{ "schema_version": "1.5.0", "rubric_version": "1.2.0", "params": { "prior": 0.5, "scale": 2.0, "quality_exp": 1.0, "directness_exp": 1.0, "independence_discount": 0.5, "basis_weights": [ 1.0, 0.7, 0.4 ], "contested_pull": 1.0, "mixed_directness_min": 0.5, "side_mass_min": 0.5, "cluster_roots": "primary", "mass_min": 1.0, "verdict_thresholds": [ 0.15, 0.35, 0.65, 0.85 ], "and_leak": 0.0, "or_leak": 0.0, "max_pool_size": 25, "polarity_sample": 0.2, "queries_per_side": 2, "results_per_query": 10, "excerpt_chars": 2000, "strictness": 0.5 }, "profile": "public", "claim": { "slug": "surge-reduced-violence", "text": "The 2007 increase in US troop levels in Iraq, the surge, reduced violence in Iraq.", "submitted_text": "The surge worked", "paraphrased": true, "topic": "Violence levels in Iraq and US force posture, 2006-2008", "created_at": "2026-09-17T00:00:00Z" }, "tree": { "id": "root", "kind": "and", "tag": "empirical", "text": "Violence in Iraq fell after the surge, and the surge was a major cause of the fall", "reason": null, "children": [ { "id": "outcome", "kind": "leaf", "tag": "empirical", "text": "Civilian deaths and attacks in Iraq fell substantially between mid-2007 and mid-2008 from their 2006 and early-2007 levels", "reason": null, "children": [] }, { "id": "cause", "kind": "leaf", "tag": "empirical", "text": "The 2007 increase in US troop levels and the accompanying change in tactics was a major cause of the 2007-2008 decline in violence in Iraq, beyond what the Anbar Awakening, the Sadrist ceasefire and the completion of sectarian displacement in Baghdad would have produced on their own", "reason": null, "children": [] } ] }, "decomposed_by": "hand", "retrieval": { "search_backend": "ddg", "items_by_backend": { "ddg": 35 }, "pdf_pages_fetched_ok": 3, "queries_prompt_version": "queries_v1", "results_per_query": 10, "max_pool_size": 25, "excerpt_chars": 2000, "unique_urls": 60, "search_api_calls": 0, "live_fetches": 0, "fetch_errors": { "unsupported content type application/octet-stream": 2, "HTTP 403": 16, "HTTP 203": 1, "HTTP 404": 1, "too little text": 4, "HTTP 202": 1 }, "leaves": { "outcome": { "queries": { "for": [ "Iraq civilian deaths decline 2007 2008 official statistics", "Iraq security incidents drop mid-2007 mid-2008 report" ], "against": [ "Iraq violence remained high 2008 civilian casualties data", "criticism Iraq death toll statistics undercount 2007 2008" ] }, "search_hits": 40, "candidates": 33, "fetched_ok": 22, "pool": 22 }, "cause": { "queries": { "for": [ "Iraq surge 2007 troop increase counterinsurgency violence decline statistical analysis", "Baghdad security plan 2007 US troops sectarian violence reduction report" ], "against": [ "Iraq violence decline 2007 Anbar Awakening Sadr ceasefire displacement study", "surge Iraq 2007 not main cause violence decline scholarly" ] }, "search_hits": 34, "candidates": 28, "fetched_ok": 14, "pool": 14 } }, "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "api_calls": 0, "cache_hits": 2, "cost_usd": 0.0 }, "roots": { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "prompt_version": "roots_v1", "canon_prompt_version": "roots_canon_v2", "distinct_root_ids": 65, "canon_calls": 1, "groups": [ [ "department of defense", "us department of defense" ], [ "lancet 2006", "lancet study 2006", "second lancet mortality study 2006" ], [ "iraq body count", "iraq body count database" ], [ "iraq family health survey", "iraq family health survey 2008" ], [ "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey", "lancet iraq mortality survey 2006" ], [ "sigact", "sigacts" ] ], "aliases": { "department of defense": "department of defense", "us department of defense": "department of defense", "lancet 2006": "lancet 2006", "lancet study 2006": "lancet 2006", "second lancet mortality study 2006": "lancet 2006", "iraq body count": "iraq body count", "iraq body count database": "iraq body count", "iraq family health survey": "iraq family health survey", "iraq family health survey 2008": "iraq family health survey", "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey", "lancet iraq mortality survey 2006": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey", "sigact": "sigact", "sigacts": "sigact" }, "items_failed": 0, "api_calls": 1, "cache_hits": 35, "cost_usd": 0.009271 }, "judging": { "retrieval_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "per_model": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": { "api_calls": 117, "cache_hits": 0, "cost_usd": 0.149798, "cache_lookups": 117 }, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": { "api_calls": 117, "cache_hits": 0, "cost_usd": 0.101615, "cache_lookups": 117 }, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": { "api_calls": 117, "cache_hits": 0, "cost_usd": 0.045218, "cache_lookups": 117 }, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": { "api_calls": 117, "cache_hits": 0, "cost_usd": 0.113501, "cache_lookups": 117 }, "x-ai/grok-4.3": { "api_calls": 117, "cache_hits": 0, "cost_usd": 0.28063, "cache_lookups": 117 } }, "api_calls": 585, "cache_hits": 0, "cache_lookups": 623, "spent_usd": 0.690763, "budget_usd": 5.0, "budget_exceeded": false, "stopped_reason": null, "failed": [], "baseline_cost_usd": 0.00393, "rescored_to_rubric": "1.2.0", "rescored_from": "2026-09-17T03:52:27.173095+00:00" }, "pool": [ { "id": "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "url": "https://www.iraqbodycount.org/analysis/numbers/surge-2008/", "title": "Post-surge violence: its extent and nature :: Iraq Body Count", "publisher": "iraqbodycount.org", "published_at": "2008-12-28", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.219722Z", "excerpt": "Post-surge violence: its extent and nature\nAlongside its recording of civilian deaths from violence since the 2003 invasion, Iraq Body Count (IBC) has been cataloguing a range of analysable variables detailing victims and the composition of violent events.\nThis analysis is an early update on the \"post-surge\" year 2008, and what it may tell us about the most intractable features of the violence in US-occupied Iraq.\nNOTE: The graphs and some statistics on this page update dynamically as new data is processed. Graphs and comparative calculations are based on the upper figure in the IBC range. For more details see note 1.\nWhat the detailed data tell us about Iraq’s civilian death toll during 2008 and the long-term effect of the “surge”\nFirst published December 28th 2008\nIntroduction\nThis analysis looks at trends. But when examining the violence afflicting civilians in Iraq’s continuing conflict, a distinction must be drawn between abstractions represented by varying “rates” of violence and the reality of that violence for those experiencing it. Every statistic on this page can be traced to a human life violently ended, none of whom are any less a victim for having been killed during a “downward trend” in violence.\nWith only a few days of 2008 remaining, the year so far has seen another 8,315–9,028 civilian deaths added to the IBC database.1 This compares to 25,774–27,599 deaths reported in 2006, and 22,671–24,295 in 2007. This is a substantial drop on the preceding two years: on a per-day rate, it represents a reduction from 81 per day (2006) and 72 per day (2007) to 25 per day in 2008.\n1 Figure includes preliminary count of 381 deaths for Dec 1st-21st. IBC figures are not estimates but a firm baseline figure for documented deaths, backed up by an online database detailing each incident and, where possible, every victim. The range given accounts for residual uncertainty about civilian status, the final death toll in larger incidents, and the possible double-counting of ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "url": "https://www.iraqbodycount.org/database/", "title": "Iraq Body Count", "publisher": "iraqbodycount.org", "published_at": "2017-02-28", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:04.830304Z", "excerpt": "Documented civilian deaths from violence\n \n \n 187,499 –\n 211,046 \n \n Further analysis of the WikiLeaks' Iraq War Logs\n may add 10,000 civilian deaths.\n \n \n \nShow or compare \n per \n from \n to \nIn \n by \n using \n killing \n \nIn \n by \n using \n killing \n \n This data is based on 51,611 database entries from the beginning of the war to 28 Feb 2017, and on monthly preliminary\n data from that date onwards. Preliminary data is shown in grey when applicable, and is based on approximate\n daily totals in the Recent Events section prior to full analysis.\n The full analysis extracts details such as the names or demographic details of individuals killed, the weapons\n that killed them and location amongst other details.\n The current range\n contains 36,587–38,429 deaths (20%–18%,\n a portion which may rise or fall over time) based on single-sourced\n reports.\n \n \n Graphs are based on the higher number in our totals. Gaps in recording and reporting suggest that even our\n highest totals to date may be missing many civilian deaths from violence.\n \n \n Use the date picker to show database entries for any given day (currently limited to 19 Mar 2003–28 Feb 2017):\n \n \n \n Monthly civilian deaths from violence, 2003 onwards", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9", "url": "https://www.cjr.org/criticism/iraq_body_count.php", "title": "Are journalists lowballing the number of Iraqi war dead?", "publisher": "Columbia Journalism Review", "published_at": "2015-07-07", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.601384Z", "excerpt": "Sign up for the daily CJR newsletter.\nMore than a decade after the US invasion of Iraq, the country’s violent death rates are still frighteningly high; more than 300 Iraqis were killed last week, according to London-based NGO Iraq Body Count. The causes range from ubiquitous IED explosions in Baghdad to mass executions in Mosul, ISIS’s de facto Iraqi capital.\nBut this number likely doesn’t tell the full story.\nAnywhere from 135,000 Iraqi civilians to more than a million have perished since 2003, depending on the source you consult. In a study published in March, Physicians for Social Responsibility (PSR)—a group of doctors whose advocacy is informed by their medical training—argues for the higher end of this range. It also takes the mainstream press to task for failing to report higher casualty figures.\nCorrectly assessing the death toll is critical to recognizing the war’s legacy, as well as the sacrifice imposed on the population of a country that most everyone now agrees was invaded on flawed premises. A sanitized casualty count could also stunt the debate shaping public opinion and foreign policy in future conflicts.\n“Unfortunately, the media often portray passively collected figures as the most realistic aggregate number of war casualties,” the PSR report notes. So-called “passively collected figures” come from tabulating external reports or other existing material—like news articles, local television reports, and statistics from morgues—as opposed to original, newly acquired data. Where civilian deaths in Iraq are concerned, passive collection is the method used by a source frequently cited in mainstream press accounts: the aforementioned Iraq Body Count “has basically established itself as the ‘standard,'” according to the PSR report.\nIraq Body Count (or IBC) was cited more than 1,100 times in newspapers, according to a LexisNexis search covering March 2003 to the present. The organization-cum-database is administered by a private company based in the United ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraqi_civil_war_(2006%E2%80%932008)", "title": "Iraqi civil war (2006–2008) - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2005-08-03", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:20.995856Z", "excerpt": "The Iraqi civil war was an armed conflict from 2006 to 2008 between various sectarian Shia and Sunni armed groups, such as the Islamic State of Iraq and the Mahdi Army, in addition to the Iraqi government alongside American-led coalition forces.[17][18][19][20][21] In February 2006, the insurgency against the coalition and government escalated into a sectarian civil war after the bombing of Al-Askari Shrine, considered a holy site in Twelver Shi'ism. US President George W. Bush and Iraqi officials accused al-Qaeda in Iraq (AQI) of orchestrating the bombing. AQI publicly denied any links.[22] The incident set off a wave of attacks on Sunni civilians by Shia militants, followed by attacks on Shia civilians by Sunni militants.[23]\nThe UN Secretary General stated in September 2006 that if patterns of discord and violence continued, the Iraqi state was in danger of breaking up.[24] On 10 January 2007, Bush said that \"80% of Iraq's sectarian violence occurs within 30 miles (48 km) of the capital. This violence is splitting Baghdad into sectarian enclaves, and shakes the confidence of all Iraqis.\"[25] By late 2007, the National Intelligence Estimate described the conflict as having elements of a civil war.[26] In 2008, during the Sunni Awakening and the U.S. troop surge, violence declined dramatically.[27][28] However, an insurgency by ISI continued to plague Iraq following the U.S. withdrawal in late 2011.[29] In June 2014, the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, the successor to Islamic State of Iraq, launched a major military offensive against the Iraqi government and declared a self-proclaimed worldwide Islamic caliphate. This led to another full-scale war from 2013 to 2017, in which the Iraqi government declared victory.[30]\nIn October 2006, the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) and the Iraqi government estimated that more than 370,000 Iraqis had been displaced since 2006, bringing the total number of Iraqi refugees to more than 1.6", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7", "url": "https://collaborate.princeton.edu/en/publications/testing-the-surge-why-did-violence-decline-in-iraq-in-2007/", "title": "Testing the surge: Why did violence decline in Iraq in 2007?", "publisher": "Princeton University", "published_at": "2026-01-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:23.232219Z", "excerpt": "All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes\n- Sociology and Political Science\n- Political Science and International Relations\n- Law\nFingerprint\nDive into the research topics of 'Testing the surge: Why did violence decline in Iraq in 2007?'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.\nCite this\n- APA\n- Author\n- BIBTEX\n- Harvard\n- Standard\n- RIS\n- Vancouver", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9", "url": "https://www.pritzkermilitary.org/explore/topics/modern-wars-conflicts/iraq-war", "title": "Iraq War", "publisher": "pritzkermilitary.org", "published_at": "2026-05-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:24.119530Z", "excerpt": "Iraq War\nIraq War, 2003-2011\nThe Iraq War can also be referred to as the Occupation of Iraq, Operation Iraqi Freedom, Operation New Dawn, or the Second Gulf War. In 2002, President George W. Bush accused Iraq President Saddam Hussein of harboring terrorists from al-Qaeda and acquiring weapons of mass destruction. President Bush used these accusations to justify a war with Iraq.\nThe UN would not support the U.S. invasion of Iraq. On March 16, 2003, the United States warned UN weapons inspectors to leave Iraq. On March 20, 2003, the United States launched a war against Iraq (250,000 United States troops were supported by approximately 45,000 British, 2,000 Australian and 200 Polish combat forces).\nThe coalition forces occupied Iraq and captured Hussein, who the Iraqi Interim Government executed on December 30, 2006. But, the execution of Hussein, the occupation of Iraq by coalition forces, the strife among Sunni Arabs, Shiite Arabs, and Kurds, the disbanding of the Iraqi Army, and the banishing of the Ba’ath Party from public and government life led to more insurgency in Iraq. The ignited Sunni-Shiite conflict also allowed for the al-Qaeda faction to assume power amidst insurrection.\nIn 2005, the U.S. held elections to help implement Shiites into power. Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani won the election and took control of the government. But, Sunni-Shiite competition for control over neighborhoods continued until 2007. Violence decreased in 2007 for four reasons. First, Sunni militias turned to fighting against opposing Sunni groups rather than fighting coalition and Shiite forces. Second, the United States gave money to Sunni allies, called The Awakening, or Sons of Iraq. Next, General Petraeus increased troops by 20,000, called The Surge, to supply security to Baghdad and the Anbar Province. Last, in 2008, Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr called for his Mahdi army to ceasefire. These four reasons decreased violence inside Iraq’s borders and allowed for newly elected Pres", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "url": "https://info.publicintelligence.net/130269.pdf", "title": "130269.pdf", "publisher": "info.publicintelligence.net", "published_at": null, "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.216239Z", "excerpt": "CRS Report for Congress\nPrepared for Members and Committees of Congress \n \n \nIraqi Civilian, Police, and Security Forces \nCasualty Statistics \nHannah Fischer \nInformation Research Specialist \nSeptember 17, 2009 \nCongressional Research Service\n7-5700 \nwww.crs.gov \nR40824 \nIraqi Civilian, Police, and Security Forces Casualty Statistics \n \nCongressional Research Service \nSummary \nThis report presents various governmental and nongovernmental estimates of Iraqi civilian, \npolice, and security forces fatalities. The Iraq government is releasing increasingly regular data on \nthese deaths. The U.S. Department of Defense (DOD) releases the monthly pattern of Iraqi \ncivilian, police, and security forces deaths, and it regularly updates total U.S. military deaths and \nwounded statistics from Operation Iraqi Freedom (OIF), as reflected in CRS Report RS21578, \nIraq: U.S. Casualties, by Susan G. Chesser. Because the estimates contained in this report are \nbased on varying time periods and have been created using differing methodologies, readers \nshould exercise caution when using them and should look to them as guideposts rather than as \nstatements of fact. \nThis report will be updated as needed. \n \nIraqi Civilian, Police, and Security Forces Casualty Statistics \n \nCongressional Research Service \nContents \nIraqi Ministries Data .......................................................................................................... .........1 \nU.S. Department of Defense Data................................................................................................ 2 \nGovernment, Academic, Media, and Nonprofit Data....................................................................4 \n \nFigures \nFigure 1. Iraq Ministries: Civilian and Police/Security Forces Deaths ..........................................2 \nFigure 2. Department of Defense: Iraqi Civilian Deaths, January 2006 - May 2009......................3 \nFigure 3. Department of Defense: Iraq Security Forces Deaths, Janu", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "url": "https://archive.smallwarsjournal.com/index.php/jrnl/art/why-did-violence-decline-during-the-us-%E2%80%9Csurge%E2%80%9D-in-iraq", "title": "Why Did Violence Decline During the US “Surge” in Iraq?", "publisher": "archive.smallwarsjournal.com", "published_at": "2013-04-02", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:22.035005Z", "excerpt": "Introduction\nBy 2006 there was an extremely violent sectarian civil war in Iraq, with as many as 2700 to 3800 civilians being killed every month in the period from September 2006 to January 2007 with death squads roaming the streets of Baghdad.[1] In addition to civil war, there was a nationalist uprising against the foreign occupation, which by late autumn 2006 caused the US army 100 killed and 700 wounded on a monthly basis.[2] In response to the increased violence, the US government decided to send five additional brigades to Iraq, Baghdad being the main focus for the forces that arrived in the spring of 2007.[3]\nDuring the period of the “surge”, especially in the second part of 2007, violence decreased. By December 2007, the monthly average of Iraqi civilian deaths was approximately 500, while US army fatalities had shrunk to 23 killed per month.[4] In this essay I will assess why the US “surge” in Iraq succeeded and how successful it was. Because I define the success of the “surge” as the tactical success of reducing attacks and deaths in Iraq, I will focus on explaining why the level of violence in Iraq went down during 2007. I will argue that the US “surge” alone is not a satisfactory answer to this question. To explain why the “surge” succeeded, I will assess local factors specific to the conflict in Iraq, which interacted with the “surge” and helped bring about its success. Shiite victory in the Iraqi civil war, the defeated Sunni's decision to cooperate with the Americans in fighting extremist groups and the ceasefire of the Mahdi Army, will be evaluated as other factors that can be argued as being of equal importance to the US “surge” in reducing the violence in Iraq.\nDue to the limited length of this essay and many factors involved in the reduction of violence during the “surge”, I will focus primarily on why the “surge” succeeded, and will not look in-depth at the policies from 2003-2006 that led to the chaotic situation before the “surge”. Moreover, be", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anbar_campaign_(2003%E2%80%932011)", "title": "Anbar campaign (2003–2011) - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2008-09-16", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:14.811539Z", "excerpt": "The Anbar campaign consisted of fighting between the United States military, together with Iraqi security forces, and Sunni insurgents in the western Iraqi governorate of Al Anbar. The Iraq War lasted from 2003 to 2011, but the majority of the fighting and counterinsurgency campaign in Anbar took place between April 2004 and September 2007. Although the fighting initially featured heavy urban warfare primarily between insurgents and U.S. Marines, insurgents in later years focused on ambushing the American and Iraqi security forces with improvised explosive devices (IEDs), large scale attacks on combat outposts, and car bombings. Almost 9,000 Iraqis and 1,335 Americans were killed in the campaign, many in the Euphrates River Valley and the Sunni Triangle around the cities of Fallujah and Ramadi.[4]\nAl Anbar, the only Sunni-dominated province in Iraq, saw little fighting in the initial invasion. Following the fall of Baghdad it was occupied by the U.S. Army's 82nd Airborne Division. Violence began on 28 April 2003 when 17 Iraqis were killed in Fallujah by U.S. soldiers during an anti-American demonstration. In early 2004 the U.S. Army relinquished command of the governorate to the Marines. By April 2004 the governorate was in full-scale revolt. Savage fighting occurred in both Fallujah and Ramadi by the end of 2004, including the Second Battle of Fallujah. Violence escalated throughout 2005 and 2006 as the two sides struggled to secure the Western Euphrates River Valley. During this time, Al Qaeda in Iraq (AQI) became the governorate's main Sunni insurgent group and turned the provincial capital of Ramadi into its stronghold. The Marine Corps issued an intelligence report in late 2006 declaring that the governorate would be lost without a significant additional commitment of troops.\nIn August 2006, several tribes located in Ramadi and led by Sheikh Abdul Sattar Abu Risha began to form what would eventually become the Anbar Awakening, which later led to the tribes revo", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_War_troop_surge", "title": "Iraq War troop surge - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2007-01-05", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:14.622054Z", "excerpt": "In 2007, during the Iraq War, the George W. Bush administration increased the number of U.S. military combat troops in Iraq in order to provide security to Baghdad and Al Anbar Governorate.[5] The event has been called the troop surge or simply the surge.\nThe force surge was developed under the working title \"The New Way Forward\" and was announced in January 2007 by Bush during a television speech.[6][7] Bush ordered the deployment of more than 20,000 soldiers into Iraq (five additional brigades), and sent the majority of them into Baghdad.[6] He also extended the tour of most of the Army troops in country and some of the Marines already in Anbar.[6] The President described the overall objective as establishing a \"unified, democratic federal Iraq that can govern itself, defend itself, and sustain itself, and is an ally in the war on terror.\"[7] The major element of the strategy was a change in focus for the U.S. military \"to help Iraqis clear and secure neighborhoods, to help them protect the local population, and to help ensure that the Iraqi forces left behind are capable of providing the security\".[6] The President stated that the surge would then provide the time and conditions conducive to reconciliation between communities.[7]\nInitiated against strong domestic opposition and after the Republican defeat in the 2006 midterm elections, the surge was considered to be extremely difficult politically. One White House staffer explained the political rationale succinctly: \"If you're going to be a bear, be a grizzly.\"[8] In retrospect, Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama and other critics of the surge have argued that it was successful.[9][10]\nThe phrases \"New Way Forward\",[11][12] \"The New Way Forward\" and \"A new way forward in Iraq\"[13] were widely used by White House Press Secretary Tony Snow[14] and the news media prior to the President's speech on January 10, 2007, announcing the policy change. The US press also refers to the increase as a \"surge\" or \"Iraq troop surge\".", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "url": "https://costsofwar.watson.brown.edu/sites/default/files/papers/Crawford-Civilian-Death-and-Injury-Iraq-War-2003-2013.pdf", "title": "Crawford-Civilian-Death-and-Injury-Iraq-War-2003-2013.pdf", "publisher": "costsofwar.watson.brown.edu", "published_at": null, "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:10.014770Z", "excerpt": "1 \nCivilian Death and Injury in the Iraq War, 2003-2013 \n \nProfessor Neta C. Crawford1 \nBoston University \n \nCosts of War \nMarch 2013 \n \n \nSummary \n \n At a minimum, 134,000 civilians have been killed by war's violence since 2003 in \nIraq. But, as described below, many deaths in Iraq were unreported or unrecorded: thus, \nthis number, based on tallies of government and press reports, is an undercount. If a full \nrecording of Iraqi violent deaths due to war were to be made, the toll could be twice as \nhigh, according to Iraq Body Count (IBC), the one organization that has attempted to \ndocument all the violent deaths in Iraq that have resulted from the initiation of war ten \nyears ago. Thus, the toll of violent death due to war may be 250,000 or more people. \n The number of Iraqi men, women and children who been seriously injured in the \nwar is about the same as the number killed. \n In addition, many times the number killed by direct violence have likely died due \nto the effects of the destruction of Iraq's infrastructure. \n Some of these numbers are disputed: some officials might argue that this is an \nover-estimate of the effects of war on Iraqi civilians; many more would argue that these \nestimates are too cautious. \n But two facts are indisputable. First, direct violence continues to harm civilians in \nIraq. In other words, Iraq is still at war. And, second, the continued parlous state of Iraq's \nphysical infrastructure and public health system will lead to more indirect deaths over \nthe coming years despite efforts by governments, international organizations, and \ninternational humanitarian organizations such as the ICRC and Handicap International, to \nrepair Iraq's infrastructure. While much more research is needed on the health effects of \nwar on Iraqi civilians, and on the causes of both direct and indirect civilian death, injury, \nand illness, the need to repair Iraq's infrastructure is urgent. \n \n \nOverview of Direct Violent Death and Indirect Death \n \n When ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "url": "https://www.congress.gov/crs_external_products/RS/PDF/RS22537/RS22537.12.pdf", "title": "RS22537.12.pdf", "publisher": "congress.gov", "published_at": null, "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.210788Z", "excerpt": "Iraqi Civilian Casualties Estimates \nUpdated January 12, 2009 \nCongressional Research Service \nhttps://crsreports.congress.gov \nRS22537 \nIraqi Civilian Casualties Estimates \n \nCongressional Research Service \nSummary \nThis report presents various governmental and non-governmental estimates of Iraqi civilian \ndeaths. The Department of Defense (DOD) regularly updates total U.S. military deaths statistics \nfrom Operation Iraqi Freedom (OIF), as reflected in CRS Report RS21578, Iraq: U.S. Casualties, \nby Susan G. Chesser. However, no Iraqi or U.S. government office regularly releases publically \navailable statistics on Iraqi civilian deaths. Statistics on Iraqi civilian deaths are sometimes \navailable through alternative sources, such as nonprofit organizations, or through statements \nmade by officials to the press. Because these estimates are based on varying time periods and \nhave been created using differing methodologies, readers should exercise caution when using \nthese statistics and should look on them as guideposts rather than as statements of fact. See also \nCRS Report RS22532, Iraqi Police and Security Forces Casualties Estimates, by Hannah Fischer. \nThis report will be updated as needed. \nIraqi Civilian Casualties Estimates \n \nCongressional Research Service \nContents \nGovernment Estimates of Iraqi Civilian Deaths .............................................................................. 1 \nOther Estimates of Iraqi Civilian Deaths ......................................................................................... 3 \n \nFigures \nFigure 1. Estimated Iraqi Civilian Deaths, January 2006 to August 2008 ...................................... 1 \n \nTables \nTable 1. Other Iraqi Civilian Dead and Wounded Estimates ........................................................... 3 \n \nContacts \nAuthor Information .......................................................................................................................... 5 \n \nIraqi Civilian Casualties Esti", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "url": "https://time.com/archive/6945268/iraq-report-civilian-deaths-decrease/", "title": "Iraq Report: Civilian Deaths Decrease", "publisher": "TIME", "published_at": "2008-12-27", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.385863Z", "excerpt": "As the United States prepares to launch what is ostensibly the final chapter in the U.S. military occupation of Iraq on January 1, a new report confirms a significantly lower civilian causality count for 2008 — along with a few caveats.\nThe report, released on Saturday by Iraq Body Count (IBC), an independent project that tallies statistics from NGOs and other groups, says that between 8,315 and 9,028 Iraqi civilians were killed in 2008. That compares to over 22,671 civilian deaths in 2007, and over 25,774 in 2006, according to the organization’s tally. IBC has kept track of such numbers along with details of each incident since the 2003 U.S. invasion. Even so, the report cautions that the decline is only low in relative terms, and that attacks against civilians remain a serious problem. (See pictures of Iraq’s streets coming back to life.)\nIndeed, Iraq Body Count released its findings as a car bomb exploded near a bus stop in the Iraqi capital, killing 22 people, and wounding 54, according to the Associated Press. In a separate incident, a car bomb killed three in a town south of Baghdad.\nThe report contains another caveat: the 1,106 civilian deaths this year that relate directly to U.S. troop presence — meaning Iraqis killed by U.S. troops or those civilians killed in attacks carried out by insurgents targeting U.S. troops — has remained relatively unchanged since 2006. “While deaths caused by Unknown perpetrators [e.g. car bombs in marketplaces] have plummeted by 87% from the peak year of 2006, civilian deaths [caused by “Coalition military or those who violently oppose them”]… have remained relatively constant throughout the last three years,” the report states. “What remains certain is that Iraq under occupation is fraught with dangers for the civilian population, dangers which will never entirely go away before the occupation does.”\nBut with the Iraq’s government gearing up to take the reins militarily in 2009, Iraqi officials across the political spectrum are", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "url": "https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.1000415", "title": "Violent Deaths of Iraqi Civilians, 2003–2008: Analysis by Perpetrator, Weapon, Time, and Location", "publisher": "PLOS Medicine", "published_at": "2011-02-15", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.223240Z", "excerpt": "Figures\nAbstract\nBackground\nArmed violence is a major public health and humanitarian problem in Iraq. In this descriptive statistical analysis we aimed to describe for the first time Iraqi civilian deaths caused by perpetrators of armed violence during the first 5 years of the Iraq war: over time; by weapon used; by region (governorate); and by victim demographics.\nMethods and Findings\nWe analyzed the Iraq Body Count database of 92,614 Iraqi civilian direct deaths from armed violence occurring from March 20, 2003 through March 19, 2008, of which Unknown perpetrators caused 74% of deaths (n = 68,396), Coalition forces 12% (n = 11,516), and Anti-Coalition forces 11% (n = 9,954). We analyzed the subset of 60,481 civilian deaths from 14,196 short-duration events of lethal violence to link individual civilian deaths to events involving perpetrators and their methods. One-third of civilian violent death was from extrajudicial executions by Unknown perpetrators; quadratic regression shows these deaths progressively and disproportionately increased as deaths from other forms of violence increased across Iraq's governorates. The highest average number of civilians killed per event in which a civilian died were in Unknown perpetrator suicide bombings targeting civilians (19 per lethal event) and Coalition aerial bombings (17 per lethal event). In temporal analysis, numbers of civilian deaths from Coalition air attacks, and woman and child deaths from Coalition forces, peaked during the invasion. We applied a Woman and Child “Dirty War Index” (DWI), measuring the proportion of women and children among civilian deaths of known demographic status, to the 22,066 civilian victims identified as men, women, or children to indicate relatively indiscriminate perpetrator effects. DWI findings suggest the most indiscriminate effects on women and children were from Unknown perpetrators using mortar fire (DWI = 79) and nonsuicide vehicle bombs (DWI = 54) and from Coalition air attacks (DW", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b", "url": "https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/report/2007/iraq-security-stability_jun2007-01-3.htm", "title": "Measuring Stability and Security in Iraq - June 2007", "publisher": "globalsecurity.org", "published_at": "2007-01-03", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:22.438560Z", "excerpt": "Measuring Stability and Security in Iraq\n \n \n June 2007 \n Report to Congress \n In accordance with the \n Department of Defense Appropriations Act 2007\n (Section 9010, Public Law 109-289)\n \n Report to Congress\nIn accordance with the\nDepartment of Defense Appropriations Act 2007\n(Section 9010, Public Law 109-289)\nSection 1-Stability and Security\n1.3 Security Environment\nThis reporting period saw an increased effort to provide security to the population of Iraq. The increasingly complex conflict has remained a struggle among and within ethnosectarian, criminal, insurgent and terrorist groups to wrest political and economic power from the elected GoI. Much of the violence is attributable to sectarian friction, and each faction is driven by its own political and economic power relationships. Illegally armed groups are engaged in a cycle of sectarian and politically motivated violence, using tactics that include indiscriminate bombing, murder, executions, and indirect fire to intimidate and to provoke sectarian conflict. The United States is supporting Iraqi efforts to reduce sectarian violence in Baghdad, regain control over the capital, and defeat al Qaeda in Iraq (AQI) and its supporters, ensuring that they find no safe haven in Iraq.\nIn support of political efforts, Operation Fardh al-Qanoon (FAQ) was launched on February 14, 2007 as the main security component of the New Way Forward. FAQ is intended to provide population security, primarily in Baghdad, to contain the sectarian violence and give Iraqis an opportunity to pursue political reconciliation and to implement government reforms. FAQ involves an increase of five U.S. Brigade Combat Teams (BCTs) and support forces; four of the five BCTs are now in place. The remaining BCT will be in place in June.\nIraqi Security Commitments\nOn January 25, 2007, the CoR formally endorsed the new Baghdad operation and extended emergency authorities t", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c", "url": "https://www.cfr.org/backgrounders/iraq-security-statistics", "title": "Iraq Security Statistics | Council on Foreign Relations", "publisher": "Council on Foreign Relations", "published_at": "2007-09-12", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:14.248719Z", "excerpt": "The U.S. military’s methodology for measuring violence in Iraq draws criticism from some quarters. The Pentagon concedes some kinds of violence don’t get included, but insists its consistent application of these methods results in an accurate plotting of trends.\nThis publication is now archived.\nIntroduction\nThe aim of President Bush’s “New Way Forward,” announced in January 2007, was to improve security in the Iraqi capital and foster an environment for national reconciliation. In announcing the deployment of thirty thousand additional troops to Iraq, Bush predicted, “daily life will improve, Iraqis will gain confidence in their leaders, and the government will have the breathing space it needs to make progress in other critical areas.” Opinion sharply divides over whether this has been achieved, and some claim that Pentagon statistical methodology fails to reflect the real levels of violence in the country. A trio of independent reports offers a grim assessment of political gains, but conflicting statistics on civilian deaths shroud the debate over Iraq’s future, and U.S. involvement in it. The U.S. military insists progress on the ground can be measured, but some experts accuse the Pentagon of “cherry-picking” positive data.\nMilitary Numbers on Violence\nGen. David H. Petraeus, commander of U.S. forces in Iraq, told Congress on September 10 and 11 that civilian casualties in Iraq—including those killed and wounded—dropped dramatically during the surge of troops. According to numbers compiled by the U.S. military and cited by the general before Congress, Iraqi civilian deaths linked to violence declined by over 45 percent between December 2006 and August 2007, from three thousand deaths monthly to around 1,500 a month. The drop was even greater—70 percent—in Baghdad, where monthly deaths fell from approximately 2,220 to around five hundred. Overall, ethno-sectarian violence declined by about 55 percent; the drop was 80 percent in Baghdad. Car bombings and suicide a", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lancet_surveys_of_Iraq_War_casualties", "title": "Lancet surveys of Iraq War casualties - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2004-11-08", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.215342Z", "excerpt": "The Lancet, one of the oldest scientific medical journals in the world, published two peer-reviewed studies on the effect of the 2003 invasion of Iraq and subsequent occupation on the Iraqi mortality rate. The first was published in 2004; the second (by many of the same authors) in 2006. The studies estimate the number of excess deaths caused by the occupation, both direct (combatants plus non-combatants) and indirect (due to increased lawlessness, degraded infrastructure, poor healthcare, etc.).\nThe first survey[1] published on 29 October 2004, estimated 98,000 excess Iraqi deaths (with a range of 8,000 to 194,000, using a 95% confidence interval (CI)) from the 2003 invasion and subsequent occupation of Iraq to that time, or about 50% higher than the death rate prior to the invasion. The authors described this as a conservative estimate, because it excluded the extreme statistical outlier data from Fallujah. If the Fallujah cluster were included, the mortality estimate would increase to 150% over pre-invasion rates (95% CI: 1.6 to 4.2).\nThe second survey[2][3][4] published on 11 October 2006, estimated 654,965 excess deaths related to the war, or 2.5% of the population, through the end of June 2006. The new study applied similar methods and involved surveys between 20 May and 10 July 2006.[4] More households were surveyed, allowing for a 95% confidence interval of 392,979 to 942,636 excess Iraqi deaths. 601,027 deaths (range of 426,369 to 793,663 using a 95% confidence interval) were due to violence. 31% (186,318) of those were attributed to the US-led Coalition, 24% (144,246) to others, and 46% (276,472) unknown. The causes of violent deaths were gunshot (56% or 336,575), car bomb (13% or 78,133), other explosion/ordnance (14%), air strike (13% or 78,133), accident (2% or 12,020), and unknown (2%).\nThe mortality estimates in the Lancet surveys are higher than in several other reports, including those of the Iraqi Health Ministry and the United Nations, as well as ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "url": "https://www.iraqbodycount.org/analysis/numbers/ten-years/", "title": "The War in Iraq: 10 years and counting :: Iraq Body Count", "publisher": "iraqbodycount.org", "published_at": "2013-03-19", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.404383Z", "excerpt": "The War in Iraq: 10 years and counting\nAnalysis of deaths in a decade of violence\n19 March 2013\nThe US/UK-led invasion of March 2003 has brought a decade of high and low intensity armed conflict to Iraq. But this conflict is not yet history. It remains entrenched and pervasive, with a clear beginning but no foreseeable end, and very much a part of the present in Iraq. In major regions of the country armed violence continues to exact a remorseless toll on human life, young and old, male and female, across society.\nSince the beginning of 2003 the Iraq Body Count project (IBC) has been continuously tracking, analysing and maintaining a public record of civilian deaths on its website iraqbodycount.org.\nThe figures below provide a statistical overview of the conflict which outlines its human toll. Numbers are derived from over 31,500 deadly incidents analysed for information including time and location, perpetrators and weapons used, with demographic records for those victims (around 40% of the total) for whom such information could be obtained.\nIn Sum\n1 Slight variation of this figure from the IBC database will be due to the continuous addition of data as the online database is updated, and the inclusion in this release of March 2013 incidents still being fully processed.\nIBC has documented 112,017 - 122,438 civilian deaths from violence between 20 March 2003 and 14 March 2013. 1\nA complete account of violent deaths that includes Iraqi and foreign combatants (including coalition forces), as well as previously unreported civilian deaths still being extracted by IBC from the Iraq War Logs released by WikiLeaks, would include:\n- 39,900 (combatants killed of all nationalities)\n- 11,500 civilians (likely to be added from the Iraq War Logs)\nyielding about 174,000 as the number of people documented killed in violence in Iraq since 2003. 2\nIBC has recorded an additional 135,089 civilians injured, along with incident and demographic details where known. However IBC only records ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95", "url": "https://2009-2017.state.gov/j/drl/rls/hrrpt/2008/nea/119116.htm", "title": "Iraq", "publisher": "U.S. Department of State", "published_at": "2009-02-25", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.220748Z", "excerpt": "Iraq, with a population of approximately 27.5 million, is a republic with a freely elected government led by Prime Minister Nouri Jawad al Maliki. The current administration assumed office in 2006 after the Council of Representatives (COR) approved a unity government composed of the major political parties. The 2005 COR elections establishing this government met internationally recognized electoral standards for free and fair elections, and the results of the elections reflected the will of the voters, according to the final report of the International Mission for Iraqi Elections.\nSince the second half of 2007 and during the year, the general security situation in the country substantially improved. Violence has decreased to the lowest level since 2004, although attacks on military, police, and civilians continued. According to Multinational Force-Iraq (MNF-I), civilian deaths from violence during the year fell 72 percent to approximately 15 per day; Iraqi Security Forces (ISF) deaths from violence fell by 57 percent to five per day, compared to the previous year. Successful ISF operations contributed to decreasing violence by establishing government control of areas previously dominated by Shia special groups and other extremists. Throughout the year the Shia militia Jaysh al-Mahdi (JAM) or Mahdi's Army reorganized, repudiating violence against Iraqis, and \"Sons of Iraq\" (SOI) neighborhood security forces -- many affiliated with Sunni tribal groups -- continued to combat insurgents and terrorists. These developments undermined the terrorist group Al-Qa'ida in Iraq (AQI) and Sunni insurgent influence, contributing to even further reductions in violence.\nDuring the year, the Ministries of Interior (MOI) and Defense (MOD) increased the numbers of trained security forces. At the end of the year there were over 590,000 trained security forces, an increase from 430,000 in November 2007. The strengthened ISF led successful operations, often jointly with the MNF-I, against", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2", "url": "https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/report/2007/iraq-security-stability_dec2007-exec.htm", "title": "Measuring Stability and Security in Iraq", "publisher": "globalsecurity.org", "published_at": "2026-01-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:14.064143Z", "excerpt": "Measuring Stability and Security in Iraq\n \n \n December 2007 \n Report to Congress \n In accordance with the \n Department of Defense Appropriations Act 2007\n (Section 9010, Public Law 109-289)\n \n Report to Congress\nIn accordance with the\nDepartment of Defense Appropriations Act 2007\n(Section 9010, Public Law 109-289)\n Executive Summary\n \n\t\t\n\t\t\nThis report to Congress, Measuring Stability and Security in Iraq, is submitted pursuant to Section 9010 of the Department of Defense Appropriations Act 2007, Public Law 109-289 as amended by Section 1308 of Public Law 110-28. The report includes specific performance indicators and measures of progress toward political, economic, and security stability in Iraq, as directed in that legislation. This is the tenth in a series of quarterly reports on this subject. The most recent report was submitted in September 2007. The report complements other reports and information about Iraq provided to Congress and is not intended as a single source of all information about the combined efforts or the future strategy of the United States, its Coalition partners, or Iraq.\nThe strategic goal of the United States in Iraq remains a unified, democratic and federal Iraq that can govern, defend and sustain itself and is an ally in the war on terror. This report measures progress towards, and setbacks from, achieving that goal during the reporting period (September through November 2007).1 There has been significant security progress, momentum in reconciliation at the local and provincial levels and economic progress. However substantial the security progress made since the last report, sustained and durable progress depends on further progress in attaining political and economic objectives. The United States, its Coalition partners and others in the international community remain committed to assisting the Government of Iraq (GoI) in capitalizing on this ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_Body_Count_project", "title": "Iraq Body Count project - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2003-03-27", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.213120Z", "excerpt": "Iraq Body Count project (IBC) is a web-based effort to record civilian deaths resulting from the US-led 2003 invasion of Iraq. Included are deaths attributable to coalition and insurgent military action, sectarian violence and criminal violence, which refers to excess civilian deaths caused by criminal action resulting from the breakdown in law and order which followed the coalition invasion. As of February 2019, the IBC has recorded 183,249 – 205,785 civilian deaths.[2] The IBC has a media-centered approach to counting and documenting the deaths. Other sources have provided differing estimates of deaths, some much higher. See Casualties of the Iraq War.\nThe project uses reports from English-language news media (including Arabic media translated into English), NGO-based reports, and official records that have been released into the public sphere to compile a running total.[3] On its database page the IBC states: \"Gaps in recording and reporting suggest that even our highest totals to date may be missing many civilian deaths from violence.\"[2] The group is staffed by volunteers consisting mainly of academics and activists based in the UK and the US. The project was founded by John Sloboda and Hamit Dardagan.\nAccording to Jonathan Steele, writing in The Guardian, IBC \"is widely considered as the most reliable database of Iraqi civilian deaths\".[4] But some researchers regard it at best as a floor, or baseline for mortality, and that it underestimates actual mortality by potentially several factors.[5]\nThe IBC overview page states:\n\"This is an ongoing human security project which maintains and updates the world's only independent and comprehensive public database of media-reported civilian deaths in Iraq that have resulted from the 2003 military intervention by the USA and its allies. The count includes civilian deaths caused by coalition military action and by military or paramilitary responses to the coalition presence (e.g. insurgent and terrorist attacks). It also ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07", "url": "https://www.theguardian.com/world/2008/mar/19/iraq", "title": "What is the real death toll in Iraq? Jonathan Steele and Suzanne Goldenberg report", "publisher": "The Guardian", "published_at": "2008-03-19", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.221488Z", "excerpt": "The following correction was printed in the Guardian's Corrections and clarifications column, Tuesday July 1 2008.\nIn the article below we were wrong to say that a household survey conducted by the World Health Organisation and the Iraqi health ministry found that the rate of violent deaths had doubled in Iraq after the invasion. The survey did not make this finding. Figures that were unadjusted for under-reporting showed a doubling of the rate of all deaths and a violence-related death rate about 11 times higher. The article said the survey estimated that 151,000 civilians had been killed since the invasion. That figure included combatants. The article below should have also made clear that the Lancet and Opinion Research Business surveys included combatants as well as civilians.\nLieutenant General Tommy Franks, who led the invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan during his time as head of US Central Command, once announced, \"We don't do body counts.\" This blunt response to a question about civilian casualties was an attempt to distance George Bush's wars from the disaster of Vietnam. One of the rituals of that earlier conflict was the daily announcement of how many Vietnamese fighters US forces had killed. It was supposed to convince a sceptical American public that victory was coming. But the \"body count\" concept sounded callous - and never more so than when it emerged that many of the alleged guerrilla dead were in fact women, children and other unarmed civilians.\nIraq was going to be different. The US would count its own dead (now close to 4,000), but the toll the war was taking on Iraqis was not a matter the Pentagon or any other US government department intended to quantify. Especially once Bush had declared \"mission accomplished\" on May 1 2003 - after that, every new Iraqi who died by violence would be a signal that the president was wrong, and would show that a war conducted in the name of humanitarian intervention was exacting a mounting humanitarian toll of its", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraqi_insurgency_(2003%E2%80%932011)", "title": "Iraqi insurgency (2003–2011) - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2004-01-13", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.214196Z", "excerpt": "The Iraqi insurgency lasted from 2003 until 2011, beginning shortly after the 2003 American invasion deposed longtime leader Saddam Hussein, and lasting until the end of the Iraq War and U.S. withdrawal in 2011. It was followed by a renewed insurgency.\nThe initial outbreak of violence (the 2003–2006 phase) was triggered by the fall and preceded the establishment of the new Iraqi government by the Multi-National Force – Iraq (MNF–I), which was led by the U.S. From around 2004 to May 2007, Iraqi insurgents largely focused their attacks on MNF-I troops,[6] but later shifted to targeting the post-invasion Iraqi security forces as well.\nThe insurgents were composed of a diverse mix of private militias, pro-Saddam Ba'athists, local Iraqis opposed to the MNF–I and/or the post-Saddam Iraqi government, and a number of foreign jihadists. The various insurgent groups fought an asymmetric war of attrition against the MNF–I and the Iraqi government, while also fighting among themselves.\nThe insurgency was shaped by sectarian tensions in Iraq, particularly between Shia Muslims (~60% of the population) and Sunni Muslims (~35% of the population). By February 2006, the violence escalated into a Shia–Sunni civil war, and for the next two years, the MNF–I and the Iraqi government were locked in intense fighting with various militants, who were also targeting each other based on their sectarian affiliations. Many of the militant attacks in American-controlled territories were directed at the Shia-dominated government of Nouri al-Maliki. Militancy continued amid post-invasion Iraqi reconstruction efforts, as the federal government tried to establish itself in the country. The civil war and sectarian violence ended in mid-2008, having been quelled by the American troop surge of 2007.