws on named UNMOVIC/IAEA reports and inspection data, making it credible reporting with identifiable official sources.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses UN inspections of Iraq's chemical weapons programs and unresolved disarmament issues, but it does not report on whether Iraq actually held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document notes unresolved chemical-weapons disarmament issues and inadequate Iraqi declarations, but it does not report direct discovery or confirmed existence of militarily significant chemical stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq declaration december 2002\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2938, "completion_tokens": 9332, "total_tokens": 12270, "reasoning_tokens": 9074 }, "cost_usd": 0.033605676, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.237457Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "The source is an advocacy/documentary website presenting a 'claims vs. facts' narrative rather than an established news or scholarly outlet, with indirect or absent citations to intelligence findings. It lacks peer review, editorial standards, or primary documentation.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "bush administration" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "curveball" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "defense intelligence agency" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an advocacy/documentary website presenting a 'claims vs. facts' narrative rather than an established news or scholarly outlet, with indirect or absent citations to intelligence findings. It lacks peer review, editorial standards, or primary documentation.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether Iraq had mobile biological weapons labs, a specific component of the broader biological weapons stockpile/production claim, but does not cover the full proposition of stockpiles or an active production program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that no mobile biological weapons labs were found and that the trailers found after the invasion were not bioweapons labs, directly contradicting a specific alleged biological weapons production program, though it does not address all possible stockpiles or programs.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush administration\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi defector curveball\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"defense intelligence agency\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2864, "completion_tokens": 1731, "total_tokens": 4595, "reasoning_tokens": 1435 }, "cost_usd": 0.003715296, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.237598Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.1, "quality_rationale": "Grokipedia is an AI-generated encyclopedia with no named authors, editorial oversight, or peer review, and its citations are not independently verifiable. It is therefore unreliable as evidence on Iraq's WMD programs, regardless of the accuracy of its summary.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.1, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Grokipedia is an AI-generated encyclopedia with no named authors, editorial oversight, or peer review, and its citations are not independently verifiable. It is therefore unreliable as evidence on Iraq's WMD programs, regardless of the accuracy of its summary.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports post-invasion findings that Iraq had no operational WMD stockpiles and had destroyed its known chemical stockpiles by 1991, which precisely addresses whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that post-invasion inspections and the Duelfer Report found no operational chemical weapons stockpiles and that Iraq had destroyed its known WMD stockpiles by 1991, directly contradicting the claim that Iraq held militarily significant chemical stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2833, "completion_tokens": 1294, "total_tokens": 4127, "reasoning_tokens": 1012 }, "cost_usd": 0.002784715, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.237727Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "This is a partisan political press release from a congresswoman's office, not independent reporting or an official inquiry; it selectively quotes primary sources but offers no methodology or balanced sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cheney meet the press 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush state of the union 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a partisan political press release from a congresswoman's office, not independent reporting or an official inquiry; it selectively quotes primary sources but offers no methodology or balanced sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's biological weapons as part of a broader critique of Bush administration WMD claims, including a direct quote asserting Iraq had biological weapons and could produce more, but it does not specifically test or report on the March 2003 stockpile/production proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document quotes David Kay's inspection-based conclusion that no large WMD stockpiles or production plants were found, directly undermining the claim of biological stockpiles or active production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay new york times interview 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cheney meet the press 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"powell un security council 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush state of the union 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3510, "completion_tokens": 6182, "total_tokens": 9692, "reasoning_tokens": 6000 }, "cost_usd": 0.013806261, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.237896Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.4, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source with no formal peer review, named authorship, or editorial accountability; it cites sources but is not authoritative for historical evidence.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "riegle report 1994" }, { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source with no formal peer review, named authorship, or editorial accountability; it cites sources but is not authoritative for historical evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly states that Iraq's biological weapons program no longer existed when the Bush administration cited it as justification for the 2003 invasion, directly addressing whether Iraq had such weapons or an active program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt states the BW program no longer existed by the 2003 invasion, contradicting an active production program, though it does not explicitly address retained stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"riegle report 1994\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2980, "completion_tokens": 9363, "total_tokens": 12343, "reasoning_tokens": 9143 }, "cost_usd": 0.032883636, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.238080Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary chronology from a reputable arms-control NGO with editorial standards and named contact, drawing on official UN resolutions, IAEA/UNMOVIC inspections, and public statements. It is neither peer-reviewed nor a primary record itself, so it falls below an official inquiry or primary document.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary chronology from a reputable arms-control NGO with editorial standards and named contact, drawing on official UN resolutions, IAEA/UNMOVIC inspections, and public statements. It is neither peer-reviewed nor a primary record itself, so it falls below an official inquiry or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports UN inspectors' finding that Iraq did not possess chemical or biological weapons in the period immediately before March 2003, which is exactly the proposition under test.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that UN inspectors conducted over 900 inspections and did not find that Iraq possessed chemical or biological weapons, directly contradicting the claim of militarily significant chemical stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush state of the union 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2911, "completion_tokens": 1841, "total_tokens": 4752, "reasoning_tokens": 1611 }, "cost_usd": 0.0038880246, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.238201Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary chronology from a reputable arms-control NGO with editorial standards and named contact, drawing on official UN resolutions, IAEA/UNMOVIC inspections, and public statements. It is neither peer-reviewed nor a primary record itself, so it falls below an official inquiry or primary document.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary chronology from a reputable arms-control NGO with editorial standards and named contact, drawing on official UN resolutions, IAEA/UNMOVIC inspections, and public statements. It is neither peer-reviewed nor a primary record itself, so it falls below an official inquiry or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly states that UN inspectors did not find that Iraq possessed biological weapons during inspections from November 2002 until March 2003, which explicitly addresses the sub-claim about Iraqi biological weapons stockpiles or production at that time.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that UN inspectors in Iraq from November 2002 to March 2003 did not find that Iraq possessed chemical or biological weapons, which directly contradicts the sub-claim that Iraq held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active biological weapons production program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush state of the union 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2919, "completion_tokens": 1328, "total_tokens": 4247, "reasoning_tokens": 1026 }, "cost_usd": 0.003300166, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.238323Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "UN News is a reputable official outlet reporting direct, named statements from Hans Blix, the head of UNMOVIC, in a contemporaneous press encounter; however, it is a news report relaying his remarks rather than the underlying inspection report, transcript, or official inquiry record.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"UN News is a reputable official outlet reporting direct, named statements from Hans Blix, the head of UNMOVIC, in a contemporaneous press encounter; however, it is a news report relaying his remarks rather than the underlying inspection report, transcript, or official inquiry record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses whether Iraq used banned weapons such as missiles and chemical/biological agents, but it does not address Iraq's nuclear weapons program or its reconstitution.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses missile ranges and chemical or biological weapons but does not address Iraq's nuclear weapons program, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un news\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2482, "completion_tokens": 4714, "total_tokens": 7196, "reasoning_tokens": 4557 }, "cost_usd": 0.016112529599999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.238449Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "It is an unsigned secondary webpage from a photo-collection site with no citations to primary documents or official records, relaying a familiar narrative with little sourcing.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "curveball" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "german intelligence" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"It is an unsigned secondary webpage from a photo-collection site with no citations to primary documents or official records, relaying a familiar narrative with little sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly concerns the alleged Iraqi mobile biological weapons production facilities, which is exactly the active biological weapons production program element of the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document characterizes the mobile biological weapons facilities as 'supposed' and based on Curveball's discredited testimony, undermining the claim that Iraq had an active biological weapons production program in March 2003, though it does not directly address stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"curveball\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"german intelligence\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cia\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"powell un speech 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2767, "completion_tokens": 4281, "total_tokens": 7048, "reasoning_tokens": 4185 }, "cost_usd": 0.012639455999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.238582Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official United Nations Security Council document (S/2006/420) transmitting a UNMOVIC compendium, making it a primary official record with direct institutional sourcing and no evident conflicts of interest. It is authoritative on Iraq's proscribed weapons programmes, though it is a summary compendium rather than the complete underlying raw record.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official United Nations Security Council document (S/2006/420) transmitting a UNMOVIC compendium, making it a primary official record with direct institutional sourcing and no evident conflicts of interest. It is authoritative on Iraq's proscribed weapons programmes, though it is a summary compendium rather than the complete underlying raw record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a UNMOVIC compendium summary covering Iraq's chemical, biological, and missile proscribed programmes, so it closely addresses the biological weapons question but is broader than the specific March 2003 stockpile/production claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only describes post-1991 destruction of Iraq's declared WMD programmes and does not address whether Iraq had biological weapons stockpiles or active biological weapons production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3147, "completion_tokens": 4697, "total_tokens": 7844, "reasoning_tokens": 4452 }, "cost_usd": 0.010512799199999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.238696Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a verbatim primary transcript of an official U.S. government address to the UN Security Council, published on the official White House archive site, making it a definitive primary record of the administration's claims and cited intelligence. Its high fidelity as a document is not diminished by the fact that the underlying intelligence assertions were later largely discredited, which concerns the conclusion rather than the source.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a verbatim primary transcript of an official U.S. government address to the UN Security Council, published on the official White House archive site, making it a definitive primary record of the administration's claims and cited intelligence. Its high fidelity as a document is not diminished by the fact that the underlying intelligence assertions were later largely discredited, which concerns the conclusion rather than the source.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq's general WMD disarmament obligations and inspections, a broader question that only partly covers the specific claim about biological weapons stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only discusses Iraq's general WMD disarmament obligations and concealment, without mentioning biological weapons stockpiles or production.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us state department 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3021, "completion_tokens": 2327, "total_tokens": 5348, "reasoning_tokens": 2053 }, "cost_usd": 0.004345416, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.238816Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a verbatim primary transcript of an official U.S. government address to the UN Security Council, published on the official White House archive site, making it a definitive primary record of the administration's claims and cited intelligence. Its high fidelity as a document is not diminished by the fact that the underlying intelligence assertions were later largely discredited, which concerns the conclusion rather than the source.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a verbatim primary transcript of an official U.S. government address to the UN Security Council, published on the official White House archive site, making it a definitive primary record of the administration's claims and cited intelligence. Its high fidelity as a document is not diminished by the fact that the underlying intelligence assertions were later largely discredited, which concerns the conclusion rather than the source.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Powell's UN address on Iraq's disarmament obligations under Resolution 1441 addresses the broader question of Iraq's WMD programs and compliance, which closely relates to but does not directly test the specific proposition that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt is Powell's opening framing of Iraq's general WMD disarmament obligations under Resolution 1441 and makes no claim at all about a reconstituted nuclear weapons program, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us state department 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3005, "completion_tokens": 926, "total_tokens": 3931, "reasoning_tokens": 616 }, "cost_usd": 0.0027543396, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.238966Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a report from the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, a reputable policy research institution, that explicitly examines the unclassified prewar intelligence record and administration statements, giving it strong sourcing and editorial credibility. However, it is a policy-study synthesis rather than a peer-reviewed study or official inquiry, and the excerpt itself is partly a secondary summary of the Carnegie report.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, { "type": "study", "id": "wmd in iraq evidence and implications" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a report from the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, a reputable policy research institution, that explicitly examines the unclassified prewar intelligence record and administration statements, giving it strong sourcing and editorial credibility. However, it is a policy-study synthesis rather than a peer-reviewed study or official inquiry, and the excerpt itself is partly a secondary summary of the Carnegie report.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The report examines Iraq's WMD programs and evidence found, including chemical weapons, but addresses the specific claim of militarily significant chemical stockpiles in March 2003 only as part of a broader WMD assessment.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt indicates the administration downgraded its claims from actual weapons and massive stockpiles of agent to programs and capabilities, implying that militarily significant chemical stockpiles were not found, though it does not directly present inspection findings.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"carnegie endowment for international peace\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wmd in iraq evidence and implications\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2862, "completion_tokens": 3107, "total_tokens": 5969, "reasoning_tokens": 2824 }, "cost_usd": 0.0054862949999999995, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.239078Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Reputable, named-author policy analysis from the Carnegie Endowment that directly compares official CIA National Intelligence Estimate documents, giving it strong sourcing; however, it is a think-tank analysis rather than a peer-reviewed study or official inquiry.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.25, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable, named-author policy analysis from the Carnegie Endowment that directly compares official CIA National Intelligence Estimate documents, giving it strong sourcing; however, it is a think-tank analysis rather than a peer-reviewed study or official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader controversy over Iraq's WMD programs and intelligence estimates, but it does not specifically examine whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.25, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document argues the intelligence community overstated Iraq's weapons threat and notes WMD were not found, indirectly suggesting Iraq had not reconstituted nuclear weapons, but it never directly examines the nuclear program itself.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"carnegie endowment for international peace\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia white paper iraqs weapons of mass destruction\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2970, "completion_tokens": 1348, "total_tokens": 4318, "reasoning_tokens": 1079 }, "cost_usd": 0.0031220946, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.239205Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.0, "quality_rationale": "The document is an official CIA FOIA library page, but its content concerns Nixon's 1972 China trip and contains nothing about Iraq's weapons programmes or stockpiles in 2002-2004, so it has no evidentiary value on the specified topic.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an official CIA FOIA library page, but its content concerns Nixon's 1972 China trip and contains nothing about Iraq's weapons programmes or stockpiles in 2002-2004, so it has no evidentiary value on the specified topic.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a CIA FOIA reading room page about Nixon's 1972 trip to China and contains no information about Iraq or chemical weapons in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a CIA FOIA reading room page about Nixon's 1972 China trip and contains no content addressing Iraq or chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3138, "completion_tokens": 1895, "total_tokens": 5033, "reasoning_tokens": 1773 }, "cost_usd": 0.004963701, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.239317Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.0, "quality_rationale": "The document is an official CIA FOIA library page, but its content concerns Nixon's 1972 China trip and contains nothing about Iraq's weapons programmes or stockpiles in 2002-2004, so it has no evidentiary value on the specified topic.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an official CIA FOIA library page, but its content concerns Nixon's 1972 China trip and contains nothing about Iraq's weapons programmes or stockpiles in 2002-2004, so it has no evidentiary value on the specified topic.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a CIA FOIA reading room page describing a collection about Nixon's 1972 China trip, with no mention of Iraq, its nuclear program, or March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a CIA FOIA reading room page about Nixon's 1972 China trip and contains no content whatsoever about Iraq or its nuclear program, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3134, "completion_tokens": 1951, "total_tokens": 5085, "reasoning_tokens": 1822 }, "cost_usd": 0.0048604356, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.239419Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "GlobalSecurity.org is a widely used security reference that here relays and quotes the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate, a named official primary source, but the page itself is a secondary compilation without peer review or explicit authorship.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"GlobalSecurity.org is a widely used security reference that here relays and quotes the October 2002 National Intelligence Estimate, a named official primary source, but the page itself is a secondary compilation without peer review or explicit authorship.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a 2003 prewar assessment explicitly reporting that Iraq's offensive BW program was active and that Baghdad had biological weapons, which is exactly the proposition under test.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt relays the October 2002 NIE's assessment that Iraq had biological weapons and an active offensive BW program, which supports the sub-claim but is an intelligence assertion rather than direct observation and predates March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2982, "completion_tokens": 2842, "total_tokens": 5824, "reasoning_tokens": 2633 }, "cost_usd": 0.0064918014, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.239554Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official UN Security Council document transmitting UNMOVIC's quarterly report, a primary source with named institutional authorship and no apparent conflicts of interest.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official UN Security Council document transmitting UNMOVIC's quarterly report, a primary source with named institutional authorship and no apparent conflicts of interest.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a UNMOVIC quarterly report on inspections and unresolved disarmament issues in Iraq just before March 2003, closely addressing the status of Iraq's prohibited weapons programs including chemical weapons, though the excerpt does not explicitly mention chemical stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only describes UNMOVIC's inspection activities and briefings, with no content on whether Iraq held chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3147, "completion_tokens": 2056, "total_tokens": 5203, "reasoning_tokens": 1922 }, "cost_usd": 0.006203675, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.239686Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The excerpt is from the Iraq Survey Group Final Report, an official government inquiry based on primary investigative access and documentation, though it is hosted by the secondary aggregator globalsecurity.org rather than the original publisher.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt is from the Iraq Survey Group Final Report, an official government inquiry based on primary investigative access and documentation, though it is hosted by the secondary aggregator globalsecurity.org rather than the original publisher.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly states that Iraq did not reconstitute a nuclear weapons capability after 1991, directly addressing the exact proposition of whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The ISG Final Report directly states that Iraq did not reconstitute a nuclear weapons capability after 1991, contradicting the sub-claim that it had done so by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2866, "completion_tokens": 718, "total_tokens": 3584, "reasoning_tokens": 532 }, "cost_usd": 0.0020374996, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.239803Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official UN Security Council record of a primary statement by UNMOVIC Executive Chairman Hans Blix, providing direct evidence on inspections and Iraqi weapons programmes. It is a primary document from a authoritative source, though it is an oral introduction rather than the full underlying report.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official UN Security Council record of a primary statement by UNMOVIC Executive Chairman Hans Blix, providing direct evidence on inspections and Iraqi weapons programmes. It is a primary document from a authoritative source, though it is an oral introduction rather than the full underlying report.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses UNMOVIC inspection logistics and access in March 2003 but does not mention chemical weapons or stockpiles, making it only tangential background to the specific claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only covers inspection logistics and surveillance, with no mention of chemical weapons stockpiles, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic 12th quarterly report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2996, "completion_tokens": 4341, "total_tokens": 7337, "reasoning_tokens": 4176 }, "cost_usd": 0.0080173932, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.239940Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "It is a named expert analysis published by a reputable arms-control organization, drawing directly on official IAEA/UNMOVIC reports and statements, but it is a secondary advocacy-oriented article rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea march 2003 report" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"It is a named expert analysis published by a reputable arms-control organization, drawing directly on official IAEA/UNMOVIC reports and statements, but it is a secondary advocacy-oriented article rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports the IAEA's March 2003 finding on whether Iraq had revived its nuclear weapons program, which is exactly the proposition under test.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The IAEA's inspection results, based on over a hundred suspect-site visits and interviews with former WMD scientists, reported 'no evidence or plausible indication of the revival of a nuclear weapons programme in Iraq,' directly contradicting the claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea march 2003 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic march 2003 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"bush administration statements\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3010, "completion_tokens": 4701, "total_tokens": 7711, "reasoning_tokens": 4918 }, "cost_usd": 0.0173183446, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.240089Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a verbatim transcript of an official U.S. government presentation to the UN Security Council, making it a primary document of a key official record, though it is advocacy by a partisan actor rather than an independent or peer-reviewed assessment.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi defectors" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a verbatim transcript of an official U.S. government presentation to the UN Security Council, making it a primary document of a key official record, though it is advocacy by a partisan actor rather than an independent or peer-reviewed assessment.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is the nuclear-weapons section of Powell's February 2003 U.N. presentation explicitly arguing that Iraq was reconstituting its nuclear program, directly addressing the exact proposition about Iraq's nuclear program status as of March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Powell's presentation asserts that since 1998 Iraq's efforts to reconstitute its nuclear program have focused on acquiring fissile material, directly supporting the claim that reconstitution was underway, though it describes an ongoing effort rather than a completed program.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n\\\"roots\\\": [\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us intelligence community\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi defectors\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cnn\\\"}\\n]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2953, "completion_tokens": 2918, "total_tokens": 5871, "reasoning_tokens": 2646 }, "cost_usd": 0.0101636046, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.240212Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is ordinary journalism relaying David Kay's statements and the CIA/ISG findings without independent primary sourcing or peer review. It reports on official claims but is a secondary news account rather than a primary document or inquiry report.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate armed services committee 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is ordinary journalism relaying David Kay's statements and the CIA/ISG findings without independent primary sourcing or peer review. It reports on official claims but is a secondary news account rather than a primary document or inquiry report.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports David Kay's assessment that the post-invasion search would not find significant chemical or biological weapons stockpiles in Iraq, which speaks exactly to whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports David Kay stating he did not expect the search to find significant chemical or biological weapons stockpiles and that Iraq had destroyed its pre-1991 prohibited weapons without resuming large-scale production, which directly contradicts the claim that Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay statements 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia announcement january 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate armed services committee hearing 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2817, "completion_tokens": 831, "total_tokens": 3648, "reasoning_tokens": 566 }, "cost_usd": 0.0025958762, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.240330Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Reputable think-tank commentary by a named expert, but it is a secondary analysis/opinion piece relying on public statements and news editorials rather than peer-reviewed research or primary records.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jordan times editorial 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable think-tank commentary by a named expert, but it is a secondary analysis/opinion piece relying on public statements and news editorials rather than peer-reviewed research or primary records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraq's broader failure to comply with UN disarmament orders and the imminence of the WMD threat, but it does not specifically mention biological weapons stockpiles or an active biological weapons production program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Powell's UN presentation on Iraqi deception and lack of imminent threat but does not specifically address biological weapons stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un security council presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"jordan times editorial 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3010, "completion_tokens": 4945, "total_tokens": 7955, "reasoning_tokens": 4732 }, "cost_usd": 0.009634991568, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.240462Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Reputable think-tank commentary by a named expert, but it is a secondary analysis/opinion piece relying on public statements and news editorials rather than peer-reviewed research or primary records.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jordan times editorial 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable think-tank commentary by a named expert, but it is a secondary analysis/opinion piece relying on public statements and news editorials rather than peer-reviewed research or primary records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader question of Iraq's WMD disarmament compliance and the perceived threat in early 2003, but it does not specifically report on whether Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses Iraqi noncompliance and lack of imminent threat but does not address whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un security council presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"jordan times editorial 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3018, "completion_tokens": 4925, "total_tokens": 7943, "reasoning_tokens": 4706 }, "cost_usd": 0.009724440168, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.240592Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "CNN is a reputable mainstream outlet reporting on an official CIA/Iraq Survey Group report, with named author Charles Duelfer and Senate testimony, but it is secondary journalism relaying primary official findings rather than the primary document or a peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CNN is a reputable mainstream outlet reporting on an official CIA/Iraq Survey Group report, with named author Charles Duelfer and Senate testimony, but it is secondary journalism relaying primary official findings rather than the primary document or a peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports the CIA/Duelfer finding that Iraq did not possess WMD stockpiles at the time of the March 2003 invasion, which is exactly the proposition under test.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The CIA/Duelfer report concludes Iraq did not possess illicit weapons stockpiles at the time of the March 2003 invasion and that its WMD program was essentially destroyed in 1991, directly contradicting the claim of militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfel\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3010, "completion_tokens": 861, "total_tokens": 3871, "reasoning_tokens": 584 }, "cost_usd": 0.002448711, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.240707Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "CNN is a reputable mainstream outlet reporting on an official CIA/Iraq Survey Group report, with named author Charles Duelfer and Senate testimony, but it is secondary journalism relaying primary official findings rather than the primary document or a peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CNN is a reputable mainstream outlet reporting on an official CIA/Iraq Survey Group report, with named author Charles Duelfer and Senate testimony, but it is secondary journalism relaying primary official findings rather than the primary document or a peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports the CIA/Duelfer conclusion that Iraq had no WMD stockpiles and no production program at the time of the March 2003 invasion, which directly encompasses the biological weapons sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports the CIA/Duelfer Iraq Survey Group conclusion that Iraq did not possess illicit weapons stockpiles at the time of the March 2003 invasion and had not begun any program to produce them, directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfel\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3000, "completion_tokens": 1984, "total_tokens": 4984, "reasoning_tokens": 1841 }, "cost_usd": 0.003687252, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.240835Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Reputable arms-control NGO chronology that draws on official records, IAEA findings, and named sources, but it is a secondary advocacy-oriented compilation rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "arms control association" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable arms-control NGO chronology that draws on official records, IAEA findings, and named sources, but it is a secondary advocacy-oriented compilation rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly discusses the Bush administration's claim that Iraq was reconstituting its nuclear weapons program by March 2003 and notes IAEA inspectors found no evidence of such reconstitution.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that IAEA inspectors on the ground in Iraq found no evidence Baghdad had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program, and that U.S. intelligence assessments cast doubt on the claim, directly undercutting the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"arms control association\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush administration\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2835, "completion_tokens": 701, "total_tokens": 3536, "reasoning_tokens": 470 }, "cost_usd": 0.0023623559695, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.240971Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a reputable, editorially reviewed arms-control publication reporting on official investigations and citing named primary sources such as the White House press secretary, the Duelfer report, and UN inspectors. It is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document, so it merits 0.7.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a reputable, editorially reviewed arms-control publication reporting on official investigations and citing named primary sources such as the White House press secretary, the Duelfer report, and UN inspectors. It is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document, so it merits 0.7.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on the failure to find significant Iraqi WMD stockpiles after the March 2003 invasion, specifically including chemical weapons stockpiles, which exactly bears on whether Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles at that time.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that the Iraq Survey Group's interim report concluded Iraq had no WMD stockpiles and that UN inspectors found no evidence of such stockpiles, directly contradicting the claim that Iraq held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2898, "completion_tokens": 1119, "total_tokens": 4017, "reasoning_tokens": 820 }, "cost_usd": 0.002950501, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.241089Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a reputable, editorially reviewed arms-control publication reporting on official investigations and citing named primary sources such as the White House press secretary, the Duelfer report, and UN inspectors. It is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document, so it merits 0.7.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a reputable, editorially reviewed arms-control publication reporting on official investigations and citing named primary sources such as the White House press secretary, the Duelfer report, and UN inspectors. It is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document, so it merits 0.7.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports on the Iraq Survey Group's conclusion that Iraq had no WMD stockpiles and mentions biological weapons among the pre-war claims and unaccounted materials, but it addresses the biological weapons sub-claim only as part of the broader WMD investigation rather than specifically testing biological stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that the Iraq Survey Group's interim report said Iraq had no WMD stockpiles and that UN inspectors found no evidence Iraq had WMD stockpiles or had reconstituted related programs, directly contradicting the claim of biological weapons stockpiles or active production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2863, "completion_tokens": 1663, "total_tokens": 4526, "reasoning_tokens": 1429 }, "cost_usd": 0.003439102, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.241223Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a reputable, editorially reviewed arms-control publication reporting on official investigations and citing named primary sources such as the White House press secretary, the Duelfer report, and UN inspectors. It is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document, so it merits 0.7.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a reputable, editorially reviewed arms-control publication reporting on official investigations and citing named primary sources such as the White House press secretary, the Duelfer report, and UN inspectors. It is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document, so it merits 0.7.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses pre-invasion claims about Iraq's nuclear program and UN inspectors' findings on reconstituted WMD-related programs, but frames this within the broader WMD hunt rather than focusing specifically on nuclear reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that UN weapons inspectors found no evidence Iraq had reconstituted its related WMD programs prior to the March 2003 invasion, directly contradicting the claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2871, "completion_tokens": 2015, "total_tokens": 4886, "reasoning_tokens": 1739 }, "cost_usd": 0.003906931, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.241378Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a reputable, editorially reviewed arms-control publication reporting on official investigations and citing named primary sources such as the White House press secretary, the Duelfer report, and UN inspectors. It is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document, so it merits 0.7.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a reputable, editorially reviewed arms-control publication reporting on official investigations and citing named primary sources such as the White House press secretary, the Duelfer report, and UN inspectors. It is secondary reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document, so it merits 0.7.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses pre-invasion claims about Iraq's nuclear program and UN inspectors' findings on reconstituted WMD-related programs, but frames this within the broader WMD hunt rather than focusing specifically on nuclear reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that the ISG's September 2004 interim report found Iraq had no WMD stockpiles and that UN inspectors found no evidence Iraq had reconstituted its related programs, which supports the sub-claim, though the nuclear program specifically is only indirectly addressed.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 826, "completion_tokens": 83, "total_tokens": 909, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00020844, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.241378Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a declassified government exhibit (Office of the Vice President memo with attached CIA paper) submitted in legal proceedings, making it a primary official document with identifiable provenance and Bates numbers. It is a contemporaneous government record rather than peer-reviewed analysis, but its status as an official primary document places it near the top of the scale.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "new yorker article sy hersh" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "british white paper september 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a declassified government exhibit (Office of the Vice President memo with attached CIA paper) submitted in legal proceedings, making it a primary official document with identifiable provenance and Bates numbers. It is a contemporaneous government record rather than peer-reviewed analysis, but its status as an official primary document places it near the top of the scale.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the Iraq-Niger uranium allegation and related WMD intelligence disputes, which are adjacent to but do not directly test the specific claim that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document concerns only the credibility of alleged Iraq-Niger uranium procurement reporting (CIA skepticism about a foreign service report, disputed British claims), not whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program, so it neither directly supports nor contradicts that broader sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia paper april 3 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"new yorker article sy hersh\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"british white paper september 2002\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3417, "completion_tokens": 1245, "total_tokens": 4662, "reasoning_tokens": 909 }, "cost_usd": 0.0036693402112500002, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.241565Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia encyclopedia article, a tertiary/secondary source with no author, no peer review, and several unsourced or citation-needed passages, though it does cite UN Security Council resolutions and other references. It relays official findings rather than constituting a primary record, placing it at the level of ordinary secondary reporting.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia encyclopedia article, a tertiary/secondary source with no author, no peer review, and several unsourced or citation-needed passages, though it does cite UN Security Council resolutions and other references. It relays official findings rather than constituting a primary record, placing it at the level of ordinary secondary reporting.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes UNMOVIC's creation and inspection mandate regarding Iraq's WMD disarmament, which is an adjacent question to whether Iraq actually held militarily significant chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003, but it does not directly test or report on that specific proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes UNMOVIC's mandate and inspection history but provides no direct evidence about actual Iraqi chemical weapon stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3072, "completion_tokens": 2358, "total_tokens": 5430, "reasoning_tokens": 2087 }, "cost_usd": 0.0080094072, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.241733Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia encyclopedia article, a tertiary/secondary source with no author, no peer review, and several unsourced or citation-needed passages, though it does cite UN Security Council resolutions and other references. It relays official findings rather than constituting a primary record, placing it at the level of ordinary secondary reporting.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia encyclopedia article, a tertiary/secondary source with no author, no peer review, and several unsourced or citation-needed passages, though it does cite UN Security Council resolutions and other references. It relays official findings rather than constituting a primary record, placing it at the level of ordinary secondary reporting.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses UNMOVIC's broader mandate to disarm Iraq of WMDs and inspection history, but does not specifically report on biological weapons stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses UNMOVIC's mandate and inspection history regarding Iraq's WMDs generally, but never mentions biological weapons stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3037, "completion_tokens": 2429, "total_tokens": 5466, "reasoning_tokens": 2169 }, "cost_usd": 0.0078841632, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.241863Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia encyclopedia article, a tertiary/secondary source with no author, no peer review, and several unsourced or citation-needed passages, though it does cite UN Security Council resolutions and other references. It relays official findings rather than constituting a primary record, placing it at the level of ordinary secondary reporting.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia encyclopedia article, a tertiary/secondary source with no author, no peer review, and several unsourced or citation-needed passages, though it does cite UN Security Council resolutions and other references. It relays official findings rather than constituting a primary record, placing it at the level of ordinary secondary reporting.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses UNMOVIC's broader mandate to disarm Iraq of WMDs and inspection history, but does not specifically report on biological weapons stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document only describes UNMOVIC's creation, mandate, and inspection history regarding Iraq's WMD disarmament, making no factual observation about whether Iraq actually held biological weapons stockpiles or ran an active BW program in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 856, "completion_tokens": 352, "total_tokens": 1208, "reasoning_tokens": 276 }, "cost_usd": 0.00064524, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.241863Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia encyclopedia article, a tertiary/secondary source that summarizes and cites primary documents and news reports but has no independent peer review or editorial accountability comparable to an official inquiry. It is ordinary, generally sourced journalism-style compilation rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "office of the vice president" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia encyclopedia article, a tertiary/secondary source that summarizes and cites primary documents and news reports but has no independent peer review or editorial accountability comparable to an official inquiry. It is ordinary, generally sourced journalism-style compilation rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports Powell's 2003 UN claims about Iraq's WMD and chemical weapons and inspections, but does not specifically address whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses Powell's assertions about chemical and other WMD and later doubts about the underlying intelligence but never mentions nuclear weapons or a reconstituted nuclear program, so it neither supports nor contradicts the nuclear-specific sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of state february 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"office of the vice president\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2938, "completion_tokens": 2174, "total_tokens": 5112, "reasoning_tokens": 1905 }, "cost_usd": 0.0038121796, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.242030Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia encyclopedia article, a tertiary/secondary source that summarizes and cites primary documents and news reports but has no independent peer review or editorial accountability comparable to an official inquiry. It is ordinary, generally sourced journalism-style compilation rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "office of the vice president" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia encyclopedia article, a tertiary/secondary source that summarizes and cites primary documents and news reports but has no independent peer review or editorial accountability comparable to an official inquiry. It is ordinary, generally sourced journalism-style compilation rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports Powell's 2003 UN claims about Iraq's WMD and chemical weapons and inspections, but does not specifically address whether Iraq had reconstituted a nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses Powell's claims about chemical and other WMD and later doubts about the intelligence, but it does not mention Iraq's nuclear weapons program, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of state february 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"office of the vice president\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 850, "completion_tokens": 560, "total_tokens": 1410, "reasoning_tokens": 601 }, "cost_usd": 0.000927, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.242030Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Reputable specialized journalism (C&EN, ACS) that explicitly names and summarizes the Duelfer/Iraq Survey Group official report as its central primary source; secondary rather than primary or peer-reviewed.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate armed services committee 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable specialized journalism (C&EN, ACS) that explicitly names and summarizes the Duelfer/Iraq Survey Group official report as its central primary source; secondary rather than primary or peer-reviewed.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt directly reports Duelfer survey findings of no Iraqi BW stockpiles or active production programs existing in 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports the Iraq Survey Group's post-invasion search findings of no evidence of BW stockpiles or active production programs as of 2003, with destruction in the early 1990s and no resumption plans after 1995.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"senate armed services committee 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3522, "completion_tokens": 3062, "total_tokens": 6584, "reasoning_tokens": 3021 }, "cost_usd": 0.01385914, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.242195Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "NBC News article directly quotes and summarizes the official Duelfer addendum to the Iraq Survey Group report (a named primary/official inquiry document), though the piece itself is secondary journalism rather than the primary record.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"NBC News article directly quotes and summarizes the official Duelfer addendum to the Iraq Survey Group report (a named primary/official inquiry document), though the piece itself is secondary journalism rather than the primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports the Iraq Survey Group's exhaustive final conclusion that no WMD programs or stockpiles of any kind existed, directly covering the biological component as part of the overall WMD investigation.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Duelfer's final ISG report states the WMD investigation (including biological programs) found nothing after exhaustive searches and detainee debriefings.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfers\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3358, "completion_tokens": 1793, "total_tokens": 5151, "reasoning_tokens": 1577 }, "cost_usd": 0.00820366, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.242317Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official final report of the Iraq Survey Group (US government inquiry with on-site access and primary records from 2003-2004); hosted by globalsecurity.org but constitutes the inquiry document itself rather than secondary analysis.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official final report of the Iraq Survey Group (US government inquiry with on-site access and primary records from 2003-2004); hosted by globalsecurity.org but constitutes the inquiry document itself rather than secondary analysis.