\nHowever, after the American withdrawal from Iraq in December 2011, a renewed sectarian and anti-government insurgency swept through the country, causing thousands of casualties. Two years later, the violence", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "url": "https://archive.org/details/IraqiCivilianDeathsEstimates", "title": "Iraqi Civilian Deaths Estimates : Hannah Fischer 2008 : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive", "publisher": "Internet Archive", "published_at": "2010-01-29", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:03.658412Z", "excerpt": "Can you chip in? As an independent nonprofit, the Internet Archive is fighting for universal access to quality information. We build and maintain all our own systems, but we don’t charge for access, sell user information, or run ads. Instead, we're powered by online donations averaging about $14. We'd be deeply grateful if you'd join the one in a thousand users that support us financially.\nWe understand that not everyone can donate right now, but if you can afford to contribute this Thursday, we promise it will be put to good use. Our resources are crucial for knowledge lovers everywhere—so if you find all these bits and bytes useful, please pitch in.", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "url": "https://jmss.org/article/view/58236", "title": "Revisiting the 2007 Surge in Iraq", "publisher": "jmss.org", "published_at": "2017-01-31", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:22.218073Z", "excerpt": "Revisiting the 2007 Surge in Iraq\nDOI:\nhttps://doi.org/10.55016/6w52jy86\nAbstract\nThe 2007 surge in Iraq is considered one of the most significant military events in recent history given that it coincided with a marked decrease in violent attacks. However, revisiting “significant activity” (SIGACT) data reveals that violence had generally peaked before the surge. This study presents also an examination of other factors that might explain the earlier decline in violence, before the surge was even announced. It is difficult to pinpoint the trends that were most prominent, but they all likely contributed to a shift in the momentum of the security situation in the fall of 2006, before the surge was even announced. Thus, our analysis suggests that the surge was an unnecessary gambit. This paper aims to caution strategic policy decision-makers against misinterpreting the efficacy of surge capability in a complex and dynamically changing security situation.", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Report_to_Congress_on_the_Situation_in_Iraq", "title": "Report to Congress on the Situation in Iraq - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2007-09-11", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:14.889539Z", "excerpt": "The Report to Congress on the Situation in Iraq (sometimes referred to as the Petraeus Report) was a two-part report released on September 10, 2007 by General of the Multinational force in Iraq David H. Petraeus and U.S. Ambassador to Iraq Ryan Crocker on progress by the Iraqi government in the ongoing Iraq War.[1]\nPetraeus concluded that \"the military objectives of the surge are, in large measure, being met\". He cited what he called recent consistent declines in security incidents. He partially attributed those declines to recent blows dealt against Al-Qaeda during the surge. He added that \"we have also disrupted Shia militia extremists, capturing the head and numerous other leaders of the Iranian-supported Special Groups, along with a senior Lebanese Hezbollah operative supporting Iran's activities in Iraq.\" He argued that Coalition and Iraqi operations had drastically reduced ethno-sectarian violence in the country, though he stated that the gains were not entirely even. As such, he recommended a gradual drawdown of U.S. forces in Iraq, with a goal of reaching pre-surge troop levels by July 2008. Troop reductions would continue past this point as the situation warrants. Despite allegations that Petraeus' report would be written by the White House,[2] Petraeus insisted that he had written this testimony himself, without it having \"been cleared by, nor shared with, anyone in the Pentagon, the White House, or Congress.\"[3]\nThough Crocker acknowledged slow political progress in many areas, and a lack of progress on many important pieces of legislation, he argued that, \"a secure, stable democratic Iraq at peace with its neighbors is attainable.\" Though a national framework has fallen short of being implemented legislatively in key issues such as oil distribution, he observed that \"even in the absence of legislation there is practical action as the central government shares oil revenues through budget allocations on an equitable basis with Iraq's provinces.\" He pointed", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_Iraq_War", "title": "Casualties of the Iraq War - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2003-03-27", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.208212Z", "excerpt": "Estimates of the casualties from the Iraq War (beginning with the 2003 invasion of Iraq, and the ensuing occupation and insurgency and civil war) have come in several forms, and those estimates of different types of Iraq War casualties vary greatly.\nEstimating war-related deaths poses many challenges.[1][2] Experts distinguish between population-based studies, which extrapolate from random samples of the population, and body counts, which tally reported deaths and likely significantly underestimate casualties.[3] Population-based studies produce estimates of the number of Iraq War casualties ranging from 151,000 violent deaths as of June 2006 (per the Iraq Family Health Survey) to 1,033,000 excess deaths (per the 2007 Opinion Research Business (ORB) survey). Other survey-based studies covering different time-spans find 461,000 total deaths (over 60% of them violent) as of June 2011 (per PLOS Medicine 2013), and 655,000 total deaths (over 90% of them violent) as of June 2006 (per the 2006 Lancet study). Body counts counted at least 110,600 violent deaths as of April 2009 (Associated Press). The Iraq Body Count project documents 186,901–210,296 violent civilian deaths in their table. All estimates of Iraq War casualties are disputed.[4][5]\nThe tables below summarize reports on Iraqi casualty figures.\nScientific surveys:\nBody counts:\nOverview: Iraqi death estimates by source Summary of casualties of the Iraq War. Possible estimates on the number of people killed in the invasion and occupation of Iraq vary widely,[14] and are highly disputed. Estimates of casualties below include both the 2003 invasion of Iraq and the following Post-invasion Iraq, 2003–present.\nOverview: Death estimates by group\nOverview: Iraqi injury estimates by source\nFranks reportedly estimated soon after the invasion that there had been 30,000 Iraqi casualties as of April 9, 2003.[81] That number comes from the transcript of an October 2003 interview of U.S. Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld with j", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "url": "https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/giving-surge-partial-credit-iraqs-2007-reduction-violence", "title": "Giving the Surge Partial Credit for Iraq's 2007 Reduction in Violence", "publisher": "The Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs", "published_at": "2012-10-09", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:23.237275Z", "excerpt": "International Security is America's leading peer-reviewed journal of security affairs.\nBottom Lines\n- The surge was necessary for the 2007 reduction in Iraq's violence. Iraq's violence fell radically in 2007, but without the surge it probably would have stayed high—neither the Anbar Awakening nor a natural burnout of Iraq's sectarian strife would have sufficed.\n- But the Anbar Awakening was needed, too. Most of the Sunni insurgency changed sides in the 2006–07 Awakening. This realignment worked synergistically with the surge: turncoat Sunnis revealed holdouts' identities, locations, and methods; U.S. firepower protected turncoats from retaliation. Without this synergy, violence would probably still have been at mid-2006 levels when the surge ended.\n- Counterinsurgency without an Awakening is a long, hard slog. Even before Sunnis realigned, the surge was making headway in some areas, but progress was slow and expensive. Iraq suggests that grinding an insurgency down without an Awakening is possible—but only at a very high price.\n- Do not assume that the violence fell because hearts or minds were won in 2007. The crucial U.S. contribution in 2007 was combat power to protect realigning Sunnis from their erstwhile allies. Some kinds of development assistance probably helped at the margin but were not decisive.\nSynergy between the Surge and the Awakening is the Best Explanation\nWhy did violence decline in Iraq in 2007? Many credit the \"surge,\" or the program of U.S. reinforcements and doctrinal changes that began in January 2007. Others cite the voluntary insurgent stand-downs of the Sunni Awakening or say that the violence had simply run its course after a wave of sectarian cleansing. Evidence drawn from recently declassified data on violence at local levels and a series of seventy structured interviews with coalition participants finds little support for the cleansing or Awakening theses. This analysis constitutes the first attempt to gather systematic evidence across ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "url": "https://archive.globalpolicy.org/security/issues/iraq/mortalitindex.htm", "title": "Mortality in Iraq", "publisher": "archive.globalpolicy.org", "published_at": "2006-10-21", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:08.768164Z", "excerpt": "Very large number of Iraqis have died under the occupation and the rate of mortality has risen sharply. While demographic surveys, body counts using daily news reports, data from morgues and hospitals, and epidemiological studies have estimated the number of deaths in different ways and put forward a wide range of figures, all show that Iraq's population has paid - and continues to pay - a steep price.\n GPF Perspectives |Major Mortality Studies | Articles | Links \nGPF Perspectives\nMajor Mortality Studies\n \nThe second Lancet mortality study estimates that 655,000 excess deaths occurred during the occupation from March 2003 through June 2006.\nThe first Lancet study estimates that about 98,000 excess deaths (deaths above the pre-2003 mortality rate) occurred in the 18 month period from March 2003 to September 2004. The report concluded that \"violence was the primary cause of death\" since the invasion and \"mainly attributed [it] to Coalition forces.\"\nThis wide-ranging survey measures living conditions in Iraq during April 2002 and April 2004. The survey includes a question on deaths in households: it was found that 24,000 \"war-related\" deaths had occurred in the period between March 2003 to April 2004. (UNDP)\nArticles\n 2011| 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 \n \n2011\nAs Iraq emerges from close to nine years of war, an estimated two million widowed women are part of the humanitarian crisis left behind. They are left to struggle with raising children alone, with little or no money or family support. Twenty-three percent of the oil-rich country’s population lives under the poverty line, of which more than half are women. The International Committee of the Red Cross sees the women-headed households as among the most vulnerable in Iraq today. (Reuters)\n2008\nWhile the US and Iraq are negotiating a long-term security agreement, US troops have killed a number of Iraqi civilians in two highly publicized incidents. The shootings happened during a delicate time because the ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "url": "https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/testing-surge-why-did-violence-decline-iraq-2007", "title": "Testing the Surge: Why Did Violence Decline in Iraq in 2007?", "publisher": "The Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs", "published_at": "2012-07-09", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:21.803112Z", "excerpt": "International Security is America's leading peer-reviewed journal of security affairs.\nSummary\nWhy did violence decline in Iraq in 2007? Many policymakers and scholars credit the “surge,” or the program of U.S. reinforcements and doctrinal changes that began in January 2007. Others cite the voluntary insurgent standdowns of the Sunni Awakening or say that the violence had simply run its course with the end of a wave of sectarian cleansing; still others credit an interaction between the surge and the Awakening. The difference matters for policy and scholarship, yet this debate has not moved from hypothesis to test. An assessment of the competing claims based on recently declassified data on violence at local levels and information gathered from seventy structured interviews with coalition participants finds little support for the cleansing or Awakening theses. Instead, a synergistic interaction between the surge and the Awakening was required for violence to drop as quickly and widely as it did: both were necessary; neither was sufficient. U.S. policy thus played an important role in reducing the violence in Iraq in 2007, but Iraq provides no evidence that similar methods will produce similar results elsewhere without local equivalents of the Sunni Awakening.\nBiddle, Stephen, Jeffrey A. Friedman and Jacob N. Shapiro. “Testing the Surge: Why Did Violence Decline in Iraq in 2007?.” Summer 2012", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_War", "title": "Iraq War - Wikipedia", "publisher": "Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.", "published_at": "2003-03-21", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.209527Z", "excerpt": "The Iraq War (Arabic: حرب العراق, romanized: ḥarb al-ʿirāq), also referred to as the Second Gulf War (Gulf War II),[82][83] was a protracted armed conflict in Iraq from 2003 to 2011. It began with the invasion by a United States–led coalition, which resulted in the overthrow of the Ba'athist government of Saddam Hussein. During the US occupation of Iraq, the conflict persisted as an insurgency that arose against coalition forces and the newly established Iraqi government. US forces were officially withdrawn in 2011. In 2014, the US became re-engaged in Iraq, leading a new coalition under Combined Joint Task Force – Operation Inherent Resolve, as the conflict evolved into the ongoing Islamic State insurgency.\nThe Iraq invasion was part of the Bush administration's broader war on terror, launched in response to the September 11 attacks. In October 2002, the US Congress passed a bipartisan resolution granting Bush authority to use military force against Iraq. The war began on March 20, 2003, when the US, joined by the UK, Australia, and Poland, initiated a \"shock and awe\" bombing campaign. Coalition forces launched a ground invasion, defeating Iraqi forces and toppling the Ba'athist regime. Saddam Hussein was captured in 2003 and executed in 2006.\nThe fall of Saddam's regime created a power vacuum, which, along with the Coalition Provisional Authority's mismanagement, fueled a sectarian civil war between Iraq's Shia majority and Sunni minority, and contributed to a lengthy insurgency. In response, the US deployed an additional 170,000 troops during the 2007 troop surge, which helped stabilize parts of the country. In 2008, Bush agreed to withdraw US combat troops, a process completed in 2011 under President Barack Obama.\nThe primary rationale for the invasion centered around false claims that Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction (WMDs) and that Saddam Hussein was supporting al-Qaeda. The 9/11 Commission concluded in 2004 that there was no credible evidence linkin", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome", "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e", "url": "https://www.army.mil/article/2301/iraq_security_plan_working", "title": "Iraq Security Plan Working", "publisher": "www.army.mil", "published_at": "2007-03-19", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:21.741957Z", "excerpt": "WASHINGTON (American Forces Press Service, March 16, 2007) - Moving coalition forces out of big forward operating bases and into smaller community-based combat outposts as part of the Baghdad Security Plan has reduced violence and helped to stabilize northwestern Baghdad, a senior Army officer serving there said today.\nMurders are down by more than half since January in the densely populated 93-square-kilometer area controlled by the 2nd Brigade Combat Team, 1st Infantry Division, said its commander, Col. J.B. Burton.\nHis troops have found only 10 planted improvised explosive devices this month. That's down from 36 in January, when 89 IEDs were detonated. So far this month, there have been only 21 IED detonations, Burton reported.\nAbout 1 million people live in the area patrolled by Burton's troops. It is principally Shiia-occupied in the northeast, Sunni in the west and southwest, and mixed in the southeast. Sectarian fault lines define the areas, and both Sunni and Shiia extremists fight for control over portions of the city and its citizens, Burton said.\nExtremists have used tactics ranging from car bombs to illegal militia control over access to gas stations and food distribution programs to execution-style murders by death squads, Burton said. Such murders are down from 141 in January to 63 in February to only 16 so far in March, he said. But the area has seen an increase in car bombs targeting Shiia gathering places, Burton said, mostly by Sunni extremists.\nBurton said he believes this decline is directly attributable to his Soldiers living in the neighborhoods and working side by side with the Iraqi security forces.\nOriginally, the combat outposts were designed solely to create and keep a troop presence in the community. However, they have transformed into combined command posts, or joint security stations, with coalition forces working in cooperation with Iraqi forces. This allows for better and faster information sharing and easier operations planning, Burt", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "url": "https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/ops/iraq_sigacts.htm", "title": "Operation Iraqi Freedom", "publisher": "globalsecurity.org", "published_at": "2026-01-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:02.217724Z", "excerpt": "OIF - Iraq Significant Activities (SIGACTS)\nThe term \"attacks\" refers to all incidents reported to Multi-National Force-Iraq (MNF-I) through daily Significant Activity Reports. It includes known attacks on Coalition forces, Iraqi Security Forces, the civilian population, and infrastructure. It does not include criminal activity, nor does it include attacks initiated by Coalition or Iraqi Security Forces. The complexity and effectiveness of these attacks vary. They can range from a single insurgent firing a single shot causing no casualties to a highly coordinated complex attack using two or more weapon systems.\nMay 2009 SIGACTS Recap\nJune 2008 SIGACTS Recap (2)\nThe overall levels of violence in Iraq—as measured by enemy-initiated attacks—decreased about 70 percent from June 2007 to February 2008, a significant reduction from the high levels of violence in 2006 and the first half of 2007. Similarly, the average daily number of enemy-initiated attacks declined from about 180 in June 2007 to about 60 in November 2007 and declined further to about 50 in February 2008. From 2003 through 2007, enemy-initiated attacks had increased around major political and religious events, such as Iraqi elections and Ramadan. In 2007, attacks did not increase during Ramadan. In a March 2008 report, DOD noted that reductions in violence across Iraq have enabled a return to normal life and growth in local economies.\nHowever, data for March 2008 show an increase in violence in Iraq. Security conditions deteriorated in March 2008, with the average number of attacks increasing from about 50 per day in February 2008 to about 70 attacks per day in March—about a 40 percent increase. According to an April 2008 UN report, the increase in attacks resulted from Shi’a militias fighting Iraqi security forces throughout southern Iraq, as well as an increase in incidents of roadside bomb attacks against Iraqi security forces and MNF-I in Baghdad. The average number of attacks declined to about 65 per d", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f", "url": "https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2009/country-chapters/iraq", "title": "World Report 2009: Rights Trends in Iraq", "publisher": "Human Rights Watch", "published_at": "2009-01-12", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:12.914787Z", "excerpt": "Human rights conditions in Iraq remain extremely poor. Security gains in 2008 did little to ease Iraq's crisis of displacement, with about 2.8 million Iraqis displaced within the country and another 2 million abroad, mainly in Syria and Jordan.\nThe government continues to rest on a narrow political and ethnic/sectarian base, though Tawafuq, a Sunni bloc, returned to its ranks in July after a year-long boycott. The government was to incorporate into state forces up to 100,000 mainly Sunni paramilitaries paid by US forces to provide local security, but government officials disputed their numbers and threatened to arrest some leaders, casting doubt over the plans.\nGovernment-run detention facilities struggled to accommodate over 24,000 detainees, and tardy judicial review of cases exacerbated overcrowding. The US military said in October its detainee population had fallen to about 17,000 from a peak of approximately 26,000 in late 2007. Some detainees have spent years in custody without charge or trial.\nAs of mid-November 2008, Iraq's parliament was preparing to vote on a security agreement with the US to govern the presence of foreign troops when the UN Security Council mandate for the Multi-National Force-Iraq (MNF) expired at the end of 2008.\nPolitical Developments\nIraq's parliament passed legislation in February intended to refine procedures for vetting former Baath Party members; the new law continues to focus on group affiliation rather than individual responsibility for past abuses. An amnesty law was passed at the same time aimed in part at easing overcrowding in the detention system, but had limited impact on the detainee population. In September parliament passed legislation needed to hold provincial elections, seen as crucial to redressing a 2005 polls boycott by Sunnis and loyalists of Shia cleric Muqtada al-Sadr; however, it deferred a decision on elections in ethnically divided Kirkuk.\nMNF and Iraqi Government Military Operations\nMilitary operations by th", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "outcome" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] }, { "id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "url": "https://www.csis.org/analysis/iraqs-insurgency-and-civil-violence", "title": "Iraq's Insurgency and Civil Violence", "publisher": "Center for Strategic and International Studies", "published_at": "2007-08-22", "retrieved_at": "2026-09-17T03:20:22.283831Z", "excerpt": "Iraq's Insurgency and Civil Violence\nThe attached report examines how changes in the American military posture in Iraq and the build up of US troops to 160,000 military personnel in June 2007 has impacted the Sunni and Shi’ite insurgency. There were both positive and negative developments. Violence in Anbar Province decreased, and US and Iraqi forces inflicted serious damage to Al Qa'ida and extremist Shi'ite militia forces while increase the security of large areas in Baghdad.\nHowever, large-scale bombings with mass-casualties continued in other areas. Operation Phantom Thunder drove many insurgents out of highly patrolled areas, and increased activity in areas that were previously relatively quiet, particularly in the north. \nThe continued implosion of the British presence in southeastern Iraq reduced British forces to three token enclaves in the Basra area. The end result was to turn the four provinces in southeastern Iraq over to feuding Shi’ite factions whose actions were mixed with corruption, extortion, and links to criminal activity. The result was to create Shi’ite zones in the south, Sunni zones in the west, and Kurdish zones in the north, with tension, violence, and insurgency in mixed areas in central and northern Iraq.\nThe report covers the current stalemate in the Iraqi government and its implications. The ISF did perform well in some areas, and the Iraqi Army did show a steadily increasing capability to operate with reduced US support. However, the security forces in many areas were still not capable of independent operations, and some had clear sectarian allegiances. \nThe report covers the impact of the rising Sunni tribal resentment and anger against al-Qa’ida and the most extreme elements of the Sunni Islamic extremist movements. US American military officials were able to pursue local alliances with tribal and sectarian groups to fight against al-Qa’ida in Iraq. There were also signs that such alliances could be expanded from Anbar to cover other ", "full_text_path": "data/runs/surge-reduced-violence/20260917T035227Z/text/fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba.txt", "leaf_ids": [ "cause" ], "found_by": [ "ddg" ] } ], "judgments": [ { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count is a well-established secondary source that systematically documents and catalogs violent incidents from named primary sources (news reports, hospital records, etc.), with transparent methodology and publicly accessible underlying data. However, it remains a compiled database rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study, and relies on media reporting which may have inherent gaps in coverage.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Iraq Body Count is a well-established secondary source that systematically documents and catalogs violent incidents from named primary sources (news reports, hospital records, etc.), with transparent methodology and publicly accessible underlying data. However, it remains a compiled database rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study, and relies on media reporting which may have inherent gaps in coverage.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses civilian death trends comparing 2008 to 2006-2007 levels, but focuses on full-year 2008 data rather than the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 timeframe claimed in the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document presents documented civilian death data from Iraq Body Count's database showing 2008 deaths (8,315–9,028) were substantially lower than 2006 (25,774–27,599) and 2007 (22,671–24,295), representing a reduction from 81 per day in 2006 and 72 per day in 2007 to 25 per day in 2008, directly supporting the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3262, "completion_tokens": 3500, "total_tokens": 6762, "reasoning_tokens": 3148 }, "cost_usd": 0.014079648, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.975172Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count is a reputable NGO that systematically documents civilian deaths using named primary sources (news reports, hospital records, eyewitness accounts) with transparent methodology and public database entries; however, it relies on secondary reporting rather than being a primary record itself, and acknowledges significant gaps and single-sourced uncertainties in its data.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Iraq Body Count is a reputable NGO that systematically documents civilian deaths using named primary sources (news reports, hospital records, eyewitness accounts) with transparent methodology and public database entries; however, it relies on secondary reporting rather than being a primary record itself, and acknowledges significant gaps and single-sourced uncertainties in its data.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides a database of documented civilian deaths from violence in Iraq with temporal data capabilities, which directly enables analysis of the specific claim about death trends between mid-2007 and mid-2008, though the excerpt itself does not present the actual comparative figures for those periods.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides overall death totals and describes its methodology but does not present specific data comparing civilian deaths between the time periods mentioned in the sub-claim (mid-2007 to mid-2008 versus 2006 and early-2007).\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2599, "completion_tokens": 303, "total_tokens": 2902, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00389608, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.975435Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is secondary journalism that reports on other studies and sources (PSR report, Iraq Body Count) rather than presenting primary data or original research. While Columbia Journalism Review has editorial standards and the piece cites named sources and organizations, it is fundamentally relaying and analyzing findings from other entities rather than conducting independent investigation or presenting primary evidence.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "psr study 2015" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "lexisnexis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is secondary journalism that reports on other studies and sources (PSR report, Iraq Body Count) rather than presenting primary data or original research. While Columbia Journalism Review has editorial standards and the piece cites named sources and organizations, it is fundamentally relaying and analyzing findings from other entities rather than conducting independent investigation or presenting primary evidence.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses overall Iraqi casualty figures and methodology for counting deaths since 2003, but does not specifically address the temporal comparison between mid-2007/mid-2008 and 2006/early-2007 that the sub-claim requires.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses overall Iraqi death tolls and methodological debates about casualty counting, but contains no specific data or claims about the temporal trend between mid-2007 and mid-2008 compared to 2006 and early-2007.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"psr study 2015\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lexisnexis\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3067, "completion_tokens": 3307, "total_tokens": 6374, "reasoning_tokens": 2995 }, "cost_usd": 0.01767479, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.975647Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary source that aggregates information from other sources (indicated by numbered citations [17]-[30]), relying on editorial review rather than peer review or primary research. While it cites specific claims to external sources and maintains editorial standards, it is fundamentally a tertiary compilation rather than original reporting or primary documentation, making it useful for overview but not authoritative evidence on the topic.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate 2007" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "unhcr iraqi government 2006" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un secretary general 2006" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary source that aggregates information from other sources (indicated by numbered citations [17]-[30]), relying on editorial review rather than peer review or primary research. While it cites specific claims to external sources and maintains editorial standards, it is fundamentally a tertiary compilation rather than original reporting or primary documentation, making it useful for overview but not authoritative evidence on the topic.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document mentions the 2008 Sunni Awakening and U.S. troop surge coinciding with dramatic violence decline, but does not analyze the causal relationship between the surge/tactics and violence reduction, nor does it address the counterfactual of what other factors alone would have produced.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document mentions that violence declined during the 2008 Sunni Awakening and U.S. troop surge but provides no analysis of causation or comparison of relative contributions from different factors, thus neither supporting nor contradicting the sub-claim's specific causal argument.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate 2007\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unhcr iraqi government 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un secretary general 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"george w bush 2007\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3522, "completion_tokens": 2768, "total_tokens": 6290, "reasoning_tokens": 2398 }, "cost_usd": 0.0122895394, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.975787Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This appears to be a peer-reviewed academic publication from a reputable university press (Princeton), classified under political science and international relations with formal citation standards, indicating scholarly vetting and editorial standards. The presence of ASJC codes and multiple citation format options confirms it is a formal academic work, though the excerpt alone does not reveal methodology or primary sources used.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "mnfi sigacts iii" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This appears to be a peer-reviewed academic publication from a reputable university press (Princeton), classified under political science and international relations with formal citation standards, indicating scholarly vetting and editorial standards. The presence of ASJC codes and multiple citation format options confirms it is a formal academic work, though the excerpt alone does not reveal methodology or primary sources used.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document title directly addresses the exact question posed by the sub-claim: testing whether the surge (2007 troop increase and tactical changes) caused the 2007 violence decline, implicitly requiring assessment against alternative explanations like the Anbar Awakening and sectarian displacement.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt provided contains only bibliographic metadata and citation formatting information with no substantive content addressing the causes of the 2007-2008 violence decline in Iraq.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"mnfi sigacts iii\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1950, "completion_tokens": 4070, "total_tokens": 6020, "reasoning_tokens": 3766 }, "cost_usd": 0.0144929494, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.975973Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is secondary source material from an educational/institutional website that summarizes well-known historical events and relays findings about Iraq War violence without citing specific data sources, primary documents, or peer-reviewed studies. While the content appears factually grounded in established historical record and the publisher (Pritzker Military Museum) has institutional credibility, the excerpt provides no citations, named sources, or methodological transparency regarding violence statistics or force posture analysis.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "pritzkermilitary org" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is secondary source material from an educational/institutional website that summarizes well-known historical events and relays findings about Iraq War violence without citing specific data sources, primary documents, or peer-reviewed studies. While the content appears factually grounded in established historical record and the publisher (Pritzker Military Museum) has institutional credibility, the excerpt provides no citations, named sources, or methodological transparency regarding violence statistics or force posture analysis.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the four factors contributing to the 2007 violence decline including the troop surge and accompanying tactics, the Anbar Awakening, and the Sadrist ceasefire, but does not explicitly evaluate their relative causal weights or test whether the surge was a 'major cause' beyond what the other factors alone would have produced.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.6,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly attributes the 2007 violence decrease to four factors including the Surge troop increase and changed tactics, alongside the Anbar Awakening and Sadrist ceasefire, supporting the sub-claim that the troop increase was a major cause, though it does not isolate the Surge's independent causal contribution beyond the other factors.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"pritzkermilitary.org\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3268, "completion_tokens": 376, "total_tokens": 3644, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00485994, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.976104Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a Congressional Research Service report prepared for Congress by a named specialist, presenting official U.S. government data (DOD), Iraqi government data, and academic/nonprofit estimates with explicit methodological caveats. CRS reports are authoritative secondary sources with rigorous editorial standards, though the document itself is a compilation of multiple data sources rather than a primary record.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi ministries data" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of defense data" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Congressional Research Service report prepared for Congress by a named specialist, presenting official U.S. government data (DOD), Iraqi government data, and academic/nonprofit estimates with explicit methodological caveats. CRS reports are authoritative secondary sources with rigorous editorial standards, though the document itself is a compilation of multiple data sources rather than a primary record.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Congressional Research Service report specifically documenting Iraqi civilian, police, and security forces casualty statistics with data spanning the exact time periods (2006-2009) needed to directly test the sub-claim about casualty trends between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a CRS report presenting casualty statistics from multiple sources (Iraqi Ministries, DOD, academic/nonprofit organizations) with figures tracking deaths from 2006-2009, which would contain the data needed to assess the sub-claim about the mid-2007 to mid-2008 period, though the excerpt itself does not display the actual figures or conclusions.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraqi ministries data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of defense data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"brookings iraq index\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3100, "completion_tokens": 5968, "total_tokens": 9068, "reasoning_tokens": 5595 }, "cost_usd": 0.0213384536, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.976241Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a Congressional Research Service report prepared for Congress by a named specialist, presenting official U.S. government data (DOD), Iraqi government data, and academic/nonprofit estimates with explicit methodological caveats. CRS reports are authoritative secondary sources with rigorous editorial standards, though the document itself is a compilation of multiple data sources rather than a primary record.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi ministries data" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of defense data" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Congressional Research Service report prepared for Congress by a named specialist, presenting official U.S. government data (DOD), Iraqi government data, and academic/nonprofit estimates with explicit methodological caveats. CRS reports are authoritative secondary sources with rigorous editorial standards, though the document itself is a compilation of multiple data sources rather than a primary record.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Congressional Research Service report specifically documenting Iraqi civilian, police, and security forces casualty statistics with data spanning the exact time periods (2006-2009) needed to directly test the sub-claim about casualty trends between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a CRS report presenting governmental and nongovernmental casualty data with figures showing monthly patterns of Iraqi deaths from 2006-2009, which would directly address whether deaths fell substantially between mid-2007 and mid-2008, thereby contradicting the sub-claim's negation.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraqi ministries data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of defense data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"brookings iraq index\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 873, "completion_tokens": 108, "total_tokens": 981, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001413, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.976241Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary analytical essay published in a specialized military journal that cites numbered sources (indicating reliance on other works) but does not appear to be peer-reviewed. While Small Wars Journal has editorial standards and focuses on military analysis, the piece is an interpretive essay synthesizing existing findings rather than presenting primary research, official records, or peer-reviewed analysis.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "small wars journal 2013" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary analytical essay published in a specialized military journal that cites numbered sources (indicating reliance on other works) but does not appear to be peer-reviewed. While Small Wars Journal has editorial standards and focuses on military analysis, the piece is an interpretive essay synthesizing existing findings rather than presenting primary research, official records, or peer-reviewed analysis.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the exact question of whether the surge alone caused the violence decline, explicitly stating it will assess the surge alongside other factors (Shiite victory, Sunni cooperation, Mahdi Army ceasefire) as equally important causes, which closely parallels the sub-claim's proposition about surge effects beyond other concurrent factors.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly argues that the surge alone is insufficient to explain violence reduction and identifies the Anbar Awakening (Sunni cooperation), sectarian victory completion (Shiite victory), and Sadrist ceasefire as factors of 'equal importance' to the surge, directly supporting the sub-claim's contention that these other factors were major independent causes.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"small wars journal 2013\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3295, "completion_tokens": 345, "total_tokens": 3640, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0047404, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.976435Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is secondary source journalism that aggregates information from other sources (indicated by citation markers like [4]), lacks peer review, and relies on editorial standards that vary by article quality. While the Wikimedia Foundation maintains reasonable editorial practices and the article cites sources, Wikipedia entries are not primary documents and lack the rigor of peer-reviewed scholarship or official records.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "us marine corps history division" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "icasualties" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us marine corps intelligence report 2006" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is secondary source journalism that aggregates information from other sources (indicated by citation markers like [4]), lacks peer review, and relies on editorial standards that vary by article quality. While the Wikimedia Foundation maintains reasonable editorial practices and the article cites sources, Wikipedia entries are not primary documents and lack the rigor of peer-reviewed scholarship or official records.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the Anbar Awakening's formation and the Anbar campaign's timeline, which are mentioned as alternative explanations in the sub-claim, but does not directly address whether the 2007 troop surge and tactical changes were a major independent cause of the 2007-2008 violence decline.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the Anbar Awakening's formation and the general timeline of violence in Anbar, but makes no causal claims about the relative contributions of the 2007 troop surge versus the Awakening, ceasefire, or sectarian displacement to the 2007-2008 violence decline.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us marine corps history division\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"icasualties\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us marine corps intelligence report 2006\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3494, "completion_tokens": 4315, "total_tokens": 7809, "reasoning_tokens": 3947 }, "cost_usd": 0.018633924, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.976576Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia article relaying official statements and policy announcements from named government sources (Bush, White House Press Secretary Tony Snow) and citing secondary reporting, but lacking primary documents, peer review, or independent verification of claims about violence levels and force posture effects. The excerpt provides factual policy description rather than evidence-based analysis of the stated topic.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush address to the nation january 10 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house fact sheet the new way forward in iraq" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bob woodward the war within 2008" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hillary clinton and barack obama statements on surge" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia article relaying official statements and policy announcements from named government sources (Bush, White House Press Secretary Tony Snow) and citing secondary reporting, but lacking primary documents, peer review, or independent verification of claims about violence levels and force posture effects. The excerpt provides factual policy description rather than evidence-based analysis of the stated topic.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly describes the 2007 troop surge and its stated tactical changes, but does not address the causal claim about violence decline or compare it against alternative explanations like the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the surge's stated objectives and that critics later argued it was successful, but provides no evidence about the actual causal relationship between the surge and the 2007-2008 violence decline, nor does it address the relative contributions of the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush address to the nation january 10 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house fact sheet the new way forward in iraq\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"bob woodward the war within 2008\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hillary clinton and barack obama statements on surge\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3196, "completion_tokens": 7518, "total_tokens": 10714, "reasoning_tokens": 7777 }, "cost_usd": 0.03352528, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.976692Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a peer-reviewed academic work by a named professor at an established university, published through a recognized research institute (Costs of War at Brown University), with explicit sourcing to Iraq Body Count and government/press reports. However, it falls short of 0.9 because it is a secondary analysis synthesizing existing data rather than a primary document, and the exact peer-review status and editorial standards of the Costs of War project are not explicitly stated in the excerpt.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a peer-reviewed academic work by a named professor at an established university, published through a recognized research institute (Costs of War at Brown University), with explicit sourcing to Iraq Body Count and government/press reports. However, it falls short of 0.9 because it is a secondary analysis synthesizing existing data rather than a primary document, and the exact peer-review status and editorial standards of the Costs of War project are not explicitly stated in the excerpt.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses civilian deaths in Iraq across the 2003-2013 period and would contain data on trends between mid-2007 and mid-2008, making it highly relevant to the sub-claim, though the excerpt provided does not explicitly present the specific temporal comparison being tested.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt provides overall casualty estimates and general statements about ongoing violence but contains no specific data comparing civilian deaths between the time periods (mid-2007 to mid-2008 versus 2006 and early-2007) mentioned in the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3397, "completion_tokens": 3814, "total_tokens": 7211, "reasoning_tokens": 3479 }, "cost_usd": 0.015106488, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.976810Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a peer-reviewed academic work by a named professor at an established university, published through a recognized research institute (Costs of War at Brown University), with explicit sourcing to Iraq Body Count and government/press reports. However, it falls short of 0.9 because it is a secondary analysis synthesizing existing data rather than a primary document, and the exact peer-review status and editorial standards of the Costs of War project are not explicitly stated in the excerpt.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a peer-reviewed academic work by a named professor at an established university, published through a recognized research institute (Costs of War at Brown University), with explicit sourcing to Iraq Body Count and government/press reports. However, it falls short of 0.9 because it is a secondary analysis synthesizing existing data rather than a primary document, and the exact peer-review status and editorial standards of the Costs of War project are not explicitly stated in the excerpt.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses civilian deaths in Iraq across the 2003-2013 period and would contain data on trends between mid-2007 and mid-2008, making it highly relevant to the sub-claim, though the excerpt provided does not explicitly present the specific temporal comparison being tested.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt provides overall casualty estimates for 2003-2013 but does not contain specific data comparing civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008 versus 2006 and early-2007, which is required to evaluate the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 980, "completion_tokens": 99, "total_tokens": 1079, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001475, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.976810Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Congressional Research Service is a reputable, non-partisan legislative branch agency with established editorial standards and transparency. The document explicitly acknowledges methodological limitations and varying data sources (government and NGO estimates), demonstrates appropriate caution about data reliability, and cites primary sources including DOD records and named alternative sources, though it is a secondary compilation rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "congressional research service" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Congressional Research Service is a reputable, non-partisan legislative branch agency with established editorial standards and transparency. The document explicitly acknowledges methodological limitations and varying data sources (government and NGO estimates), demonstrates appropriate caution about data reliability, and cites primary sources including DOD records and named alternative sources, though it is a secondary compilation rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Iraqi civilian death estimates and includes a figure covering January 2006 to August 2008, which encompasses the exact time period in the sub-claim (mid-2007 to mid-2008), making it highly relevant though the excerpt does not explicitly state whether deaths fell substantially during that specific interval.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt provides only a summary and table of contents indicating the document contains estimates and figures on Iraqi civilian deaths from January 2006 to August 2008, but does not present the actual data, trends, or analysis needed to evaluate whether deaths fell substantially between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"congressional research service\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2834, "completion_tokens": 341, "total_tokens": 3175, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.004516104, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.976987Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "TIME article relays findings from Iraq Body Count, a named independent organization with documented methodology (tracking incidents since 2003), and includes specific numerical data with caveats. However, it is secondary reporting of another organization's research rather than primary documentation, and lacks direct access to underlying source data or methodology details.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "associated press" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"TIME article relays findings from Iraq Body Count, a named independent organization with documented methodology (tracking incidents since 2003), and includes specific numerical data with caveats. However, it is secondary reporting of another organization's research rather than primary documentation, and lacks direct access to underlying source data or methodology details.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports civilian death statistics comparing 2008 (8,315-9,028), 2007 (22,671), and 2006 (25,774), explicitly confirming the substantial decrease in civilian deaths from 2006-2007 levels to 2008, which precisely matches the sub-claim's timeframe and proposition.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.85,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document presents direct data from Iraq Body Count showing civilian deaths fell from over 25,774 in 2006 and over 22,671 in 2007 to 8,315-9,028 in 2008, which directly supports the sub-claim of substantial decline between mid-2007 and mid-2008 from earlier 2006-2007 levels.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"associated press\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3275, "completion_tokens": 1271, "total_tokens": 4546, "reasoning_tokens": 910 }, "cost_usd": 0.008938, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.977108Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a peer-reviewed study published in PLOS Medicine (high-impact open-access journal with rigorous peer review standards) analyzing a large, named primary dataset (Iraq Body Count database of 92,614 documented deaths) using transparent statistical methods. The source provides specific methodology, named data sources, and quantified findings, meeting the standards of peer-reviewed research on a sensitive empirical topic.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a peer-reviewed study published in PLOS Medicine (high-impact open-access journal with rigorous peer review standards) analyzing a large, named primary dataset (Iraq Body Count database of 92,614 documented deaths) using transparent statistical methods. The source provides specific methodology, named data sources, and quantified findings, meeting the standards of peer-reviewed research on a sensitive empirical topic.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly analyzes Iraqi civilian deaths from March 2003 through March 2008, including temporal trends that would directly measure whether deaths fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008 compared to 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document analyzes 92,614 Iraqi civilian deaths from March 2003 through March 2008 using the Iraq Body Count database, and the temporal analysis framework supports the sub-claim's timeframe (mid-2007 to mid-2008 compared to 2006 and early-2007), though the excerpt does not explicitly state the magnitude of the decline.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3095, "completion_tokens": 345, "total_tokens": 3440, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00455978, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.977220Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a peer-reviewed study published in PLOS Medicine (high-impact open-access journal with rigorous peer review standards) analyzing a large, named primary dataset (Iraq Body Count database of 92,614 documented deaths) using transparent statistical methods. The source provides specific methodology, named data sources, and quantified findings, meeting the standards of peer-reviewed research on a sensitive empirical topic.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a peer-reviewed study published in PLOS Medicine (high-impact open-access journal with rigorous peer review standards) analyzing a large, named primary dataset (Iraq Body Count database of 92,614 documented deaths) using transparent statistical methods. The source provides specific methodology, named data sources, and quantified findings, meeting the standards of peer-reviewed research on a sensitive empirical topic.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly analyzes Iraqi civilian deaths from March 2003 through March 2008, including temporal trends that would directly measure whether deaths fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008 compared to 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document analyzes Iraq Body Count data through March 19, 2008, and describes temporal patterns of civilian deaths, but the excerpt does not explicitly state whether deaths fell substantially between mid-2007 and mid-2008, thus it does not directly support the negation claimed in the sub-claim; however, the study's focus on analyzing deaths across the full 2003-2008 period and mention of peak periods during invasion suggests deaths did not remain at early-2007 levels, contradicting the sub-claim's assertion.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 921, "completion_tokens": 157, "total_tokens": 1078, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001706, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.977220Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a primary document: an official Department of Defense report to Congress mandated by statute (Public Law 109-289), representing authoritative government records on Iraq security metrics. While hosted on globalsecurity.org (a secondary aggregator), the source material itself is a primary official document with institutional accountability and no apparent conflicts of interest in its production.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense report to congress june 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a primary document: an official Department of Defense report to Congress mandated by statute (Public Law 109-289), representing authoritative government records on Iraq security metrics. While hosted on globalsecurity.org (a secondary aggregator), the source material itself is a primary official document with institutional accountability and no apparent conflicts of interest in its production.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly describes the 2007 troop increase and its stated security objectives in Baghdad, but does not empirically analyze whether this increase was a major cause of violence decline compared to other factors like the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the 2007 troop increase and Operation Fardh al-Qanoon as launched in February 2007 but provides no data comparing violence levels before/after the surge or isolating its causal contribution relative to other factors like the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"department of defense report to congress june 2007\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3102, "completion_tokens": 346, "total_tokens": 3448, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00454124, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.977393Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is from a reputable think tank (CFR) with editorial standards, cites named primary sources (Gen. Petraeus's Congressional testimony, Pentagon data), and acknowledges methodological criticisms transparently. However, it is secondary reporting on official statistics rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed analysis, and the excerpt shows it presents competing claims without independent verification of the underlying data.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "us military iraq violence statistics" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "gen david petraeus testimony september 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is from a reputable think tank (CFR) with editorial standards, cites named primary sources (Gen. Petraeus's Congressional testimony, Pentagon data), and acknowledges methodological criticisms transparently. However, it is secondary reporting on official statistics rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed analysis, and the excerpt shows it presents competing claims without independent verification of the underlying data.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports military statistics on civilian death declines between December 2006 and August 2007, which closely overlaps the mid-2007 to mid-2008 timeframe and 2006-early 2007 baseline specified in the sub-claim, though it does not extend to mid-2008.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites U.S. military statistics asserting that civilian deaths declined over 45% between December 2006 and August 2007, directly supporting the sub-claim's timeframe and direction, though the document itself notes methodological criticisms and is archived from September 2007 (before mid-2008).\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us military iraq violence statistics\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"gen david petraeus testimony september 2007\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2909, "completion_tokens": 1255, "total_tokens": 4164, "reasoning_tokens": 875 }, "cost_usd": 0.0084248, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.977526Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary source (Wikipedia article) describing peer-reviewed primary studies published in The Lancet, a highly reputable medical journal with rigorous editorial standards. The excerpt provides specific methodological details, confidence intervals, and cites the original peer-reviewed publications, making it a reliable summary of primary research evidence, though not itself a primary document.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary source (Wikipedia article) describing peer-reviewed primary studies published in The Lancet, a highly reputable medical journal with rigorous editorial standards. The excerpt provides specific methodological details, confidence intervals, and cites the original peer-reviewed publications, making it a reliable summary of primary research evidence, though not itself a primary document.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides mortality estimates through mid-2006 and discusses methodology, but does not directly address trends or comparisons between mid-2007 and mid-2008, which is the specific time period and comparison required by the sub-claim.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes Lancet survey estimates through mid-2006 and early 2006, but contains no data or analysis comparing civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008 versus 2006-2007, which is required to evaluate the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3392, "completion_tokens": 338, "total_tokens": 3730, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00471648, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.977645Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary source (Wikipedia article) describing peer-reviewed primary studies published in The Lancet, a highly reputable medical journal with rigorous editorial standards. The excerpt provides specific methodological details, confidence intervals, and cites the original peer-reviewed publications, making it a reliable summary of primary research evidence, though not itself a primary document.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary source (Wikipedia article) describing peer-reviewed primary studies published in The Lancet, a highly reputable medical journal with rigorous editorial standards. The excerpt provides specific methodological details, confidence intervals, and cites the original peer-reviewed publications, making it a reliable summary of primary research evidence, though not itself a primary document.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides mortality estimates through mid-2006 and discusses methodology, but does not directly address trends or comparisons between mid-2007 and mid-2008, which is the specific time period and comparison required by the sub-claim.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes Lancet survey estimates of excess deaths through mid-2006 and early 2006, but contains no data or analysis comparing civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008 versus 2006-2007 levels, which is what the sub-claim addresses.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 991, "completion_tokens": 105, "total_tokens": 1096, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001516, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.977645Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count is a well-established NGO with transparent methodology (31,500+ incidents analyzed with documented sourcing criteria), publicly accessible database, and consistent peer engagement, making it reputable reporting with named sources and systematic documentation. However, it is not peer-reviewed research or a primary government record, and as an advocacy organization focused on documenting civilian casualties, it has inherent methodological constraints and potential selection bias in what incidents are recorded.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq war logs wikileaks" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Iraq Body Count is a well-established NGO with transparent methodology (31,500+ incidents analyzed with documented sourcing criteria), publicly accessible database, and consistent peer engagement, making it reputable reporting with named sources and systematic documentation. However, it is not peer-reviewed research or a primary government record, and as an advocacy organization focused on documenting civilian casualties, it has inherent methodological constraints and potential selection bias in what incidents are recorded.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides overall civilian death statistics from Iraq Body Count covering the full 2003-2013 period, which encompasses the 2006-2008 timeframe in question, but does not specifically isolate or analyze the mid-2007 to mid-2008 period or compare it to 2006-early 2007 levels as the sub-claim requires.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides overall decade-long statistics and general conflict description but contains no specific data comparing civilian deaths between the 2006-early 2007 period and the mid-2007 to mid-2008 period needed to evaluate the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq war logs wikileaks\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3130, "completion_tokens": 359, "total_tokens": 3489, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00462626, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.977813Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is an official U.S. State Department document citing named primary sources (Multinational Force-Iraq, Iraqi ministries, International Mission for Iraqi Elections) with specific quantitative data and attributions. However, it is a secondary government summary rather than a primary record, and State Department publications on Iraq during this period have known credibility concerns regarding conflict-of-interest bias in presenting U.S. policy favorably.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "multinational force iraq" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "international mission for iraqi elections" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of state" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official U.S. State Department document citing named primary sources (Multinational Force-Iraq, Iraqi ministries, International Mission for Iraqi Elections) with specific quantitative data and attributions. However, it is a secondary government summary rather than a primary record, and State Department publications on Iraq during this period have known credibility concerns regarding conflict-of-interest bias in presenting U.S. policy favorably.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports that civilian deaths from violence fell 72 percent to approximately 15 per day during the year (2008), and explicitly states 'Since the second half of 2007 and during the year, the general security situation in the country substantially improved,' which directly addresses the sub-claim about substantial declines in civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly cites MNF-I data showing civilian deaths fell 72 percent to approximately 15 per day during 2008 compared to the previous year, and states the general security situation 'substantially improved' since the second half of 2007, with violence at its lowest level since 2004, though the specific 2006/early-2007 baseline comparison is implicit rather than explicit.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"multinational force iraq\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"international mission for iraqi elections\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of state\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3194, "completion_tokens": 1928, "total_tokens": 5122, "reasoning_tokens": 1526 }, "cost_usd": 0.009997824, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.977924Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official U.S. Department of Defense report to Congress mandated by statute (Public Law 109-289), representing a primary government document with institutional accountability and systematic data collection requirements. While published on globalsecurity.org (a secondary host), the source material itself is an authoritative primary record from a named government agency with clear legal authority and obligation to provide factual reporting.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official U.S. Department of Defense report to Congress mandated by statute (Public Law 109-289), representing a primary government document with institutional accountability and systematic data collection requirements. While published on globalsecurity.org (a secondary host), the source material itself is an authoritative primary record from a named government agency with clear legal authority and obligation to provide factual reporting.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a December 2007 report that mentions 'significant security progress' during September-November 2007, but does not directly present data comparing civilian deaths/attacks across the specific time periods (mid-2007 to mid-2008 versus 2006 and early-2007) required to test the sub-claim.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports on the September-November 2007 period and mentions 'significant security progress' but provides no specific data comparing civilian deaths or attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008, nor does it establish baseline levels from 2006 and early-2007.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"department of defense\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2901, "completion_tokens": 336, "total_tokens": 3237, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00456412, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.978037Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "IBC is a secondary source that systematically compiles primary sources (news media, NGO reports, official records) using transparent methodology, has academic/activist staffing with named founders, and is widely cited by reputable outlets; however, it relies on media reporting rather than being a primary document itself, and acknowledges its own limitations in coverage.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jonathan steele guardian" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"IBC is a secondary source that systematically compiles primary sources (news media, NGO reports, official records) using transparent methodology, has academic/activist staffing with named founders, and is widely cited by reputable outlets; however, it relies on media reporting rather than being a primary document itself, and acknowledges its own limitations in coverage.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the Iraq Body Count project methodology and overall death totals but provides no temporal data comparing civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008 versus 2006 and early-2007, making it only tangential background on the counting mechanism.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the Iraq Body Count project's methodology and overall death totals but contains no data, analysis, or claims about trends between mid-2007 and mid-2008 compared to 2006 and early-2007.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"jonathan steele guardian\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2886, "completion_tokens": 1797, "total_tokens": 4683, "reasoning_tokens": 1470 }, "cost_usd": 0.010494759999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.978175Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is reputable journalism from a major newspaper reporting on multiple survey findings (WHO/Iraqi health ministry, Lancet, Opinion Research Business) with named sources and official records, but it is secondary reporting on others' research rather than primary research itself. The prominent correction notice indicates editorial standards and accountability, though it also reveals significant errors in the original reporting that undermine confidence in the initial analysis.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "who iraqi health ministry survey 2008" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "orb iraq mortality survey 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is reputable journalism from a major newspaper reporting on multiple survey findings (WHO/Iraqi health ministry, Lancet, Opinion Research Business) with named sources and official records, but it is secondary reporting on others' research rather than primary research itself. The prominent correction notice indicates editorial standards and accountability, though it also reveals significant errors in the original reporting that undermine confidence in the initial analysis.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses methodologies and controversies around counting Iraqi deaths generally, but does not directly address trends in civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008 or compare those periods to 2006-early 2007 levels.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses methodological issues with death toll surveys and the US policy of not counting Iraqi deaths, but contains no data or claims about trends in civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"who iraqi health ministry survey 2008\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet iraq mortality survey 2006\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"orb iraq mortality survey 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of defense\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2968, "completion_tokens": 1508, "total_tokens": 4476, "reasoning_tokens": 1156 }, "cost_usd": 0.00944136, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.978293Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is ordinary journalism/encyclopedia relaying findings from other sources (indicated by citation markers like [6]), with editorial standards but no peer review. While it synthesizes information on the topic, it is a secondary source dependent on cited references rather than primary documentation or original research, making it suitable for general overview but not authoritative evidence on specific violence metrics or force posture details.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is ordinary journalism/encyclopedia relaying findings from other sources (indicated by citation markers like [6]), with editorial standards but no peer review. While it synthesizes information on the topic, it is a secondary source dependent on cited references rather than primary documentation or original research, making it suitable for general overview but not authoritative evidence on specific violence metrics or force posture details.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the timeframe and trend in question (mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline) by stating 'The civil war and sectarian violence ended in mid-2008, having been quelled by the American troop surge of 2007,' which closely relates to the claimed reduction in civilian deaths and attacks, though it does not provide specific casualty figures or quantitative evidence.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that 'the civil war and sectarian violence ended in mid-2008, having been quelled by the American troop surge of 2007,' which directly supports the sub-claim that civilian deaths and attacks fell substantially between mid-2007 and mid-2008 from their 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3160, "completion_tokens": 353, "total_tokens": 3513, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00513452, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.978405Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The Internet Archive is hosting a peer-reviewed or official government report (Hannah Fischer's 2008 Congressional Research Service study on Iraqi civilian deaths), which is a primary or near-primary source document with established institutional credibility. The Archive itself is a reputable, non-profit digital preservation organization with transparent operations and no apparent conflicts of interest on this topic.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq ministry of health" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Internet Archive is hosting a peer-reviewed or official government report (Hannah Fischer's 2008 Congressional Research Service study on Iraqi civilian deaths), which is a primary or near-primary source document with established institutional credibility. The Archive itself is a reputable, non-profit digital preservation organization with transparent operations and no apparent conflicts of interest on this topic.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt contains only a donation appeal from the Internet Archive with no substantive content about Iraqi civilian deaths, casualty trends, or the 2006-2008 time period.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt provided contains only a donation solicitation from the Internet Archive and no substantive content about Iraqi civilian deaths or trends between 2007-2008.\\\"}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey 2008\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq ministry of health\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1930, "completion_tokens": 5618, "total_tokens": 7548, "reasoning_tokens": 5330 }, "cost_usd": 0.02457128, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.978546Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The Internet Archive is hosting a peer-reviewed or official government report (Hannah Fischer's 2008 Congressional Research Service study on Iraqi civilian deaths), which is a primary or near-primary source document with established institutional credibility. The Archive itself is a reputable, non-profit digital preservation organization with transparent operations and no apparent conflicts of interest on this topic.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq ministry of health" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Internet Archive is hosting a peer-reviewed or official government report (Hannah Fischer's 2008 Congressional Research Service study on Iraqi civilian deaths), which is a primary or near-primary source document with established institutional credibility. The Archive itself is a reputable, non-profit digital preservation organization with transparent operations and no apparent conflicts of interest on this topic.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt contains only a donation appeal from the Internet Archive with no substantive content about Iraqi civilian deaths, casualty trends, or the 2006-2008 time period.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt provided contains only a donation solicitation from the Internet Archive and no substantive content about Iraqi civilian deaths or trends between 2007-2008.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey 2008\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq ministry of health\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 600, "completion_tokens": 74, "total_tokens": 674, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00097, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.978546Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This appears to be a peer-reviewed academic article (indicated by DOI, abstract format, and jmss.org publication) that uses primary military data (SIGACT records) as its evidentiary basis. However, the source quality is limited to 0.7 rather than 0.9 because the excerpt does not confirm peer-review status, and the journal's reputation and editorial standards are not independently verifiable from the information provided.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This appears to be a peer-reviewed academic article (indicated by DOI, abstract format, and jmss.org publication) that uses primary military data (SIGACT records) as its evidentiary basis. However, the source quality is limited to 0.7 rather than 0.9 because the excerpt does not confirm peer-review status, and the journal's reputation and editorial standards are not independently verifiable from the information provided.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether the 2007 surge was a major cause of the 2007-2008 violence decline by examining alternative explanations and arguing violence peaked before the surge, though it does not explicitly analyze the specific counterfactual of what would have occurred without the surge relative to the Anbar Awakening, ceasefire, and sectarian displacement.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly contradicts the sub-claim by asserting that violence had peaked before the surge was announced, that other factors explained earlier decline, and that the surge was 'unnecessary,' though the specific evidentiary basis (SIGACT data examination versus interpretive analysis) is not fully detailed in the excerpt.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"sigact\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2132, "completion_tokens": 638, "total_tokens": 2770, "reasoning_tokens": 325 }, "cost_usd": 0.0051584, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.978716Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This appears to be a peer-reviewed academic article (indicated by DOI, abstract format, and jmss.org publication) that uses primary military data (SIGACT records) as its evidentiary basis. However, the source quality is limited to 0.7 rather than 0.9 because the excerpt does not confirm peer-review status, and the journal's reputation and editorial standards are not independently verifiable from the information provided.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This appears to be a peer-reviewed academic article (indicated by DOI, abstract format, and jmss.org publication) that uses primary military data (SIGACT records) as its evidentiary basis. However, the source quality is limited to 0.7 rather than 0.9 because the excerpt does not confirm peer-review status, and the journal's reputation and editorial standards are not independently verifiable from the information provided.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether the 2007 surge was a major cause of the 2007-2008 violence decline by examining alternative explanations and arguing violence peaked before the surge, though it does not explicitly analyze the specific counterfactual of what would have occurred without the surge relative to the Anbar Awakening, ceasefire, and sectarian displacement.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document's analysis of SIGACT data provides finding-based evidence that violence peaked before the surge and that other factors contributed to decline before the surge was announced, supporting the sub-claim that the surge was not a major cause; however, the conclusion that the surge was 'unnecessary' is an assertion rather than direct measurement.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"sigact\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 687, "completion_tokens": 111, "total_tokens": 798, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001242, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.978716Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary source (Wikipedia article) describing a primary document (the official Petraeus Report to Congress), with named sources, official attribution, and citations. However, it is a tertiary summary rather than the primary report itself, and Wikipedia's editorial standards, while generally reliable for factual summaries, are not equivalent to peer review or official publication.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary source (Wikipedia article) describing a primary document (the official Petraeus Report to Congress), with named sources, official attribution, and citations. However, it is a tertiary summary rather than the primary report itself, and Wikipedia's editorial standards, while generally reliable for factual summaries, are not equivalent to peer review or official publication.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses Petraeus's claims about the surge's military objectives being met and violence declines, including attribution to operations against Al-Qaeda and Shia militias, which is central to evaluating the sub-claim's core proposition about the surge's causal role in violence reduction.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.6,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Petraeus attributes declines in security incidents to the surge's military operations against Al-Qaeda and Shia militias, and credits Coalition operations with drastically reducing ethno-sectarian violence, supporting the sub-claim that the surge was a major cause of the 2007-2008 violence decline, though the document does not isolate the surge's effect from other factors like the Anbar Awakening or sectarian displacement.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3111, "completion_tokens": 1227, "total_tokens": 4338, "reasoning_tokens": 870 }, "cost_usd": 0.007872168, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.978882Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary source that aggregates and summarizes findings from primary studies and other sources (surveys, body counts, official statements) rather than conducting original research. While it cites multiple sources and distinguishes between methodologies, it lacks the editorial rigor and peer review of academic journals, and Wikipedia's content is subject to editing and potential bias, though it does attempt to present multiple estimates and acknowledge disputes.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "opinion research business survey 2007" }, { "type": "study", "id": "plos medicine 2013" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary source that aggregates and summarizes findings from primary studies and other sources (surveys, body counts, official statements) rather than conducting original research. While it cites multiple sources and distinguishes between methodologies, it lacks the editorial rigor and peer review of academic journals, and Wikipedia's content is subject to editing and potential bias, though it does attempt to present multiple estimates and acknowledge disputes.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses Iraq War casualties broadly and mentions various time periods and estimates, but does not specifically analyze the temporal trend of civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008 compared to 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides general casualty estimates and methodological overview but contains no specific data comparing civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008 versus 2006 and early-2007 periods.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet study 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"opinion research business survey 2007\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"plos medicine 2013\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3317, "completion_tokens": 3123, "total_tokens": 6440, "reasoning_tokens": 2787 }, "cost_usd": 0.01375976, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.978993Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a peer-reviewed journal article (International Security) published by a reputable research institution (Belfer Center), employing systematic methodology including declassified data and 70 structured interviews with primary participants, meeting the standards of academic scholarship on a contemporary policy question.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "declassified iraq violence data 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a peer-reviewed journal article (International Security) published by a reputable research institution (Belfer Center), employing systematic methodology including declassified data and 70 structured interviews with primary participants, meeting the standards of academic scholarship on a contemporary policy question.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether the surge was a major cause of the 2007-2008 violence decline and explicitly evaluates it against the Anbar Awakening and sectarian displacement explanations, though it frames the answer as synergistic rather than isolating the surge's independent contribution.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document supports the sub-claim by arguing the surge was necessary and a major cause of violence reduction beyond what the Awakening or sectarian cleansing alone would have produced, though it bases this on structured interviews and declassified data analysis (finding) combined with causal arguments (assertion) rather than direct experimental evidence.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"declassified iraq violence data 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3318, "completion_tokens": 1617, "total_tokens": 4935, "reasoning_tokens": 1289 }, "cost_usd": 0.01091682, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.979105Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a peer-reviewed journal article (International Security) published by a reputable research institution (Belfer Center), employing systematic methodology including declassified data and 70 structured interviews with primary participants, meeting the standards of academic scholarship on a contemporary policy question.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "declassified iraq violence data 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a peer-reviewed journal article (International Security) published by a reputable research institution (Belfer Center), employing systematic methodology including declassified data and 70 structured interviews with primary participants, meeting the standards of academic scholarship on a contemporary policy question.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether the surge was a major cause of the 2007-2008 violence decline and explicitly evaluates it against the Anbar Awakening and sectarian displacement explanations, though it frames the answer as synergistic rather than isolating the surge's independent contribution.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly contradicts the sub-claim by arguing that the surge was necessary for the 2007 violence reduction and would not have occurred without it, while acknowledging the Anbar Awakening's role as synergistic rather than sufficient alone, based on declassified violence data and structured interviews combined with analytical argument.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"declassified iraq violence data 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 972, "completion_tokens": 112, "total_tokens": 1084, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001532, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.979105Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary source aggregating findings from peer-reviewed studies (Lancet mortality studies) and official reports (UNDP survey), but the document itself is a curated collection/summary rather than original research. While it cites reputable primary sources, it functions as a journalism-style compilation relaying other people's findings without independent methodology or primary data collection.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "first lancet mortality study 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "undp iraq living conditions survey 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "global policy forum" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary source aggregating findings from peer-reviewed studies (Lancet mortality studies) and official reports (UNDP survey), but the document itself is a curated collection/summary rather than original research. While it cites reputable primary sources, it functions as a journalism-style compilation relaying other people's findings without independent methodology or primary data collection.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides background on Iraqi mortality studies and deaths through mid-2006, but does not directly address the specific claim about trends in civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008, which falls outside its primary temporal focus.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is dated October 2006 and contains only historical data through mid-2006, with no information about the mid-2007 to mid-2008 period needed to evaluate the sub-claim about changes between those timeframes.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"second lancet mortality study 2006\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"first lancet mortality study 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"undp iraq living conditions survey 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"global policy forum\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3109, "completion_tokens": 377, "total_tokens": 3486, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00456158, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.979315Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary source aggregating findings from peer-reviewed studies (Lancet mortality studies) and official reports (UNDP survey), but the document itself is a curated collection/summary rather than original research. While it cites reputable primary sources, it functions as a journalism-style compilation relaying other people's findings without independent methodology or primary data collection.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "first lancet mortality study 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "undp iraq living conditions survey 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "global policy forum" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary source aggregating findings from peer-reviewed studies (Lancet mortality studies) and official reports (UNDP survey), but the document itself is a curated collection/summary rather than original research. While it cites reputable primary sources, it functions as a journalism-style compilation relaying other people's findings without independent methodology or primary data collection.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides background on Iraqi mortality studies and deaths through mid-2006, but does not directly address the specific claim about trends in civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008, which falls outside its primary temporal focus.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides mortality estimates through mid-2006 and mentions 2008 incidents but contains no data comparing civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008 versus 2006-early 2007 levels, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"second lancet mortality study 2006\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"first lancet mortality study 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"undp iraq living conditions survey 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"global policy forum\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 924, "completion_tokens": 103, "total_tokens": 1027, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001439, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.979315Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a peer-reviewed article published in International Security, a leading academic journal in security studies, employing rigorous methodology combining declassified data with 70 structured interviews. The source represents high-quality scholarly research with transparent methods and primary source engagement, though it is a secondary analysis rather than a pure primary document.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a peer-reviewed article published in International Security, a leading academic journal in security studies, employing rigorous methodology combining declassified data with 70 structured interviews. The source represents high-quality scholarly research with transparent methods and primary source engagement, though it is a secondary analysis rather than a pure primary document.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly tests the exact proposition by examining whether the 2007 surge in troop levels and tactical changes was a major independent cause of violence decline, comparing it against alternative explanations (Anbar Awakening, sectarian cleansing, Sadrist ceasefire) and their interactions.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document's finding that a 'synergistic interaction between the surge and the Awakening was required' and that 'both were necessary; neither was sufficient' directly supports the sub-claim that the surge was a major cause beyond other factors alone, though the document emphasizes interaction rather than the surge as the sole driver.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"sigacts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2695, "completion_tokens": 2358, "total_tokens": 5053, "reasoning_tokens": 2030 }, "cost_usd": 0.01255892, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.979625Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources rather than providing primary evidence. While Wikipedia maintains editorial standards and requires citations, it is fundamentally a tertiary reference work that aggregates and summarizes existing knowledge, making it ordinary journalism-adjacent in nature rather than a direct evidence source for specific violence metrics or force posture data during 2006-2008.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources rather than providing primary evidence. While Wikipedia maintains editorial standards and requires citations, it is fundamentally a tertiary reference work that aggregates and summarizes existing knowledge, making it ordinary journalism-adjacent in nature rather than a direct evidence source for specific violence metrics or force posture data during 2006-2008.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document mentions the 2007 troop surge and its stabilizing effect, which is adjacent to the sub-claim about civilian deaths falling between mid-2007 and mid-2008, but does not directly report casualty figures or trends for that specific period.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document mentions the 2007 troop surge 'helped stabilize parts of the country' but provides no specific data, measurements, or direct observations about civilian deaths or attacks in the 2006-2008 period to directly support or contradict the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3093, "completion_tokens": 313, "total_tokens": 3406, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0043859, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.979760Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources rather than providing primary evidence. While Wikipedia maintains editorial standards and requires citations, it is fundamentally a tertiary reference work that aggregates and summarizes existing knowledge, making it ordinary journalism-adjacent in nature rather than a direct evidence source for specific violence metrics or force posture data during 2006-2008.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary source that synthesizes information from other sources rather than providing primary evidence. While Wikipedia maintains editorial standards and requires citations, it is fundamentally a tertiary reference work that aggregates and summarizes existing knowledge, making it ordinary journalism-adjacent in nature rather than a direct evidence source for specific violence metrics or force posture data during 2006-2008.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document mentions the 2007 troop surge and its role in stabilizing parts of Iraq, but does not address the specific causal claim about whether the surge was a major cause of the 2007-2008 violence decline beyond the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, and sectarian displacement factors.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states the 2007 troop surge 'helped stabilize parts of the country' but provides no analysis of whether this was a major cause beyond the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement—the specific counterfactual comparison required by the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3161, "completion_tokens": 343, "total_tokens": 3504, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0046039, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.979831Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is an official U.S. military press release with named primary sources (Col. J.B. Burton, a senior Army officer with direct command responsibility) and specific operational data from the 2nd Brigade Combat Team. However, it is inherently advocacy material from an interested party promoting a policy initiative, lacks independent verification, and presents only one perspective on a contested topic, limiting its evidentiary value despite the official sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "american forces press service" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "col jb burton 2nd brigade combat team 1st infantry division" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official U.S. military press release with named primary sources (Col. J.B. Burton, a senior Army officer with direct command responsibility) and specific operational data from the 2nd Brigade Combat Team. However, it is inherently advocacy material from an interested party promoting a policy initiative, lacks independent verification, and presents only one perspective on a contested topic, limiting its evidentiary value despite the official sourcing.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the 2007 troop level increase and tactical changes (moving to community-based outposts) and reports violence decline in one Baghdad sector, but does not isolate this cause from the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement factors mentioned in the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.6,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides direct observations of violence reduction in one Baghdad sector attributed to the tactical change of moving forces into community-based outposts (part of the 2007 surge strategy), but offers only limited scope and does not address whether this exceeded what other factors alone would have produced.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"american forces press service\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"col jb burton 2nd brigade combat team 1st infantry division\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3045, "completion_tokens": 384, "total_tokens": 3429, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00462516, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.979897Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source cites official U.S. military records (MNF-I SIGACTS reports, DOD reports) and UN documentation as primary sources for violence metrics, with transparent methodology explaining what incidents are counted. However, it is a secondary compilation website rather than the original primary documents themselves, and lacks peer review, though it demonstrates editorial standards in sourcing and attribution.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.75, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "mnf i significant activity reports" }, { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, { "type": "study", "id": "un april 2008 report" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source cites official U.S. military records (MNF-I SIGACTS reports, DOD reports) and UN documentation as primary sources for violence metrics, with transparent methodology explaining what incidents are counted. However, it is a secondary compilation website rather than the original primary documents themselves, and lacks peer review, though it demonstrates editorial standards in sourcing and attribution.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on enemy-initiated attacks declining from June 2007 to February 2008 and provides specific data on this period, but focuses on attacks broadly rather than specifically isolating civilian deaths and civilian-targeted attacks as distinct metrics.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.75,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports measured data showing enemy-initiated attacks decreased approximately 70% from June 2007 to February 2008, with daily averages declining from ~180 to ~50, directly supporting the sub-claim of substantial falls between mid-2007 and mid-2008, though the March 2008 uptick slightly qualifies the overall trend.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"mnf i significant activity reports\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"dod march 2008 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un april 2008 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3161, "completion_tokens": 1255, "total_tokens": 4416, "reasoning_tokens": 897 }, "cost_usd": 0.00870664, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.979966Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source cites official U.S. military records (MNF-I SIGACTS reports, DOD reports) and UN documentation as primary sources for violence metrics, with transparent methodology explaining what incidents are counted. However, it is a secondary compilation website rather than the original primary documents themselves, and lacks peer review, though it demonstrates editorial standards in sourcing and attribution.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "mnf i significant activity reports" }, { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, { "type": "study", "id": "un april 2008 report" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source cites official U.S. military records (MNF-I SIGACTS reports, DOD reports) and UN documentation as primary sources for violence metrics, with transparent methodology explaining what incidents are counted. However, it is a secondary compilation website rather than the original primary documents themselves, and lacks peer review, though it demonstrates editorial standards in sourcing and attribution.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on enemy-initiated attacks declining from June 2007 to February 2008 and provides specific data on this period, but focuses on attacks broadly rather than specifically isolating civilian deaths and civilian-targeted attacks as distinct metrics.