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The scope note discusses the ISG investigation process and prewar assumptions about WMD but provides no direct reporting on actual chemical stockpiles existing in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt discusses investigation process and challenges but states no findings on existence of stockpiles in 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3280, "completion_tokens": 1622, "total_tokens": 4902, "reasoning_tokens": 1440 }, "cost_usd": 0.007638770719499999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.242425Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia article is a tertiary compilation relying on secondary citations to official reports (UNMOVIC, ISG, CIA) rather than primary records itself; Wikimedia editorial standards exist but lack peer review or original sourcing.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq intelligence commission" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia article is a tertiary compilation relying on secondary citations to official reports (UNMOVIC, ISG, CIA) rather than primary records itself; Wikimedia editorial standards exist but lack peer review or original sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt directly reports the official CIA conclusion that Iraq had no WMD stockpiles (including chemical) in March 2003, plus findings on the absence of post-1991 chemical warheads.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports ISG/CIA inspection findings that Iraq held no WMD stockpiles (including chemical) in March 2003, with only pre-1991 remnants found.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq intelligence commission\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3469, "completion_tokens": 8320, "total_tokens": 11789, "reasoning_tokens": 8094 }, "cost_usd": 0.0410282, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.242543Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia article is a tertiary compilation relying on secondary citations to official reports (UNMOVIC, ISG, CIA) rather than primary records itself; Wikimedia editorial standards exist but lack peer review or original sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq intelligence commission" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia article is a tertiary compilation relying on secondary citations to official reports (UNMOVIC, ISG, CIA) rather than primary records itself; Wikimedia editorial standards exist but lack peer review or original sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports general WMD findings (no stockpiles or production programs in 2003) that encompass biological weapons as a core category, though without isolating bio-specific evidence.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt directly reports CIA and ISG inspection findings that Iraq had neither stockpiles nor active production programs for illicit WMD (including biological) as of March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq intelligence commission\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3477, "completion_tokens": 8681, "total_tokens": 12158, "reasoning_tokens": 8456 }, "cost_usd": 0.0419407, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.242649Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a republication of an official primary speech transcript on citizenreviewonline.org, a low-profile non-governmental site with no evident editorial standards or track record indicated; it directly reproduces the source text rather than analyzing or sourcing it further.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a republication of an official primary speech transcript on citizenreviewonline.org, a low-profile non-governmental site with no evident editorial standards or track record indicated; it directly reproduces the source text rather than analyzing or sourcing it further.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is Powell's Feb 2003 UN speech on Iraq's overall WMD disarmament obligations and inspections, which touches nuclear issues only as one component of a much broader case.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided excerpt addresses Iraq's WMD obligations in general terms but contains no content on nuclear weapons or any reconstitution of a nuclear program.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3402, "completion_tokens": 5598, "total_tokens": 9000, "reasoning_tokens": 5840 }, "cost_usd": 0.02219428, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.242779Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Declassified excerpts of the official October 2002 NIE, a primary intelligence community product entered into the Congressional Record; hosted by irp.fas.org as an archival source with no evident alteration or secondary interpretation.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Declassified excerpts of the official October 2002 NIE, a primary intelligence community product entered into the Congressional Record; hosted by irp.fas.org as an archival source with no evident alteration or secondary interpretation.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The October 2002 NIE excerpt directly reports the intelligence judgment that Iraq was attempting to reconstitute its nuclear capacity, addressing the core proposition though the assessment predates March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"October 2002 NIE asserts ongoing WMD programs and a future nuclear weapon this decade if unchecked, without addressing reconstitution status by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3561, "completion_tokens": 4294, "total_tokens": 7855, "reasoning_tokens": 4109 }, "cost_usd": 0.01643213, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.242890Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "SIPRI is a reputable non-partisan research institute with strong track record on arms control; the piece draws on named primary sources such as David Kay's 2004 Senate testimony and ISG/UN inspection records, though presented as reflective analysis rather than a formal inquiry or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"SIPRI is a reputable non-partisan research institute with strong track record on arms control; the piece draws on named primary sources such as David Kay's 2004 Senate testimony and ISG/UN inspection records, though presented as reflective analysis rather than a formal inquiry or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document addresses the broader WMD claim (including but not limited to chemical weapons) and reports that no WMD stockpiles existed, without isolating chemical weapons or March 2003 stockpiles specifically.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document states the ISG found no WMD and explicitly declares the premise that Iraq had WMD 'none of them was true' based on post-invasion inspections.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay senate testimony 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3601, "completion_tokens": 6325, "total_tokens": 9926, "reasoning_tokens": 6076 }, "cost_usd": 0.0158659464, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.242999Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "SIPRI is a reputable non-partisan research institute with strong track record on arms control; the piece draws on named primary sources such as David Kay's 2004 Senate testimony and ISG/UN inspection records, though presented as reflective analysis rather than a formal inquiry or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"SIPRI is a reputable non-partisan research institute with strong track record on arms control; the piece draws on named primary sources such as David Kay's 2004 Senate testimony and ISG/UN inspection records, though presented as reflective analysis rather than a formal inquiry or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document addresses the broader WMD claims and post-invasion findings in general terms without isolating or directly reporting on biological weapons stockpiles or production.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document states the invasion premise that Iraq had WMD (including biological) was false and ISG found none, based on Kay testimony and analysis of pre-war intelligence.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay senate testimony 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3609, "completion_tokens": 6277, "total_tokens": 9886, "reasoning_tokens": 6044 }, "cost_usd": 0.015755946399999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.243113Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is the official Iraq Survey Group (Duelfer) report, an authoritative government inquiry drawing on primary records, interviews, and inspections; globalsecurity.org is a reliable archival publisher of such documents with no evident conflicts.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is the official Iraq Survey Group (Duelfer) report, an authoritative government inquiry drawing on primary records, interviews, and inspections; globalsecurity.org is a reliable archival publisher of such documents with no evident conflicts.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is the ISG final report covering Iraq's nuclear efforts through 2003, but the excerpt focuses on pre-1980s history and general timelines rather than the 2003 reconstitution status itself.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt covers only pre-1980 nuclear ambitions and facilities with no reference to post-1991 reconstitution or status in 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3517, "completion_tokens": 4253, "total_tokens": 7770, "reasoning_tokens": 4064 }, "cost_usd": 0.01538616, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.243221Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary compilation relying on citations to other sources rather than primary records or original research; it follows editorial standards but lacks peer review or official status.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary compilation relying on citations to other sources rather than primary records or original research; it follows editorial standards but lacks peer review or official status.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt covers Iraq's pre-1991 chemical weapons use and subsequent destruction/cessation of programs plus inspections through early 2003, but addresses only the broader historical WMD topic without directly examining stockpiles present in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt states Iraq's chemical weapons stockpile was destroyed after 1991, programs ceased, and US/UK claims of continued stockpiling were false assertions.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3394, "completion_tokens": 2292, "total_tokens": 5686, "reasoning_tokens": 2019 }, "cost_usd": 0.009564369149, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.243339Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary compilation relying on citations to other sources rather than primary records or original research; it follows editorial standards but lacks peer review or official status.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary compilation relying on citations to other sources rather than primary records or original research; it follows editorial standards but lacks peer review or official status.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document summarizes pre-1991 programs and post-Gulf War halts plus 2002-2003 inspections but does not report or test the specific March 2003 status of stockpiles or active production.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document states Iraq's biological program halted after 1991 per UN resolutions and calls later claims of continuation false assertions.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3402, "completion_tokens": 1979, "total_tokens": 5381, "reasoning_tokens": 1722 }, "cost_usd": 0.008791869149, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.243450Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary compilation relying on citations to other sources rather than primary records or original research; it follows editorial standards but lacks peer review or official status.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "united nations special commission" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary compilation relying on citations to other sources rather than primary records or original research; it follows editorial standards but lacks peer review or official status.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document summarizes pre-1991 programs and post-Gulf War halts plus 2002-2003 inspections but does not report or test the specific March 2003 status of stockpiles or active production.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document states Iraq's biological program halted after 1991 per UN resolutions, inspections found no active programs, and US/UK claims of continuation were false assertions.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 687\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations special commission\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council resolution 1441\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1011, "completion_tokens": 640, "total_tokens": 1651, "reasoning_tokens": 582 }, "cost_usd": 0.00266215, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.243450Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a direct transcript of an official UN Security Council presentation by the chief weapons inspector (primary record from the head of UNMOVIC). CNN is a reputable outlet for verbatim official transcripts with transparent sourcing and no evident conflicts.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a direct transcript of an official UN Security Council presentation by the chief weapons inspector (primary record from the head of UNMOVIC). CNN is a reputable outlet for verbatim official transcripts with transparent sourcing and no evident conflicts.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The transcript covers procedural aspects of UNMOVIC inspections but makes no reference to nuclear program findings or reconstitution.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt addresses only inspection access and logistics with no content on nuclear programs or reconstitution.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3457, "completion_tokens": 1681, "total_tokens": 5138, "reasoning_tokens": 1492 }, "cost_usd": 0.00773232, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.243628Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia that aggregates and summarizes other sources rather than presenting primary records or original analysis; the excerpt cites references but relies on external reporting and official documents without independent verification or peer review.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia that aggregates and summarizes other sources rather than presenting primary records or original analysis; the excerpt cites references but relies on external reporting and official documents without independent verification or peer review.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt directly reports the ISG/Duelfer findings on the size and military significance of Iraq's chemical weapon stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt states that the ISG's post-invasion report found only small chemical stockpiles inadequate for a militarily significant threat.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3400, "completion_tokens": 5595, "total_tokens": 8995, "reasoning_tokens": 5420 }, "cost_usd": 0.0249845, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.244113Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia that aggregates and summarizes other sources rather than presenting primary records or original analysis; the excerpt cites references but relies on external reporting and official documents without independent verification or peer review.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia that aggregates and summarizes other sources rather than presenting primary records or original analysis; the excerpt cites references but relies on external reporting and official documents without independent verification or peer review.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document describes the ISG mission to investigate Iraqi WMD stockpiles and programs including biological agents, directly encompassing the sub-claim as one component of that broader WMD inquiry.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt mentions the ISG hunt for biological agents but reports findings only for chemical WMDs and does not address biological stockpiles or production.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3408, "completion_tokens": 5987, "total_tokens": 9395, "reasoning_tokens": 5806 }, "cost_usd": 0.0259745, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.244248Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia that aggregates and summarizes other sources rather than presenting primary records or original analysis; the excerpt cites references but relies on external reporting and official documents without independent verification or peer review.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia that aggregates and summarizes other sources rather than presenting primary records or original analysis; the excerpt cites references but relies on external reporting and official documents without independent verification or peer review.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes the Iraq Survey Group's mandate to search for WMD programs broadly but provides no specific reporting or findings on nuclear reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt addresses only chemical WMD findings and makes no reference to nuclear programs or reconstitution.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3394, "completion_tokens": 5946, "total_tokens": 9340, "reasoning_tokens": 5781 }, "cost_usd": 0.025854500000000002, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.244349Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Official IAEA Bulletin article (iaea.org) quoting named primary source Hans Blix with direct knowledge of 2002-2003 inspections; reputable institutional publisher with high editorial standards but secondary reporting rather than raw primary record.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official IAEA Bulletin article (iaea.org) quoting named primary source Hans Blix with direct knowledge of 2002-2003 inspections; reputable institutional publisher with high editorial standards but secondary reporting rather than raw primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports Blix's account of general WMD inspections through March 2003 and notes one nuclear-related finding, but addresses the broader disarmament question rather than the specific nuclear reconstitution claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Blix reports ~700 inspections (including at intelligence sites) found no WMD and only minor remnants such as nuclear documents, with Iraq cooperating on destruction verification up to March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3815, "completion_tokens": 5031, "total_tokens": 8846, "reasoning_tokens": 4803 }, "cost_usd": 0.0136498096, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.244450Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Official IAEA Bulletin article (iaea.org) quoting named primary source Hans Blix with direct knowledge of 2002-2003 inspections; reputable institutional publisher with high editorial standards but secondary reporting rather than raw primary record.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official IAEA Bulletin article (iaea.org) quoting named primary source Hans Blix with direct knowledge of 2002-2003 inspections; reputable institutional publisher with high editorial standards but secondary reporting rather than raw primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports Blix's account of general WMD inspections through March 2003 and notes one nuclear-related finding, but addresses the broader disarmament question rather than the specific nuclear reconstitution claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Blix reports 700 inspections found no WMD or active nuclear program, only minor remnants or documents, directly supporting absence of reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1093, "completion_tokens": 456, "total_tokens": 1549, "reasoning_tokens": 398 }, "cost_usd": 0.00230465, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.244450Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.4, "quality_rationale": "Opendemocracy article is secondary expert commentary reviewing the ISG report, drawing on the author's prior Unscom experience but offering no new primary data or official records; lacks peer review, editorial standards of a scholarly journal, or direct sourcing beyond personal recollection.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Opendemocracy article is secondary expert commentary reviewing the ISG report, drawing on the author's prior Unscom experience but offering no new primary data or official records; lacks peer review, editorial standards of a scholarly journal, or direct sourcing beyond personal recollection.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reviews ISG findings on the presence or absence of actual chemical weapons stockpiles in Iraq shortly after the 2003 invasion, directly engaging the core question of their existence at that time.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt notes that the ISG found no traces of actual chemical weapons, directly undercutting the existence of militarily significant stockpiles in 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq survey group interim report 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3390, "completion_tokens": 10224, "total_tokens": 13614, "reasoning_tokens": 9996 }, "cost_usd": 0.02446234152, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.244623Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "UN News is an official UN outlet with strong editorial standards, but the item is secondary journalism summarizing Powell's speech and his unsubstantiated claims of 'solid intelligence' rather than reproducing primary records or named sources.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"UN News is an official UN outlet with strong editorial standards, but the item is secondary journalism summarizing Powell's speech and his unsubstantiated claims of 'solid intelligence' rather than reproducing primary records or named sources.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports Powell's Feb 2003 presentation on Iraq's general failure to disarm and material breach of resolutions but does not address the nuclear weapons program specifically.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq's general failure to disarm and material breach of resolutions but makes no reference to its nuclear weapons program or any reconstitution of it.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"powell presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un news\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3381, "completion_tokens": 4714, "total_tokens": 8095, "reasoning_tokens": 4508 }, "cost_usd": 0.016546889999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.244728Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official October 2002 NIE Key Judgments published by FAS/irp.fas.org, a recognized archive of primary US intelligence documents with transparent provenance and no evident conflicts; this is a direct primary record of the intelligence community's assessment rather than secondary reporting or advocacy.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official October 2002 NIE Key Judgments published by FAS/irp.fas.org, a recognized archive of primary US intelligence documents with transparent provenance and no evident conflicts; this is a direct primary record of the intelligence community's assessment rather than secondary reporting or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt directly reports the October 2002 NIE judgment that Baghdad is reconstituting its nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"October 2002 NIE asserts that most agencies judge Baghdad is reconstituting its nuclear weapons program as of late 2002, directly supporting the claim of reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3276, "completion_tokens": 1725, "total_tokens": 5001, "reasoning_tokens": 1524 }, "cost_usd": 0.007829197536, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.244850Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official U.S. government commission report (Silberman-Robb) published on whitehouse.archives.gov, drawing directly on classified NIEs, executive orders, and Intelligence Community records with detailed endnotes; constitutes an authoritative official inquiry rather than secondary journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official U.S. government commission report (Silberman-Robb) published on whitehouse.archives.gov, drawing directly on classified NIEs, executive orders, and Intelligence Community records with detailed endnotes; constitutes an authoritative official inquiry rather than secondary journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt discusses the 2002 NIE process and scope on Iraq WMD programs but does not report on or test actual 2003 stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses the 2002 NIE intelligence judgments and commission process but provides no information on actual 2003 stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3543, "completion_tokens": 1877, "total_tokens": 5420, "reasoning_tokens": 1613 }, "cost_usd": 0.00872016, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.244949Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official U.S. government commission report (Silberman-Robb) published on whitehouse.archives.gov, drawing directly on classified NIEs, executive orders, and Intelligence Community records with detailed endnotes; constitutes an authoritative official inquiry rather than secondary journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official U.S. government commission report (Silberman-Robb) published on whitehouse.archives.gov, drawing directly on classified NIEs, executive orders, and Intelligence Community records with detailed endnotes; constitutes an authoritative official inquiry rather than secondary journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt discusses the 2002 NIE process and scope on Iraq WMD programs but does not report on or test actual 2003 stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt addresses only pre-war NIE intelligence judgments and process, without any content on actual 2003 stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1041, "completion_tokens": 650, "total_tokens": 1691, "reasoning_tokens": 604 }, "cost_usd": 0.00272465, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.244949Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official U.S. government commission report (Silberman-Robb) published on whitehouse.archives.gov, drawing directly on classified NIEs, executive orders, and Intelligence Community records with detailed endnotes; constitutes an authoritative official inquiry rather than secondary journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "national intelligence council" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official U.S. government commission report (Silberman-Robb) published on whitehouse.archives.gov, drawing directly on classified NIEs, executive orders, and Intelligence Community records with detailed endnotes; constitutes an authoritative official inquiry rather than secondary journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt is from the 2005 WMD intelligence commission report and directly references the 2002 NIE judgments on Iraq's biological weapons programs, addressing the sub-claim as part of its core inquiry into pre-war assessments.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt discusses pre-war 2002 NIE coordination and structure but states no findings or assessments on actual Iraqi BW stockpiles or production in 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence council\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"commission on the intelligence capabilities of the united states\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"intelligence community\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3551, "completion_tokens": 2068, "total_tokens": 5619, "reasoning_tokens": 1783 }, "cost_usd": 0.00920766, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245066Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "CNN news article is ordinary journalism that relays Powell's public UN presentation and quoted intelligence claims without independent verification or primary records.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us electronic intercepts" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us satellite photographs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CNN news article is ordinary journalism that relays Powell's public UN presentation and quoted intelligence claims without independent verification or primary records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports Powell's Feb 2003 claims of Iraqi WMD deception and chemical munitions activity but does not address biological stockpiles or production programs.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt discusses general deception and chemical munitions but makes no reference to biological weapons stockpiles or production.