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.85,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports direct measurements from SIGACTS data showing attacks decreased approximately 70% from June 2007 to February 2008 and daily attacks fell from ~180 to ~50, directly contradicting the sub-claim's negation of substantial decline.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"mnf i significant activity reports\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"dod march 2008 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un april 2008 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 908, "completion_tokens": 99, "total_tokens": 1007, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001403, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.979966Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Human Rights Watch is a reputable international organization with established editorial standards and named sourcing (e.g., US military statements, parliament actions, government officials). However, this is a secondary synthesis report rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study, and specific methodologies and primary sources for violence statistics are not detailed in the excerpt.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "human rights watch" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unhcr iom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us military" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi government" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Human Rights Watch is a reputable international organization with established editorial standards and named sourcing (e.g., US military statements, parliament actions, government officials). However, this is a secondary synthesis report rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study, and specific methodologies and primary sources for violence statistics are not detailed in the excerpt.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document mentions 'security gains in 2008' and detainee population reductions but does not directly report on civilian deaths, attacks, or violence trends between mid-2007 and mid-2008, addressing only a broader security context rather than the specific casualty claim.\\\"}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document mentions 'security gains in 2008' but provides no specific data on civilian deaths or attacks to directly address the sub-claim about their decline between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"human rights watch\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unhcr iom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us military\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi government\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3031, "completion_tokens": 2158, "total_tokens": 5189, "reasoning_tokens": 2085 }, "cost_usd": 0.0120714, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980064Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "CSIS is a reputable think tank with established editorial standards and subject-matter expertise on Middle East security issues. The document appears to be a formal analytical report drawing on official military data, named operations, and documented developments (troop levels, provincial changes, ISF performance), though it is secondary analysis rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CSIS is a reputable think tank with established editorial standards and subject-matter expertise on Middle East security issues. The document appears to be a formal analytical report drawing on official military data, named operations, and documented developments (troop levels, provincial changes, ISF performance), though it is secondary analysis rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the 2007 troop surge's impact on violence and mentions the Anbar Awakening as a factor, but does not isolate the surge's independent causal contribution or systematically compare it against the other mechanisms (Sadrist ceasefire, sectarian displacement) specified in the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.6,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly observes that violence decreased in Anbar Province and security improved in Baghdad following the troop surge and tactical changes, and notes US ability to pursue local alliances against al-Qaeda, but does not isolate the surge's independent causal contribution from other factors like the Awakening or sectarian displacement.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"csis\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3025, "completion_tokens": 339, "total_tokens": 3364, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0044572, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980128Z" }, { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "CSIS is a reputable think tank with established editorial standards and subject-matter expertise on Middle East security issues. The document appears to be a formal analytical report drawing on official military data, named operations, and documented developments (troop levels, provincial changes, ISF performance), though it is secondary analysis rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CSIS is a reputable think tank with established editorial standards and subject-matter expertise on Middle East security issues. The document appears to be a formal analytical report drawing on official military data, named operations, and documented developments (troop levels, provincial changes, ISF performance), though it is secondary analysis rather than a primary document or peer-reviewed study.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"directness\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses the 2007 troop surge's impact on violence and mentions the Anbar Awakening as a factor, but does not isolate the surge's independent causal contribution or systematically compare it against the other mechanisms (Sadrist ceasefire, sectarian displacement) specified in the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"direction\": \"```json\\n{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.6,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document attributes violence reduction in Anbar to US troop increases and changed tactics (Operation Phantom Thunder), while separately noting Sunni tribal resentment against al-Qaeda and US alliances with tribal groups, suggesting the surge itself was a major causal factor rather than merely supplementary to other factors.\\\"\\n}\\n```\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"csis\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 919, "completion_tokens": 108, "total_tokens": 1027, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001459, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980128Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count is a specialized, transparent casualty database built from documented incidents and incident-level sourcing, making it a primary-record-based research resource rather than simple commentary. It is not peer-reviewed in the journal sense, but it has strong methodological standards and a long track record for conflict mortality reporting.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.94, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Iraq Body Count is a specialized, transparent casualty database built from documented incidents and incident-level sourcing, making it a primary-record-based research resource rather than simple commentary. It is not peer-reviewed in the journal sense, but it has strong methodological standards and a long track record for conflict mortality reporting.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly compares civilian death totals in 2008 with 2006 and 2007 and describes a substantial reduction, but it does not specifically isolate the mid-2007 to mid-2008 period or directly compare attack counts over those exact intervals.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.94,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly reports that 2008 civilian deaths were far below 2006 and 2007 levels, stating a reduction from 81/day in 2006 and 72/day in 2007 to 25/day in 2008, which supports a substantial decline by mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3103, "completion_tokens": 3402, "total_tokens": 6505, "reasoning_tokens": 3148 }, "cost_usd": 0.012746148, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980224Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count is a specialized research database using documented incident-level reports, with transparent methods, explicit uncertainty ranges, and ongoing updates based on sourced event records. It is not a peer-reviewed journal, but it is a reputable, methodologically explicit secondary compilation with strong editorial standards and no obvious partisan authorship.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Iraq Body Count is a specialized research database using documented incident-level reports, with transparent methods, explicit uncertainty ranges, and ongoing updates based on sourced event records. It is not a peer-reviewed journal, but it is a reputable, methodologically explicit secondary compilation with strong editorial standards and no obvious partisan authorship.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The Iraq Body Count database directly tracks monthly civilian deaths from violence in Iraq over time, so it closely bears on whether deaths fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008, though the excerpt does not itself state that exact comparison.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.8,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The Iraq Body Count database’s monthly civilian-deaths data and graph are presented as recorded counts, and its overall trend for Iraq during 2007–2008 is consistent with a substantial decline from the 2006/early-2007 peak.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2348, "completion_tokens": 245, "total_tokens": 2593, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00279958, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980285Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Columbia Journalism Review article, so it has editorial standards, but it is a magazine/news analysis piece rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study. It relies mainly on secondary sources and quoted advocacy/reporting about casualty estimates, with limited direct primary sourcing.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "psr study 2015" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "lexisnexis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Columbia Journalism Review article, so it has editorial standards, but it is a magazine/news analysis piece rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study. It relies mainly on secondary sources and quoted advocacy/reporting about casualty estimates, with limited direct primary sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is about overall Iraqi war death estimates and media reporting, not specifically about changes in civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008 versus 2006 and early 2007.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses that Iraq’s violent death rates remained high and critiques casualty-count methods, but it does not provide specific evidence about a substantial fall in civilian deaths or attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008 versus 2006/early 2007.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"psr study 2015\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lexisnexis\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2867, "completion_tokens": 3249, "total_tokens": 6116, "reasoning_tokens": 2995 }, "cost_usd": 0.01655779, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980349Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary, collaboratively edited source with variable editorial control rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed publication. It may summarize named sources, but the provenance and reliability depend on the specific citations and the article’s current state rather than a formal publisher vetting process.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.35, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate 2007" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "unhcr iraqi government 2006" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un secretary general 2006" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a secondary, collaboratively edited source with variable editorial control rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed publication. It may summarize named sources, but the provenance and reliability depend on the specific citations and the article’s current state rather than a formal publisher vetting process.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly discusses the 2008 decline in violence and explicitly mentions the U.S. troop surge alongside the Sunni Awakening, but it does not assess the surge’s independent causal contribution relative to the other factors in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.35,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says violence declined dramatically in 2008 during the Sunni Awakening and the U.S. troop surge, which supports the claim that the surge and tactics changes were a major cause, but it does not compare their effect against the other listed factors.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate 2007\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unhcr iraqi government 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un secretary general 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"george w bush 2007\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3298, "completion_tokens": 2683, "total_tokens": 5981, "reasoning_tokens": 2398 }, "cost_usd": 0.0109430394, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980409Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This appears to be a university-published scholarly work on an academic research platform, which typically implies editorial oversight and a formal research method. It is not a primary record, but it is much closer to peer-reviewed academic evidence than to journalism or opinion.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "mnfi sigacts iii" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This appears to be a university-published scholarly work on an academic research platform, which typically implies editorial oversight and a formal research method. It is not a primary record, but it is much closer to peer-reviewed academic evidence than to journalism or opinion.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The title directly indicates the document is about testing whether the 2007 surge caused the decline in violence in Iraq, which closely matches the sub-claim, though the excerpt itself provides no substantive findings or comparison to the alternative explanations.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt provides only bibliographic metadata and a title, with no substantive findings or claims about the causes of the 2007-2008 decline in violence in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"mnfi sigacts iii\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1836, "completion_tokens": 3996, "total_tokens": 5832, "reasoning_tokens": 3766 }, "cost_usd": 0.013598699399999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980485Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a general informational webpage from a military history organization, but the excerpt provides no citations, named primary sources, or clear editorial methodology. It appears to be a secondary summary from a likely reputable institution, yet not at a level of rigor approaching peer-reviewed work or primary records.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.84, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "pritzkermilitary org" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a general informational webpage from a military history organization, but the excerpt provides no citations, named primary sources, or clear editorial methodology. It appears to be a secondary summary from a likely reputable institution, yet not at a level of rigor approaching peer-reviewed work or primary records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly discusses the 2007 violence decline in Iraq and names the surge, Anbar Awakening, and the Sadrist ceasefire as causes, but it does not explicitly assess whether the surge was a major cause beyond what the other factors would have produced on their own.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.84,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt explicitly states that violence decreased in 2007 for four reasons, including the U.S. troop increase ('The Surge'), alongside the Awakening and the Sadrist ceasefire, which supports the claim that the surge was a major contributing cause.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"pritzkermilitary.org\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3031, "completion_tokens": 266, "total_tokens": 3297, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0033814400000000003, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980546Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a Congressional Research Service report, a high-standard government research product with editorial review and explicit discussion of sources and methodological limits. It is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary record, but it draws on official and other named data sources and is generally reliable for evidence context.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi ministries data" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of defense data" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Congressional Research Service report, a high-standard government research product with editorial review and explicit discussion of sources and methodological limits. It is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary record, but it draws on official and other named data sources and is generally reliable for evidence context.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The report directly compiles Iraqi civilian casualty statistics over time, including monthly civilian death patterns from January 2006 through May 2009, which closely relates to assessing whether deaths fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says the report includes U.S. Department of Defense monthly data on Iraqi civilian deaths, and its figure spans January 2006 to May 2009, which is consistent with showing the mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline relative to 2006/early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraqi ministries data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of defense data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"brookings iraq index\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2856, "completion_tokens": 5879, "total_tokens": 8735, "reasoning_tokens": 5595 }, "cost_usd": 0.0200337036, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980607Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a Congressional Research Service report, a high-standard government research product with editorial review and explicit discussion of sources and methodological limits. It is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary record, but it draws on official and other named data sources and is generally reliable for evidence context.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi ministries data" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of defense data" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Congressional Research Service report, a high-standard government research product with editorial review and explicit discussion of sources and methodological limits. It is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary record, but it draws on official and other named data sources and is generally reliable for evidence context.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The report directly compiles Iraqi civilian casualty statistics over time, including monthly civilian death patterns from January 2006 through May 2009, which closely relates to assessing whether deaths fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.85,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The report’s summary and figures present monthly Iraqi civilian death data showing higher levels in 2006/early 2007 and a substantial decline by mid-2008, which directly contradicts the claim that such deaths and attacks did not fall substantially.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraqi ministries data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of defense data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"brookings iraq index\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 783, "completion_tokens": 77, "total_tokens": 860, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00093375, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980607Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary analytical essay published on Small Wars Journal, a reputable niche outlet with editorial oversight but not peer review. It cites sources in-text, but the excerpt itself is not primary evidence and does not indicate a rigorous research or official-document standard.", "directness": 0.9, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "small wars journal 2013" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a secondary analytical essay published on Small Wars Journal, a reputable niche outlet with editorial oversight but not peer review. It cites sources in-text, but the excerpt itself is not primary evidence and does not indicate a rigorous research or official-document standard.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly examines why violence declined during the 2007 surge and explicitly weighs the surge against local factors including the Sunni cooperation/Anbar Awakening and the Mahdi Army ceasefire, closely matching the sub-claim though not necessarily the exact sectarian-displacement component.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.8,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The essay explicitly argues that the surge alone was not a satisfactory explanation and that local factors such as Sunni cooperation in Anbar and the Mahdi Army ceasefire were of equal importance, which cuts against the claim that the troop increase and tactics were a major cause beyond those factors.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"small wars journal 2013\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3138, "completion_tokens": 250, "total_tokens": 3388, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0034019000000000002, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980699Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article, which is a tertiary source with variable editorial control and no stable primary authorship. It may cite sources, but as presented it is not a primary record or a strongly vetted scholarly/official publication, so it is limited evidence quality.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "us marine corps history division" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "icasualties" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us marine corps intelligence report 2006" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.3,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article, which is a tertiary source with variable editorial control and no stable primary authorship. It may cite sources, but as presented it is not a primary record or a strongly vetted scholarly/official publication, so it is limited evidence quality.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses the Anbar Awakening and the broader Iraq war violence timeline, but it does not directly evaluate the 2007 troop surge’s independent causal contribution to the 2007-2008 decline in violence relative to other factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.4,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"mixed\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says violence in Anbar was worsening until 2006, then mentions the Anbar Awakening and also the Marine Corps’ late-2006 intelligence judgment that more troops were needed, which is consistent with a view that the troop surge and tactics helped reduce violence beyond other factors, but it does not directly compare their separate effects.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us marine corps history division\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"icasualties\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us marine corps intelligence report 2006\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3228, "completion_tokens": 4238, "total_tokens": 7466, "reasoning_tokens": 3947 }, "cost_usd": 0.017290674, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980760Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary, collaboratively edited reference work with variable sourcing and no formal peer review, so it is only ordinary reference quality for this topic. It may summarize cited news and official materials, but the platform’s open-editing model and variable editorial control limit it as evidence.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush address to the nation january 10 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house fact sheet the new way forward in iraq" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bob woodward the war within 2008" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hillary clinton and barack obama statements on surge" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a secondary, collaboratively edited reference work with variable sourcing and no formal peer review, so it is only ordinary reference quality for this topic. It may summarize cited news and official materials, but the platform’s open-editing model and variable editorial control limit it as evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt describes the 2007 troop surge, its tactical shift toward securing neighborhoods, and its intended role in reducing violence, but it does not directly assess whether it was a major cause beyond the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement effects.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt describes the troop surge, its goals, and later retrospective opinions that it was successful, but it does not compare the surge's causal contribution against the Anbar Awakening, the Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush address to the nation january 10 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house fact sheet the new way forward in iraq\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"bob woodward the war within 2008\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hillary clinton and barack obama statements on surge\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3025, "completion_tokens": 7442, "total_tokens": 10467, "reasoning_tokens": 7777 }, "cost_usd": 0.03230478, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980847Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a university-hosted research report by a named professor from Brown’s Costs of War project, with apparent academic editorial standards and transparent use of government and press tallies plus Iraq Body Count. It is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary record, but its sourcing and institutional backing make it strong evidence.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a university-hosted research report by a named professor from Brown’s Costs of War project, with apparent academic editorial standards and transparent use of government and press tallies plus Iraq Body Count. It is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary record, but its sourcing and institutional backing make it strong evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses Iraqi civilian deaths over the broader 2003-2013 war period and may include time trends, but the excerpt does not specifically focus on the mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline relative to 2006 and early 2007.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.2,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says direct violence continued to harm civilians in Iraq and discusses overall civilian deaths since 2003, but it does not directly compare mid-2007/mid-2008 levels with 2006 and early-2007 levels; at most it loosely fits a general decline context.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3127, "completion_tokens": 3737, "total_tokens": 6864, "reasoning_tokens": 3479 }, "cost_usd": 0.013763988, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980912Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a university-hosted research report by a named professor from Brown’s Costs of War project, with apparent academic editorial standards and transparent use of government and press tallies plus Iraq Body Count. It is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary record, but its sourcing and institutional backing make it strong evidence.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a university-hosted research report by a named professor from Brown’s Costs of War project, with apparent academic editorial standards and transparent use of government and press tallies plus Iraq Body Count. It is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary record, but its sourcing and institutional backing make it strong evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document discusses Iraqi civilian deaths over the broader 2003-2013 war period and may include time trends, but the excerpt does not specifically focus on the mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline relative to 2006 and early 2007.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.6,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says civilian deaths in Iraq continued and gives no indication of a substantial fall from 2006/early-2007 to mid-2008, which fits the negated claim, but it does not directly present the relevant mid-2007 to mid-2008 comparison.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 881, "completion_tokens": 90, "total_tokens": 971, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00106575, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.980912Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a Congressional Research Service report hosted on congress.gov, a highly reputable, nonpartisan policy research product with clear editorial standards and institutional accountability. It is a secondary synthesis of governmental and nongovernmental estimates rather than a primary record, but its sourcing and methodology are transparent and careful.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "congressional research service" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Congressional Research Service report hosted on congress.gov, a highly reputable, nonpartisan policy research product with clear editorial standards and institutional accountability. It is a secondary synthesis of governmental and nongovernmental estimates rather than a primary record, but its sourcing and methodology are transparent and careful.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":1.0,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is specifically about Iraqi civilian casualties estimates and includes a figure covering January 2006 to August 2008, directly addressing changes in civilian deaths over the relevant period.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.7,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"mixed\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The report’s figure on estimated Iraqi civilian deaths from January 2006 to August 2008 indicates that deaths were lower by mid-2008 than in 2006/early 2007, though it is a compilation of estimates rather than direct measured counts.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"congressional research service\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2596, "completion_tokens": 241, "total_tokens": 2837, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.003184104, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981000Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "TIME is a mainstream news magazine with editorial standards, but this piece is a secondary report summarizing findings from Iraq Body Count rather than presenting original primary records. It cites an identifiable source and AP for some incident details, but the evidence base is still indirect and not peer-reviewed or official inquiry.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "associated press" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"TIME is a mainstream news magazine with editorial standards, but this piece is a secondary report summarizing findings from Iraq Body Count rather than presenting original primary records. It cites an identifiable source and AP for some incident details, but the evidence base is still indirect and not peer-reviewed or official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly reports a substantial drop in civilian deaths in 2008 versus 2006 and 2007, which closely overlaps with the claim’s mid-2007 to mid-2008 comparison, though it does not specifically analyze that exact period or attack counts.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt reports Iraq Body Count data showing 2008 civilian deaths were far below 2006 and 2007 levels, and says deaths from unknown perpetrators had plummeted by 87% from 2006, which supports a substantial mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline relative to 2006/early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"associated press\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3112, "completion_tokens": 1191, "total_tokens": 4303, "reasoning_tokens": 910 }, "cost_usd": 0.0077025, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981073Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published in PLOS Medicine, a peer-reviewed journal with strong editorial standards. This is a secondary statistical analysis using a large public database (Iraq Body Count), with clear methods and no obvious conflict of interest, though it is not a primary record itself.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Published in PLOS Medicine, a peer-reviewed journal with strong editorial standards. This is a secondary statistical analysis using a large public database (Iraq Body Count), with clear methods and no obvious conflict of interest, though it is not a primary record itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The article directly analyzes Iraqi civilian deaths over time through March 2008 and includes temporal trends, which is closely related to assessing whether deaths and attacks fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008, though it does not exactly focus on that specific comparison window or on attacks broadly.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.8,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The article analyzes recorded civilian deaths through March 2008 and reports temporal patterns showing violence and deaths had fallen from earlier peaks, consistent with a substantial drop by mid-2008 relative to 2006/early 2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2912, "completion_tokens": 241, "total_tokens": 3153, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00319753, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981145Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published in PLOS Medicine, a peer-reviewed journal with strong editorial standards. This is a secondary statistical analysis using a large public database (Iraq Body Count), with clear methods and no obvious conflict of interest, though it is not a primary record itself.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.74, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Published in PLOS Medicine, a peer-reviewed journal with strong editorial standards. This is a secondary statistical analysis using a large public database (Iraq Body Count), with clear methods and no obvious conflict of interest, though it is not a primary record itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The article directly analyzes Iraqi civilian deaths over time through March 2008 and includes temporal trends, which is closely related to assessing whether deaths and attacks fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008, though it does not exactly focus on that specific comparison window or on attacks broadly.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.74,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt reports analyzed death data through early 2008 and says deaths from Coalition air attacks peaked during the invasion, which supports the idea that civilian deaths/attacks were not substantially falling from 2006 to mid-2008 rather than showing such a decline.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 851, "completion_tokens": 79, "total_tokens": 930, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00099375, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981145Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This is an official U.S. Department of Defense report to Congress, which gives it strong institutional credibility and primary-source value on Iraq security conditions and U.S. force posture. It is still a government narrative rather than an independent inquiry, so it falls short of the highest evidence tier.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.55, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense report to congress june 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an official U.S. Department of Defense report to Congress, which gives it strong institutional credibility and primary-source value on Iraq security conditions and U.S. force posture. It is still a government narrative rather than an independent inquiry, so it falls short of the highest evidence tier.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The report directly describes the 2007 U.S. troop increase and new security tactics in Iraq and frames them as intended to reduce violence, but it does not analyze whether they were the major cause beyond the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, and sectarian displacement effects.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.55,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document says the 2007 Baghdad operation increased U.S. brigade combat teams and was intended to provide population security, contain sectarian violence, and support reductions in violence, which is consistent with the troop surge/tactics being a major cause, though it does not compare effects against the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"department of defense report to congress june 2007\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2933, "completion_tokens": 287, "total_tokens": 3220, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0033959899999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981230Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Council on Foreign Relations is a reputable policy publisher with editorial standards, but this is a secondary explainer rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study. It summarizes U.S. military figures and cited reports, so it is useful evidence but not definitive.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.74, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "us military iraq violence statistics" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "gen david petraeus testimony september 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Council on Foreign Relations is a reputable policy publisher with editorial standards, but this is a secondary explainer rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study. It summarizes U.S. military figures and cited reports, so it is useful evidence but not definitive.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly discusses a substantial decline in Iraqi civilian deaths and violence during 2007, which is closely related to the mid-2007 to mid-2008 comparison, but it does not cover the full time span or specifically compare against 2006 and early 2007 levels through mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.74,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt reports U.S. military figures that civilian deaths in Iraq dropped dramatically from December 2006 to August 2007, which supports the claim of a substantial fall from 2006/early-2007 levels toward mid-2008, though it does not reach mid-2008 directly.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us military iraq violence statistics\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"gen david petraeus testimony september 2007\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2750, "completion_tokens": 1176, "total_tokens": 3926, "reasoning_tokens": 875 }, "cost_usd": 0.0072333, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981290Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article from the Wikimedia Foundation, so it is secondary/tertiary rather than a primary record and is not itself peer reviewed. It may summarize peer-reviewed studies and cite sources, but as a wiki page its editorial control and sourcing reliability are more variable than reputable journalism or official records.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article from the Wikimedia Foundation, so it is secondary/tertiary rather than a primary record and is not itself peer reviewed. It may summarize peer-reviewed studies and cite sources, but as a wiki page its editorial control and sourcing reliability are more variable than reputable journalism or official records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt concerns overall excess mortality in Iraq up to mid-2006, not the specific change in civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt reports estimated excess deaths through June 2006 from Lancet surveys, but it does not address whether civilian deaths and attacks fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3221, "completion_tokens": 259, "total_tokens": 3480, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00344473, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981351Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article from the Wikimedia Foundation, so it is secondary/tertiary rather than a primary record and is not itself peer reviewed. It may summarize peer-reviewed studies and cite sources, but as a wiki page its editorial control and sourcing reliability are more variable than reputable journalism or official records.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article from the Wikimedia Foundation, so it is secondary/tertiary rather than a primary record and is not itself peer reviewed. It may summarize peer-reviewed studies and cite sources, but as a wiki page its editorial control and sourcing reliability are more variable than reputable journalism or official records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt concerns overall excess mortality in Iraq up to mid-2006, not the specific change in civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Lancet mortality estimates through mid-2006 and does not address whether civilian deaths and attacks fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 926, "completion_tokens": 58, "total_tokens": 984, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0009555, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981351Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count is a specialized, transparent research project with a long-running public database and documented incident-level methodology, but it is not peer-reviewed and relies on media, hospital, and other reported sources rather than primary field verification for every case. As an evidence source on violence levels and force posture, it is more credible than ordinary advocacy or journalism, though still a secondary compiled record.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.3, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq war logs wikileaks" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Iraq Body Count is a specialized, transparent research project with a long-running public database and documented incident-level methodology, but it is not peer-reviewed and relies on media, hospital, and other reported sources rather than primary field verification for every case. As an evidence source on violence levels and force posture, it is more credible than ordinary advocacy or journalism, though still a secondary compiled record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is a broad statistical overview of civilian deaths and injuries in Iraq over a decade, but the excerpt does not specifically compare mid-2007 to mid-2008 against 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.3,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says IBC continuously tracked and analyzed civilian death incidents and provides decade-wide totals, which is compatible with (though not directly specific to) a substantial decline in civilian deaths and attacks by mid-2008 relative to 2006 and early 2007.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq war logs wikileaks\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2915, "completion_tokens": 279, "total_tokens": 3194, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00334276, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981439Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official U.S. Department of State publication, which generally has strong editorial standards and uses government/military reporting and official records. It is not a primary record itself, but for this topic it draws on contemporaneous official data and is a highly credible secondary source.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "multinational force iraq" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "international mission for iraqi elections" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of state" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is an official U.S. Department of State publication, which generally has strong editorial standards and uses government/military reporting and official records. It is not a primary record itself, but for this topic it draws on contemporaneous official data and is a highly credible secondary source.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly reports a substantial drop in civilian deaths during 2008 beginning in the second half of 2007, but it does not explicitly compare mid-2007 to mid-2008 or to 2006 and early-2007 levels in the exact terms of the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly states that since the second half of 2007 violence substantially improved and that civilian deaths from violence fell 72 percent during the year, which supports a substantial decline from 2006/early-2007 levels by mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"multinational force iraq\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"international mission for iraqi elections\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of state\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2985, "completion_tokens": 1804, "total_tokens": 4789, "reasoning_tokens": 1526 }, "cost_usd": 0.008527824, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981516Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This appears to be a reproduced U.S. Department of Defense Report to Congress, which is a primary official source with named institutional authorship and formal government reporting standards. The globalsecurity.org publisher is a secondary host rather than the original issuing body, so it is strong but not a definitive primary repository.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This appears to be a reproduced U.S. Department of Defense Report to Congress, which is a primary official source with named institutional authorship and formal government reporting standards. The globalsecurity.org publisher is a secondary host rather than the original issuing body, so it is strong but not a definitive primary repository.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is a security report on Iraq with a reporting period in late 2007, so it is adjacent to the claim about declining civilian deaths and attacks in mid-2007 to mid-2008, but the excerpt does not directly provide that exact comparison or time window.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.7,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"mixed\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The report says there was 'significant security progress' in Iraq during September-November 2007, which supports a drop in attacks and violence compared with earlier levels, but the excerpt does not provide specific civilian-death or mid-2008 figures and is largely a progress assertion.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"department of defense\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2727, "completion_tokens": 267, "total_tokens": 2994, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00341487, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981579Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article summarizing a civilian-death tracking project, not a primary record or peer-reviewed study. It describes a media-centered database compiled from news, NGO, and official reports, which makes it useful secondary evidence but with limited direct sourcing and editorial reliability compared with official records or scholarly work.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jonathan steele guardian" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article summarizing a civilian-death tracking project, not a primary record or peer-reviewed study. It describes a media-centered database compiled from news, NGO, and official reports, which makes it useful secondary evidence but with limited direct sourcing and editorial reliability compared with official records or scholarly work.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document is about a database of Iraqi civilian deaths and attacks across the Iraq war, which is adjacent to the mid-2007 to mid-2008 trend claim, but it does not directly present that specific time-period comparison.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"mixed\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt describes the Iraq Body Count project and its methodology, but it gives no mid-2007 to mid-2008 comparison of civilian deaths or attacks in Iraq versus 2006/early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"jonathan steele guardian\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2708, "completion_tokens": 1739, "total_tokens": 4447, "reasoning_tokens": 1470 }, "cost_usd": 0.00940926, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981639Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The Guardian is a reputable newspaper with editorial standards, but this is a journalistic article drawing on other studies and commentary rather than presenting primary evidence. It is useful secondary reporting, though not as strong as an official inquiry or peer-reviewed source, and the excerpt also shows a later correction on key details.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "who iraqi health ministry survey 2008" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "orb iraq mortality survey 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The Guardian is a reputable newspaper with editorial standards, but this is a journalistic article drawing on other studies and commentary rather than presenting primary evidence. It is useful secondary reporting, though not as strong as an official inquiry or peer-reviewed source, and the excerpt also shows a later correction on key details.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses Iraq civilian death counts and violence-related mortality in general, but it does not directly compare mid-2007 to mid-2008 or specifically address a substantial fall from 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses the lack of reliable body counts and the humanitarian toll in general, but it does not provide evidence that civilian deaths or attacks fell substantially between mid-2007 and mid-2008 relative to 2006/early-2007.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"who iraqi health ministry survey 2008\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet iraq mortality survey 2006\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"orb iraq mortality survey 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of defense\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2807, "completion_tokens": 1459, "total_tokens": 4266, "reasoning_tokens": 1156 }, "cost_usd": 0.00839961, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981700Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary source with editorial oversight and citation requirements, but it is not itself primary evidence and can vary in sourcing quality by article and revision. For this topic it is usable for orientation, but it is weaker than official records, peer-reviewed studies, or well-sourced investigative reporting.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary source with editorial oversight and citation requirements, but it is not itself primary evidence and can vary in sourcing quality by article and revision. For this topic it is usable for orientation, but it is weaker than official records, peer-reviewed studies, or well-sourced investigative reporting.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses the overall 2006–mid-2008 violence trend and says the civil war and sectarian violence ended in mid-2008, but it does not directly quantify civilian deaths or attacks or compare mid-2007/mid-2008 levels to 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.8,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says sectarian violence and the civil war ended in mid-2008 after the 2007 troop surge, which supports the claim that civilian deaths and attacks had fallen substantially by that time compared with the 2006/early-2007 peak, though it does not provide specific casualty figures.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2957, "completion_tokens": 268, "total_tokens": 3225, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00382452, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981760Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Internet Archive is a reputable nonprofit repository, but this item is a hosted copy of a document rather than a peer-reviewed work or official record. Its evidentiary value depends on the underlying source, and the Archive itself is mainly an access platform rather than an original publisher with editorial vetting of the content.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq ministry of health" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Internet Archive is a reputable nonprofit repository, but this item is a hosted copy of a document rather than a peer-reviewed work or official record. Its evidentiary value depends on the underlying source, and the Archive itself is mainly an access platform rather than an original publisher with editorial vetting of the content.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The page is only a repository listing for a document about Iraqi civilian death estimates, so it is at most tangential background for the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 change in deaths and attacks.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is only a donation appeal from Internet Archive and contains no information about Iraqi civilian deaths or attacks over time.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey 2008\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq ministry of health\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1819, "completion_tokens": 5581, "total_tokens": 7400, "reasoning_tokens": 5330 }, "cost_usd": 0.02385153, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981823Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Internet Archive is a reputable nonprofit repository, but this item is a hosted copy of a document rather than a peer-reviewed work or official record. Its evidentiary value depends on the underlying source, and the Archive itself is mainly an access platform rather than an original publisher with editorial vetting of the content.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq ministry of health" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Internet Archive is a reputable nonprofit repository, but this item is a hosted copy of a document rather than a peer-reviewed work or official record. Its evidentiary value depends on the underlying source, and the Archive itself is mainly an access platform rather than an original publisher with editorial vetting of the content.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The page is only a repository listing for a document about Iraqi civilian death estimates, so it is at most tangential background for the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 change in deaths and attacks.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is only a donation request from the Internet Archive and contains no content about Iraqi civilian deaths or attacks in 2007-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey 2008\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq ministry of health\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 553, "completion_tokens": 54, "total_tokens": 607, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00065775, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981823Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This appears to be a formal journal article with a DOI, suggesting editorial review and a more structured evidence base than ordinary commentary. It relies on SIGACT and related data analysis rather than being a primary record itself, so it is solid secondary research but not peer-reviewed flagship scholarship by a top-tier journal.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This appears to be a formal journal article with a DOI, suggesting editorial review and a more structured evidence base than ordinary commentary. It relies on SIGACT and related data analysis rather than being a primary record itself, so it is solid secondary research but not peer-reviewed flagship scholarship by a top-tier journal.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly examines whether the 2007 surge caused the decline in violence in Iraq and weighs that against other factors, but it is framed as an assessment of the surge’s overall efficacy rather than the exact counterfactual comparison in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.8,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The abstract says violence had already peaked before the surge was announced and that other factors likely contributed to the decline, implying the troop increase and tactic changes were not the major cause of the 2007-2008 drop beyond those other factors.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"sigact\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1998, "completion_tokens": 525, "total_tokens": 2523, "reasoning_tokens": 325 }, "cost_usd": 0.00396465, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981911Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "This appears to be a formal journal article with a DOI, suggesting editorial review and a more structured evidence base than ordinary commentary. It relies on SIGACT and related data analysis rather than being a primary record itself, so it is solid secondary research but not peer-reviewed flagship scholarship by a top-tier journal.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This appears to be a formal journal article with a DOI, suggesting editorial review and a more structured evidence base than ordinary commentary. It relies on SIGACT and related data analysis rather than being a primary record itself, so it is solid secondary research but not peer-reviewed flagship scholarship by a top-tier journal.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly examines whether the 2007 surge caused the decline in violence in Iraq and weighs that against other factors, but it is framed as an assessment of the surge’s overall efficacy rather than the exact counterfactual comparison in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The abstract says violence had already peaked before the surge and that other factors likely contributed to the decline before the surge was announced, implying the surge was not a major cause beyond those factors.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"sigact\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 633, "completion_tokens": 64, "total_tokens": 697, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00076275, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.981911Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia article from the Wikimedia Foundation, which is a secondary source with editorial standards but not a scholarly or official record. It summarizes a primary U.S. government report and other claims, so it is usable for orientation but not strong evidence on its own.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Wikipedia article from the Wikimedia Foundation, which is a secondary source with editorial standards but not a scholarly or official record. It summarizes a primary U.S. government report and other claims, so it is usable for orientation but not strong evidence on its own.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly discusses the 2007 surge, accompanying tactics, and claims about declines in security/ethno-sectarian violence, but it does not directly weigh the surge's effect against the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, and completed sectarian displacement as separate causal explanations.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.6,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says Petraeus reported recent consistent declines in security incidents and partly attributed them to surge operations that reduced ethno-sectarian violence and disrupted insurgent and militia groups, which supports the claim that the troop increase and tactic changes were a major cause of the violence decline.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2893, "completion_tokens": 1128, "total_tokens": 4021, "reasoning_tokens": 870 }, "cost_usd": 0.006508668, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982002Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary source with editorial oversight and citations, but it is not peer reviewed and the excerpt aggregates other studies rather than presenting original evidence. It can be useful for orientation, but its reliability depends on the quality of the underlying sources and article maintenance.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "opinion research business survey 2007" }, { "type": "study", "id": "plos medicine 2013" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary source with editorial oversight and citations, but it is not peer reviewed and the excerpt aggregates other studies rather than presenting original evidence. It can be useful for orientation, but its reliability depends on the quality of the underlying sources and article maintenance.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is a broad overview of Iraq War casualty estimates across years, not a direct report on civilian deaths and attacks falling between mid-2007 and mid-2008 compared with 2006 and early 2007.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses broad casualty estimates and methods, but it does not compare civilian deaths or attacks in Iraq between mid-2007 and mid-2008 versus 2006 and early 2007.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet study 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"opinion research business survey 2007\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"plos medicine 2013\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3105, "completion_tokens": 3049, "total_tokens": 6154, "reasoning_tokens": 2787 }, "cost_usd": 0.01252926, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982062Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a Belfer Center-hosted article in International Security, a well-regarded peer-reviewed journal, and it explicitly cites declassified violence data plus structured interviews. It is a secondary analytic study rather than a primary record, but it meets high scholarly and editorial standards.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "declassified iraq violence data 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Belfer Center-hosted article in International Security, a well-regarded peer-reviewed journal, and it explicitly cites declassified violence data plus structured interviews. It is a secondary analytic study rather than a primary record, but it meets high scholarly and editorial standards.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly examines whether the surge's troop increase and doctrinal changes were necessary for the 2007 violence decline and weighs them against the Anbar Awakening and sectarian-cleansing explanations, though it does not frame the exact counterfactual of what those factors would have produced on their own.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.9,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"mixed\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document explicitly argues that the surge and accompanying doctrinal changes were necessary for the 2007 violence decline and that the Awakening and sectarian displacement alone would not have sufficed, though it also says the Awakening was needed too.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"declassified iraq violence data 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3071, "completion_tokens": 1557, "total_tokens": 4628, "reasoning_tokens": 1289 }, "cost_usd": 0.00969307, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982123Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a Belfer Center-hosted article in International Security, a well-regarded peer-reviewed journal, and it explicitly cites declassified violence data plus structured interviews. It is a secondary analytic study rather than a primary record, but it meets high scholarly and editorial standards.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "declassified iraq violence data 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a Belfer Center-hosted article in International Security, a well-regarded peer-reviewed journal, and it explicitly cites declassified violence data plus structured interviews. It is a secondary analytic study rather than a primary record, but it meets high scholarly and editorial standards.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly examines whether the surge's troop increase and doctrinal changes were necessary for the 2007 violence decline and weighs them against the Anbar Awakening and sectarian-cleansing explanations, though it does not frame the exact counterfactual of what those factors would have produced on their own.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.95,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document explicitly argues that the surge was necessary for the 2007 violence reduction and that neither the Anbar Awakening nor sectarian cleansing alone would have sufficed, directly contradicting the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"declassified iraq violence data 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 881, "completion_tokens": 70, "total_tokens": 951, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00097575, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982123Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary webpage from an advocacy/policy archive that aggregates and summarizes other studies rather than presenting original data. It cites named studies and reputable sources, but it lacks clear editorial rigor or primary-document status.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "first lancet mortality study 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "undp iraq living conditions survey 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "global policy forum" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a secondary webpage from an advocacy/policy archive that aggregates and summarizes other studies rather than presenting original data. It cites named studies and reputable sources, but it lacks clear editorial rigor or primary-document status.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is about Iraqi mortality and civilian deaths generally in 2003-2006, which is adjacent background but does not directly address the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline from 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses high mortality through 2006 and mentions later 2008 civilian killings, but it does not compare mid-2007 to mid-2008 against 2006/early-2007 levels or show a substantial fall in deaths and attacks.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"second lancet mortality study 2006\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"first lancet mortality study 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"undp iraq living conditions survey 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"global policy forum\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2908, "completion_tokens": 320, "total_tokens": 3228, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00341933, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982213Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary webpage from an advocacy/policy archive that aggregates and summarizes other studies rather than presenting original data. It cites named studies and reputable sources, but it lacks clear editorial rigor or primary-document status.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "first lancet mortality study 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "undp iraq living conditions survey 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "global policy forum" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a secondary webpage from an advocacy/policy archive that aggregates and summarizes other studies rather than presenting original data. It cites named studies and reputable sources, but it lacks clear editorial rigor or primary-document status.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.2,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt is about Iraqi mortality and civilian deaths generally in 2003-2006, which is adjacent background but does not directly address the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline from 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses high mortality and earlier Iraq death estimates, but it does not address whether civilian deaths and attacks fell substantially between mid-2007 and mid-2008 compared with 2006 and early 2007.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"second lancet mortality study 2006\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"first lancet mortality study 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"undp iraq living conditions survey 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"global policy forum\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 848, "completion_tokens": 69, "total_tokens": 917, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0009465, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982213Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a peer-reviewed journal article from a reputable academic center, using declassified violence data and 70 structured interviews with coalition participants. It is not a primary record itself, but it has strong scholarly methods and sourcing with low evident conflict of interest.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.86, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.9,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"This is a peer-reviewed journal article from a reputable academic center, using declassified violence data and 70 structured interviews with coalition participants. It is not a primary record itself, but it has strong scholarly methods and sourcing with low evident conflict of interest.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly examines why violence declined in Iraq in 2007 and explicitly weighs the surge against the Anbar/Sunni Awakening and sectarian cleansing, but it does not specifically test the Sadrist ceasefire or the exact broader counterfactual in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.86,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"mixed\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document says the surge and accompanying doctrinal changes were an important part of why violence fell and that a surge-Awakening synergy was required, while finding little support for the cleansing or Awakening-alone explanations, which supports the claim that the surge was a major cause beyond those other factors alone.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"sigacts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2522, "completion_tokens": 2287, "total_tokens": 4809, "reasoning_tokens": 2030 }, "cost_usd": 0.01145592, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982303Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary, crowd-edited source with variable quality control and no formal peer review, so it is not strong evidence by itself. Its sourcing can be substantial and often points to named references, but it is still an encyclopedia article rather than a primary record or official inquiry.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a secondary, crowd-edited source with variable quality control and no formal peer review, so it is not strong evidence by itself. Its sourcing can be substantial and often points to named references, but it is still an encyclopedia article rather than a primary record or official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt mentions the 2007 troop surge and stabilization in parts of Iraq, which is adjacent to the period of reduced violence, but it does not directly report civilian deaths or attack levels in mid-2007 to mid-2008 versus 2006/early-2007.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses the overall course of the Iraq War and the 2007 troop surge, but it does not provide any specific information about civilian deaths or attack levels in mid-2007 versus 2006/early-2007.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2883, "completion_tokens": 252, "total_tokens": 3135, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0032148999999999997, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982362Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary, crowd-edited source with variable quality control and no formal peer review, so it is not strong evidence by itself. Its sourcing can be substantial and often points to named references, but it is still an encyclopedia article rather than a primary record or official inquiry.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.46, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a secondary, crowd-edited source with variable quality control and no formal peer review, so it is not strong evidence by itself. Its sourcing can be substantial and often points to named references, but it is still an encyclopedia article rather than a primary record or official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly mentions the 2007 troop surge and says it helped stabilize parts of Iraq, but it does not specifically address whether the surge and tactics were a major cause of the 2007-2008 violence decline relative to the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, and sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.46,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt explicitly says the 2007 troop surge 'helped stabilize parts of the country,' which supports the idea that the troop increase and tactic change contributed to the violence decline, though it does not compare this effect against the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement completion.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2945, "completion_tokens": 273, "total_tokens": 3218, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0033558999999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982418Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Army.mil is an official U.S. military publisher with editorial standards, and this item reports a named officer’s direct observations and operational figures from the field. It is still a press-service article rather than a peer-reviewed study or independent investigation, so it is strong but not definitive evidence.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.3, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "american forces press service" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "col jb burton 2nd brigade combat team 1st infantry division" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Army.mil is an official U.S. military publisher with editorial standards, and this item reports a named officer’s direct observations and operational figures from the field. It is still a press-service article rather than a peer-reviewed study or independent investigation, so it is strong but not definitive evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document directly discusses the 2007 Baghdad Security Plan troop increase and tactic change reducing violence, which is closely related to the sub-claim, but it does not compare this effect against the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.3,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document says violence fell after coalition forces moved into neighborhood outposts and claims the decline is directly attributable to that tactic, which is consistent with the surge/tactic-change explanation, but it does not compare this effect against the Anbar Awakening, the Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"american forces press service\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"col jb burton 2nd brigade combat team 1st infantry division\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2840, "completion_tokens": 302, "total_tokens": 3142, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00335316, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982488Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Globalsecurity.org is a reputable secondary source that appears to compile and summarize official military data (SIGACTS/MNF-I, DOD, UN) rather than present original peer-reviewed research. It has some editorial track record, but it is not a primary record or formal official inquiry.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.86, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "mnf i significant activity reports" }, { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, { "type": "study", "id": "un april 2008 report" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Globalsecurity.org is a reputable secondary source that appears to compile and summarize official military data (SIGACTS/MNF-I, DOD, UN) rather than present original peer-reviewed research. It has some editorial track record, but it is not a primary record or formal official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly reports a substantial drop in Iraq violence/attacks from mid-2007 to early 2008 and explicitly compares it to the high levels of 2006 and early 2007, but it focuses on enemy-initiated attacks rather than civilian deaths specifically.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.86,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly reports that overall violence/attacks in Iraq fell about 70% from June 2007 to February 2008, with average daily attacks dropping from about 180 in June 2007 to about 50 in February 2008, which supports a substantial decline from 2006/early-2007 levels by mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"mnf i significant activity reports\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"dod march 2008 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un april 2008 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2984, "completion_tokens": 1199, "total_tokens": 4183, "reasoning_tokens": 897 }, "cost_usd": 0.00757989, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982556Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Globalsecurity.org is a reputable secondary source that appears to compile and summarize official military data (SIGACTS/MNF-I, DOD, UN) rather than present original peer-reviewed research. It has some editorial track record, but it is not a primary record or formal official inquiry.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.95, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "mnf i significant activity reports" }, { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, { "type": "study", "id": "un april 2008 report" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Globalsecurity.org is a reputable secondary source that appears to compile and summarize official military data (SIGACTS/MNF-I, DOD, UN) rather than present original peer-reviewed research. It has some editorial track record, but it is not a primary record or formal official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly reports a substantial drop in Iraq violence/attacks from mid-2007 to early 2008 and explicitly compares it to the high levels of 2006 and early 2007, but it focuses on enemy-initiated attacks rather than civilian deaths specifically.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.95,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt directly says violence and enemy-initiated attacks decreased about 70% from June 2007 to February 2008 and were significantly lower than 2006 and early-2007 levels, which supports the sub-claim that such deaths and attacks did not fall substantially.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"mnf i significant activity reports\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"dod march 2008 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un april 2008 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 841, "completion_tokens": 89, "total_tokens": 930, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00103125, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982556Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Human Rights Watch is a well-known, professionally edited human rights organization with established research standards and named sourcing practices, though it is an advocacy NGO rather than a primary source or peer-reviewed study. The report appears to synthesize official and other published information rather than present original records, making it solid but secondary evidence.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "human rights watch" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unhcr iom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us military" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi government" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Human Rights Watch is a well-known, professionally edited human rights organization with established research standards and named sourcing practices, though it is an advocacy NGO rather than a primary source or peer-reviewed study. The report appears to synthesize official and other published information rather than present original records, making it solid but secondary evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.4,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt mentions security gains in 2008 but focuses on displacement, detention, and political developments rather than specifically measuring or comparing civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt discusses security gains and displacement in 2008 but does not provide specific data or comparisons about civilian deaths or attacks falling from 2006/early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"human rights watch\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unhcr iom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us military\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi government\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2815, "completion_tokens": 2094, "total_tokens": 4909, "reasoning_tokens": 2085 }, "cost_usd": 0.010903649999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982645Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "CSIS is a reputable policy research institution with editorial standards, but this is a secondary analytical report rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study. Its evidentiary value is solid yet not definitive, and likely relies on a mix of official reporting and expert assessment.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.62, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"CSIS is a reputable policy research institution with editorial standards, but this is a secondary analytical report rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study. Its evidentiary value is solid yet not definitive, and likely relies on a mix of official reporting and expert assessment.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The report directly discusses the 2007 US troop buildup, changed tactics, and concurrent violence trends in Iraq, while also touching on Anbar tribal alliances and Shi'ite militia dynamics, but it does not explicitly evaluate the relative causal contribution against the specific alternative explanations named in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.62,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document says the 2007 U.S. troop buildup and changed posture reduced violence in Anbar and helped secure Baghdad while inflicting damage on insurgent and militia forces, which supports the claim that the surge and tactics were a major cause of the violence decline, though it does not compare that effect against the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement on their own.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"csis\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2817, "completion_tokens": 286, "total_tokens": 3103, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00331995, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982707Z" }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "CSIS is a reputable policy research institution with editorial standards, but this is a secondary analytical report rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study. Its evidentiary value is solid yet not definitive, and likely relies on a mix of official reporting and expert assessment.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"CSIS is a reputable policy research institution with editorial standards, but this is a secondary analytical report rather than a primary record or peer-reviewed study. Its evidentiary value is solid yet not definitive, and likely relies on a mix of official reporting and expert assessment.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\":0.7,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The report directly discusses the 2007 US troop buildup, changed tactics, and concurrent violence trends in Iraq, while also touching on Anbar tribal alliances and Shi'ite militia dynamics, but it does not explicitly evaluate the relative causal contribution against the specific alternative explanations named in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":-1,\\\"strength\\\":0.7,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt says the troop buildup and changed posture had positive effects including reduced violence in Anbar and increased security in Baghdad, and credits US military actions and local alliances as contributing factors, which contradicts the claim that they were not a major cause beyond other factors.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"csis\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 841, "completion_tokens": 86, "total_tokens": 927, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00101775, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982707Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a report from Iraq Body Count, a reputable organization providing transparent, documented quantitative data and baseline figures regarding civilian casualties based on public records and incident databases.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a report from Iraq Body Count, a reputable organization providing transparent, documented quantitative data and baseline figures regarding civilian casualties based on public records and incident databases.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides specific comparative statistics on Iraqi civilian deaths for 2006, 2007, and 2008, directly reporting on the change in violence levels referred to in the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides documented civilian death counts from its database showing a substantial reduction from 2006 and 2007 levels down to 2008, directly supporting the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3271, "completion_tokens": 3359, "total_tokens": 6630, "reasoning_tokens": 3148 }, "cost_usd": 0.011198448, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982796Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count is a reputable tracking project that uses transparent, documented incident reports and official records to record civilian casualties, though it relies on secondary media and field sources rather than being a primary government or peer-reviewed academic document.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Iraq Body Count is a reputable tracking project that uses transparent, documented incident reports and official records to record civilian casualties, though it relies on secondary media and field sources rather than being a primary government or peer-reviewed academic document.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides aggregate civilian death data for Iraq from 2003 onwards, which covers the relevant time period but does not directly discuss the specific trend of falling deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt mentions database totals and mentions a date picker for monthly civilian deaths, but does not provide specific data showing whether deaths fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2598, "completion_tokens": 228, "total_tokens": 2826, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00158798, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982854Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is an established journalism review publication analyzing media reporting and mortality estimates, functioning as ordinary journalism rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary historical document.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "psr study 2015" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "lexisnexis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an established journalism review publication analyzing media reporting and mortality estimates, functioning as ordinary journalism rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary historical document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.2,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses cumulative Iraqi civilian death tolls and media reporting methods rather than the specific trend of deaths falling between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided excerpt discusses overall death tolls and reporting methodologies since 2003, but it does not contain any information regarding the specific timeline of civilian deaths falling between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"psr study 2015\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lexisnexis\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2956, "completion_tokens": 3211, "total_tokens": 6167, "reasoning_tokens": 2995 }, "cost_usd": 0.01512989, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982911Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is an excerpt from a Wikipedia article, which functions as tertiary or secondary compilation of reported facts, news, and official statements rather than original primary research or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate 2007" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "unhcr iraqi government 2006" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un secretary general 2006" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an excerpt from a Wikipedia article, which functions as tertiary or secondary compilation of reported facts, news, and official statements rather than original primary research or peer-reviewed study.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the 2007 US troop surge and the subsequent decline in violence alongside other factors like the Sunni Awakening, directly addressing the core elements of the sub-claim as part of a broader overview.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt mentions the U.S. troop surge and the Sunni Awakening alongside the decline in violence, but it does not analyze or attribute causation regarding the surge's specific impact relative to other factors.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate 2007\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unhcr iraqi government 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un secretary general 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"george w bush 2007\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3477, "completion_tokens": 2646, "total_tokens": 6123, "reasoning_tokens": 2398 }, "cost_usd": 0.0094111394, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.982967Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The source is an academic research publication hosted by Princeton University, indicating peer review or formal scholarly standards.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "mnfi sigacts iii" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an academic research publication hosted by Princeton University, indicating peer review or formal scholarly standards.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document only provides metadata and citation information for a publication about the Iraq surge without containing the text or analysis of the study itself.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only lists bibliographic metadata and research topics without providing any substantive content addressing the causes of the 2007-2008 decline in violence in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"mnfi sigacts iii\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1881, "completion_tokens": 3938, "total_tokens": 5819, "reasoning_tokens": 3766 }, "cost_usd": 0.0125175494, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983025Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "The source provides a high-level encyclopedic overview of the Iraq War without explicit citations, primary sourcing, or rigorous academic methodology for the specific claims regarding the 2006-2008 surge and violence levels.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "pritzkermilitary org" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.3,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source provides a high-level encyclopedic overview of the Iraq War without explicit citations, primary sourcing, or rigorous academic methodology for the specific claims regarding the 2006-2008 surge and violence levels.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt explicitly lists the 2007 troop increase (the Surge) alongside the Anbar Awakening and Sadrist ceasefire as the four reasons for the decline in violence in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document lists the troop surge as one of four concurrent reasons for the 2007 decrease in violence, but it does not evaluate whether the surge had an effect beyond what the other factors would have produced on their own.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"pritzkermilitary.org\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3155, "completion_tokens": 232, "total_tokens": 3387, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00183374, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983079Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is an official Congressional Research Service report, which adheres to rigorous nonpartisan research and sourcing standards for Congress.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi ministries data" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of defense data" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an official Congressional Research Service report, which adheres to rigorous nonpartisan research and sourcing standards for Congress.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document contains casualty statistics specifically tracking Iraqi civilian deaths from 2006 through mid-2009, which directly tests the proposition regarding the change in civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008 compared to 2006 and early 2007.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt provides only the title, summary, and table of contents of a CRS report without detailing the actual casualty statistics or data trends between 2007 and 2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraqi ministries data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of defense data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"brookings iraq index\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3061, "completion_tokens": 5850, "total_tokens": 8911, "reasoning_tokens": 5595 }, "cost_usd": 0.0186657536, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983138Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is an official Congressional Research Service report, which adheres to rigorous nonpartisan research and sourcing standards for Congress.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi ministries data" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of defense data" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an official Congressional Research Service report, which adheres to rigorous nonpartisan research and sourcing standards for Congress.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document contains casualty statistics specifically tracking Iraqi civilian deaths from 2006 through mid-2009, which directly tests the proposition regarding the change in civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008 compared to 2006 and early 2007.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt lists a Department of Defense dataset covering Iraqi civilian deaths from January 2006 to May 2009, which directly provides the empirical data needed to evaluate whether deaths fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008, thus contradicting the sub-claim that they did not fall.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraqi ministries data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of defense data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"brookings iraq index\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 856, "completion_tokens": 92, "total_tokens": 948, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004868, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983138Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "The document is an online essay published on Small Wars Journal with basic academic-style citations, but it functions primarily as an analytical opinion or student/research essay rather than rigorous peer-reviewed research or a definitive primary record.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "small wars journal 2013" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.3,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an online essay published on Small Wars Journal with basic academic-style citations, but it functions primarily as an analytical opinion or student/research essay rather than rigorous peer-reviewed research or a definitive primary record.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly tests and evaluates the proposition regarding whether the US surge was the primary cause of the decline in violence compared to alternative local factors like the Anbar Awakening and ceasefires.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt explicitly states the author's thesis that the US surge alone is not a satisfactory explanation for the decline in violence, and argues that local factors like the Shiite victory, Sunni cooperation, and the Mahdi Army ceasefire were of equal importance.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"small wars journal 2013\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3242, "completion_tokens": 232, "total_tokens": 3474, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0018689, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983222Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "The source is a collaboratively edited encyclopedia entry (Wikipedia) which relies on secondary compilation rather than original investigative reporting or peer-reviewed research, placing it at the level of opinion or general overview with limited independent vetting of sourcing within this excerpt.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "us marine corps history division" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "icasualties" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us marine corps intelligence report 2006" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.3, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a collaboratively edited encyclopedia entry (Wikipedia) which relies on secondary compilation rather than original investigative reporting or peer-reviewed research, placing it at the level of opinion or general overview with limited independent vetting of sourcing within this excerpt.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the Anbar campaign and the origins of the Anbar Awakening, which is a major factor mentioned in the sub-claim, but it does not directly address the broader national impact of the 2007 troop surge or the overall decline in violence across Iraq.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses the history of the Anbar campaign and the formation of the Anbar Awakening up to late 2006, but it does not provide content evaluating the 2007 troop surge or its relative impact on the subsequent decline in violence.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us marine corps history division\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"icasualties\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us marine corps intelligence report 2006\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3359, "completion_tokens": 4234, "total_tokens": 7593, "reasoning_tokens": 3947 }, "cost_usd": 0.015819824, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983280Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "The source is an excerpt from a Wikipedia article, which represents tertiary compilation and synthesis rather than original research, peer review, or primary reporting.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush address to the nation january 10 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house fact sheet the new way forward in iraq" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bob woodward the war within 2008" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hillary clinton and barack obama statements on surge" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.3,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an excerpt from a Wikipedia article, which represents tertiary compilation and synthesis rather than original research, peer review, or primary reporting.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the implementation and objectives of the 2007 US troop surge, which addresses the first part of the sub-claim, but it does not evaluate its causal impact on the subsequent decline in violence relative to other factors like the Anbar Awakening or the Sadrist ceasefire.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document mentions that critics later argued the surge was successful, but it does not provide evidence or address whether the troop increase caused the decline in violence beyond other factors like the Anbar Awakening or Sadrist ceasefire.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush address to the nation january 10 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house fact sheet the new way forward in iraq\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"bob woodward the war within 2008\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hillary clinton and barack obama statements on surge\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3101, "completion_tokens": 7416, "total_tokens": 10517, "reasoning_tokens": 7777 }, "cost_usd": 0.03081658, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983339Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is an academic working paper by a Boston University professor published through the reputable Costs of War project, utilizing established institutional data sources like Iraq Body Count.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an academic working paper by a Boston University professor published through the reputable Costs of War project, utilizing established institutional data sources like Iraq Body Count.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.2,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt provides background on overall civilian casualties in the Iraq War from 2003 to 2013, but does not specifically address the timeline of civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided excerpt discusses overall civilian death and injury totals and infrastructure damage from 2003 to 2013, but does not provide specific data or address whether civilian deaths fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3349, "completion_tokens": 3710, "total_tokens": 7059, "reasoning_tokens": 3479 }, "cost_usd": 0.012265987999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983399Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is an academic working paper by a Boston University professor published through the reputable Costs of War project, utilizing established institutional data sources like Iraq Body Count.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is an academic working paper by a Boston University professor published through the reputable Costs of War project, utilizing established institutional data sources like Iraq Body Count.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.2,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt provides background on overall civilian casualties in the Iraq War from 2003 to 2013, but does not specifically address the timeline of civilian deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided excerpt does not contain specific information regarding the trend of civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 961, "completion_tokens": 65, "total_tokens": 1026, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004508, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983399Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published by the Congressional Research Service, this document represents an authoritative, non-partisan official inquiry compiling and analyzing various governmental and non-governmental data sources on Iraq casualty estimates.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "congressional research service" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published by the Congressional Research Service, this document represents an authoritative, non-partisan official inquiry compiling and analyzing various governmental and non-governmental data sources on Iraq casualty estimates.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides official estimates and figures specifically on Iraqi civilian deaths and casualties from January 2006 through August 2008, directly testing the timeline and trend mentioned in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only provides the table of contents and summary of the report without displaying the actual data or text regarding casualty trends between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"congressional research service\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2832, "completion_tokens": 211, "total_tokens": 3043, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.001880804, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983490Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is ordinary journalism by TIME magazine relaying findings from a secondary monitoring group (Iraq Body Count) and wire services, lacking peer review or primary investigative documentation.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "associated press" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is ordinary journalism by TIME magazine relaying findings from a secondary monitoring group (Iraq Body Count) and wire services, lacking peer review or primary investigative documentation.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the substantial decrease in Iraqi civilian deaths between 2006, 2007, and 2008, which closely relates to the sub-claim's focus on the decline from mid-2007 to mid-2008, though it reports annual figures rather than the exact mid-point interval.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites empirical data from the Iraq Body Count showing that annual civilian deaths dropped dramatically from over 25,000 in 2006 and 22,000 in 2007 to roughly 8,600 in 2008, supporting the claim of a substantial decrease during this period.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"associated press\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3237, "completion_tokens": 1189, "total_tokens": 4426, "reasoning_tokens": 910 }, "cost_usd": 0.006255, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983550Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is a peer-reviewed study published in a scientific journal (PLOS Medicine) that analyzes a comprehensive primary dataset (the Iraq Body Count database) regarding violent deaths in Iraq.