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us electronic intercepts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us satellite photographs\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cnn\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3640, "completion_tokens": 6566, "total_tokens": 10206, "reasoning_tokens": 6379 }, "cost_usd": 0.0217260516, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245158Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "CNN news article is ordinary journalism that relays Powell's public UN presentation and quoted intelligence claims without independent verification or primary records.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us electronic intercepts" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us satellite photographs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CNN news article is ordinary journalism that relays Powell's public UN presentation and quoted intelligence claims without independent verification or primary records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports Powell's Feb 2003 claims of Iraqi WMD deception and chemical munitions activity but does not address biological stockpiles or production programs.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document asserts Iraqi deception on unspecified weapons (with chemical examples) but does not address biological stockpiles or production.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us electronic intercepts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us satellite photographs\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cnn\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1023, "completion_tokens": 573, "total_tokens": 1596, "reasoning_tokens": 527 }, "cost_usd": 0.00244245, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245158Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is the official Iraq Survey Group Final Report (Duelfer Report), an authoritative US government inquiry drawing on primary records, inspections, and interviews. Globalsecurity.org is a neutral archival publisher with no evident conflicts.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is the official Iraq Survey Group Final Report (Duelfer Report), an authoritative US government inquiry drawing on primary records, inspections, and interviews. Globalsecurity.org is a neutral archival publisher with no evident conflicts.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes the ISG report's timeline and analysis of Iraqi CW programs and policy through 2003, directly encompassing the March 2003 period as part of its WMD assessment.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt addresses regime WMD strategy and intent through 2003 but contains no statements on actual 2003 CW stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3508, "completion_tokens": 4073, "total_tokens": 7581, "reasoning_tokens": 3885 }, "cost_usd": 0.01754658, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245291Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "National Security Archive (GWU) is a reputable academic publisher of declassified primary records with explicit citations to official documents such as NSD 54 and UNSCOM reports; the excerpt is secondary narrative but directly anchored in named primary sources rather than journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"National Security Archive (GWU) is a reputable academic publisher of declassified primary records with explicit citations to official documents such as NSD 54 and UNSCOM reports; the excerpt is secondary narrative but directly anchored in named primary sources rather than journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt covers 1990-1998 inspections and 2001 policy debates on WMD programs but contains no information on stockpiles or their status in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt covers events only through 2001 and makes no statement on 2003 stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3416, "completion_tokens": 5027, "total_tokens": 8443, "reasoning_tokens": 4813 }, "cost_usd": 0.017502919999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245383Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "National Security Archive (GWU) is a reputable academic publisher of declassified primary records with explicit citations to official documents such as NSD 54 and UNSCOM reports; the excerpt is secondary narrative but directly anchored in named primary sources rather than journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"National Security Archive (GWU) is a reputable academic publisher of declassified primary records with explicit citations to official documents such as NSD 54 and UNSCOM reports; the excerpt is secondary narrative but directly anchored in named primary sources rather than journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses pre-1998 inspections and general WMD policy history but provides only tangential background on Iraq's programs without addressing the March 2003 status of biological weapons.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses pre-2003 history, UNSCOM inspections ending in 1998, and US policy concerns about possible reconstitution but offers no findings or assertions on active BW stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3424, "completion_tokens": 5267, "total_tokens": 8691, "reasoning_tokens": 5028 }, "cost_usd": 0.01811292, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245487Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "National Security Archive (GWU) is a reputable academic publisher of declassified primary records with explicit citations to official documents such as NSD 54 and UNSCOM reports; the excerpt is secondary narrative but directly anchored in named primary sources rather than journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"National Security Archive (GWU) is a reputable academic publisher of declassified primary records with explicit citations to official documents such as NSD 54 and UNSCOM reports; the excerpt is secondary narrative but directly anchored in named primary sources rather than journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses pre-1998 inspections and general WMD policy history but provides only tangential background on Iraq's programs without addressing the March 2003 status of biological weapons.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document covers only pre-1999 inspections and 2001 policy statements with no content on March 2003 stockpiles or programs.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 994, "completion_tokens": 636, "total_tokens": 1630, "reasoning_tokens": 585 }, "cost_usd": 0.0026309, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245487Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "National Security Archive (GWU) is a reputable academic publisher of declassified primary records with explicit citations to official documents such as NSD 54 and UNSCOM reports; the excerpt is secondary narrative but directly anchored in named primary sources rather than journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"National Security Archive (GWU) is a reputable academic publisher of declassified primary records with explicit citations to official documents such as NSD 54 and UNSCOM reports; the excerpt is secondary narrative but directly anchored in named primary sources rather than journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt provides historical background on pre-2001 WMD inspection regimes and general US concerns about possible future reconstitution of Iraqi programs but does not address the nuclear program status in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document discusses pre-2003 policy concerns and potential for Iraq to reconstitute WMD programs after 1998 but provides no information on whether reconstitution had actually occurred by March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3410, "completion_tokens": 5135, "total_tokens": 8545, "reasoning_tokens": 4894 }, "cost_usd": 0.01776542, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245606Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "National Security Archive (GWU) is a reputable academic publisher of declassified primary records with explicit citations to official documents such as NSD 54 and UNSCOM reports; the excerpt is secondary narrative but directly anchored in named primary sources rather than journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolutions" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"National Security Archive (GWU) is a reputable academic publisher of declassified primary records with explicit citations to official documents such as NSD 54 and UNSCOM reports; the excerpt is secondary narrative but directly anchored in named primary sources rather than journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt provides historical background on pre-2001 WMD inspection regimes and general US concerns about possible future reconstitution of Iraqi programs but does not address the nuclear program status in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses pre-2003 status quo and potential for reconstitution attempts but provides no information on whether Iraq had actually reconstituted its nuclear program by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"national security directive 54\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unscom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolutions\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 987, "completion_tokens": 651, "total_tokens": 1638, "reasoning_tokens": 594 }, "cost_usd": 0.00265965, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245606Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia with collaborative editing and variable editorial standards rather than peer review or official status; the excerpt relies on citations to external accounts but itself provides no primary records or original sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia with collaborative editing and variable editorial standards rather than peer review or official status; the excerpt relies on citations to external accounts but itself provides no primary records or original sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports allegations and post-invasion findings specifically about mobile biological weapons production labs, which is a core component of active BW program claims.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document states subsequent investigations found no evidence of the alleged mobile biological weapons labs or production facilities.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"colin powell un presentation 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3324, "completion_tokens": 1793, "total_tokens": 5117, "reasoning_tokens": 1554 }, "cost_usd": 0.00822129, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245726Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "globalsecurity.org is a reputable aggregator that directly names and quotes the 2002 NIE official assessment as its source; the page is secondary compilation rather than primary record or peer-reviewed work.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "previous intelligence reports" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"globalsecurity.org is a reputable aggregator that directly names and quotes the 2002 NIE official assessment as its source; the page is secondary compilation rather than primary record or peer-reviewed work.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt directly reports the 2002 NIE's conclusions on Iraq's CW stockpile size and production status immediately prior to March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports the 2002 NIE's high-confidence assessment that Iraq possessed 100-500 MT of CW agents (including recent production), directly supporting the sub-claim of militarily significant stockpiles in 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"previous intelligence reports\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3242, "completion_tokens": 2815, "total_tokens": 6057, "reasoning_tokens": 2787 }, "cost_usd": 0.012141850000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245810Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "CRS reports are official congressional research products by subject specialists, drawing directly on primary records such as UN resolutions, inspection reports, and agency data with transparent sourcing and nonpartisan editorial standards.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CRS reports are official congressional research products by subject specialists, drawing directly on primary records such as UN resolutions, inspection reports, and agency data with transparent sourcing and nonpartisan editorial standards.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document analyzes 2002-2003 UN inspections specifically for Iraqi WMD (including chemical), covering the exact pre-invasion period referenced in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports inspectors found insufficient evidence of WMD to justify force but makes no direct claim about actual stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3654, "completion_tokens": 2970, "total_tokens": 6624, "reasoning_tokens": 2775 }, "cost_usd": 0.0116454322, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245898Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "CRS reports are official congressional research products by subject specialists, drawing directly on primary records such as UN resolutions, inspection reports, and agency data with transparent sourcing and nonpartisan editorial standards.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CRS reports are official congressional research products by subject specialists, drawing directly on primary records such as UN resolutions, inspection reports, and agency data with transparent sourcing and nonpartisan editorial standards.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The report analyzes UN/IAEA inspections for WMD (including nuclear) conducted through March 2003 and their findings on undeclared activities, directly addressing the status of Iraq's nuclear program at the relevant date as part of the broader WMD question.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses general WMD inspections and undeclared activities without addressing nuclear program reconstitution.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3648, "completion_tokens": 3072, "total_tokens": 6720, "reasoning_tokens": 2869 }, "cost_usd": 0.011892932200000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.245972Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia relying on user editing and citations to other sources rather than original primary research or official inquiry; its editorial standards and publisher track record provide transparency but no peer review or institutional authority.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "human rights watch" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia relying on user editing and citations to other sources rather than original primary research or official inquiry; its editorial standards and publisher track record provide transparency but no peer review or institutional authority.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document exclusively covers Iraq's chemical weapons program and contains no information on biological weapons.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt addresses only chemical weapons programs ending by 1991 and contains no statements about biological weapons.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"united nations\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"human rights watch\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3550, "completion_tokens": 10930, "total_tokens": 14480, "reasoning_tokens": 10752 }, "cost_usd": 0.0350579778, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.246049Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia article (secondary/tertiary encyclopedia entry) summarizing an official Senate report; cites named primary records but is not itself primary, peer-reviewed, or an official inquiry.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia article (secondary/tertiary encyclopedia entry) summarizing an official Senate report; cites named primary records but is not itself primary, peer-reviewed, or an official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt summarizes a report on prewar intelligence assessments and failures regarding Iraqi WMD programs up to 1998, addressing the intelligence process rather than the factual status of stockpiles in 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt addresses only pre-1998 compliance issues and intelligence assessment failures without stating or observing any facts about 2003 stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence 2004\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3264, "completion_tokens": 2152, "total_tokens": 5416, "reasoning_tokens": 1962 }, "cost_usd": 0.00867641, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.246129Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia article (secondary/tertiary encyclopedia entry) summarizing an official Senate report; cites named primary records but is not itself primary, peer-reviewed, or an official inquiry.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia article (secondary/tertiary encyclopedia entry) summarizing an official Senate report; cites named primary records but is not itself primary, peer-reviewed, or an official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is the Senate report on U.S. intelligence assessments of Iraqi WMD programs immediately prior to the 2003 invasion, which directly encompasses evaluations of biological weapons claims.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses prewar intelligence failures and general WMD compliance issues but makes no statement on actual Iraqi BW stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence 2004\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3272, "completion_tokens": 1972, "total_tokens": 5244, "reasoning_tokens": 1782 }, "cost_usd": 0.00823641, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.246211Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "PBS FRONTLINE is a reputable journalistic outlet with strong editorial standards and a track record of in-depth interviews; this is a 2016 transcript of direct interview remarks by Colin Powell (a named primary participant) rather than an official inquiry, peer-reviewed study, or contemporaneous primary record.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "frontline pbs" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell interview february 2016" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "the secret history of isis documentary" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"PBS FRONTLINE is a reputable journalistic outlet with strong editorial standards and a track record of in-depth interviews; this is a 2016 transcript of direct interview remarks by Colin Powell (a named primary participant) rather than an official inquiry, peer-reviewed study, or contemporaneous primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt states that Iraq's weapons program was nonexistent as confirmed by later intelligence, addressing the core claim of program reconstitution around the 2003 invasion though without specifying the nuclear component.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document states that post-invasion intelligence confirmed Iraq's weapons program was nonexistent, contradicting any reconstitution by 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"frontline pbs\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"colin powell interview february 2016\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"the secret history of isis documentary\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3678, "completion_tokens": 2035, "total_tokens": 5713, "reasoning_tokens": 1801 }, "cost_usd": 0.00899135, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.246293Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "UN News is the official UN media outlet with strong editorial standards and direct access to Security Council archives; the piece is reputable secondary reporting that cites named primary records (Powell's 2003 presentation, satellite images, audio) but is not itself a primary document on Iraq's weapons programmes.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council meeting february 5 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"UN News is the official UN media outlet with strong editorial standards and direct access to Security Council archives; the piece is reputable secondary reporting that cites named primary records (Powell's 2003 presentation, satellite images, audio) but is not itself a primary document on Iraq's weapons programmes.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports Powell's Feb 2003 WMD presentation focused on biological agents and anthrax, addressing the broader WMD claims that partly overlap the nuclear-specific sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document describes 2003 claims focused on biological agents/anthrax with no reference to nuclear weapons or programs.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council meeting february 5 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3435, "completion_tokens": 4409, "total_tokens": 7844, "reasoning_tokens": 4216 }, "cost_usd": 0.012425301199999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.246374Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable nonpartisan outlet with editorial standards that directly cites the official Iraq Survey Group final report and describes its methods; this is secondary reporting grounded in named primary/official records rather than original primary material or peer-reviewed research.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable nonpartisan outlet with editorial standards that directly cites the official Iraq Survey Group final report and describes its methods; this is secondary reporting grounded in named primary/official records rather than original primary material or peer-reviewed research.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports the Iraq Survey Group's conclusion that all chemical weapon stockpiles had already been destroyed prior to the 2003 invasion.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports ISG's post-invasion inspections and searches found Iraq had destroyed all chemical weapon stockpiles prior to March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3496, "completion_tokens": 1968, "total_tokens": 5464, "reasoning_tokens": 1776 }, "cost_usd": 0.00971084, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.246457Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable nonpartisan outlet with editorial standards that directly cites the official Iraq Survey Group final report and describes its methods; this is secondary reporting grounded in named primary/official records rather than original primary material or peer-reviewed research.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable nonpartisan outlet with editorial standards that directly cites the official Iraq Survey Group final report and describes its methods; this is secondary reporting grounded in named primary/official records rather than original primary material or peer-reviewed research.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports the Iraq Survey Group's conclusion that all chemical weapon stockpiles had already been destroyed prior to the 2003 invasion.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Document directly reports ISG determination that Iraq had destroyed all existing chemical weapon stockpiles before 2003 invasion.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1013, "completion_tokens": 599, "total_tokens": 1612, "reasoning_tokens": 558 }, "cost_usd": 0.00256215, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.246457Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable nonpartisan outlet with editorial standards that directly cites the official Iraq Survey Group final report and describes its methods; this is secondary reporting grounded in named primary/official records rather than original primary material or peer-reviewed research.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable nonpartisan outlet with editorial standards that directly cites the official Iraq Survey Group final report and describes its methods; this is secondary reporting grounded in named primary/official records rather than original primary material or peer-reviewed research.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports the Iraq Survey Group's conclusion that Iraq had destroyed all biological weapons stockpiles and abandoned related programs by 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports the Iraq Survey Group's post-invasion determination, based on systematic searches and evidence collection, that Iraq had destroyed all chemical/biological stockpiles and abandoned related programs before 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3504, "completion_tokens": 2153, "total_tokens": 5657, "reasoning_tokens": 1949 }, "cost_usd": 0.010183339999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.246589Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "FactCheck.org is a reputable nonpartisan outlet with editorial standards that directly cites the official Iraq Survey Group final report and describes its methods; this is secondary reporting grounded in named primary/official records rather than original primary material or peer-reviewed research.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"FactCheck.org is a reputable nonpartisan outlet with editorial standards that directly cites the official Iraq Survey Group final report and describes its methods; this is secondary reporting grounded in named primary/official records rather than original primary material or peer-reviewed research.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports ISG conclusion that Iraq abandoned its nuclear weapons quest (part of broader WMD assessment), directly addressing program status around 2003 though framed within overall WMD question.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports the Iraq Survey Group's post-invasion inspections and evidence collection concluding that Iraq had abandoned its nuclear weapons program, directly contradicting reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group final report\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3490, "completion_tokens": 2275, "total_tokens": 5765, "reasoning_tokens": 2068 }, "cost_usd": 0.01047084, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.246696Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Arms Control Association article citing named U.S. military officials, Rumsfeld statements, and UNMOVIC reports; reputable secondary reporting with transparent sourcing from official records rather than primary document or peer-reviewed analysis.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "kimmitt press briefing may 17 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "rumsfeld heritage foundation may 17 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Arms Control Association article citing named U.S. military officials, Rumsfeld statements, and UNMOVIC reports; reputable secondary reporting with transparent sourcing from official records rather than primary document or peer-reviewed analysis.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports discovery of a single old sarin round used as an IED and references pre-1991 production discrepancies, providing only tangential background on the existence of significant 2003 stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reports one pre-1991 sarin shell found (and notes pre-war accounting discrepancies) but offers no information on whether militarily significant stockpiles existed in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"kimmitt press briefing may 17 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"rumsfeld heritage foundation may 17 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic march 2003 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3369, "completion_tokens": 6103, "total_tokens": 9472, "reasoning_tokens": 5845 }, "cost_usd": 0.015991570288, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.246803Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "armscontrol.org is a reputable specialist publisher that draws directly on named official records (UNMOVIC/IAEA inspection counts, May 30 report, Resolution 1441); the piece is secondary synthesis rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq declaration december 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"armscontrol.org is a reputable specialist publisher that draws directly on named official records (UNMOVIC/IAEA inspection counts, May 30 report, Resolution 1441); the piece is secondary synthesis rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports on the scope and outcomes of UN chemical-weapons inspections through March 2003 and notes unresolved disarmament issues, but does not directly examine or report the existence of stockpiles at that date.