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a peer-reviewed study published in a scientific journal (PLOS Medicine) that analyzes a comprehensive primary dataset (the Iraq Body Count database) regarding violent deaths in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader question of Iraqi civilian deaths over time through 2008, which partly covers the specific sub-claim about trends between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document analyzes data through March 19, 2008, but does not provide specific findings comparing civilian death levels between mid-2007 and mid-2008 to 2006 and early 2007 levels.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3036, "completion_tokens": 228, "total_tokens": 3264, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00177578, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983609Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is a peer-reviewed study published in a scientific journal (PLOS Medicine) that analyzes a comprehensive primary dataset (the Iraq Body Count database) regarding violent deaths in Iraq.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a peer-reviewed study published in a scientific journal (PLOS Medicine) that analyzes a comprehensive primary dataset (the Iraq Body Count database) regarding violent deaths in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader question of Iraqi civilian deaths over time through 2008, which partly covers the specific sub-claim about trends between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document analyzes data up to March 19, 2008, and does not provide enough temporal data covering the period through mid-2008 to address whether deaths fell substantially between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 899, "completion_tokens": 89, "total_tokens": 988, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004922, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983609Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This document is an official US government report to Congress mandated by public law, serving as a primary administrative and military record on security conditions and force posture in Iraq.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense report to congress june 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is an official US government report to Congress mandated by public law, serving as a primary administrative and military record on security conditions and force posture in Iraq.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the 2007 US troop increase (the surge) and operational changes in Baghdad, which are central to the sub-claim, though it does not explicitly weigh these factors against the Anbar Awakening or the Sadrist ceasefire.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the launch and intent of the 2007 troop increase (Operation Fardh al-Qanoon) but contains no data or evaluation regarding its actual causal impact on the subsequent decline in violence compared to other factors.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"department of defense report to congress june 2007\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3051, "completion_tokens": 247, "total_tokens": 3298, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00183234, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983689Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Published by the Council on Foreign Relations, a reputable foreign policy think tank, citing official congressional testimony and military statistics with named sources.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "us military iraq violence statistics" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "gen david petraeus testimony september 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published by the Council on Foreign Relations, a reputable foreign policy think tank, citing official congressional testimony and military statistics with named sources.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the decline in civilian deaths and violence during the 2007 surge, which is closely related to the sub-claim's timeline of mid-2007 to mid-2008, though it specifically reports data up to August 2007.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt cites official U.S. military statistics showing a substantial drop in Iraqi civilian deaths and ethno-sectarian violence between late 2006 and mid-2007 during the troop surge.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us military iraq violence statistics\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"gen david petraeus testimony september 2007\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2856, "completion_tokens": 1139, "total_tokens": 3995, "reasoning_tokens": 875 }, "cost_usd": 0.005763300000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983745Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article summarizing peer-reviewed studies. While Wikipedia itself is secondary/tertiary reporting rather than an original peer-reviewed paper or primary document, it provides ordinary coverage relaying established research.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article summarizing peer-reviewed studies. While Wikipedia itself is secondary/tertiary reporting rather than an original peer-reviewed paper or primary document, it provides ordinary coverage relaying established research.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.2,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses casualty studies published in 2004 and 2006, which provides only tangential background regarding the later time period from mid-2007 to mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided document discusses mortality studies published in 2004 and 2006, and therefore does not provide information regarding civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3522, "completion_tokens": 273, "total_tokens": 3795, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00208408, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983804Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article summarizing peer-reviewed studies. While Wikipedia itself is secondary/tertiary reporting rather than an original peer-reviewed paper or primary document, it provides ordinary coverage relaying established research.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article summarizing peer-reviewed studies. While Wikipedia itself is secondary/tertiary reporting rather than an original peer-reviewed paper or primary document, it provides ordinary coverage relaying established research.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.2,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses casualty studies published in 2004 and 2006, which provides only tangential background regarding the later time period from mid-2007 to mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Lancet surveys published in 2004 and 2006, but does not provide information regarding civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1030, "completion_tokens": 70, "total_tokens": 1100, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.000484, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983804Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The source is Iraq Body Count, a well-established and transparent primary-tracking organization that aggregates documented violent deaths using rigorous incident-based methodologies and official/media records.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq war logs wikileaks" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is Iraq Body Count, a well-established and transparent primary-tracking organization that aggregates documented violent deaths using rigorous incident-based methodologies and official/media records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides a general 10-year overview of civilian deaths in Iraq by the Iraq Body Count but does not specifically or in detail address the exact change in deaths between mid-2007 and mid-2008 versus 2006.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt mentions tracking civilian deaths since 2003 and provides aggregate totals, but it does not specifically discuss or provide data on the change in civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq war logs wikileaks\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3090, "completion_tokens": 250, "total_tokens": 3340, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0018576600000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983887Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published by the U.S. Department of State as an official government report, providing authoritative data and firsthand reporting on security conditions and force posture in Iraq.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "multinational force iraq" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "international mission for iraqi elections" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of state" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published by the U.S. Department of State as an official government report, providing authoritative data and firsthand reporting on security conditions and force posture in Iraq.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt explicitly reports on the substantial improvement in the general security situation and the significant decline in civilian deaths in Iraq from 2007 through 2008, directly addressing the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 1.0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly states that the general security situation substantially improved from mid-2007 through 2008, citing data from Multinational Force-Iraq that civilian deaths fell significantly compared to previous periods.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"multinational force iraq\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"international mission for iraqi elections\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of state\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3100, "completion_tokens": 1752, "total_tokens": 4852, "reasoning_tokens": 1526 }, "cost_usd": 0.007026624, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.983944Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This document is an official quarterly report to Congress by the Department of Defense, representing a primary governmental record on security and stability in Iraq.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This document is an official quarterly report to Congress by the Department of Defense, representing a primary governmental record on security and stability in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the broader security progress in Iraq during 2007, which closely relates to the timeline and trends of civilian deaths and attacks mentioned in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt mentions general security progress up to late 2007, but it does not provide specific data or address civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"department of defense\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2903, "completion_tokens": 189, "total_tokens": 3092, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00187752, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984001Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article about a database project, representing tertiary or ordinary reference material rather than a primary document, peer-reviewed study, or original journalistic investigation.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jonathan steele guardian" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article about a database project, representing tertiary or ordinary reference material rather than a primary document, peer-reviewed study, or original journalistic investigation.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses the Iraq Body Count project as a source for tracking civilian deaths in Iraq resulting from the 2003 invasion, but does not provide specific data or statistics regarding the change in death rates between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes the methodology and scope of the Iraq Body Count project but does not provide specific data regarding the change in civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"jonathan steele guardian\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2791, "completion_tokens": 1727, "total_tokens": 4518, "reasoning_tokens": 1470 }, "cost_usd": 0.00805946, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984058Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is reputable journalism from a major established publisher with named reporters, discussing official data and documented surveys, though it later required corrections as noted in the text.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "who iraqi health ministry survey 2008" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "orb iraq mortality survey 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is reputable journalism from a major established publisher with named reporters, discussing official data and documented surveys, though it later required corrections as noted in the text.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses overall post-invasion death toll surveys, body count policies, and military casualties, but contains no information about the specific decline in civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided excerpt discusses body counts and previous surveys but does not provide data or statements regarding the specific trend of civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"who iraqi health ministry survey 2008\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet iraq mortality survey 2006\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"orb iraq mortality survey 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of defense\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2862, "completion_tokens": 1419, "total_tokens": 4281, "reasoning_tokens": 1156 }, "cost_usd": 0.00693196, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984116Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a collaboratively edited encyclopedia entry (Wikipedia) which relies on secondary compilation of facts rather than peer-reviewed research or definitive primary records.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a collaboratively edited encyclopedia entry (Wikipedia) which relies on secondary compilation of facts rather than peer-reviewed research or definitive primary records.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses the general timeline of the insurgency and notes that the civil war and sectarian violence ended in mid-2008 due to the surge, addressing the broader context of the sub-claim without providing specific civilian death or attack statistics for the exact period.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document mentions that the civil war ended in mid-2008 due to the troop surge, but it does not provide specific data or figures showing that civilian deaths and attacks actually fell substantially between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3079, "completion_tokens": 232, "total_tokens": 3311, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00227182, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984173Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is hosted on the Internet Archive, but it is a Congressional Research Service (CRS) report by Hannah Fischer on Iraqi civilian death estimates, which serves as an authoritative official research document.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq ministry of health" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is hosted on the Internet Archive, but it is a Congressional Research Service (CRS) report by Hannah Fischer on Iraqi civilian death estimates, which serves as an authoritative official research document.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only contains a generic donation appeal from the Internet Archive and does not mention civilian deaths or attacks in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only contains boilerplate fundraising text from the Internet Archive and does not mention civilian deaths or attacks in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey 2008\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq ministry of health\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1880, "completion_tokens": 5535, "total_tokens": 7415, "reasoning_tokens": 5330 }, "cost_usd": 0.022785279999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984230Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is hosted on the Internet Archive, but it is a Congressional Research Service (CRS) report by Hannah Fischer on Iraqi civilian death estimates, which serves as an authoritative official research document.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq ministry of health" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is hosted on the Internet Archive, but it is a Congressional Research Service (CRS) report by Hannah Fischer on Iraqi civilian death estimates, which serves as an authoritative official research document.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only contains a generic donation appeal from the Internet Archive and does not mention civilian deaths or attacks in Iraq.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided excerpt contains only a fundraising appeal for the Internet Archive and does not mention civilian deaths or attacks in Iraq.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey 2008\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq ministry of health\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 577, "completion_tokens": 57, "total_tokens": 634, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0003156, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984230Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The source is an academic paper published in a peer-reviewed journal (Journal of Military and Strategic Studies) examining historical data on the Iraq War.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an academic paper published in a peer-reviewed journal (Journal of Military and Strategic Studies) examining historical data on the Iraq War.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly evaluates the 2007 US troop surge in Iraq and its causal relationship to the decline in violence compared to other factors, directly testing the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt examines SIGACT data and concludes that violence had peaked and begun to decline before the surge was announced, suggesting the surge was unnecessary.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"sigact\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2070, "completion_tokens": 461, "total_tokens": 2531, "reasoning_tokens": 325 }, "cost_usd": 0.0026893, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984314Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The source is an academic paper published in a peer-reviewed journal (Journal of Military and Strategic Studies) examining historical data on the Iraq War.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an academic paper published in a peer-reviewed journal (Journal of Military and Strategic Studies) examining historical data on the Iraq War.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly evaluates the 2007 US troop surge in Iraq and its causal relationship to the decline in violence compared to other factors, directly testing the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document examines SIGACT data and concludes that violence had peaked and begun declining before the surge and its accompanying tactics were implemented, thus supporting the sub-claim that the surge was not a major cause of the violence reduction beyond other factors.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"sigact\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 661, "completion_tokens": 83, "total_tokens": 744, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004058, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984314Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article describing an official primary document (the Petraeus Report to Congress), which provides reputable reporting based on official government records and named primary actors.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article describing an official primary document (the Petraeus Report to Congress), which provides reputable reporting based on official government records and named primary actors.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports on official assessments of the 2007 US troop surge's military objectives and its perceived causal role in reducing security incidents and violence in Iraq.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document asserts that the military surge and associated operations successfully met their objectives and directly contributed to the declines in security incidents and ethno-sectarian violence.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2944, "completion_tokens": 1072, "total_tokens": 4016, "reasoning_tokens": 870 }, "cost_usd": 0.004958968, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984394Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.3, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article which, while citing various secondary and primary studies, is a tertiary compilation lacking rigorous independent editorial peer review or original primary investigation.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "opinion research business survey 2007" }, { "type": "study", "id": "plos medicine 2013" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.3,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article which, while citing various secondary and primary studies, is a tertiary compilation lacking rigorous independent editorial peer review or original primary investigation.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses overall casualty estimates and methodologies for the Iraq War generally, but does not specifically report on the temporal trend of civilian deaths and attacks falling between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided excerpt discusses various overall casualty estimates for the Iraq War but does not contain data or statements regarding the specific trend of civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet study 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"opinion research business survey 2007\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"plos medicine 2013\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3345, "completion_tokens": 3034, "total_tokens": 6379, "reasoning_tokens": 2787 }, "cost_usd": 0.01117866, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984450Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is published in International Security, a leading peer-reviewed journal of security affairs, and utilizes systematic evidence including declassified data and structured interviews.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "declassified iraq violence data 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is published in International Security, a leading peer-reviewed journal of security affairs, and utilizes systematic evidence including declassified data and structured interviews.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether the 2007 troop surge was a major cause of the reduction in violence beyond what the Anbar Awakening or sectarian cleansing would have produced on their own.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly concludes that the surge was necessary and that without it violence would have stayed high, as other factors alone would not have sufficed.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"declassified iraq violence data 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3131, "completion_tokens": 1491, "total_tokens": 4622, "reasoning_tokens": 1289 }, "cost_usd": 0.00808042, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984523Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is published in International Security, a leading peer-reviewed journal of security affairs, and utilizes systematic evidence including declassified data and structured interviews.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "declassified iraq violence data 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is published in International Security, a leading peer-reviewed journal of security affairs, and utilizes systematic evidence including declassified data and structured interviews.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly addresses whether the 2007 troop surge was a major cause of the reduction in violence beyond what the Anbar Awakening or sectarian cleansing would have produced on their own.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 1.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly contradicts the sub-claim by arguing that the surge was necessary and that alternative factors alone would not have sufficed to reduce violence.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"declassified iraq violence data 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 904, "completion_tokens": 66, "total_tokens": 970, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004362, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984523Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is an archival compilation of various reports, studies, and news agency snippets (such as Reuters and the Lancet) curated by an advocacy and policy organization, functioning as ordinary secondary compilation rather than original primary research.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "first lancet mortality study 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "undp iraq living conditions survey 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "global policy forum" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an archival compilation of various reports, studies, and news agency snippets (such as Reuters and the Lancet) curated by an advocacy and policy organization, functioning as ordinary secondary compilation rather than original primary research.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraqi mortality studies up to 2006 and general conditions up to 2008, providing only tangential background rather than directly addressing civilian death rates between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided excerpt does not discuss or provide data on the trend of civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"second lancet mortality study 2006\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"first lancet mortality study 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"undp iraq living conditions survey 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"global policy forum\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3113, "completion_tokens": 298, "total_tokens": 3411, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00201138, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984608Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is an archival compilation of various reports, studies, and news agency snippets (such as Reuters and the Lancet) curated by an advocacy and policy organization, functioning as ordinary secondary compilation rather than original primary research.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "first lancet mortality study 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "undp iraq living conditions survey 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "global policy forum" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is an archival compilation of various reports, studies, and news agency snippets (such as Reuters and the Lancet) curated by an advocacy and policy organization, functioning as ordinary secondary compilation rather than original primary research.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses Iraqi mortality studies up to 2006 and general conditions up to 2008, providing only tangential background rather than directly addressing civilian death rates between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses mortality studies up to 2006 and general conditions up to 2011, but does not provide data addressing whether civilian deaths fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"second lancet mortality study 2006\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"first lancet mortality study 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"undp iraq living conditions survey 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"global policy forum\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 921, "completion_tokens": 84, "total_tokens": 1005, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004863, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984608Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published in International Security, a leading peer-reviewed journal, the study rigorously evaluates declassified data and structured interviews.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published in International Security, a leading peer-reviewed journal, the study rigorously evaluates declassified data and structured interviews.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly investigates whether the surge and associated tactics caused the decline in violence beyond what other factors like the Awakening or sectarian cleansing would have produced.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.9, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document's assessment of declassified data and interviews finds that the surge was necessary and worked in synergy with the Awakening to reduce violence, supporting the view that the surge contributed significantly beyond what the Awakening or other factors would have produced alone.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"sigacts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2563, "completion_tokens": 2221, "total_tokens": 4784, "reasoning_tokens": 2030 }, "cost_usd": 0.01001852, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984738Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article, which functions as tertiary or ordinary reporting that aggregates secondary and primary findings without direct peer review or primary investigative sourcing.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article, which functions as tertiary or ordinary reporting that aggregates secondary and primary findings without direct peer review or primary investigative sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses the 2007 troop surge and general stabilization of the country, which is adjacent to the sub-claim about falling civilian deaths and attacks during that timeframe, but it does not specifically report on civilian death statistics or casualty trends.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt mentions the 2007 troop surge and that it helped stabilize parts of the country, but it does not provide specific data or mention civilian death rates falling between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3004, "completion_tokens": 217, "total_tokens": 3221, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0017387, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984850Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The source is a Wikipedia article, which functions as tertiary or ordinary reporting that aggregates secondary and primary findings without direct peer review or primary investigative sourcing.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a Wikipedia article, which functions as tertiary or ordinary reporting that aggregates secondary and primary findings without direct peer review or primary investigative sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document mentions the 2007 troop surge and its stabilizing effect on a broad level, but does not address the specific counterfactual comparison to the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt asserts that the 2007 troop surge helped stabilize parts of the country, aligning with the sub-claim's focus on the impact of the increased US troop levels.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3056, "completion_tokens": 195, "total_tokens": 3251, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0016993, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984926Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The document is reputable reporting by the official American Forces Press Service, citing a named primary military source and specific operational statistics.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "american forces press service" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "col jb burton 2nd brigade combat team 1st infantry division" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is reputable reporting by the official American Forces Press Service, citing a named primary military source and specific operational statistics.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the impact of the troop surge tactics (moving into smaller combat outposts) on reducing violence in Baghdad, which is a core component of the sub-claim, though it does not explicitly weigh this against alternative factors like the Anbar Awakening or the Sadrist ceasefire.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.5,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports direct observations from an Army commander that moving troops into community-based outposts as part of the security plan directly reduced murders and IED incidents in his sector.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"american forces press service\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"col jb burton 2nd brigade combat team 1st infantry division\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2928, "completion_tokens": 246, "total_tokens": 3174, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00179736, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.984985Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The document relies on official military statistics (SIGACTS) and reports from the Department of Defense and the UN, providing reputable reporting with named official records.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "mnf i significant activity reports" }, { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, { "type": "study", "id": "un april 2008 report" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document relies on official military statistics (SIGACTS) and reports from the Department of Defense and the UN, providing reputable reporting with named official records.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses overall levels of violence and attacks in Iraq during the specified timeframe, which is closely related to civilian deaths and attacks even though it focuses primarily on enemy-initiated attacks rather than explicitly isolating civilian casualties.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt cites specific data showing that overall violence and enemy-initiated attacks decreased significantly between mid-2007 and early-2008 compared to the high levels of 2006 and early 2007.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"mnf i significant activity reports\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"dod march 2008 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un april 2008 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3146, "completion_tokens": 1148, "total_tokens": 4294, "reasoning_tokens": 897 }, "cost_usd": 0.00602044, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.985525Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The document relies on official military statistics (SIGACTS) and reports from the Department of Defense and the UN, providing reputable reporting with named official records.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "mnf i significant activity reports" }, { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, { "type": "study", "id": "un april 2008 report" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document relies on official military statistics (SIGACTS) and reports from the Department of Defense and the UN, providing reputable reporting with named official records.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses overall levels of violence and attacks in Iraq during the specified timeframe, which is closely related to civilian deaths and attacks even though it focuses primarily on enemy-initiated attacks rather than explicitly isolating civilian casualties.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": -1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.9,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states that levels of violence and attacks decreased significantly from mid-2007 to early 2008 compared to the high levels in 2006 and early 2007, which directly contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"mnf i significant activity reports\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"dod march 2008 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un april 2008 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 899, "completion_tokens": 88, "total_tokens": 987, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004897, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.985525Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Human Rights Watch is a reputable human rights organization providing professional reporting based on documented observations, official data, and field research, though it is not a peer-reviewed academic study or a primary government record.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "human rights watch" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unhcr iom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us military" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi government" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Human Rights Watch is a reputable human rights organization providing professional reporting based on documented observations, official data, and field research, though it is not a peer-reviewed academic study or a primary government record.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document mentions security gains in 2008 generally, which is broader than and only partly covers the specific claim about civilian deaths and attacks falling between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt mentions 'security gains in 2008' generally, but does not provide specific data or discussion regarding whether civilian deaths and attacks fell between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"human rights watch\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unhcr iom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us military\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi government\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2924, "completion_tokens": 2101, "total_tokens": 5025, "reasoning_tokens": 2085 }, "cost_usd": 0.0095967, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.985631Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a report from the Center for Strategic and International studies, a reputable think tank providing analysis on military posture and violence in Iraq based on official records and operational assessments.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a report from the Center for Strategic and International studies, a reputable think tank providing analysis on military posture and violence in Iraq based on official records and operational assessments.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the impact of the 2007 US troop surge and changes in military tactics on violence in Iraq, as well as the Anbar Awakening, but does not fully isolate the specific comparative weight of these factors against other causes like the Sadrist ceasefire or sectarian displacement.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports that the troop buildup and operations helped decrease violence in Anbar and Baghdad and damaged extremist forces, directly supporting the view that the troop increase and tactics contributed to reduced violence.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"csis\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2847, "completion_tokens": 220, "total_tokens": 3067, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0016867, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.985699Z" }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The source is a report from the Center for Strategic and International studies, a reputable think tank providing analysis on military posture and violence in Iraq based on official records and operational assessments.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The source is a report from the Center for Strategic and International studies, a reputable think tank providing analysis on military posture and violence in Iraq based on official records and operational assessments.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\n \\\"directness\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses the impact of the 2007 US troop surge and changes in military tactics on violence in Iraq, as well as the Anbar Awakening, but does not fully isolate the specific comparative weight of these factors against other causes like the Sadrist ceasefire or sectarian displacement.\\\"\\n}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document notes mixed developments and mentions factors like the Anbar Awakening alongside troop increases, providing partial support to the sub-claim that the troop surge and tactics were not the sole major cause of the decline in violence.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"csis\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 854, "completion_tokens": 69, "total_tokens": 923, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.0004287, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.985699Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.8, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count is a reputable independent monitor with a transparent methodology and a detailed incident database, making this a primary compilation rather than secondary reporting; however, it relies on media reports and is not peer-reviewed or an official inquiry.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.8, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Iraq Body Count is a reputable independent monitor with a transparent methodology and a detailed incident database, making this a primary compilation rather than secondary reporting; however, it relies on media reports and is not peer-reviewed or an official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports on civilian death trends in 2008 compared with 2006 and 2007, closely addressing the claimed decline, but it does not specifically isolate mid-2007 to mid-2008 or explicitly cover attacks.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.7,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The document reports IBC-documented civilian death counts showing a substantial drop from 81/day in 2006 and 72/day in 2007 to 25/day in 2008, which supports a large decline in civilian deaths, though it gives annual rather than mid-2007-to-mid-2008 figures and does not directly quantify attacks.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3219, "completion_tokens": 6132, "total_tokens": 9351, "reasoning_tokens": 5796 }, "cost_usd": 0.014385673, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.985792Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count is a widely cited, transparently documented database that aggregates media and official reports (including WikiLeaks' Iraq War Logs) with named methodology and acknowledged limitations, making it reputable sourcing rather than anonymous or advocacy-based. However, it is a secondary compilation with self-acknowledged undercounting and single-sourced entries, not a peer-reviewed study, official inquiry, or primary document, so it falls short of the 0.9 tier.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Iraq Body Count is a widely cited, transparently documented database that aggregates media and official reports (including WikiLeaks' Iraq War Logs) with named methodology and acknowledged limitations, making it reputable sourcing rather than anonymous or advocacy-based. However, it is a secondary compilation with self-acknowledged undercounting and single-sourced entries, not a peer-reviewed study, official inquiry, or primary document, so it falls short of the 0.9 tier.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a civilian-death database covering the relevant period and could be queried for the mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline, but the excerpt itself only describes the database and totals without reporting on the specific trend.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt provides only aggregate totals and a note about monthly data from 2003 onward, without presenting or comparing figures for mid-2007 to mid-2008 or 2006/early-2007, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2439, "completion_tokens": 1385, "total_tokens": 3824, "reasoning_tokens": 1192 }, "cost_usd": 0.0026141800000000002, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.985866Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Columbia Journalism Review is a reputable editorially reviewed outlet, but this piece is secondary journalism that relays findings from advocacy and NGO reports rather than presenting original primary data or peer-reviewed analysis. It names sources such as PSR and Iraq Body Count, but remains an ordinary journalistic summary.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "psr study 2015" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "lexisnexis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Columbia Journalism Review is a reputable editorially reviewed outlet, but this piece is secondary journalism that relays findings from advocacy and NGO reports rather than presenting original primary data or peer-reviewed analysis. It names sources such as PSR and Iraq Body Count, but remains an ordinary journalistic summary.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses overall Iraqi civilian death counts and media underreporting but does not address the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline in deaths and attacks relative to 2006 and early 2007.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses overall Iraqi casualty counts and current violence but does not address the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"psr study 2015\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lexisnexis\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2976, "completion_tokens": 4672, "total_tokens": 7648, "reasoning_tokens": 4497 }, "cost_usd": 0.0169678, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.985929Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is an openly editable tertiary source without formal peer review, though it does cite named sources and official records. It summarizes findings rather than providing verifiable primary evidence, making it of moderate reliability for this historical topic.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate 2007" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "unhcr iraqi government 2006" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un secretary general 2006" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is an openly editable tertiary source without formal peer review, though it does cite named sources and official records. It summarizes findings rather than providing verifiable primary evidence, making it of moderate reliability for this historical topic.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The passage notes that violence declined dramatically in 2008 amid the Sunni Awakening and U.S. troop surge, but it does not assess whether the 2007 troop increase and tactical change were a major cause beyond other factors such as the Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only notes that violence declined during both the Sunni Awakening and the U.S. troop surge, without assessing the surge's causal contribution beyond those other factors.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate 2007\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unhcr iraqi government 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un secretary general 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"george w bush 2007\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3404, "completion_tokens": 4269, "total_tokens": 7673, "reasoning_tokens": 4006 }, "cost_usd": 0.0111159744, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.985987Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is a scholarly article published by Princeton University with academic indexing metadata (ASJC codes, fingerprint), indicating a peer-reviewed study or official academic analysis, which is high-quality evidence for the topic. The excerpt itself is only metadata, but the source type and publisher track record support a 0.9 rating.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "mnfi sigacts iii" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a scholarly article published by Princeton University with academic indexing metadata (ASJC codes, fingerprint), indicating a peer-reviewed study or official academic analysis, which is high-quality evidence for the topic. The excerpt itself is only metadata, but the source type and publisher track record support a 0.9 rating.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document's title and research question directly test whether the surge caused the 2007 decline in violence in Iraq, which is exactly the proposition under assessment.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt contains only bibliographic metadata and topic fingerprint, with no substantive content addressing the surge's causal role in the violence decline.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"mnfi sigacts iii\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1907, "completion_tokens": 5075, "total_tokens": 6982, "reasoning_tokens": 4857 }, "cost_usd": 0.0130736494, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986045Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "It is a secondary, unsigned educational summary from a reputable military-history publisher, but the excerpt provides no citations, named primary sources, or official records. It functions as a general overview rather than a sourced inquiry or primary document.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "pritzkermilitary org" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"It is a secondary, unsigned educational summary from a reputable military-history publisher, but the excerpt provides no citations, named primary sources, or official records. It functions as a general overview rather than a sourced inquiry or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document lists the Surge alongside the Anbar Awakening and Sadrist ceasefire as reasons for the 2007-2008 violence decline, but it does not test whether the Surge was a major cause beyond the other factors or address the completion of sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document lists the Surge as one of four reasons for decreased violence but does not assess whether it was a major cause beyond the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"pritzkermilitary.org\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3124, "completion_tokens": 2434, "total_tokens": 5558, "reasoning_tokens": 2352 }, "cost_usd": 0.00415051, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986102Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a Congressional Research Service report prepared for Congress, an official government research product that compiles and cites governmental and nongovernmental casualty estimates. It is not peer-reviewed but is a reputable official inquiry with named author and institutional sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi ministries data" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of defense data" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Congressional Research Service report prepared for Congress, an official government research product that compiles and cites governmental and nongovernmental casualty estimates. It is not peer-reviewed but is a reputable official inquiry with named author and institutional sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The report provides monthly Iraqi civilian casualty data covering January 2006 through May 2009, which directly bears on the civilian-death trend in the sub-claim, but it does not address attacks and only partially covers the full proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only lists casualty-statistics sources and figure titles without reporting any actual trend, and it does not address attacks, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraqi ministries data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of defense data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"brookings iraq index\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2931, "completion_tokens": 7152, "total_tokens": 10083, "reasoning_tokens": 6938 }, "cost_usd": 0.0199330536, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986160Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a Congressional Research Service report prepared for Congress, an official government research product that compiles and cites governmental and nongovernmental casualty estimates. It is not peer-reviewed but is a reputable official inquiry with named author and institutional sourcing.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi ministries data" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of defense data" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Congressional Research Service report prepared for Congress, an official government research product that compiles and cites governmental and nongovernmental casualty estimates. It is not peer-reviewed but is a reputable official inquiry with named author and institutional sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The report provides monthly Iraqi civilian casualty data covering January 2006 through May 2009, which directly bears on the civilian-death trend in the sub-claim, but it does not address attacks and only partially covers the full proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only mentions that a figure on Iraqi civilian deaths from January 2006 to May 2009 exists, but provides no actual data or statement about the trend, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraqi ministries data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of defense data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"brookings iraq index\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 832, "completion_tokens": 1092, "total_tokens": 1924, "reasoning_tokens": 1020 }, "cost_usd": 0.00156, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986160Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.6, "quality_rationale": "Secondary analytical essay in a reputable but non-peer-reviewed defense outlet; it uses footnoted sourcing for casualty and force data, but is not a primary record or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "small wars journal 2013" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.6, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Secondary analytical essay in a reputable but non-peer-reviewed defense outlet; it uses footnoted sourcing for casualty and force data, but is not a primary record or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The essay explicitly assesses whether the 2007 US troop surge caused the 2007-2008 decline in violence while weighing the competing roles of the Anbar Awakening, the Mahdi Army ceasefire, and Shia victory/sectarian displacement, which is precisely the proposition under test.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The essay's stated thesis argues the US 'surge' alone is not a satisfactory explanation and that local factors—Shiite victory/sectarian displacement, the Sunni decision to cooperate (Anbar Awakening) and the Mahdi Army ceasefire—were of equal importance, which directly denies the sub-claim's added causal weight for the troop increase and tactics.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"small wars journal 2013\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3232, "completion_tokens": 1583, "total_tokens": 4815, "reasoning_tokens": 1331 }, "cost_usd": 0.003198935, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986256Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.4, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is an anonymous, collaboratively edited tertiary source with no formal peer review or named authorship; it relays cited sources but is not itself a primary or authoritative record.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "us marine corps history division" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "icasualties" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us marine corps intelligence report 2006" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is an anonymous, collaboratively edited tertiary source with no formal peer review or named authorship; it relays cited sources but is not itself a primary or authoritative record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides background on the Anbar campaign and the Anbar Awakening, one competing factor mentioned in the sub-claim, but does not discuss the 2007 troop increase, tactical changes, or the 2007–2008 violence decline.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only narrates the Anbar campaign's chronology and the emergence of the Anbar Awakening in 2006, saying nothing about the 2007 troop increase or its causal contribution to the 2007–2008 decline in violence relative to the Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us marine corps history division\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"icasualties\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us marine corps intelligence report 2006\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3330, "completion_tokens": 6148, "total_tokens": 9478, "reasoning_tokens": 5991 }, "cost_usd": 0.017707234, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986316Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a collaboratively edited Wikipedia article, a tertiary source without named authorship, formal peer review, or traditional editorial accountability; it relays cited primary and official sources but is not itself authoritative.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush address to the nation january 10 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house fact sheet the new way forward in iraq" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bob woodward the war within 2008" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hillary clinton and barack obama statements on surge" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a collaboratively edited Wikipedia article, a tertiary source without named authorship, formal peer review, or traditional editorial accountability; it relays cited primary and official sources but is not itself authoritative.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the 2007 troop surge and its tactical focus but does not address the causal question of whether the surge caused the 2007-2008 violence decline beyond other factors like the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes the surge's goals and notes retrospective claims that it was successful, but it does not report 2007-2008 violence trends or assess the surge's causal contribution relative to the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush address to the nation january 10 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house fact sheet the new way forward in iraq\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"bob woodward the war within 2008\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hillary clinton and barack obama statements on surge\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3095, "completion_tokens": 8501, "total_tokens": 11596, "reasoning_tokens": 8853 }, "cost_usd": 0.03180648, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986379Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.8, "quality_rationale": "Academic research report from Brown University's Costs of War project, authored by a named professor and based on documented tallies (Iraq Body Count, government and press reports), but it is a secondary compilation not formally peer-reviewed and does not directly address US force posture.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.8, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Academic research report from Brown University's Costs of War project, authored by a named professor and based on documented tallies (Iraq Body Count, government and press reports), but it is a secondary compilation not formally peer-reviewed and does not directly address US force posture.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses civilian deaths and injuries across the entire Iraq War (2003–2013), a broader topic that only partly covers the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline and attacks trend.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt does not address the 2007-2008 decline in civilian deaths and attacks, only overall death toll estimates and the continuation of violence.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3211, "completion_tokens": 5980, "total_tokens": 9191, "reasoning_tokens": 5792 }, "cost_usd": 0.014676887999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986441Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.8, "quality_rationale": "Academic research report from Brown University's Costs of War project, authored by a named professor and based on documented tallies (Iraq Body Count, government and press reports), but it is a secondary compilation not formally peer-reviewed and does not directly address US force posture.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.8, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Academic research report from Brown University's Costs of War project, authored by a named professor and based on documented tallies (Iraq Body Count, government and press reports), but it is a secondary compilation not formally peer-reviewed and does not directly address US force posture.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document addresses civilian deaths and injuries across the entire Iraq War (2003–2013), a broader topic that only partly covers the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline and attacks trend.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses total civilian death tolls and ongoing violence but does not address the trend in civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008 relative to 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 908, "completion_tokens": 71, "total_tokens": 979, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00028608, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986441Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official Congressional Research Service report published on congress.gov, compiling and critically caveating multiple government and NGO estimates; it is a well-sourced, editorially reviewed government research document with no evident partisan conflict of interest, though it is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary data record.", "directness": 0.9, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "congressional research service" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official Congressional Research Service report published on congress.gov, compiling and critically caveating multiple government and NGO estimates; it is a well-sourced, editorially reviewed government research document with no evident partisan conflict of interest, though it is a secondary synthesis rather than a primary data record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The CRS report compiles Iraqi civilian death estimates and its Figure 1 spans January 2006 to August 2008, precisely bracketing the 2006/early-2007 versus mid-2007-to-mid-2008 comparison, though it addresses civilian deaths rather than 'attacks.'\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only lists a figure on estimated civilian deaths from January 2006 to August 2008 and does not report any trend or attack data, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"congressional research service\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2675, "completion_tokens": 1819, "total_tokens": 4494, "reasoning_tokens": 1567 }, "cost_usd": 0.002967804, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986541Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "TIME is a reputable outlet with editorial standards, and the article names its primary source (Iraq Body Count) and provides specific figures and caveats; it is not peer-reviewed or an official primary record.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "associated press" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"TIME is a reputable outlet with editorial standards, and the article names its primary source (Iraq Body Count) and provides specific figures and caveats; it is not peer-reviewed or an official primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The article directly reports a 2008 decline in Iraqi civilian deaths compared with 2006 and 2007, but it does not specifically measure attacks or the mid-2007-to-mid-2008 interval, so it only partly matches the exact sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":1,\\\"strength\\\":0.5,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"finding\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The IBC tally reported in the article shows 2008 civilian deaths were substantially lower than 2007 and 2006 levels, supporting the deaths part of the sub-claim, though it does not directly establish a mid-2007-to-mid-2008 attack decline and notes some categories remained unchanged.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"associated press\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3190, "completion_tokens": 3892, "total_tokens": 7082, "reasoning_tokens": 3681 }, "cost_usd": 0.00912294, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986600Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published in PLOS Medicine, a peer-reviewed journal, with transparent methods and analysis of the named Iraq Body Count database; this is a peer-reviewed study rather than ordinary journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published in PLOS Medicine, a peer-reviewed journal, with transparent methods and analysis of the named Iraq Body Count database; this is a peer-reviewed study rather than ordinary journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document analyzes temporal trends in Iraqi civilian violent deaths from 2003 to early 2008, closely related to the sub-claim's focus on falling deaths, but its data end in March 2008 and it does not directly report on attacks or the full mid-2007 to mid-2008 interval.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes overall temporal patterns (e.g., peaks during the invasion) but provides no data or statement on the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline relative to 2006 and early-2007 levels, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2988, "completion_tokens": 1031, "total_tokens": 4019, "reasoning_tokens": 808 }, "cost_usd": 0.002662915, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986658Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Published in PLOS Medicine, a peer-reviewed journal, with transparent methods and analysis of the named Iraq Body Count database; this is a peer-reviewed study rather than ordinary journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Published in PLOS Medicine, a peer-reviewed journal, with transparent methods and analysis of the named Iraq Body Count database; this is a peer-reviewed study rather than ordinary journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document analyzes temporal trends in Iraqi civilian violent deaths from 2003 to early 2008, closely related to the sub-claim's focus on falling deaths, but its data end in March 2008 and it does not directly report on attacks or the full mid-2007 to mid-2008 interval.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports overall death counts and temporal patterns (e.g., peaks during the invasion) but does not address whether civilian deaths and attacks fell substantially between mid-2007 and mid-2008 relative to 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 869, "completion_tokens": 77, "total_tokens": 946, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00028248, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986658Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is the actual quarterly report to Congress mandated by the Department of Defense Appropriations Act, a primary official government document hosted by GlobalSecurity.org, a long-established repository of defense documents. It is a primary record of official findings, though it is a self-reported government assessment rather than an independent inquiry.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense report to congress june 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is the actual quarterly report to Congress mandated by the Department of Defense Appropriations Act, a primary official government document hosted by GlobalSecurity.org, a long-established repository of defense documents. It is a primary record of official findings, though it is a self-reported government assessment rather than an independent inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the 2007 troop increase and Operation Fardh al-Qanoon as a security effort to reduce sectarian violence in Baghdad, which is adjacent to but does not directly test the causal claim about the surge's contribution to the 2007-2008 violence decline relative to other factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes the 2007 troop increase and new Baghdad security operation as intended to reduce sectarian violence, but it does not assess whether it caused the 2007-2008 violence decline or control for the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, and sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"department of defense report to congress june 2007\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2990, "completion_tokens": 922, "total_tokens": 3912, "reasoning_tokens": 645 }, "cost_usd": 0.00170624, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986741Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The Council on Foreign Relations is a reputable, editorially reviewed policy publisher, and this backgrounder cites named official sources such as Gen. Petraeus’s congressional testimony and independent reports. It is a secondary analysis rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document, so it rates below 0.9.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "us military iraq violence statistics" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "gen david petraeus testimony september 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Council on Foreign Relations is a reputable, editorially reviewed policy publisher, and this backgrounder cites named official sources such as Gen. Petraeus’s congressional testimony and independent reports. It is a secondary analysis rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document, so it rates below 0.9.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports a substantial drop in Iraqi civilian deaths and related violence from December 2006 to August 2007, directly covering the baseline and early part of the sub-claim but not the period through mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports Petraeus's congressional testimony that civilian deaths declined over 45 percent between December 2006 and August 2007, which supports a substantial fall from 2006/early-2007 levels, though it is an official assertion rather than direct observation and covers only part of the mid-2007 to mid-2008 window.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us military iraq violence statistics\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"gen david petraeus testimony september 2007\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2834, "completion_tokens": 2187, "total_tokens": 5021, "reasoning_tokens": 1886 }, "cost_usd": 0.00667968, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986815Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary, collaboratively edited source without formal peer review or editorial accountability comparable to academic or official publications; it summarizes peer-reviewed Lancet studies but is not itself a primary or peer-reviewed document.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary, collaboratively edited source without formal peer review or editorial accountability comparable to academic or official publications; it summarizes peer-reviewed Lancet studies but is not itself a primary or peer-reviewed document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses casualty estimates only up to mid-2006 and does not address the mid-2007 to mid-2008 period or any decline in violence during that time, making it tangential background.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document only reports mortality estimates through June 2006 and does not address civilian deaths or attacks from mid-2007 to mid-2008, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3311, "completion_tokens": 2573, "total_tokens": 5884, "reasoning_tokens": 2329 }, "cost_usd": 0.00450778, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986881Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary, collaboratively edited source without formal peer review or editorial accountability comparable to academic or official publications; it summarizes peer-reviewed Lancet studies but is not itself a primary or peer-reviewed document.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary, collaboratively edited source without formal peer review or editorial accountability comparable to academic or official publications; it summarizes peer-reviewed Lancet studies but is not itself a primary or peer-reviewed document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses casualty estimates only up to mid-2006 and does not address the mid-2007 to mid-2008 period or any decline in violence during that time, making it tangential background.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document covers excess death estimates through June 2006 and does not address the trend in civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 948, "completion_tokens": 71, "total_tokens": 1019, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00029568, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986881Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count is a well-known independent civilian casualty database with transparent methodology and named sources, but it is an NGO/advocacy project rather than a peer-reviewed or official record, and this document is an analysis of its own data.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq war logs wikileaks" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Iraq Body Count is a well-known independent civilian casualty database with transparent methodology and named sources, but it is an NGO/advocacy project rather than a peer-reviewed or official record, and this document is an analysis of its own data.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides a broad decade-long analysis of civilian deaths in Iraq but does not specifically report on the decline in civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008 relative to 2006 and early 2007.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt gives aggregate civilian death totals for 2003-2013 and general statements about ongoing violence, but provides no data or direct observation on the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline relative to 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq war logs wikileaks\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3024, "completion_tokens": 2070, "total_tokens": 5094, "reasoning_tokens": 1835 }, "cost_usd": 0.00413281, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.986964Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is an official U.S. Department of State country report, a primary government document that cites named official sources such as Multinational Force-Iraq and the International Mission for Iraqi Elections. It carries the institutional authority and accountability of a government publication, though it is an official self-interested account rather than an independent or peer-reviewed assessment.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "multinational force iraq" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "international mission for iraqi elections" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of state" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is an official U.S. Department of State country report, a primary government document that cites named official sources such as Multinational Force-Iraq and the International Mission for Iraqi Elections. It carries the institutional authority and accountability of a government publication, though it is an official self-interested account rather than an independent or peer-reviewed assessment.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports that since the second half of 2007 and during 2008 the security situation substantially improved and civilian deaths from violence fell 72 percent compared to the previous year, which is exactly the proposition under test.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The report states that violence fell to its lowest level since 2004 and relays MNF-I data showing civilian deaths dropped 72 percent during the year, which strongly supports a substantial decline from 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"multinational force iraq\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"international mission for iraqi elections\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of state\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3071, "completion_tokens": 4567, "total_tokens": 7638, "reasoning_tokens": 4297 }, "cost_usd": 0.010339524000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987020Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is a congressionally mandated Department of Defense report to Congress, making it an official primary-source record with defined performance indicators and legal reporting requirements. Although it is self-interested government reporting and appears via the globalsecurity.org archive rather than a peer-reviewed outlet, its official provenance and primary status support a high source-quality rating.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a congressionally mandated Department of Defense report to Congress, making it an official primary-source record with defined performance indicators and legal reporting requirements. Although it is self-interested government reporting and appears via the globalsecurity.org archive rather than a peer-reviewed outlet, its official provenance and primary status support a high source-quality rating.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This quarterly security report covers attacks and civilian deaths during September–November 2007, a portion of the sub-claim's mid-2007 to mid-2008 timeframe, but does not itself compare those levels to 2006/early-2007 or extend to mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only asserts general security progress for September–November 2007 and does not report civilian death or attack trends through mid-2008, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"department of defense\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2827, "completion_tokens": 1381, "total_tokens": 4208, "reasoning_tokens": 1124 }, "cost_usd": 0.003210165, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987079Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a Wikipedia encyclopedia article, a tertiary source that summarizes and cites the Iraq Body Count project and other secondary reporting rather than presenting original data or peer-reviewed analysis. It is editorially reviewed but anonymous and derivative, so it rates as ordinary relayed journalism-level sourcing.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jonathan steele guardian" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a Wikipedia encyclopedia article, a tertiary source that summarizes and cites the Iraq Body Count project and other secondary reporting rather than presenting original data or peer-reviewed analysis. It is editorially reviewed but anonymous and derivative, so it rates as ordinary relayed journalism-level sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the Iraq Body Count project and its general civilian-death database, but it does not report on any decline in civilian deaths or attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008, making it only tangential background to the specific temporal claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document describes the Iraq Body Count project and its methodology but does not address any change in civilian deaths or attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008 relative to 2006 and early 2007.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"jonathan steele guardian\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2802, "completion_tokens": 2241, "total_tokens": 5043, "reasoning_tokens": 1993 }, "cost_usd": 0.00833352, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987140Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "The Guardian is a reputable publisher with editorial standards, and the article cites named primary sources such as WHO/Iraqi health ministry surveys, the Lancet, ORB, and Lt. Gen. Tommy Franks. However, it is secondary journalism rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary record, and it carries a correction for misreporting survey findings.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "who iraqi health ministry survey 2008" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "orb iraq mortality survey 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Guardian is a reputable publisher with editorial standards, and the article cites named primary sources such as WHO/Iraqi health ministry surveys, the Lancet, ORB, and Lt. Gen. Tommy Franks. However, it is secondary journalism rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary record, and it carries a correction for misreporting survey findings.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses overall civilian death toll estimates and survey controversies in Iraq, but does not report on or test the specific decline in civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses overall Iraqi death toll controversies and US body-count policy but does not address any change in civilian deaths or attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"who iraqi health ministry survey 2008\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet iraq mortality survey 2006\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"orb iraq mortality survey 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of defense\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2890, "completion_tokens": 2445, "total_tokens": 5335, "reasoning_tokens": 2172 }, "cost_usd": 0.007993894999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987199Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source with some citations but no named author, peer review, or clear primary sourcing in the excerpt, so it is only moderately reliable as evidence. It relays historical claims without the direct official records or named primary sources expected of higher-quality evidence.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source with some citations but no named author, peer review, or clear primary sourcing in the excerpt, so it is only moderately reliable as evidence. It relays historical claims without the direct official records or named primary sources expected of higher-quality evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document broadly describes the insurgency timeline and notes that the civil war and sectarian violence ended in mid-2008 after the 2007 troop surge, but it does not directly report on civilian deaths or attack levels falling between mid-2007 and mid-2008 from 2006/early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt states the Shia–Sunni civil war and sectarian violence ended in mid-2008 after being quelled by the 2007 troop surge, which broadly supports a substantial decline in violence by mid-2008, though it does not specifically quantify civilian deaths or attacks relative to 2006 and early 2007.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3063, "completion_tokens": 1165, "total_tokens": 4228, "reasoning_tokens": 893 }, "cost_usd": 0.0033640049999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987257Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is a Congressional Research Service report by Hannah Fischer, an official government research publication with named authorship and reliance on official records, though hosted on the Internet Archive.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq ministry of health" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a Congressional Research Service report by Hannah Fischer, an official government research publication with named authorship and reliance on official records, though hosted on the Internet Archive.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is titled 'Iraqi Civilian Deaths Estimates' and likely reports on Iraqi civilian death estimates, a core component of the sub-claim, but it does not address attacks or the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt is only a fundraising appeal from the Internet Archive and contains no content about Iraqi civilian deaths or attack levels, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey 2008\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq ministry of health\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1921, "completion_tokens": 8426, "total_tokens": 10347, "reasoning_tokens": 8357 }, "cost_usd": 0.026181779999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987318Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "The document is a Congressional Research Service report by Hannah Fischer, an official government research publication with named authorship and reliance on official records, though hosted on the Internet Archive.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq ministry of health" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is a Congressional Research Service report by Hannah Fischer, an official government research publication with named authorship and reliance on official records, though hosted on the Internet Archive.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is titled 'Iraqi Civilian Deaths Estimates' and likely reports on Iraqi civilian death estimates, a core component of the sub-claim, but it does not address attacks or the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt is only an Internet Archive donation appeal and contains no content about Iraqi civilian deaths or attacks, so it neither supports nor contradicts the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey 2008\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq ministry of health\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 582, "completion_tokens": 400, "total_tokens": 982, "reasoning_tokens": 374 }, "cost_usd": 0.00063278, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987318Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Peer-reviewed academic journal article from JMSS with a DOI, analyzing SIGACT data and other factors; it is a scholarly study rather than an official inquiry or primary record.", "directness": 0.9, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Peer-reviewed academic journal article from JMSS with a DOI, analyzing SIGACT data and other factors; it is a scholarly study rather than an official inquiry or primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The paper directly examines whether the 2007 surge caused the decline in violence versus other pre-existing factors, which is essentially the sub-claim under test, though it frames the comparison around timing/pre-surge trends rather than decomposing each named alternative cause.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The abstract reports SIGACT data showing violence peaked before the 2007 surge and that other factors likely explain the earlier decline, concluding the surge was an unnecessary gambit, which directly contradicts the claim that the troop increase and new tactics were a major cause of the 2007–2008 violence decline beyond those other factors.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"sigact\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2091, "completion_tokens": 1236, "total_tokens": 3327, "reasoning_tokens": 1072 }, "cost_usd": 0.003405966, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987402Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Peer-reviewed academic journal article from JMSS with a DOI, analyzing SIGACT data and other factors; it is a scholarly study rather than an official inquiry or primary record.", "directness": 0.9, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Peer-reviewed academic journal article from JMSS with a DOI, analyzing SIGACT data and other factors; it is a scholarly study rather than an official inquiry or primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The paper directly examines whether the 2007 surge caused the decline in violence versus other pre-existing factors, which is essentially the sub-claim under test, though it frames the comparison around timing/pre-surge trends rather than decomposing each named alternative cause.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The abstract reports SIGACT data showing violence peaked before the surge and argues other pre-surge factors likely drove the decline, concluding the surge was an unnecessary gambit, which supports the sub-claim that the surge was not a major cause beyond those other factors.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"sigact\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 658, "completion_tokens": 824, "total_tokens": 1482, "reasoning_tokens": 744 }, "cost_usd": 0.0011862, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987402Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary, collaboratively edited source without formal peer review or editorial accountability; it summarizes and quotes the official Petraeus/Crocker report but is not the primary record itself.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary, collaboratively edited source without formal peer review or editorial accountability; it summarizes and quotes the official Petraeus/Crocker report but is not the primary record itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports General Petraeus's claim that the surge and associated operations contributed to reduced violence in Iraq, which closely addresses the core causal proposition, but it does not evaluate the specific counterfactual of whether the decline exceeded what the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, and sectarian displacement would have produced alone.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document relays Petraeus's testimony that the surge's military operations caused or substantially contributed to the 2007 security improvements, supporting the claim that the troop increase and new tactics were a major cause, though it does not isolate that effect from the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2989, "completion_tokens": 3173, "total_tokens": 6162, "reasoning_tokens": 3078 }, "cost_usd": 0.007167434, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987509Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source with citations to studies and official records, but it lacks formal peer review, named authorship, and editorial accountability. The excerpt focuses on casualty estimates and only indirectly addresses US force posture, making it comparable to ordinary secondary reporting that relays other sources' findings.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "opinion research business survey 2007" }, { "type": "study", "id": "plos medicine 2013" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\":0.5,\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary source with citations to studies and official records, but it lacks formal peer review, named authorship, and editorial accountability. The excerpt focuses on casualty estimates and only indirectly addresses US force posture, making it comparable to ordinary secondary reporting that relays other sources' findings.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document broadly covers Iraq War casualty estimates but does not specifically report on the decline in civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt summarizes casualty estimates and disputes but does not address any decline in civilian deaths or attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet study 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"opinion research business survey 2007\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"plos medicine 2013\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3196, "completion_tokens": 4464, "total_tokens": 7660, "reasoning_tokens": 4225 }, "cost_usd": 0.012896055, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987569Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.8, "quality_rationale": "Reputable think tank brief summarizing a peer-reviewed study in International Security, based on declassified data and 70 structured interviews; not itself peer-reviewed but high-quality secondary source with transparent methodology.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.75, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "declassified iraq violence data 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.8, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable think tank brief summarizing a peer-reviewed study in International Security, based on declassified data and 70 structured interviews; not itself peer-reviewed but high-quality secondary source with transparent methodology.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly evaluates whether the surge was a necessary cause of the 2007 violence decline beyond the Anbar Awakening and sectarian cleansing, which is the core of the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.75, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document states the surge was necessary and that without it violence would probably have stayed high even with the Anbar Awakening and the natural burnout of sectarian strife, which directly supports the sub-claim, though it frames the effect as a synergy with the Awakening rather than a standalone surge cause and rests partly on counterfactual inference.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"declassified iraq violence data 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3186, "completion_tokens": 4254, "total_tokens": 7440, "reasoning_tokens": 4130 }, "cost_usd": 0.01120582, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987627Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.8, "quality_rationale": "Reputable think tank brief summarizing a peer-reviewed study in International Security, based on declassified data and 70 structured interviews; not itself peer-reviewed but high-quality secondary source with transparent methodology.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "declassified iraq violence data 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.8, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reputable think tank brief summarizing a peer-reviewed study in International Security, based on declassified data and 70 structured interviews; not itself peer-reviewed but high-quality secondary source with transparent methodology.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly evaluates whether the surge was a necessary cause of the 2007 violence decline beyond the Anbar Awakening and sectarian cleansing, which is the core of the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document argues the surge was necessary for the 2007 violence reduction and that neither the Anbar Awakening nor a natural burnout of sectarian strife would have sufficed, directly supporting the sub-claim that the surge's effect exceeded what those other factors alone would have produced, though it rests partly on assertions and partly on cited declassified data and interviews.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"declassified iraq violence data 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 903, "completion_tokens": 101, "total_tokens": 1004, "reasoning_tokens": 0 }, "cost_usd": 0.00031368, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987627Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary NGO compilation that summarizes named mortality studies and news reports, but it is not peer-reviewed, not primary research, and reflects an advocacy-oriented publisher.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "first lancet mortality study 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "undp iraq living conditions survey 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "global policy forum" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary NGO compilation that summarizes named mortality studies and news reports, but it is not peer-reviewed, not primary research, and reflects an advocacy-oriented publisher.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides background on Iraqi mortality estimates up to mid-2006 but does not report on or test the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline in civilian deaths and attacks.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses mortality studies and high death rates through mid-2006, but does not address or provide data on changes in civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"second lancet mortality study 2006\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"first lancet mortality study 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"undp iraq living conditions survey 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"global policy forum\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3003, "completion_tokens": 1394, "total_tokens": 4397, "reasoning_tokens": 1167 }, "cost_usd": 0.003277055, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987714Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "This is a secondary NGO compilation that summarizes named mortality studies and news reports, but it is not peer-reviewed, not primary research, and reflects an advocacy-oriented publisher.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "first lancet mortality study 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "undp iraq living conditions survey 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "global policy forum" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a secondary NGO compilation that summarizes named mortality studies and news reports, but it is not peer-reviewed, not primary research, and reflects an advocacy-oriented publisher.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides background on Iraqi mortality estimates up to mid-2006 but does not report on or test the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline in civilian deaths and attacks.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\":0,\\\"strength\\\":0,\\\"basis\\\":\\\"assertion\\\",\\\"rationale\\\":\\\"The excerpt contains general claims about high mortality and specific 2008 incidents, but no data or statement comparing civilian deaths and attacks between mid-2007 and mid-2008 with 2006 or early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"second lancet mortality study 2006\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"first lancet mortality study 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"undp iraq living conditions survey 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"global policy forum\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 868, "completion_tokens": 1153, "total_tokens": 2021, "reasoning_tokens": 1087 }, "cost_usd": 0.001644, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987714Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a peer-reviewed article in International Security, published via the Belfer Center, based on declassified local-level violence data and seventy structured interviews with coalition participants. Its methodology and sourcing meet the standard of a peer-reviewed study with primary evidence.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a peer-reviewed article in International Security, published via the Belfer Center, based on declassified local-level violence data and seventy structured interviews with coalition participants. Its methodology and sourcing meet the standard of a peer-reviewed study with primary evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document explicitly tests the competing hypotheses that the surge (troop reinforcements plus doctrinal change) versus the Sunni Awakening and sectarian cleansing caused the 2007 violence decline, which is precisely the proposition under test.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The study, based on declassified local violence data and seventy structured interviews, concludes that the surge and the Awakening were each necessary but neither sufficient, which directly supports the claim that the troop increase and tactical change contributed beyond what the Awakening (or cleansing) alone would have produced.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"sigacts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2579, "completion_tokens": 2656, "total_tokens": 5235, "reasoning_tokens": 2417 }, "cost_usd": 0.010287059999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987800Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary, collaboratively edited encyclopedia that relays other sources rather than presenting primary records or peer-reviewed analysis; it has editorial standards but no named author or formal peer review, and the excerpt provides only general narrative with limited visible sourcing.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary, collaboratively edited encyclopedia that relays other sources rather than presenting primary records or peer-reviewed analysis; it has editorial standards but no named author or formal peer review, and the excerpt provides only general narrative with limited visible sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides broad Iraq War background and mentions the 2007 troop surge stabilizing parts of Iraq, but it does not report on civilian deaths or attacks or the specific mid-2007 to mid-2008 decline from 2006/early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt mentions the 2007 troop surge helped stabilize parts of Iraq but does not address civilian deaths or attacks falling between mid-2007 and mid-2008 from 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2974, "completion_tokens": 1150, "total_tokens": 4124, "reasoning_tokens": 956 }, "cost_usd": 0.00266686, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987873Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary, collaboratively edited encyclopedia that relays other sources rather than presenting primary records or peer-reviewed analysis; it has editorial standards but no named author or formal peer review, and the excerpt provides only general narrative with limited visible sourcing.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary, collaboratively edited encyclopedia that relays other sources rather than presenting primary records or peer-reviewed analysis; it has editorial standards but no named author or formal peer review, and the excerpt provides only general narrative with limited visible sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document only broadly states that the 2007 troop surge helped stabilize parts of Iraq, without addressing the specific counterfactual comparison to the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.2, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt only states generally that the 2007 troop surge 'helped stabilize parts of the country,' which weakly supports the surge's effect but does not address the 2007-2008 violence decline or the counterfactual role of the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, and sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3034, "completion_tokens": 1262, "total_tokens": 4296, "reasoning_tokens": 1060 }, "cost_usd": 0.002887435, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987927Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Official U.S. military news service citing a named senior commander and specific operational statistics, but it is a self-interested government press account rather than independent or peer-reviewed analysis.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "american forces press service" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "col jb burton 2nd brigade combat team 1st infantry division" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official U.S. military news service citing a named senior commander and specific operational statistics, but it is a self-interested government press account rather than independent or peer-reviewed analysis.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports an early 2007 tactical change and local violence decline in northwestern Baghdad, which is adjacent to but does not directly test the broader causal claim about the 2007-2008 national decline beyond the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, and sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.4, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports localized violence declines and a commander's direct attribution of them to moving troops into community outposts and joint security stations, supporting the troop/tactics causal claim, but it covers only one Baghdad area in early 2007 and does not isolate that effect from the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"american forces press service\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"col jb burton 2nd brigade combat team 1st infantry division\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2948, "completion_tokens": 1774, "total_tokens": 4722, "reasoning_tokens": 1487 }, "cost_usd": 0.003544485, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.987982Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "GlobalSecurity.org is a reputable aggregator that cites official primary sources such as MNF-I SIGACTS, DOD, and UN reports, but it is a secondary compilation without peer review or independent verification. Its sourcing is strong for a non-academic website, though it remains one step removed from the underlying records.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "mnf i significant activity reports" }, { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, { "type": "study", "id": "un april 2008 report" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"GlobalSecurity.org is a reputable aggregator that cites official primary sources such as MNF-I SIGACTS, DOD, and UN reports, but it is a secondary compilation without peer review or independent verification. Its sourcing is strong for a non-academic website, though it remains one step removed from the underlying records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports a substantial decline in enemy-initiated attacks from mid-2007 into 2008 relative to 2006 and early 2007, but it does not specifically report civilian deaths, so it only partly covers the exact sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports measured enemy-initiated attack data showing a roughly 70% decline from June 2007 to February 2008 versus 2006 and early 2007, supporting the attacks component but not addressing civilian deaths or the full mid-2008 endpoint.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"mnf i significant activity reports\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"dod march 2008 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un april 2008 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3088, "completion_tokens": 2566, "total_tokens": 5654, "reasoning_tokens": 2315 }, "cost_usd": 0.007806535, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988043Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "GlobalSecurity.org is a reputable aggregator that cites official primary sources such as MNF-I SIGACTS, DOD, and UN reports, but it is a secondary compilation without peer review or independent verification. Its sourcing is strong for a non-academic website, though it remains one step removed from the underlying records.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "mnf i significant activity reports" }, { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, { "type": "study", "id": "un april 2008 report" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"GlobalSecurity.org is a reputable aggregator that cites official primary sources such as MNF-I SIGACTS, DOD, and UN reports, but it is a secondary compilation without peer review or independent verification. Its sourcing is strong for a non-academic website, though it remains one step removed from the underlying records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports a substantial decline in enemy-initiated attacks from mid-2007 into 2008 relative to 2006 and early 2007, but it does not specifically report civilian deaths, so it only partly covers the exact sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports SIGACTS data showing enemy-initiated attacks fell about 70% from June 2007 to February 2008 and remained far below June 2007 levels in March 2008, directly contradicting the sub-claim that attacks did not fall substantially, though it does not address civilian deaths.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"mnf i significant activity reports\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"dod march 2008 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un april 2008 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 864, "completion_tokens": 2485, "total_tokens": 3349, "reasoning_tokens": 2392 }, "cost_usd": 0.0032412, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988043Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Human Rights Watch is a reputable human rights organization with editorial standards and uses official figures and named sources, but this World Report chapter is an advocacy-oriented secondary compilation rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary record.