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports unresolved issues and inadequate Iraqi declarations but neither states nor implies existence of stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq declaration december 2002\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3450, "completion_tokens": 9520, "total_tokens": 12970, "reasoning_tokens": 9289 }, "cost_usd": 0.037928326, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.246894Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "Advocacy site (leadingtowar.com film project) presenting curated claims-vs-facts narrative; relies on secondary summaries of intelligence reports rather than primary documents or original reporting, with clear editorial framing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "bush administration" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "curveball" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "defense intelligence agency" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Advocacy site (leadingtowar.com film project) presenting curated claims-vs-facts narrative; relies on secondary summaries of intelligence reports rather than primary documents or original reporting, with clear editorial framing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document directly reports on (non)existence of mobile bioweapons labs, a core element of the alleged active BW production program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports no mobile bioweapons labs found post-invasion and states pre-war intelligence agencies had already issued fabrication notices on the key sources.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush administration\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi defector curveball\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"defense intelligence agency\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3324, "completion_tokens": 2042, "total_tokens": 5366, "reasoning_tokens": 1796 }, "cost_usd": 0.0085743, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.246984Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "Grokipedia is an unknown publisher with no established track record or editorial standards; the text is a secondary summary citing official reports but provides no primary evidence or verifiable sourcing of its own.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Grokipedia is an unknown publisher with no established track record or editorial standards; the text is a secondary summary citing official reports but provides no primary evidence or verifiable sourcing of its own.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt directly reports the Duelfer Report and ISG findings on the absence of operational chemical weapon stockpiles in Iraq after 1991, addressing the exact March 2003 status.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports the Duelfer Report's conclusion that Iraq destroyed all known chemical stockpiles by 1991 with no post-1991 reconstitution or production, directly contradicting the existence of militarily significant stockpiles in 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3304, "completion_tokens": 1518, "total_tokens": 4822, "reasoning_tokens": 1246 }, "cost_usd": 0.00716006, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.247107Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "Partisan congressional press release from a Democratic politician using selective quotes to criticize administration statements; secondary advocacy material with citations to speeches and a NYT interview but no independent primary sourcing or official inquiry on Iraqi programs.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cheney meet the press 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush state of the union 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Partisan congressional press release from a Democratic politician using selective quotes to criticize administration statements; secondary advocacy material with citations to speeches and a NYT interview but no independent primary sourcing or official inquiry on Iraqi programs.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document quotes pre-war claims of Iraqi biological weapons stockpiles plus post-invasion assessment of absent WMD stockpiles/production, addressing the exact sub-claim within a broader WMD discussion.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Quotes Kay's assessment that Iraq had no large WMD stockpiles or ongoing production by 2003, directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay new york times interview 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cheney meet the press 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"powell un security council 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush state of the union 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3915, "completion_tokens": 3291, "total_tokens": 7206, "reasoning_tokens": 3141 }, "cost_usd": 0.01453693, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.247206Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary encyclopedia compiled from citations rather than primary records or original inquiry; it references official sources such as UNSCOM but itself follows only general editorial standards with no peer review or institutional authority on the topic.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "riegle report 1994" }, { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary encyclopedia compiled from citations rather than primary records or original inquiry; it references official sources such as UNSCOM but itself follows only general editorial standards with no peer review or institutional authority on the topic.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt explicitly states that the Iraqi BW program no longer existed at the time of the 2003 invasion, directly addressing the sub-claim's timeframe and proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt states explicitly that Iraq's BW program 'no longer existed' by the time of the 2003 invasion.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"riegle report 1994\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3496, "completion_tokens": 8307, "total_tokens": 11803, "reasoning_tokens": 8100 }, "cost_usd": 0.0360055, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.247306Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Arms Control Association is a reputable non-profit with strong editorial standards and track record on disarmament topics; this is a secondary chronology drawing on named official records (UN resolutions, inspection reports, speeches) rather than original primary data or peer-reviewed analysis.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Arms Control Association is a reputable non-profit with strong editorial standards and track record on disarmament topics; this is a secondary chronology drawing on named official records (UN resolutions, inspection reports, speeches) rather than original primary data or peer-reviewed analysis.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports UN inspectors' explicit findings on the absence of chemical weapons possession in Iraq through March 18 2003, addressing the core proposition as part of the inspections' mandate.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports that UN inspectors found no evidence Iraq possessed chemical weapons after 900+ inspections through March 18, 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush state of the union 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3381, "completion_tokens": 1841, "total_tokens": 5222, "reasoning_tokens": 1595 }, "cost_usd": 0.00806485, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.247414Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Arms Control Association is a reputable non-profit with strong editorial standards and track record on disarmament topics; this is a secondary chronology drawing on named official records (UN resolutions, inspection reports, speeches) rather than original primary data or peer-reviewed analysis.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Arms Control Association is a reputable non-profit with strong editorial standards and track record on disarmament topics; this is a secondary chronology drawing on named official records (UN resolutions, inspection reports, speeches) rather than original primary data or peer-reviewed analysis.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports UN inspectors' findings through March 18 2003 on whether Iraq possessed biological weapons.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document states UN inspectors conducted 900+ inspections through March 18 2003 and did not find Iraq possessed chemical or biological weapons.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush state of the union 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3389, "completion_tokens": 1902, "total_tokens": 5291, "reasoning_tokens": 1670 }, "cost_usd": 0.00822735, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.247531Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official UN News transcript of direct statements by UNMOVIC head Hans Blix at UN Headquarters, citing his own observations and communications with member states; constitutes a primary record from the responsible international inspection body.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un news" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official UN News transcript of direct statements by UNMOVIC head Hans Blix at UN Headquarters, citing his own observations and communications with member states; constitutes a primary record from the responsible international inspection body.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses chemical/biological weapons and missile ranges but contains no mention of nuclear weapons or programs.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses possible missile use and chemical/biological weapons but contains no statements about Iraq's nuclear program or its reconstitution.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hans blix\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un news\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2959, "completion_tokens": 4736, "total_tokens": 7695, "reasoning_tokens": 4562 }, "cost_usd": 0.01960412, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.247611Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "Secondary popular-history page from an image archive site with no evident editorial standards or primary sourcing; it relays public-domain claims about Curveball and Powell's 2003 speech without original records or verification.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "curveball" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "german intelligence" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Secondary popular-history page from an image archive site with no evident editorial standards or primary sourcing; it relays public-domain claims about Curveball and Powell's 2003 speech without original records or verification.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports on 2003 intelligence claims and images specifically alleging Iraqi mobile biological weapons production facilities.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document describes Curveball's claims of mobile bio-production labs as discredited by other intelligence sources, labeling the images as 'supposed' facilities based on false testimony.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"curveball\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"german intelligence\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"cia\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"powell un speech 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3259, "completion_tokens": 4161, "total_tokens": 7420, "reasoning_tokens": 3959 }, "cost_usd": 0.01712472, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.247699Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official UN Security Council document (S/2006/420) prepared by UNMOVIC and transmitted by the Secretary-General, drawing directly on primary inspection records, access to facilities/personnel/documents, and the commission's mandate under Chapter VII resolutions.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official UN Security Council document (S/2006/420) prepared by UNMOVIC and transmitted by the Secretary-General, drawing directly on primary inspection records, access to facilities/personnel/documents, and the commission's mandate under Chapter VII resolutions.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document summarizes Iraq's historical proscribed BW programmes post-1991 but does not address their status or activity specifically in March 2003.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt summarizes historical post-1991 dismantlement of declared programs and does not address Iraq's biological weapons status in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3653, "completion_tokens": 3640, "total_tokens": 7293, "reasoning_tokens": 3447 }, "cost_usd": 0.0131662732, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.247786Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official transcript of a U.S. Secretary of State address published on the White House archives site; constitutes a primary government record with named speakers and references to UN resolutions and inspectors, though not a peer-reviewed study or raw data collection.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official transcript of a U.S. Secretary of State address published on the White House archives site; constitutes a primary government record with named speakers and references to UN resolutions and inspectors, though not a peer-reviewed study or raw data collection.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Feb 2003 Powell speech to the UNSC directly presents the US case on Iraq's ongoing WMD programs and noncompliance with Resolution 1441, encompassing biological weapons as a core component of that assessment.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Powell's address asserts Iraq's ongoing WMD programs and concealment efforts as of early 2003, directly supporting the sub-claim via intelligence-based allegations.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us state department 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3488, "completion_tokens": 1910, "total_tokens": 5398, "reasoning_tokens": 1658 }, "cost_usd": 0.00861984, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.247867Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official transcript of a U.S. Secretary of State address published on the White House archives site; constitutes a primary government record with named speakers and references to UN resolutions and inspectors, though not a peer-reviewed study or raw data collection.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official transcript of a U.S. Secretary of State address published on the White House archives site; constitutes a primary government record with named speakers and references to UN resolutions and inspectors, though not a peer-reviewed study or raw data collection.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The February 2003 Powell speech to the UNSC directly addresses Iraq's WMD programs and compliance with disarmament resolutions in the months immediately preceding March 2003, including nuclear-related elements as part of that broader assessment.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt addresses Iraq's WMD obligations and inspections in general terms but contains no statements on nuclear weapons program status or reconstitution.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us state department 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3474, "completion_tokens": 1901, "total_tokens": 5375, "reasoning_tokens": 1652 }, "cost_usd": 0.00864704, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.247952Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.8, "quality_rationale": "Carnegie Endowment report is a secondary analytical study drawing on unclassified prewar intelligence records, administration statements, and post-invasion evidence; reputable publisher with strong editorial standards but not a primary document or official inquiry.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, { "type": "study", "id": "wmd in iraq evidence and implications" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.8, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Carnegie Endowment report is a secondary analytical study drawing on unclassified prewar intelligence records, administration statements, and post-invasion evidence; reputable publisher with strong editorial standards but not a primary document or official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a 2004 Carnegie study explicitly examining prewar claims and post-invasion evidence regarding Iraq's chemical-weapon stockpiles and related capabilities.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document notes administration's post-invasion shift in claims away from 'massive stockpiles' toward lesser capabilities, based on evidence found in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"carnegie endowment for international peace\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wmd in iraq evidence and implications\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3362, "completion_tokens": 1910, "total_tokens": 5272, "reasoning_tokens": 1694 }, "cost_usd": 0.00850686, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.248054Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Reputable think-tank analysis by a policy expert, drawing directly on named official primary records (classified vs. unclassified NIE versions) with transparent comparison methodology; not itself a primary document, peer-reviewed study, or official inquiry.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable think-tank analysis by a policy expert, drawing directly on named official primary records (classified vs. unclassified NIE versions) with transparent comparison methodology; not itself a primary document, peer-reviewed study, or official inquiry.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document analyzes the 2002 NIE's assessments and public presentation of Iraq's nuclear weapons program, directly addressing the intelligence basis for the exact proposition evaluated.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.4, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The 2004 analysis highlights intelligence misrepresentations and the post-invasion failure to find WMD, thereby contradicting pre-war claims of an active reconstituted nuclear program.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"carnegie endowment for international peace\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia white paper iraqs weapons of mass destruction\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3396, "completion_tokens": 1820, "total_tokens": 5216, "reasoning_tokens": 1563 }, "cost_usd": 0.008107860000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.248135Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.0, "quality_rationale": "The document is an official CIA FOIA archive page but describes only 1972 PRC trip materials (city guides, atlas, leadership profiles) with no connection to Iraq WMD programs 2002-2004; as evidence on the stated topic it is therefore unusable regardless of the publisher's general reliability for primary records.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an official CIA FOIA archive page but describes only 1972 PRC trip materials (city guides, atlas, leadership profiles) with no connection to Iraq WMD programs 2002-2004; as evidence on the stated topic it is therefore unusable regardless of the publisher's general reliability for primary records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document concerns only 1972 CIA materials on Nixon's China trip and has no connection to Iraq or chemical weapons.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document contains only material on 1972 CIA support for Nixon's China trip and does not address Iraq or chemical weapons.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3568, "completion_tokens": 2088, "total_tokens": 5656, "reasoning_tokens": 1902 }, "cost_usd": 0.009180976, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.248225Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.0, "quality_rationale": "The document is an official CIA FOIA archive page but describes only 1972 PRC trip materials (city guides, atlas, leadership profiles) with no connection to Iraq WMD programs 2002-2004; as evidence on the stated topic it is therefore unusable regardless of the publisher's general reliability for primary records.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an official CIA FOIA archive page but describes only 1972 PRC trip materials (city guides, atlas, leadership profiles) with no connection to Iraq WMD programs 2002-2004; as evidence on the stated topic it is therefore unusable regardless of the publisher's general reliability for primary records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document consists solely of 1972 CIA materials on Nixon's China trip and has no connection to Iraq or nuclear weapons programs.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document concerns only 1972 CIA materials on China and contains no content on Iraq or nuclear weapons programs.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3562, "completion_tokens": 2014, "total_tokens": 5576, "reasoning_tokens": 1829 }, "cost_usd": 0.009055676, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.248302Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Secondary compilation from globalsecurity.org that directly quotes and attributes assessments to the named October 2002 NIE primary intelligence document; reputable aggregator of official records but not itself an official inquiry or primary source.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Secondary compilation from globalsecurity.org that directly quotes and attributes assessments to the named October 2002 NIE primary intelligence document; reputable aggregator of official records but not itself an official inquiry or primary source.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports October 2002 NIE judgments that Iraq's BW program (R&D, production, weaponization, stockpiles) was active immediately prior to March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt relays the October 2002 NIE's judgments that Iraq's BW program was active with stockpiles and production capability, directly supporting the sub-claim though based solely on pre-2003 estimates.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3452, "completion_tokens": 2812, "total_tokens": 6264, "reasoning_tokens": 2614 }, "cost_usd": 0.0106754654, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.248377Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official UN Security Council document (S/2003/232) transmitting the quarterly report of UNMOVIC, the designated inspection and monitoring body under Security Council resolutions; constitutes a primary record from the responsible international authority with direct access to inspection data and Iraqi declarations.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official UN Security Council document (S/2003/232) transmitting the quarterly report of UNMOVIC, the designated inspection and monitoring body under Security Council resolutions; constitutes a primary record from the responsible international authority with direct access to inspection data and Iraqi declarations.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a procedural UNMOVIC quarterly report on inspection activities and unresolved disarmament issues through late February 2003, addressing the broader verification process that only partly overlaps the specific March 2003 stockpiles claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes inspection processes and unresolved issues through Feb 2003 but offers no findings or assertions on current CW stockpiles.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unmovic\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3599, "completion_tokens": 2351, "total_tokens": 5950, "reasoning_tokens": 2211 }, "cost_usd": 0.01044253, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.248457Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official final report of the Iraq Survey Group (Duelfer Report), an authorized US-led government inquiry with direct access to sites, documents, and personnel; hosted by globalsecurity.org but presented as the primary inquiry text itself.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official final report of the Iraq Survey Group (Duelfer Report), an authorized US-led government inquiry with direct access to sites, documents, and personnel; hosted by globalsecurity.org but presented as the primary inquiry text itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt explicitly reports ISG findings on whether Iraq reconstituted any nuclear weapons capability after 1991, matching the sub-claim's exact proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The ISG report directly states Iraq neither possessed a nuclear device nor attempted to reconstitute any nuclear weapons production capability after 1991, based on its post-invasion investigations.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3337, "completion_tokens": 1378, "total_tokens": 4715, "reasoning_tokens": 1182 }, "cost_usd": 0.00682351, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.248555Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official UNMOVIC Executive Chairman statement to the Security Council (un.org), constituting a primary record from the authorized international inspection body with direct access to sites and official processes.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official UNMOVIC Executive Chairman statement to the Security Council (un.org), constituting a primary record from the authorized international inspection body with direct access to sites and official processes.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes inspection processes and access in Iraq but contains no reporting on chemical weapons stockpiles or related findings.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt addresses only inspection access, logistics, and surveillance capabilities with no statements on the presence or absence of chemical weapons stockpiles.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic 12th quarterly report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3430, "completion_tokens": 4124, "total_tokens": 7554, "reasoning_tokens": 3938 }, "cost_usd": 0.0113012832, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.248641Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Reputable arms-control analysis site citing named 2003 IAEA/UNMOVIC reports and statements by ElBaradei and Blix; secondary retrospective (2013) rather than primary record or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iaea march 2003 report" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable arms-control analysis site citing named 2003 IAEA/UNMOVIC reports and statements by ElBaradei and Blix; secondary retrospective (2013) rather than primary record or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt directly quotes the IAEA Director General's March 2003 report stating no evidence of revival of Iraq's nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document directly quotes IAEA Director ElBaradei reporting no evidence of nuclear weapons program revival after 100+ site visits and interviews in early 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iaea march 2003 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unmovic march 2003 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"bush administration statements\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3502, "completion_tokens": 5022, "total_tokens": 8524, "reasoning_tokens": 5233 }, "cost_usd": 0.02170866, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.248732Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "Transcript of a government official's UN presentation citing unnamed defectors and estimates; constitutes advocacy rather than primary records or independently verified sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "intelligence community" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi defectors" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Transcript of a government official's UN presentation citing unnamed defectors and estimates; constitutes advocacy rather than primary records or independently verified sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Feb 2003 Powell transcript directly addresses Iraq's post-1998 efforts to reconstitute its nuclear program and states there is no indication of abandonment, which is a closely related question to whether reconstitution had occurred by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Powell asserts ongoing efforts since 1998 to reconstitute the program by acquiring fissile material, implying it had not yet been reconstituted by early 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n\\\"roots\\\": [\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us intelligence community\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi defectors\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"},\\n{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cnn\\\"}\\n]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3431, "completion_tokens": 4125, "total_tokens": 7556, "reasoning_tokens": 3895 }, "cost_usd": 0.01683406, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.248817Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is ordinary journalism summarizing Kay's public statements and related events, with no primary documents, original data collection, or official inquiry status.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "david kay" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate armed services committee 2004" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is ordinary journalism summarizing Kay's public statements and related events, with no primary documents, original data collection, or official inquiry status.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt directly reports Kay's assessment that no significant chemical weapons stockpiles existed or would be found after the 2003 invasion, addressing the exact proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Kay states he expects no significant chemical stockpiles to be found and believes Iraq destroyed pre-1991 weapons without resuming large-scale production.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"david kay statements 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia announcement january 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate armed services committee hearing 2004\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3305, "completion_tokens": 1656, "total_tokens": 4961, "reasoning_tokens": 1429 }, "cost_usd": 0.007439650000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.248898Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "Think-tank policy analysis/commentary by a project director, citing Powell's UN speech and secondary media like Jordan Times but providing no primary documents, original data, or official records on Iraqi weapons programmes.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jordan times editorial 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Think-tank policy analysis/commentary by a project director, citing Powell's UN speech and secondary media like Jordan Times but providing no primary documents, original data, or official records on Iraqi weapons programmes.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document analyzes Powell's 2003 UN presentation on Iraq's overall WMD noncompliance and deception but does not address biological weapons stockpiles or production programs specifically.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document discusses Powell's focus on deception and lack of evidence for imminent threat but makes no claim about actual 2003 Iraqi BW stockpiles or production.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un security council presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"jordan times editorial 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3512, "completion_tokens": 5419, "total_tokens": 8931, "reasoning_tokens": 5220 }, "cost_usd": 0.014840655568, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.248978Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "Think-tank policy analysis/commentary by a project director, citing Powell's UN speech and secondary media like Jordan Times but providing no primary documents, original data, or official records on Iraqi weapons programmes.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jordan times editorial 2003" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Think-tank policy analysis/commentary by a project director, citing Powell's UN speech and secondary media like Jordan Times but providing no primary documents, original data, or official records on Iraqi weapons programmes.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document analyzes Powell's UN speech on overall Iraqi WMD deception and lack of imminent threat but does not address or report on the nuclear weapons program's reconstitution status.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document critiques lack of evidence for imminent threat but does not address nuclear program reconstitution.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"colin powell un security council presentation february 2003\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"jordan times editorial 2003\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3498, "completion_tokens": 5290, "total_tokens": 8788, "reasoning_tokens": 5105 }, "cost_usd": 0.014433455568, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.249066Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary CNN news article relaying conclusions from the named Duelfer/Iraq Survey Group report (an official inquiry) without presenting primary data or records itself; CNN maintains standard journalistic editorial standards with no evident conflicts.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary CNN news article relaying conclusions from the named Duelfer/Iraq Survey Group report (an official inquiry) without presenting primary data or records itself; CNN maintains standard journalistic editorial standards with no evident conflicts.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports the CIA conclusion that Iraq had no WMD stockpiles (including chemical) in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports the Iraq Survey Group's inspection-based conclusion that Iraq possessed no WMD stockpiles of any kind in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfel\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3473, "completion_tokens": 1791, "total_tokens": 5264, "reasoning_tokens": 1566 }, "cost_usd": 0.007854622, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.249142Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary CNN news article relaying conclusions from the named Duelfer/Iraq Survey Group report (an official inquiry) without presenting primary data or records itself; CNN maintains standard journalistic editorial standards with no evident conflicts.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "charles duelfel" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary CNN news article relaying conclusions from the named Duelfer/Iraq Survey Group report (an official inquiry) without presenting primary data or records itself; CNN maintains standard journalistic editorial standards with no evident conflicts.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports the CIA Duelfer report conclusion that Iraq had no WMD stockpiles and no active production program as of March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports the Iraq Survey Group's conclusion of no WMD stockpiles or active production programs in March 2003, based on post-invasion inspections.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"charles duelfel\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3481, "completion_tokens": 1952, "total_tokens": 5433, "reasoning_tokens": 1718 }, "cost_usd": 0.008468722, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.249217Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Arms Control Association is a reputable non-governmental organization that produces chronologies drawing on named official records, intelligence assessments, and IAEA reports; the piece is secondary analysis rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "arms control association" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iaea" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Arms Control Association is a reputable non-governmental organization that produces chronologies drawing on named official records, intelligence assessments, and IAEA reports; the piece is secondary analysis rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document explicitly frames and reports IAEA findings on the exact reconstitution claim as context for its narrower uranium-from-Niger chronology.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document states IAEA inspectors on the ground found no evidence Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear weapons program.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"arms control association\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"senate select committee on intelligence\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iaea\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"bush administration\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3293, "completion_tokens": 1754, "total_tokens": 5047, "reasoning_tokens": 1520 }, "cost_usd": 0.0078761023695, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.249301Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Reputable specialized reporting from Arms Control Association citing named official records (Duelfer/ISG reports, White House statements, UN inspections) with clear sourcing and editorial standards; secondary rather than primary or peer-reviewed.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable specialized reporting from Arms Control Association citing named official records (Duelfer/ISG reports, White House statements, UN inspections) with clear sourcing and editorial standards; secondary rather than primary or peer-reviewed.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports ISG conclusion of no WMD stockpiles after 2003 invasion, covering chemical weapons as part of broader WMD findings.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document relays ISG inspection conclusion that Iraq had no WMD stockpiles at all after the 2003 invasion.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3328, "completion_tokens": 1792, "total_tokens": 5120, "reasoning_tokens": 1573 }, "cost_usd": 0.00791947, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.249393Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Reputable specialized reporting from Arms Control Association citing named official records (Duelfer/ISG reports, White House statements, UN inspections) with clear sourcing and editorial standards; secondary rather than primary or peer-reviewed.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable specialized reporting from Arms Control Association citing named official records (Duelfer/ISG reports, White House statements, UN inspections) with clear sourcing and editorial standards; secondary rather than primary or peer-reviewed.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports Duelfer/ISG findings of no WMD stockpiles or reconstituted programs (explicitly referencing biological weapons claims) as of post-2003 invasion, addressing the sub-claim as part of the broader WMD investigation.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports Duelfer/ISG final findings of no WMD stockpiles or reconstituted programs as of 2003, directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3336, "completion_tokens": 1736, "total_tokens": 5072, "reasoning_tokens": 1492 }, "cost_usd": 0.007789470000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.249468Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Reputable specialized reporting from Arms Control Association citing named official records (Duelfer/ISG reports, White House statements, UN inspections) with clear sourcing and editorial standards; secondary rather than primary or peer-reviewed.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable specialized reporting from Arms Control Association citing named official records (Duelfer/ISG reports, White House statements, UN inspections) with clear sourcing and editorial standards; secondary rather than primary or peer-reviewed.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports UN inspectors' pre-war finding of no evidence that Iraq had reconstituted its WMD programs (explicitly including nuclear) and contrasts it with administration claims of an active nuclear program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document relays UN inspectors' pre-invasion findings of no evidence that Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear or related WMD programs.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3322, "completion_tokens": 1883, "total_tokens": 5205, "reasoning_tokens": 1654 }, "cost_usd": 0.00820667, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.249594Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Reputable specialized reporting from Arms Control Association citing named official records (Duelfer/ISG reports, White House statements, UN inspections) with clear sourcing and editorial standards; secondary rather than primary or peer-reviewed.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house press secretary" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un weapons inspectors" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable specialized reporting from Arms Control Association citing named official records (Duelfer/ISG reports, White House statements, UN inspections) with clear sourcing and editorial standards; secondary rather than primary or peer-reviewed.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports UN inspectors' pre-war finding of no evidence that Iraq had reconstituted its WMD programs (explicitly including nuclear) and contrasts it with administration claims of an active nuclear program.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.6,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports UN inspectors found no evidence Iraq had reconstituted its nuclear or related WMD programs prior to the 2003 invasion.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"duelfer report 2004\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq survey group\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house press secretary\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"un weapons inspectors\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 989, "completion_tokens": 554, "total_tokens": 1543, "reasoning_tokens": 498 }, "cost_usd": 0.00241965, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.249594Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official declassified U.S. government exhibit (justice.gov) consisting of a 2003 OVP memo that directly quotes and cites a CIA paper plus congressional notifications; primary record with named institutional sourcing rather than secondary journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.3, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "new yorker article sy hersh" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "british white paper september 2002" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official declassified U.S. government exhibit (justice.gov) consisting of a 2003 OVP memo that directly quotes and cites a CIA paper plus congressional notifications; primary record with named institutional sourcing rather than secondary journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document discusses intelligence doubts on the specific Iraq-Niger uranium deal but does not address overall nuclear weapons program reconstitution by March 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.3, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document highlights CIA doubts and rejection of Iraq-Niger uranium reports that were cited in the NIE as evidence of nuclear procurement efforts.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia paper april 3 2003\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"new yorker article sy hersh\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"national intelligence estimate october 2002\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"british white paper september 2002\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3857, "completion_tokens": 1915, "total_tokens": 5772, "reasoning_tokens": 1647 }, "cost_usd": 0.00901997061125, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.249741Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "chem", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary encyclopedia aggregating public records with variable editorial standards and citation requirements; the excerpt shows reliance on UN resolutions but includes multiple [citation needed] markers indicating incomplete sourcing.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary encyclopedia aggregating public records with variable editorial standards and citation requirements; the excerpt shows reliance on UN resolutions but includes multiple [citation needed] markers indicating incomplete sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes the mandate and history of the UNMOVIC inspection commission but contains no reporting or data on actual Iraqi chemical-weapon holdings in 2003.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses UNMOVIC's creation and access issues through late 2002 but contains no observations or claims about Iraqi chemical weapons stockpiles in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3559, "completion_tokens": 3593, "total_tokens": 7152, "reasoning_tokens": 3375 }, "cost_usd": 0.013881036, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.249843Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary encyclopedia aggregating public records with variable editorial standards and citation requirements; the excerpt shows reliance on UN resolutions but includes multiple [citation needed] markers indicating incomplete sourcing.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary encyclopedia aggregating public records with variable editorial standards and citation requirements; the excerpt shows reliance on UN resolutions but includes multiple [citation needed] markers indicating incomplete sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt covers the pre-2003 history and mandate of the UNMOVIC inspection regime for Iraqi WMDs but reports nothing on actual 2003 biological stockpiles or production.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes UNMOVIC's mandate and pre-2003 history but contains no observations or claims about Iraqi biological weapons stockpiles or production in March 2003.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3567, "completion_tokens": 3769, "total_tokens": 7336, "reasoning_tokens": 3546 }, "cost_usd": 0.014263836, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.249947Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary encyclopedia aggregating public records with variable editorial standards and citation requirements; the excerpt shows reliance on UN resolutions but includes multiple [citation needed] markers indicating incomplete sourcing.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 687" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unscom" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary encyclopedia aggregating public records with variable editorial standards and citation requirements; the excerpt shows reliance on UN resolutions but includes multiple [citation needed] markers indicating incomplete sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt covers the pre-2003 history and mandate of the UNMOVIC inspection regime for Iraqi WMDs but reports nothing on actual 2003 biological stockpiles or production.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document discusses UNMOVIC's pre-2003 mandate and Iraq's non-cooperation but offers no findings or assertions on actual 2003 stockpiles or production.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1284\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 687\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un security council resolution 1441\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unscom\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1006, "completion_tokens": 621, "total_tokens": 1627, "reasoning_tokens": 559 }, "cost_usd": 0.0026084, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.249947Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary encyclopedia relying on secondary sourcing and volunteer editing rather than primary records or official inquiry; citations are present but the publisher has no peer-review process or track record as an authoritative evidence source on this topic.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "office of the vice president" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary encyclopedia relying on secondary sourcing and volunteer editing rather than primary records or official inquiry; citations are present but the publisher has no peer-review process or track record as an authoritative evidence source on this topic.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes Powell's Feb 2003 WMD presentation (focused on chemical weapons and general violations) but does not address nuclear reconstitution specifically.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes Powell's Feb 2003 assertions about chemical WMD production and general WMD activity but contains no reference to nuclear weapons or a reconstituted nuclear program.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of state february 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"office of the vice president\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3437, "completion_tokens": 1869, "total_tokens": 5306, "reasoning_tokens": 1636 }, "cost_usd": 0.00845567, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.250082Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary encyclopedia relying on secondary sourcing and volunteer editing rather than primary records or official inquiry; citations are present but the publisher has no peer-review process or track record as an authoritative evidence source on this topic.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, { "type": "author_group", "id": "office of the vice president" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary encyclopedia relying on secondary sourcing and volunteer editing rather than primary records or official inquiry; citations are present but the publisher has no peer-review process or track record as an authoritative evidence source on this topic.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes Powell's Feb 2003 WMD presentation (focused on chemical weapons and general violations) but does not address nuclear reconstitution specifically.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt addresses general WMD claims (esp. chemical) in Powell's Feb 2003 presentation but does not mention nuclear weapons or reconstitution.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of state february 2003\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"cia\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"author_group\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"office of the vice president\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"united nations security council\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1019, "completion_tokens": 784, "total_tokens": 1803, "reasoning_tokens": 732 }, "cost_usd": 0.00303215, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T02:28:12.250082Z" } ], "runs": [ { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "leaf_results": [ { "leaf_id": "chem", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -2.4313115019113605, "probability": 0.08081598902855641, "evidence_mass": 3.5719218749999997, "mass_for": 0.27999999999999997, "mass_against": 2.255796875, "mass_mixed": 0.734125, "contested_shrink": 0.7754915780671365, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.14579193230186752, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.024299711877729266, "clusters": [ { "id": "chem:c1", "root": { "type": "author_group", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68" ] }, { "id": "chem:c2", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2" ] }, { "id": "chem:c3", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9", "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9" ] }, { "id": "chem:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9" ] }, { "id": "chem:c5", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b" ] }, { "id": "chem:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, "member_item_ids": [ "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe" ] }, { "id": "chem:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4" ] }, { "id": "chem:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0" ] }, { "id": "chem:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e" ] }, { "id": "chem:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf" ] }, { "id": "chem:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "chem:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.9, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.3429999999999999, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.11199999999999999, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": true }, { "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.063, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.03125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 6, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.24499999999999997, "independence": 0.015625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": -0.006124999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.0078125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 8, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.00245, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 0.00390625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 9, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.0006124999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.1199999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.24499999999999997, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "chem:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "chem:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.6859999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.39199999999999996, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.055999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "bio", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -4.397864836566569, "probability": 0.012154043761453424, "evidence_mass": 5.02175, "mass_for": 0.532, "mass_against": 3.6397500000000007, "mass_mixed": 0.532, "contested_shrink": 0.8868987509965455, "one_sided": false, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.06270609041761985, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.014439613776016907, "clusters": [ { "id": "bio:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8" ] }, { "id": "bio:c2", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2" ] }, { "id": "bio:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9" ] }, { "id": "bio:c4", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b" ] }, { "id": "bio:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad" ] }, { "id": "bio:c6", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5" ] }, { "id": "bio:c7", "root": { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929" ] }, { "id": "bio:c8", "root": { "type": "author_group", "id": "bush administration" }, "member_item_ids": [ "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74" ] }, { "id": "bio:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, "member_item_ids": [ "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe" ] }, { "id": "bio:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" }, "member_item_ids": [ "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641" ] }, { "id": "bio:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4" ] }, { "id": "bio:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush state of the union 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa" ] }, { "id": "bio:c13", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b" ] }, { "id": "bio:c14", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71" ] }, { "id": "bio:c15", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "bio:c16", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e" ] }, { "id": "bio:c17", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.45, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.22049999999999997, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.055999999999999994, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.0196, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.3429999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.048999999999999995, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.6859999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.504, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.3024, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.24499999999999997, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": -0.3429999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.24499999999999997, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": -0.29399999999999993, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": true }, { "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c14", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c16", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c17", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "nuke", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -3.8372314268267864, "probability": 0.021098451461866008, "evidence_mass": 5.380999999999999, "mass_for": 0.48600000000000004, "mass_against": 3.3840000000000003, "mass_mixed": 1.0429999999999997, "contested_shrink": 0.7877060858945656, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.094287060401294, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0870853097249474, "clusters": [ { "id": "nuke:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, "member_item_ids": [ "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "arms control association" }, "member_item_ids": [ "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c8", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell interview february 2016" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c14", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council meeting february 5 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c15", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.71, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.39199999999999996, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.504, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.1764, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.6859999999999998, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.055999999999999994, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.1372, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": true }, { "item_id": "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.3429999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": -0.48019999999999985, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.2744, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "nuke:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.024000000000000004, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.3136, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.2744, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c14", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false } ] } ], "node_results": [ { "node_id": "wmd", "probability": 0.1111454432258514, "from_children": [ "chem", "bio", "nuke" ] }, { "node_id": "root", "probability": 0.1111454432258514, "from_children": [ "wmd" ] } ], "verdict": { "label": "refuted", "probability": 0.1111454432258514, "log_odds": -2.079093975999459, "evidence_mass": 3.5719218749999997, "insufficient": false, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null }, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "cache_hits": 0 }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "leaf_results": [ { "leaf_id": "chem", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -2.757724908181866, "probability": 0.05965185608832897, "evidence_mass": 2.8909374999999997, "mass_for": 0.076125, "mass_against": 1.9489999999999998, "mass_mixed": 0.30624999999999997, "contested_shrink": 0.8686397512197737, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.16404180753013076, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.09841154667077541, "clusters": [ { "id": "chem:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68" ] }, { "id": "chem:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b" ] }, { "id": "chem:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9" ] }, { "id": "chem:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9" ] }, { "id": "chem:c5", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9" ] }, { "id": "chem:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e" ] }, { "id": "chem:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0" ] }, { "id": "chem:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, "member_item_ids": [ "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe" ] }, { "id": "chem:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4" ] }, { "id": "chem:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "chem:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf" ] }, { "id": "chem:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.8819999999999999, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.44099999999999995, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.23274999999999996, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.24499999999999997, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": -0.05512499999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.03125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 6, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.45, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.005512499999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 0.015625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 0.0078125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 8, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.0014, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.00390625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 9, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.86, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.602, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.7839999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "chem:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "chem:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.126, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.11200000000000002, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.055999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.024, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "bio", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -2.2930143292409038, "probability": 0.09170316611121548, "evidence_mass": 3.6445, "mass_for": 0.956, "mass_against": 2.0824999999999996, "mass_mixed": 0.301, "contested_shrink": 0.90986674651894, "one_sided": false, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.21291189848845848, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.044034681356784316, "clusters": [ { "id": "bio:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8" ] }, { "id": "bio:c2", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2" ] }, { "id": "bio:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9" ] }, { "id": "bio:c4", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b" ] }, { "id": "bio:c5", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5" ] }, { "id": "bio:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad" ] }, { "id": "bio:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, "member_item_ids": [ "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe" ] }, { "id": "bio:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" }, "member_item_ids": [ "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641" ] }, { "id": "bio:c9", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b" ] }, { "id": "bio:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "bio:c11", "root": { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929" ] }, { "id": "bio:c12", "root": { "type": "author_group", "id": "bush administration" }, "member_item_ids": [ "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74" ] }, { "id": "bio:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush state of the union 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa" ] }, { "id": "bio:c14", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71" ] }, { "id": "bio:c15", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4" ] }, { "id": "bio:c16", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e" ] }, { "id": "bio:c17", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.86, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.8427999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.4654999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.16624999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": -0.08312499999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.022049999999999997, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.9309999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.8819999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.76, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.29791999999999996, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.3024, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.43, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.12384000000000002, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.56, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.1568, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.084, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.084, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.1176, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.084, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.084, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c14", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.65, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.1092, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.048, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c16", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.024, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c17", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "nuke", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -3.2064, "probability": 0.038925588532553346, "evidence_mass": 3.9499999999999997, "mass_for": 0.8739999999999999, "mass_against": 2.466, "mass_mixed": 0.09799999999999999, "contested_shrink": 0.9714950552646888, "one_sided": false, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.15541012375959962, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.1466609772923883, "clusters": [ { "id": "nuke:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17", "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "arms control association" }, "member_item_ids": [ "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, "member_item_ids": [ "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c6", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell interview february 2016" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c14", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council meeting february 5 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c15", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.8, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.0784, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.3528, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.92, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.18031999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.6649999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.3429999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": -0.6173999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.39199999999999996, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.3136, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0448, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.048, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "nuke:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.55, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.15840000000000004, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.04800000000000001, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": true }, { "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.3136, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.35279999999999995, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": true }, { "item_id": "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.19039999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c14", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.028800000000000006, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] } ], "node_results": [ { "node_id": "wmd", "probability": 0.17913169659617667, "from_children": [ "chem", "bio", "nuke" ] }, { "node_id": "root", "probability": 0.17913169659617667, "from_children": [ "wmd" ] } ], "verdict": { "label": "leans_refuted", "probability": 0.17913169659617667, "log_odds": -1.5222414161077256, "evidence_mass": 2.8909374999999997, "insufficient": false, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null }, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "cache_hits": 0 }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "leaf_results": [ { "leaf_id": "chem", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -8.182043734568644, "probability": 0.0002795516955165942, "evidence_mass": 6.263984375, "mass_for": 0.27999999999999997, "mass_against": 5.157500000000001, "mass_mixed": 0.39098437500000005, "contested_shrink": 0.9329183455175686, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.006514135526528214, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.005595709682483733, "clusters": [ { "id": "chem:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e" ] }, { "id": "chem:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9" ] }, { "id": "chem:c3", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2" ] }, { "id": "chem:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9" ] }, { "id": "chem:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0" ] }, { "id": "chem:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, "member_item_ids": [ "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe" ] }, { "id": "chem:c7", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b" ] }, { "id": "chem:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "chem:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e" ] }, { "id": "chem:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4" ] }, { "id": "chem:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf" ] }, { "id": "chem:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.8, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.9, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.27999999999999997, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.175, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.063, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 0.03125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 6, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.03125, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 0.015625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 7, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.015625, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 0.0078125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 8, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.0034999999999999996, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.00390625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 9, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.63, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "chem:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "chem:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.4, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.5, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.9, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.44799999999999995, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "bio", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -7.644214032869784, "probability": 0.00047857734252256407, "evidence_mass": 7.33925, "mass_for": 0.82, "mass_against": 5.33125, "mass_mixed": 0.77, "contested_shrink": 0.888748419721871, "one_sided": false, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.010099544471248181, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.00493978719338575, "clusters": [ { "id": "bio:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8" ] }, { "id": "bio:c2", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2" ] }, { "id": "bio:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush state of the union 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa" ] }, { "id": "bio:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9" ] }, { "id": "bio:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad" ] }, { "id": "bio:c6", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b" ] }, { "id": "bio:c7", "root": { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929" ] }, { "id": "bio:c8", "root": { "type": "author_group", "id": "bush administration" }, "member_item_ids": [ "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74" ] }, { "id": "bio:c9", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b" ] }, { "id": "bio:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, "member_item_ids": [ "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe" ] }, { "id": "bio:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71" ] }, { "id": "bio:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" }, "member_item_ids": [ "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641" ] }, { "id": "bio:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "bio:c14", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5" ] }, { "id": "bio:c15", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4" ] }, { "id": "bio:c16", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e" ] }, { "id": "bio:c17", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.8, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.9, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.35, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.175, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.0625, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.4, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.7, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.13999999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.1199999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.5599999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": -0.5599999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.3, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.48, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.3, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.6, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.2, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.36000000000000004, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.2, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.32000000000000006, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c14", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.23040000000000005, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c16", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c17", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "nuke", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -5.9235573859851, "probability": 0.0026685247759901426, "evidence_mass": 8.5715, "mass_for": 1.6660000000000001, "mass_against": 5.316, "mass_mixed": 1.2735, "contested_shrink": 0.845739204166919, "one_sided": false, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.019864217600871932, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0991135362130574, "clusters": [ { "id": "nuke:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, "member_item_ids": [ "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell interview february 2016" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c4", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "arms control association" }, "member_item_ids": [ "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council meeting february 5 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c14", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c15", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.8, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.7, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.008, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.13999999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.8, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.2, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.16000000000000003, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.22399999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "nuke:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.5760000000000001, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.32400000000000007, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.1199999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.36000000000000004, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.11199999999999999, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.6480000000000001, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.3136, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.3136, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c14", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] } ], "node_results": [ { "node_id": "wmd", "probability": 0.003424497297814577, "from_children": [ "chem", "bio", "nuke" ] }, { "node_id": "root", "probability": 0.003424497297814577, "from_children": [ "wmd" ] } ], "verdict": { "label": "refuted", "probability": 0.003424497297814577, "log_odds": -5.673370218091337, "evidence_mass": 6.263984375, "insufficient": false, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null }, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "cache_hits": 0 }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "leaf_results": [ { "leaf_id": "chem", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -4.597250480114165, "probability": 0.009978928769720943, "evidence_mass": 4.998234375, "mass_for": 0.27999999999999997, "mass_against": 3.5757656250000003, "mass_mixed": 0.7599375, "contested_shrink": 0.8353582369966656, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.06752587640504121, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.03339284730125997, "clusters": [ { "id": "chem:c1", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa" ] }, { "id": "chem:c2", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2" ] }, { "id": "chem:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9" ] }, { "id": "chem:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9" ] }, { "id": "chem:c5", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b" ] }, { "id": "chem:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, "member_item_ids": [ "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe" ] }, { "id": "chem:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0" ] }, { "id": "chem:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e" ] }, { "id": "chem:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "chem:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4" ] }, { "id": "chem:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf" ] }, { "id": "chem:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.1199999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.63, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.35, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.125, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.05512499999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 0.03125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 6, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.0045000000000000005, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.015625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.0078125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 8, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.1, "independence": 0.00390625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 9, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.0007031250000000001, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.45, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "chem:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "chem:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.1199999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.44799999999999995, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.2, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.32000000000000006, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.2, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.32000000000000006, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "bio", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -4.923699343767726, "probability": 0.007219675961869562, "evidence_mass": 5.42875, "mass_for": 0.352, "mass_against": 3.89375, "mass_mixed": 0.602, "contested_shrink": 0.8758186787685008, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.057307068206934736, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.02039813121722372, "clusters": [ { "id": "bio:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8" ] }, { "id": "bio:c2", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2" ] }, { "id": "bio:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9" ] }, { "id": "bio:c4", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b" ] }, { "id": "bio:c5", "root": { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929" ] }, { "id": "bio:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad" ] }, { "id": "bio:c7", "root": { "type": "author_group", "id": "bush administration" }, "member_item_ids": [ "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74" ] }, { "id": "bio:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush state of the union 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa" ] }, { "id": "bio:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, "member_item_ids": [ "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe" ] }, { "id": "bio:c10", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b" ] }, { "id": "bio:c11", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5" ] }, { "id": "bio:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71" ] }, { "id": "bio:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "bio:c14", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" }, "member_item_ids": [ "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641" ] }, { "id": "bio:c15", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4" ] }, { "id": "bio:c16", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e" ] }, { "id": "bio:c17", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.7, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.315, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.10412499999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.2, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.022500000000000003, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.19, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.44099999999999995, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.2, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.020000000000000004, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.9799999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.44799999999999995, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.028800000000000006, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.21, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.21, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.21, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.336, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.2, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.24, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.16000000000000003, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.16000000000000003, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.12, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.12, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c14", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c16", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c17", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "nuke", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -4.6545225979243385, "probability": 0.009428709528732862, "evidence_mass": 6.69, "mass_for": 0.9000000000000001, "mass_against": 4.101999999999999, "mass_mixed": 0.972, "contested_shrink": 0.8372949447606295, "one_sided": false, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.062209793514520044, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.09916043132716143, "clusters": [ { "id": "nuke:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "arms control association" }, "member_item_ids": [ "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c6", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, "member_item_ids": [ "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell interview february 2016" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c14", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council meeting february 5 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c15", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.8, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.595, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.36000000000000004, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.21600000000000003, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.1199999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.1199999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.6859999999999998, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.6859999999999998, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.055999999999999994, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.504, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.43200000000000005, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "nuke:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c14", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.25, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.055999999999999994, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] } ], "node_results": [ { "node_id": "wmd", "probability": 0.026393788267755625, "from_children": [ "chem", "bio", "nuke" ] }, { "node_id": "root", "probability": 0.026393788267755625, "from_children": [ "wmd" ] } ], "verdict": { "label": "refuted", "probability": 0.026393788267755625, "log_odds": -3.607878232243151, "evidence_mass": 4.998234375, "insufficient": false, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null }, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "cache_hits": 0 }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "leaf_results": [ { "leaf_id": "chem", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -4.618420928957469, "probability": 0.009771933593158028, "evidence_mass": 4.363734375, "mass_for": 0.27999999999999997, "mass_against": 3.45375, "mass_mixed": 0.2559375, "contested_shrink": 0.9358502388971568, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.056970528496902616, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0256567944002445, "clusters": [ { "id": "chem:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c" ] }, { "id": "chem:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b" ] }, { "id": "chem:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e" ] }, { "id": "chem:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9" ] }, { "id": "chem:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9" ] }, { "id": "chem:c6", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b" ] }, { "id": "chem:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0" ] }, { "id": "chem:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, "member_item_ids": [ "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe" ] }, { "id": "chem:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4" ] }, { "id": "chem:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "chem:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf" ] }, { "id": "chem:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.45, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.225, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.3, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.0675, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.0315, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 0.03125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 6, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.006999999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3d73d55dcda830bef2e7c8869ed15e819cdf31971bcfff40a33d06b2e3fb130e", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.015625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.09799999999999999, "independence": 0.0078125, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 8, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 0.00390625, "cluster_id": "chem:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 9, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.8, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.39199999999999996, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a31ea445d68e8b6bbdf7f79231c4decabaa455dfc017e42369cb36935de7ce9e", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.8, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.96, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b84744d17e83ec1b23affaf04d36af26ba82d47355e9eeb7e5a3b8dff8042ca9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "72594ffef9e77d552a96953e4a080ff73bc1ddd2d55d5a1806ecad4fcb21003c", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "chem:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "bc896f5d1232a0d1d19d30a285023fec17366b41a3dbea46a0ba76ca4fdc34f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "chem:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.6859999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "515d5950d5aea4972bec29c472b5fcdbacc089cd82e8a5b7e3d38300238325b9", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.39199999999999996, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "chem:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "cfce35e961ab59926707e11f565cc3cde8226db92904b6776edfaf5ffc71daf0", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.2, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.32000000000000006, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.12800000000000003, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "chem", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "chem:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "bio", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -5.132880099379563, "probability": 0.005864944206296127, "evidence_mass": 4.93725, "mass_for": 0.35, "mass_against": 3.7762500000000006, "mass_mixed": 0.42699999999999994, "contested_shrink": 0.9062208312743645, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.03363196823689021, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.01935933428164205, "clusters": [ { "id": "bio:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8" ] }, { "id": "bio:c2", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2" ] }, { "id": "bio:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush state of the union 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9" ] }, { "id": "bio:c4", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb" ] }, { "id": "bio:c5", "root": { "type": "author_group", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929" ] }, { "id": "bio:c6", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "iaea" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5" ] }, { "id": "bio:c7", "root": { "type": "author_group", "id": "bush administration" }, "member_item_ids": [ "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74" ] }, { "id": "bio:c8", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b" ] }, { "id": "bio:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad" ] }, { "id": "bio:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "senate select committee on intelligence 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4" ] }, { "id": "bio:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush state of the union 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa" ] }, { "id": "bio:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71" ] }, { "id": "bio:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1441" }, "member_item_ids": [ "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe" ] }, { "id": "bio:c14", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" }, "member_item_ids": [ "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641" ] }, { "id": "bio:c15", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "bio:c16", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e" ] }, { "id": "bio:c17", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council resolution 1284" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.5, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.45, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "117a91cda7172449c41f95ab6f18a9025a61280baab0acc1c342e126c29140c8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.22049999999999997, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "168d8f43e8d65ef080e7f8b8eb4f24de4f9b4f0c24851deae513c3ed7d39fdf8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.07875, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "bio:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.009799999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "0a61d34a28b7fe3deac05c257d993d4428c2c976a48f81a22f4c94c31d590981", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.3429999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "581caca32038c5c05fd41dddfd5b5e1c19073889f4009dcc3d655383066564b2", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "bio:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9516ec3320713facbb423f505488b940bf53a3a9559057ba70a8acef0e9fe8f9", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.9799999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "349e44dd9d5f21f6098a464f92eb6e51ac87a9d36ec6584cbe55b0dfb946140b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b7cbebe1aa35c27bcb7e372a1d2e0a683c7f09c011cd1cf73a443ec4d278f8bb", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "bio:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.1372, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "40ee224d024102341836832312bb7fd010d70c36193d4587bd41f1354bb43929", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.5599999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.4032, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7e457747f1219f7e3ebfd7685e84284231b4c2a0a329eed36387c407243bef74", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.21, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.336, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.2, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.36000000000000004, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a1eb44e716ee2d077d368dc60027e985d89f76049b3523304e3c98ed4d2b41ad", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5c96dd0a626a25297f38b58c278779acf6f7dfe3914cc2a1d84ada9afd75afc4", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.084, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.1176, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.084, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.1008, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "206115c91b76b808d76ace6e8cd4c26b83c2edfe3c05fc65b2dad31b910e2afe", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.12800000000000003, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "382a22e6dbd9253f855b9240e5838fe47fae210488f8be04863346994d7c6641", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c14", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.048, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c16", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f91a1415a2fe69892d2e937c38915666365c7455593281f42eb650f7dc7756bf", "leaf_id": "bio", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "bio:c17", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "nuke", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": -4.611112664683382, "probability": 0.009842905551657176, "evidence_mass": 5.144, "mass_for": 0.36000000000000004, "mass_against": 3.653, "mass_mixed": 0.6930000000000001, "contested_shrink": 0.8527411814704632, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.05060032804438428, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0896642747664317, "clusters": [ { "id": "nuke:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq survey group" }, "member_item_ids": [ "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bush administration" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national intelligence estimate october 2002" }, "member_item_ids": [ "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c4", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "duelfer report 2004" }, "member_item_ids": [ "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "arms control association" }, "member_item_ids": [ "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us state department 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unmovic" }, "member_item_ids": [ "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hans blix" }, "member_item_ids": [ "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell un presentation 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "colin powell interview february 2016" }, "member_item_ids": [ "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "carnegie endowment for international peace" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un security council meeting february 5 2003" }, "member_item_ids": [ "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cnn" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c14", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "national security directive 54" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40" ] }, { "id": "nuke:c15", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "cia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "bb9dd71f3d0e714ccbf11eac3fb795fc95c2002a340ea4a3a1afd4b4254e8bac", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.62, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6bf0c1bdaa2d58375400ce8ed19a1fc9fa90ce0086a49a0cc8e71de43c3378d1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.44099999999999995, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1ea73aaf2776bb111e46c07b84b6dac8d42bb1263be2d61dd463968a38fb8e17", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "nuke:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c142c83d1da891f889d0c55f6d0080b1892940c19a4f17e1efb9721735d5660d", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2c454b7f5cb6ab8573d5e60358a4bf4f51c487ae4e3e53835c4c251621f2c580", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.43200000000000005, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.7839999999999999, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "253b0bd877bd13b0e987144ad202bdb22cad4ea2ecfd384d5399d96b6531d8c2", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "db19c9791d97ce1f0e54ccfd76771e95049e76d794e184315bc75fc027c48fa4", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.7839999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a24578c90a90e2f614eb118130823ba058227f9413b9f9550e2fefcd349390d5", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "518dc25d423d4972d161318f22b3167a3502eae36d213c94895413b0b7293b26", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "23f96a4d25335bea253053441e29f58f8f2a2ed9db02a685f843caf9523e06ee", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "26572702b4608d85bb0725b490a065841a506ec1f5bff435b74fba73e45dd2f1", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.33599999999999997, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "96d433a084595f905fa34817074fad8f9958cf4d12ab03f52702314b7d2bdee8", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "29c86b12f79676a208df94513483400bb1e0a51fe70081dbc7e84543c0b5422a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.024, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "nuke:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5ce13f1d3b5bd28512bb4307a0be2587f7169e28a89aa986cd3420477e5f2202", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.3136, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ad00eac77a90d64cc07f4894b3dfc1c9713c81758ea74c3a5533af4037022a76", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.1568, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6239f7b746b93df7a41406cf0540d0ddc6e46e931e6cd1585c4b3361a496b99a", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.084, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.1008, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3f4c05dfbeb5977380a93d59bc5241870caa06a4ef9bd8ff73dad26022431a40", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c14", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ddeb81ee0f1e1d6c37fedffbf2f0a996e0b48023da9a29ae8e9df9956085de0f", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "nuke:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.3, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.0432, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": "nuke", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "nuke:c15", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] } ], "node_results": [ { "node_id": "wmd", "probability": 0.0252691233095772, "from_children": [ "chem", "bio", "nuke" ] }, { "node_id": "root", "probability": 0.0252691233095772, "from_children": [ "wmd" ] } ], "verdict": { "label": "refuted", "probability": 0.0252691233095772, "log_odds": -3.652578181123922, "evidence_mass": 4.363734375, "insufficient": false, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null }, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "cache_hits": 0 } ], "comparison": { "models": [ "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "x-ai/grok-4.3" ], "per_model": [ { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "label": "refuted", "probability": 0.1111454432258514, "log_odds": -2.079093975999459, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "judgments": 75, "items_scored": 55, "polarity_checked": 10, "polarity_inconsistent": 3, "polarity_rate": 0.3 }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "label": "leans_refuted", "probability": 0.17913169659617667, "log_odds": -1.5222414161077256, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "judgments": 75, "items_scored": 55, "polarity_checked": 10, "polarity_inconsistent": 2, "polarity_rate": 0.2 }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "label": "refuted", "probability": 0.003424497297814577, "log_odds": -5.673370218091337, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "judgments": 75, "items_scored": 55, "polarity_checked": 10, "polarity_inconsistent": 0, "polarity_rate": 0.0 }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "label": "refuted", "probability": 0.026393788267755625, "log_odds": -3.607878232243151, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "judgments": 75, "items_scored": 55, "polarity_checked": 10, "polarity_inconsistent": 0, "polarity_rate": 0.0 }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "label": "refuted", "probability": 0.0252691233095772, "log_odds": -3.652578181123922, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "judgments": 75, "items_scored": 55, "polarity_checked": 10, "polarity_inconsistent": 0, "polarity_rate": 0.0 } ], "leaves": [ { "leaf_id": "chem", "log_odds": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": -2.4313115019113605, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": -2.757724908181866, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": -8.182043734568644, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": -4.597250480114165, "x-ai/grok-4.3": -4.618420928957469 }, "probability": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.08081598902855641, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.05965185608832897, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.0002795516955165942, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.009978928769720943, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.009771933593158028 }, "evidence_mass": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 3.5719218749999997, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 2.8909374999999997, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 6.263984375, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 4.998234375, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 4.363734375 }, "spread": 5.750732232657284, "mean_pairwise_disagreement": 2.672432097218034, "consensus_log_odds": -4.597250480114165, "consensus_probability": 0.009978928769720943, "consensus_mass": 4.363734375, "consensus_insufficient": false }, { "leaf_id": "bio", "log_odds": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": -4.397864836566569, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": -2.2930143292409038, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": -7.644214032869784, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": -4.923699343767726, "x-ai/grok-4.3": -5.132880099379563 }, "probability": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.012154043761453424, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.09170316611121548, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.00047857734252256407, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.007219675961869562, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.005864944206296127 }, "evidence_mass": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 5.02175, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 3.6445, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 7.33925, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 5.42875, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 4.93725 }, "spread": 5.351199703628881, "mean_pairwise_disagreement": 2.287482934014151, "consensus_log_odds": -4.923699343767726, "consensus_probability": 0.007219675961869562, "consensus_mass": 5.02175, "consensus_insufficient": false }, { "leaf_id": "nuke", "log_odds": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": -3.8372314268267864, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": -3.2064, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": -5.9235573859851, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": -4.6545225979243385, "x-ai/grok-4.3": -4.611112664683382 }, "probability": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.021098451461866008, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.038925588532553346, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.0026685247759901426, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.009428709528732862, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.009842905551657176 }, "evidence_mass": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 5.380999999999999, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 3.9499999999999997, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 8.5715, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 6.69, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 5.144 }, "spread": 2.7171573859850997, "mean_pairwise_disagreement": 1.2503211886135503, "consensus_log_odds": -4.611112664683382, "consensus_probability": 0.009842905551657176, "consensus_mass": 5.380999999999999, "consensus_insufficient": false } ], "mean_pairwise_disagreement": 2.0700787399485785, "max_spread_leaf": "chem", "labels_agree": false, "coverage_complete": true, "quality_disagreements": [ { "item_id": "b6cc66f9e832faf2849e76b4aed8423d11668cc82f1f67fd507ca09f11e18644", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.0, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.9, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.0, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.0, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.0 }, "spread": 0.9 }, { "item_id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.7, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.9, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.3 }, "spread": 0.6000000000000001 }, { "item_id": "7ea9686720127701a0b22c92f94b14377058093c4c323377c408d53f972cc2fa", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.5, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.7, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.5, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.1, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.3 }, "spread": 0.6 }, { "item_id": "d7d95990faa47163805ce9d67bb8f5a115b12b459e84b52273fc86981011215f", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.7, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.7, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.5 }, "spread": 0.4 }, { "item_id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.5, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.3, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.7, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.3, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.3 }, "spread": 0.39999999999999997 }, { "item_id": "d4549b1cb38133d1969143cab18ae94685d6092613f9bcd18b24b72478cdef6e", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.5, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.3, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.7, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.5, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.3 }, "spread": 0.39999999999999997 }, { "item_id": "2680fb0916bfa755182b6865a8425018934960e0cb60327a153d59b118ba7a68", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.5, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.7, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.7, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.4 }, "spread": 0.29999999999999993 }, { "item_id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.9, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.7, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.9, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.9 }, "spread": 0.20000000000000007 }, { "item_id": "16c6227539b820c17c85fb76f68ce2dc6a39a94c9ffb447547f9bdf5273c9c6c", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.9, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.7, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.9, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.7 }, "spread": 0.20000000000000007 }, { "item_id": "1ccfb0cc69e99ab13e3b42a2514e93fcbcffd266f08ff541d21a5ef41b3fa9e8", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.7, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.7, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.7 }, "spread": 0.20000000000000007 } ], "direction_disagreements": [ { "item_id": "93ea734e6916dc2ddd11fc92a515c7dea46eef18505a950610d1a4209810bd1b", "leaf_id": "bio", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": -0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.7, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": -1.0, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": -0.5, "x-ai/grok-4.3": -0.9 }, "spread": 1.7 }, { "item_id": "c9e68dc16620badba1c40476b34181157b1096838e8884ca79c0d97a1db84e68", "leaf_id": "nuke", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": -0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.9, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.6, "x-ai/grok-4.3": -0.6 }, "spread": 1.6 }, { "item_id": "9fcc5d617d394d5362ce177a227537470d33f9bfc9eac0fc970523f1469c7c71", "leaf_id": "bio", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": -0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.65, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.8, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": -0.5, "x-ai/grok-4.3": -0.6 }, "spread": 1.5 }, { "item_id": "fdd1a6174176d13d96e0e297998b2a934c11b528c9701945827e983a49ff5512", "leaf_id": "nuke", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.0, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": -0.6, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.8, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.0, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.0 }, "spread": 1.4 }, { "item_id": "710a32db0111afd6c2e7b2cfa84948ab34249b50498d2076f32f712112aa3225", "leaf_id": "chem", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.0, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.45, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": -0.8, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.0, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.0 }, "spread": 1.25 }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "bio", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": -0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.0, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": -1.0, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": -0.9, "x-ai/grok-4.3": -0.7 }, "spread": 1.0 }, { "item_id": "dcde5d9ff3b1d9e0d6eb0dfe81b7bd6ff2f1d29da7a60162ef1ccadc61ea7e3b", "leaf_id": "chem", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": -0.8, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.0, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": -1.0, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": -0.9, "x-ai/grok-4.3": -0.8 }, "spread": 1.0 }, { "item_id": "8466c069fcd032d3bc51d2ea7af088bfd3f79ec6420b68610e8917f80bd001fa", "leaf_id": "bio", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": -0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.0, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": -0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": -0.8, "x-ai/grok-4.3": -0.7 }, "spread": 0.9 }, { "item_id": "12a33986b5f9fb85cdbd8f9139adcf3a6b68aabb5dc7c74f85883139cad0348c", "leaf_id": "chem", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.0, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.0, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": -0.8, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.0, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.0 }, "spread": 0.8 }, { "item_id": "194b988d0c6e0c69a09ef650a6b9a363917276ce9c8514611fd7c917ad546f85", "leaf_id": "nuke", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.7, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.8, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.5, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.0 }, "spread": 0.8 } ], "consensus_nodes": [ { "node_id": "wmd", "probability": 0.026800890537600264, "from_children": [ "chem", "bio", "nuke" ] }, { "node_id": "root", "probability": 0.026800890537600264, "from_children": [ "wmd" ] } ], "consensus_verdict": { "label": "refuted", "probability": 0.026800890537600264, "log_odds": -3.592153579868033, "evidence_mass": 4.363734375, "insufficient": false, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null } }, "baseline": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "baseline_v1", "probability": 0.05, "leaves": { "chem": 0.15, "bio": 0.2, "nuke": 0.02 }, "rationale": "Extensive post-invasion inspections and investigations (ISG, Duelfer Report) found no active WMD stockpiles or programs in Iraq as of March 2003. Iraq had destroyed its programs in the 1990s; while some ambiguity remained about past activities, no militarily significant quantities were discovered.", "cached": false, "cost_usd": 0.00093 }, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "baseline_v1", "probability": 0.08, "leaves": { "chem": 0.12, "bio": 0.08, "nuke": 0.03 }, "rationale": "Iraq did not have confirmed militarily significant chemical stockpiles, an active biological weapons program, or a reconstituted nuclear weapons program in March 2003 according to the postwar findings. The claim as a whole is therefore very unlikely to be true, even though Iraq had earlier WMD history and ambiguous concealment behavior.", "cached": false, "cost_usd": 0.000666 }, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "baseline_v1", "probability": 0.0, "leaves": { "chem": 0.0, "bio": 0.0, "nuke": 0.0 }, "rationale": "Extensive post-war investigations by the Iraq Survey Group concluded that Saddam Hussein had dismantled Iraq's active WMD programs years before the 2003 invasion, rendering the justifications false.", "cached": false, "cost_usd": 0.0002727 }, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "baseline_v1", "probability": 0.01, "leaves": { "chem": 0.01, "bio": 0.01, "nuke": 0.005 }, "rationale": "The 2004 Iraq Survey Group and later reviews found no militarily significant chemical or biological stockpiles and no reconstituted nuclear program in March 2003; Iraq's WMD capability had largely degraded after 1991.", "cached": false, "cost_usd": 0.0009966 }, "x-ai/grok-4.3": { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "baseline_v1", "probability": 0.05, "leaves": { "chem": 0.08, "bio": 0.05, "nuke": 0.02 }, "rationale": "Post-invasion inspections including the Iraq Survey Group found no militarily significant chemical or biological stockpiles and no reconstituted nuclear program by March 2003; the justification clause therefore fails on factual grounds.", "cached": false, "cost_usd": 0.00233715 } }, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null, "created_at": "2026-09-17T05:13:22.713603Z", "git_sha": "unknown" }