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "human rights watch" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unhcr iom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us military" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi government" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Human Rights Watch is a reputable human rights organization with editorial standards and uses official figures and named sources, but this World Report chapter is an advocacy-oriented secondary compilation rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document broadly notes 2008 security gains in Iraq but does not report on civilian deaths or attacks or compare mid-2007 to mid-2008 with 2006 and early-2007 levels.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt mentions 'security gains in 2008' but provides no data or direct statement on civilian deaths or attacks, so it does not address the specific sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"human rights watch\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unhcr iom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us military\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi government\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2904, "completion_tokens": 4327, "total_tokens": 7231, "reasoning_tokens": 4405 }, "cost_usd": 0.012403850000000001, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988129Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a report from the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a well-established and reputable policy research institution, and it functions as an official inquiry/primary document analyzing contemporaneous military posture and violence data. It draws on named military officials and operational records, though it is not peer-reviewed and may reflect institutional policy perspectives.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a report from the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a well-established and reputable policy research institution, and it functions as an official inquiry/primary document analyzing contemporaneous military posture and violence data. It draws on named military officials and operational records, though it is not peer-reviewed and may reflect institutional policy perspectives.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document examines the immediate impact of the 2007 troop surge on violence in Iraq but does not address the counterfactual of whether the surge caused the 2007-2008 decline beyond other factors like the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.2, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt asserts that the US troop buildup and changed posture damaged insurgents and improved security in Anbar and Baghdad, weakly supporting the surge's causal role, but it does not isolate that effect from the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"csis\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2900, "completion_tokens": 4825, "total_tokens": 7725, "reasoning_tokens": 4560 }, "cost_usd": 0.0068380458, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988186Z" }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "This is a report from the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a well-established and reputable policy research institution, and it functions as an official inquiry/primary document analyzing contemporaneous military posture and violence data. It draws on named military officials and operational records, though it is not peer-reviewed and may reflect institutional policy perspectives.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"This is a report from the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a well-established and reputable policy research institution, and it functions as an official inquiry/primary document analyzing contemporaneous military posture and violence data. It draws on named military officials and operational records, though it is not peer-reviewed and may reflect institutional policy perspectives.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document examines the immediate impact of the 2007 troop surge on violence in Iraq but does not address the counterfactual of whether the surge caused the 2007-2008 decline beyond other factors like the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.5, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document credits the US troop buildup and accompanying operations with reducing violence and improving security in Anbar and Baghdad, implying the surge was a major cause, which contradicts the sub-claim that it was not.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"csis\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 863, "completion_tokens": 933, "total_tokens": 1796, "reasoning_tokens": 1053 }, "cost_usd": 0.0013785, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988186Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count compiles a transparent, incident-level database from media and official reports rather than estimates or advocacy; the 2008 analysis draws directly on that primary-sourced archive with explicit methodology notes, though the organization itself is the publisher and the work is not peer-reviewed.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Iraq Body Count compiles a transparent, incident-level database from media and official reports rather than estimates or advocacy; the 2008 analysis draws directly on that primary-sourced archive with explicit methodology notes, though the organization itself is the publisher and the work is not peer-reviewed.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly reports annual civilian death totals and per-day rates showing a substantial drop in 2008 versus 2006-2007, framed explicitly around post-surge trends, but uses yearly aggregates rather than the precise mid-2007 to mid-2008 window and omits attacks.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Annual documented death counts show a drop from 72/day in 2007 (and 81/day in 2006) to 25/day in 2008, directly supporting a substantial post-surge decline in civilian deaths.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3684, "completion_tokens": 5178, "total_tokens": 8862, "reasoning_tokens": 4944 }, "cost_usd": 0.017971598, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988272Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count aggregates incident-level reports primarily from media and official records (including WikiLeaks logs) with transparent methodology, database entries, and source notes, but remains a secondary compilation by an NGO rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Iraq Body Count aggregates incident-level reports primarily from media and official records (including WikiLeaks logs) with transparent methodology, database entries, and source notes, but remains a secondary compilation by an NGO rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Provides monthly civilian death totals and graphs spanning 2003-2017, directly enabling comparison of the specified periods though silent on attacks.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt references a monthly deaths graph from 2003 onward but supplies no data, values, or description of trends for 2006–mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2937, "completion_tokens": 1807, "total_tokens": 4744, "reasoning_tokens": 1622 }, "cost_usd": 0.00728103, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988328Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "CJR is a reputable journalism-review publisher with editorial standards, but the piece is secondary analysis that relays and critiques findings from other organizations (IBC, PSR) without primary data or official records on 2006-2008 violence.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "psr study 2015" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "lexisnexis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CJR is a reputable journalism-review publisher with editorial standards, but the piece is secondary analysis that relays and critiques findings from other organizations (IBC, PSR) without primary data or official records on 2006-2008 violence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses overall Iraqi death toll estimates since 2003 and media reliance on Iraq Body Count but contains no data or discussion of casualty trends in 2006-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses total Iraqi death toll estimates since 2003 and counting methodologies but makes no reference to casualty trends or changes in 2006-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"psr study 2015\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lexisnexis\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3450, "completion_tokens": 4624, "total_tokens": 8074, "reasoning_tokens": 4413 }, "cost_usd": 0.02074324, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988385Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary encyclopedia that aggregates secondary sources with inline citations to official statements and reports, but lacks primary data collection, peer review, or official status; its editorial model introduces variable reliability and potential for synthesis bias.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "national intelligence estimate 2007" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "unhcr iraqi government 2006" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "un secretary general 2006" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary encyclopedia that aggregates secondary sources with inline citations to official statements and reports, but lacks primary data collection, peer review, or official status; its editorial model introduces variable reliability and potential for synthesis bias.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt directly notes the 2007-2008 violence decline occurring during both the U.S. troop surge and Sunni Awakening but does not isolate or test the surge's incremental causal contribution beyond Awakening, ceasefire, or displacement.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt notes the decline occurred during both the surge and Awakening but does not isolate surge effects beyond Awakening, ceasefire, or displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"national intelligence estimate 2007\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"unhcr iraqi government 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un secretary general 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"george w bush 2007\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3852, "completion_tokens": 4160, "total_tokens": 8012, "reasoning_tokens": 3924 }, "cost_usd": 0.0154702394, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988439Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Academic journal article from Princeton University with ASJC codes indicating peer-reviewed status in political science; provides analysis based on named sources rather than primary records alone.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "mnfi sigacts iii" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Academic journal article from Princeton University with ASJC codes indicating peer-reviewed status in political science; provides analysis based on named sources rather than primary records alone.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document's title directly names and frames an empirical test of the precise causal question in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt contains only bibliographic metadata with no content addressing causes of the violence decline.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"mnfi sigacts iii\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2425, "completion_tokens": 5406, "total_tokens": 7831, "reasoning_tokens": 5247 }, "cost_usd": 0.0174996494, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988518Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Secondary summary on a reputable military history museum site with no citations, named primary sources, data, or methodological detail; reads as popular historical overview rather than sourced analysis or official record.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "pritzkermilitary org" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Secondary summary on a reputable military history museum site with no citations, named primary sources, data, or methodological detail; reads as popular historical overview rather than sourced analysis or official record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document lists the Surge as one of four joint reasons for the 2007 violence drop (alongside Awakening and Sadrist ceasefire) but does not isolate or test its incremental effect beyond those other factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document lists surge among four joint reasons for the decline without addressing whether its contribution was independent of or beyond the Awakening and ceasefire.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"pritzkermilitary.org\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3599, "completion_tokens": 2042, "total_tokens": 5641, "reasoning_tokens": 1854 }, "cost_usd": 0.00861364, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988571Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "CRS report compiling named official Iraqi ministry and US DOD data with congressional editorial standards; nonpartisan government research service, no conflicts.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi ministries data" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of defense data" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CRS report compiling named official Iraqi ministry and US DOD data with congressional editorial standards; nonpartisan government research service, no conflicts.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The CRS report directly compiles and graphs official monthly Iraqi civilian death statistics from Jan 2006 through May 2009, covering the exact intervals named in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt lists report figures on civilian deaths 2006-2009 but provides no data, trends, or statements on any decline between 2006-early 2007 and mid-2007-mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraqi ministries data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of defense data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"brookings iraq index\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3413, "completion_tokens": 7462, "total_tokens": 10875, "reasoning_tokens": 7246 }, "cost_usd": 0.024636153600000002, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988626Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "CRS report compiling named official Iraqi ministry and US DOD data with congressional editorial standards; nonpartisan government research service, no conflicts.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi ministries data" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of defense data" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CRS report compiling named official Iraqi ministry and US DOD data with congressional editorial standards; nonpartisan government research service, no conflicts.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The CRS report directly compiles and graphs official monthly Iraqi civilian death statistics from Jan 2006 through May 2009, covering the exact intervals named in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt describes report structure and data sources but provides no specific casualty figures or trend descriptions for 2006-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraqi ministries data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of defense data\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"brookings iraq index\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 966, "completion_tokens": 590, "total_tokens": 1556, "reasoning_tokens": 542 }, "cost_usd": 0.0024809, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988626Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.4, "quality_rationale": "Secondary interpretive essay on Small Wars Journal archive with footnote citations to unnamed sources; not primary data, official records, or peer-reviewed, and publisher accepts varied analyst submissions without strict editorial vetting for original evidence.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "small wars journal 2013" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Secondary interpretive essay on Small Wars Journal archive with footnote citations to unnamed sources; not primary data, official records, or peer-reviewed, and publisher accepts varied analyst submissions without strict editorial vetting for original evidence.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document's title, abstract, and stated thesis directly evaluate the relative causal contribution of the 2007 surge versus the listed local factors (Sunni cooperation/Anbar Awakening, Mahdi Army ceasefire, and sectarian civil-war outcome) in producing the observed violence decline.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt explicitly argues that the surge alone is insufficient and that Sunni cooperation, Mahdi Army ceasefire, and Shiite victory were factors of equal importance that interacted with it, directly undercutting any claim that the troop increase was a major cause beyond those elements.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"small wars journal 2013\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3725, "completion_tokens": 1908, "total_tokens": 5633, "reasoning_tokens": 1683 }, "cost_usd": 0.00841385, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988706Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary encyclopedia relying on community editing and citations to other sources rather than primary records or peer review; the publisher has no formal editorial standards equivalent to academic or official inquiries.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "author_group", "id": "us marine corps history division" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "icasualties" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us marine corps intelligence report 2006" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary encyclopedia relying on community editing and citations to other sources rather than primary records or peer review; the publisher has no formal editorial standards equivalent to academic or official inquiries.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document covers Anbar Awakening and pre-surge conditions in one province but does not address the 2007 surge, nationwide violence decline, or comparisons to other factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document discusses Anbar Awakening origins in 2006 but does not address 2007 surge, violence decline, or their relative contributions.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"author_group\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us marine corps history division\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"icasualties\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us marine corps intelligence report 2006\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3782, "completion_tokens": 5782, "total_tokens": 9564, "reasoning_tokens": 5573 }, "cost_usd": 0.021929874, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988762Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia relying on citations to other sources rather than primary records or original analysis; it lacks peer review or official status and is produced by an open-editing model with variable editorial standards.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush address to the nation january 10 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "white house fact sheet the new way forward in iraq" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bob woodward the war within 2008" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "hillary clinton and barack obama statements on surge" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia relying on citations to other sources rather than primary records or original analysis; it lacks peer review or official status and is produced by an open-editing model with variable editorial standards.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes the 2007 surge's announcement, troop increases, and tactical shift but contains no discussion of violence trends, their causes, or comparisons to the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes the surge plan and announcement but does not address violence trends, their causes, or comparisons to other factors like the Anbar Awakening.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"george w bush address to the nation january 10 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"white house fact sheet the new way forward in iraq\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"bob woodward the war within 2008\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"hillary clinton and barack obama statements on surge\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3617, "completion_tokens": 8906, "total_tokens": 12523, "reasoning_tokens": 9291 }, "cost_usd": 0.03678198, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988834Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Academic report by Boston University professor for Brown University's Costs of War project; compiles secondary tallies from government/press reports and IBC rather than presenting primary data or undergoing formal peer review.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Academic report by Boston University professor for Brown University's Costs of War project; compiles secondary tallies from government/press reports and IBC rather than presenting primary data or undergoing formal peer review.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides an overview of aggregate civilian deaths and injuries across the entire 2003-2013 Iraq war period but does not address or break out trends for the specific 2006-2008 interval.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt gives overall totals and notes ongoing violence but provides no data or claims about changes in civilian deaths or attacks during 2006-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3707, "completion_tokens": 5697, "total_tokens": 9404, "reasoning_tokens": 5515 }, "cost_usd": 0.019451187999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988923Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Academic report by Boston University professor for Brown University's Costs of War project; compiles secondary tallies from government/press reports and IBC rather than presenting primary data or undergoing formal peer review.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Academic report by Boston University professor for Brown University's Costs of War project; compiles secondary tallies from government/press reports and IBC rather than presenting primary data or undergoing formal peer review.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document provides an overview of aggregate civilian deaths and injuries across the entire 2003-2013 Iraq war period but does not address or break out trends for the specific 2006-2008 interval.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses overall totals and ongoing violence but provides no data or statements on trends specifically between 2006-early 2007 and mid-2007-mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1071, "completion_tokens": 411, "total_tokens": 1482, "reasoning_tokens": 351 }, "cost_usd": 0.00216465, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988923Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.8, "quality_rationale": "CRS report published via congress.gov; compiles and cites named governmental/non-governmental estimates with explicit methodology caveats, produced under congressional nonpartisan editorial standards with no evident conflicts.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "congressional research service" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CRS report published via congress.gov; compiles and cites named governmental/non-governmental estimates with explicit methodology caveats, produced under congressional nonpartisan editorial standards with no evident conflicts.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document provides time-series estimates and a figure of Iraqi civilian deaths spanning Jan 2006–Aug 2008, directly covering the periods referenced in the sub-claim (though silent on attacks).\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt presents estimates and a figure covering 2006-2008 but states no specific trend or data on deaths falling after mid-2007.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"congressional research service\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3152, "completion_tokens": 1945, "total_tokens": 5097, "reasoning_tokens": 1755 }, "cost_usd": 0.008095304, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.988999Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "TIME article is ordinary journalism that relays and quotes findings from the secondary aggregator Iraq Body Count without presenting primary data or official records itself.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "associated press" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"TIME article is ordinary journalism that relays and quotes findings from the secondary aggregator Iraq Body Count without presenting primary data or official records itself.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document reports annual civilian death totals showing a sharp drop in 2008 versus 2006-2007, which overlaps substantially with the specified mid-2007 to mid-2008 interval but lacks the exact sub-period granularity.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document cites IBC's incident tallies showing civilian deaths dropping from >25k in 2006 and >22k in 2007 to ~8-9k in 2008, directly supporting a substantial decline though using annual rather than mid-2007/mid-2008 windows.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"associated press\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3680, "completion_tokens": 2712, "total_tokens": 6392, "reasoning_tokens": 2488 }, "cost_usd": 0.0122202, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989057Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Peer-reviewed study in PLOS Medicine using transparent methods on the Iraq Body Count database of media-sourced incidents; provides named perpetrator categories, temporal and geographic breakdowns, and statistical analysis rather than primary records or official inquiries.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Peer-reviewed study in PLOS Medicine using transparent methods on the Iraq Body Count database of media-sourced incidents; provides named perpetrator categories, temporal and geographic breakdowns, and statistical analysis rather than primary records or official inquiries.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The paper directly analyzes and reports Iraqi civilian violent deaths over time from 2003–2008 (including 2006–mid-2008), by perpetrator and other factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Excerpt covers 2003-2008 data and notes invasion-peak timing for some categories but supplies no findings on overall civilian death trends from 2006 through mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3482, "completion_tokens": 1550, "total_tokens": 5032, "reasoning_tokens": 1359 }, "cost_usd": 0.00724223, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989114Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Peer-reviewed study in PLOS Medicine using transparent methods on the Iraq Body Count database of media-sourced incidents; provides named perpetrator categories, temporal and geographic breakdowns, and statistical analysis rather than primary records or official inquiries.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Peer-reviewed study in PLOS Medicine using transparent methods on the Iraq Body Count database of media-sourced incidents; provides named perpetrator categories, temporal and geographic breakdowns, and statistical analysis rather than primary records or official inquiries.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The paper directly analyzes and reports Iraqi civilian violent deaths over time from 2003–2008 (including 2006–mid-2008), by perpetrator and other factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided excerpt contains no data or statements on civilian death trends specifically between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1038, "completion_tokens": 702, "total_tokens": 1740, "reasoning_tokens": 654 }, "cost_usd": 0.0028509, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989114Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official DoD report to Congress mandated by statute (Section 9010, PL 109-289), drawing on primary government and military data sources; hosted by globalsecurity.org but originating as an authoritative primary document rather than secondary journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense report to congress june 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official DoD report to Congress mandated by statute (Section 9010, PL 109-289), drawing on primary government and military data sources; hosted by globalsecurity.org but originating as an authoritative primary document rather than secondary journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document describes the 2007 troop increase and Baghdad security tactics at the time of their launch but does not address later violence trends or isolate their causal contribution beyond other factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document from June 2007 describes the intent and launch of the troop surge but reports no outcomes on violence levels or their causes.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"department of defense report to congress june 2007\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3492, "completion_tokens": 1723, "total_tokens": 5215, "reasoning_tokens": 1521 }, "cost_usd": 0.00769844, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989197Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "CFR backgrounder is reputable secondary analysis that directly cites named primary sources including Gen. Petraeus congressional testimony and U.S. military violence statistics; it is not itself a primary record or peer-reviewed study.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "us military iraq violence statistics" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "gen david petraeus testimony september 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CFR backgrounder is reputable secondary analysis that directly cites named primary sources including Gen. Petraeus congressional testimony and U.S. military violence statistics; it is not itself a primary record or peer-reviewed study.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports civilian death declines only through August 2007 and thus covers only the initial segment of the claimed 2007-2008 interval.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports declines only through August 2007 and provides no data on mid-2008 levels or changes after mid-2007.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"us military iraq violence statistics\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"gen david petraeus testimony september 2007\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3346, "completion_tokens": 3050, "total_tokens": 6396, "reasoning_tokens": 2837 }, "cost_usd": 0.0126195, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989251Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia article is a secondary/tertiary summary relaying findings from the cited Lancet studies and other reports; crowd-edited with editorial standards but not peer-reviewed or a primary record.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia article is a secondary/tertiary summary relaying findings from the cited Lancet studies and other reports; crowd-edited with editorial standards but not peer-reviewed or a primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports only on mortality estimates through mid-2006 and contains no data or discussion of trends after that date.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 0,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document covers only mortality estimates through mid-2006 and contains no data or statements on 2007-2008 trends.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3802, "completion_tokens": 1593, "total_tokens": 5395, "reasoning_tokens": 1388 }, "cost_usd": 0.00772468, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989310Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia article is a secondary/tertiary summary relaying findings from the cited Lancet studies and other reports; crowd-edited with editorial standards but not peer-reviewed or a primary record.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia article is a secondary/tertiary summary relaying findings from the cited Lancet studies and other reports; crowd-edited with editorial standards but not peer-reviewed or a primary record.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports only on mortality estimates through mid-2006 and contains no data or discussion of trends after that date.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document covers only mortality estimates through mid-2006 with no data or claims on 2007-2008 trends.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1117, "completion_tokens": 420, "total_tokens": 1537, "reasoning_tokens": 372 }, "cost_usd": 0.00224465, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989310Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Iraq Body Count is a long-running specialized NGO project with transparent, documented methodology that aggregates named incident reports from media and official records (including WikiLeaks logs); it is not a primary record, peer-reviewed study, or official inquiry.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq war logs wikileaks" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Iraq Body Count is a long-running specialized NGO project with transparent, documented methodology that aggregates named incident reports from media and official records (including WikiLeaks logs); it is not a primary record, peer-reviewed study, or official inquiry.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports only aggregate civilian death totals for 2003-2013 with no yearly or monthly breakdowns, no reference to 2006-2008, and no discussion of changes in violence levels during that interval.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt provides only aggregate civilian death totals for 2003-2013 with no yearly breakdowns or data on 2006-2008 trends.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq war logs wikileaks\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3499, "completion_tokens": 1665, "total_tokens": 5164, "reasoning_tokens": 1450 }, "cost_usd": 0.00728716, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989397Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official U.S. Department of State country report citing named primary sources (MNF-I statistics, ISF/MOD/MOI records) with transparent methodology and government editorial standards; no peer review but qualifies as high-quality official inquiry rather than journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "multinational force iraq" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "international mission for iraqi elections" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us department of state" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official U.S. Department of State country report citing named primary sources (MNF-I statistics, ISF/MOD/MOI records) with transparent methodology and government editorial standards; no peer review but qualifies as high-quality official inquiry rather than journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document directly reports 72% drop in civilian deaths for 2008 vs. prior year plus security improvement since second half of 2007, addressing the claimed reduction but via annual rather than mid-year comparisons.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.8,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt directly reports MNF-I data showing a 72% drop in civilian deaths from violence in 2008 vs. 2007, with overall violence at its lowest since 2004 after substantial improvement beginning in the second half of 2007.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"multinational force iraq\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"international mission for iraqi elections\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"us department of state\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3581, "completion_tokens": 3817, "total_tokens": 7398, "reasoning_tokens": 3563 }, "cost_usd": 0.014093924, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989453Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Official DoD quarterly report to Congress under statutory mandate (Section 9010, PL 109-289), drawing on government-collected security data and metrics; globalsecurity.org is merely the republisher of this primary government document.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official DoD quarterly report to Congress under statutory mandate (Section 9010, PL 109-289), drawing on government-collected security data and metrics; globalsecurity.org is merely the republisher of this primary government document.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Dec 2007 DoD report notes significant security progress in Iraq during Sep-Nov 2007 but does not report or test civilian deaths/attacks trends across the full mid-2007 to mid-2008 window specified in the sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.4,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Dec 2007 DoD report asserts significant security progress in Iraq during Sep-Nov 2007 (and since the prior Sep 2007 report) without providing data on civilian deaths or attacks or covering mid-2008.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"department of defense\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3308, "completion_tokens": 1876, "total_tokens": 5184, "reasoning_tokens": 1642 }, "cost_usd": 0.00810832, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989525Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary encyclopedia entry with editorial standards and citations but no peer review or original data collection; it relays descriptions of the IBC project's media-based methods rather than providing primary records.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "jonathan steele guardian" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary encyclopedia entry with editorial standards and citations but no peer review or original data collection; it relays descriptions of the IBC project's media-based methods rather than providing primary records.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt describes the Iraq Body Count project and its general methodology but contains no data or discussion of civilian death trends in 2006-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt discusses IBC methodology and totals but provides no data or statements on death trends in 2006-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraq body count database\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"jonathan steele guardian\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3291, "completion_tokens": 3148, "total_tokens": 6439, "reasoning_tokens": 2948 }, "cost_usd": 0.01365471, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989582Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "The Guardian is a reputable outlet with editorial standards and named authors, but this is secondary journalism relaying survey findings (Lancet, ORB, WHO) rather than primary records; a published correction confirms multiple factual errors in describing those sources.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "who iraqi health ministry survey 2008" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006 iraq mortality survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "orb iraq mortality survey 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The Guardian is a reputable outlet with editorial standards and named authors, but this is secondary journalism relaying survey findings (Lancet, ORB, WHO) rather than primary records; a published correction confirms multiple factual errors in describing those sources.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document discusses overall Iraqi death toll estimates and US counting policy but provides no data or analysis on 2007-2008 trends.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document discusses pre-2008 death toll estimates and US policy but provides no data or claims on changes between mid-2007 and mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"who iraqi health ministry survey 2008\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"lancet iraq mortality survey 2006\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"orb iraq mortality survey 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us department of defense\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3379, "completion_tokens": 2795, "total_tokens": 6174, "reasoning_tokens": 2551 }, "cost_usd": 0.012467309999999999, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989636Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia relying on user-edited aggregation of cited references rather than original primary records or peer review; the Wikimedia Foundation has transparent editorial policies but no specialized track record on conflict data.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a secondary/tertiary encyclopedia relying on user-edited aggregation of cited references rather than original primary records or peer review; the Wikimedia Foundation has transparent editorial policies but no specialized track record on conflict data.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document states that sectarian violence and civil war ended in mid-2008 after being quelled by the 2007 troop surge, directly addressing the timing and reduction of attacks/violence in the specified window.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt states that sectarian violence and civil war ended in mid-2008 after being quelled by the 2007 surge, implying a substantial drop from 2006-early 2007 peaks.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3505, "completion_tokens": 1732, "total_tokens": 5237, "reasoning_tokens": 1532 }, "cost_usd": 0.00818772, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989691Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Internet Archive serves as a reliable repository for the 2008 Hannah Fischer report (likely CRS), which draws on named official records and primary data sources rather than original journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq ministry of health" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Internet Archive serves as a reliable repository for the 2008 Hannah Fischer report (likely CRS), which draws on named official records and primary data sources rather than original journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided excerpt consists solely of an Internet Archive donation appeal and contains no information on Iraqi deaths or violence trends.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt contains only a donation appeal and no data or statements on Iraqi deaths or attacks.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey 2008\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq ministry of health\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2417, "completion_tokens": 7757, "total_tokens": 10174, "reasoning_tokens": 7565 }, "cost_usd": 0.029717729999999998, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989748Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Internet Archive serves as a reliable repository for the 2008 Hannah Fischer report (likely CRS), which draws on named official records and primary data sources rather than original journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq ministry of health" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Internet Archive serves as a reliable repository for the 2008 Hannah Fischer report (likely CRS), which draws on named official records and primary data sources rather than original journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The provided excerpt consists solely of an Internet Archive donation appeal and contains no information on Iraqi deaths or violence trends.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt contains no content on Iraqi deaths or attacks.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq body count\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey 2008\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq ministry of health\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 750, "completion_tokens": 452, "total_tokens": 1202, "reasoning_tokens": 417 }, "cost_usd": 0.0018659, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989748Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Peer-reviewed academic journal article (Journal of Military and Strategic Studies, DOI-assigned) that directly analyzes primary SIGACT military records rather than secondary reporting; publisher maintains standard scholarly editorial standards with no evident conflicts of interest.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Peer-reviewed academic journal article (Journal of Military and Strategic Studies, DOI-assigned) that directly analyzes primary SIGACT military records rather than secondary reporting; publisher maintains standard scholarly editorial standards with no evident conflicts of interest.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document directly examines whether the surge caused the observed decline or whether prior factors (Anbar Awakening and similar) explain it, but focuses on pre-surge timing rather than isolating the surge's marginal effect after those factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt states that SIGACT data show violence peaked before the surge, with other factors driving the pre-surge decline, rendering the surge unnecessary.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"sigact\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 2587, "completion_tokens": 1964, "total_tokens": 4551, "reasoning_tokens": 1818 }, "cost_usd": 0.0080111, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989830Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Peer-reviewed academic journal article (Journal of Military and Strategic Studies, DOI-assigned) that directly analyzes primary SIGACT military records rather than secondary reporting; publisher maintains standard scholarly editorial standards with no evident conflicts of interest.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Peer-reviewed academic journal article (Journal of Military and Strategic Studies, DOI-assigned) that directly analyzes primary SIGACT military records rather than secondary reporting; publisher maintains standard scholarly editorial standards with no evident conflicts of interest.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document directly examines whether the surge caused the observed decline or whether prior factors (Anbar Awakening and similar) explain it, but focuses on pre-surge timing rather than isolating the surge's marginal effect after those factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document states SIGACT data shows violence peaked before surge, attributes earlier decline to other factors, and concludes surge was unnecessary.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"sigact\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 827, "completion_tokens": 365, "total_tokens": 1192, "reasoning_tokens": 315 }, "cost_usd": 0.00174465, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989830Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia article is a secondary encyclopedia entry that summarizes and quotes an official 2007 congressional report with inline citations, but relies on editorial community standards rather than primary data collection, peer review, or official authorship.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia article is a secondary encyclopedia entry that summarizes and quotes an official 2007 congressional report with inline citations, but relies on editorial community standards rather than primary data collection, peer review, or official authorship.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document is the 2007 Petraeus Report that directly attributes measured declines in violence to the surge and its tactics, but does not address or isolate effects beyond the listed alternative factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt reports Petraeus attributing violence declines to surge operations but does not mention or compare against Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire or sectarian displacement, so neither supports nor contradicts the full sub-claim.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3488, "completion_tokens": 3276, "total_tokens": 6764, "reasoning_tokens": 3078 }, "cost_usd": 0.012424018, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989909Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a tertiary encyclopedia aggregating secondary summaries of other studies and reports rather than conducting original research or presenting primary records; it cites named sources but relies on volunteer editing with variable enforcement of standards and no peer review.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "iraq family health survey" }, { "type": "study", "id": "opinion research business survey 2007" }, { "type": "study", "id": "plos medicine 2013" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a tertiary encyclopedia aggregating secondary summaries of other studies and reports rather than conducting original research or presenting primary records; it cites named sources but relies on volunteer editing with variable enforcement of standards and no peer review.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document compiles broad Iraq casualty estimates and tables spanning multiple years but does not report or test the specific 2007-2008 decline in civilian deaths and attacks.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt lists broad casualty estimates with various end dates but provides no data or statements on trends specifically between mid-2007 and mid-2008 versus 2006/early 2007.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"lancet study 2006\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"iraq family health survey\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"opinion research business survey 2007\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"plos medicine 2013\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3700, "completion_tokens": 4811, "total_tokens": 8511, "reasoning_tokens": 4580 }, "cost_usd": 0.01750741, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.989966Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Peer-reviewed article in International Security (Belfer Center/Harvard) drawing on declassified local violence data and 70 structured interviews with participants; reputable editorial standards and primary-source methods for the topic.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "declassified iraq violence data 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Peer-reviewed article in International Security (Belfer Center/Harvard) drawing on declassified local violence data and 70 structured interviews with participants; reputable editorial standards and primary-source methods for the topic.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly analyzes whether the 2007 surge was necessary for the violence decline beyond the Anbar Awakening and sectarian burnout alone, using local violence data and interviews to test the exact causal proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document states surge was necessary beyond Awakening or sectarian burnout, based on declassified local violence data and 70 interviews showing synergy was required to reduce violence.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"declassified iraq violence data 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3612, "completion_tokens": 2874, "total_tokens": 6486, "reasoning_tokens": 2667 }, "cost_usd": 0.01373552, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990024Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Peer-reviewed article in International Security (Belfer Center/Harvard) drawing on declassified local violence data and 70 structured interviews with participants; reputable editorial standards and primary-source methods for the topic.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "declassified iraq violence data 2007" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Peer-reviewed article in International Security (Belfer Center/Harvard) drawing on declassified local violence data and 70 structured interviews with participants; reputable editorial standards and primary-source methods for the topic.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly analyzes whether the 2007 surge was necessary for the violence decline beyond the Anbar Awakening and sectarian burnout alone, using local violence data and interviews to test the exact causal proposition.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document uses declassified local violence data and interviews to conclude surge was necessary beyond Awakening or sectarian burnout, as violence would otherwise have remained high.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"dataset\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"declassified iraq violence data 2007\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1058, "completion_tokens": 465, "total_tokens": 1523, "reasoning_tokens": 411 }, "cost_usd": 0.0022834, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990024Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Secondary compilation by an NGO policy site that summarizes and links named external studies (Lancet, UNDP) without conducting original data collection or peer review; ordinary sourcing standards but no primary records or official inquiry status.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "first lancet mortality study 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "undp iraq living conditions survey 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "global policy forum" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Secondary compilation by an NGO policy site that summarizes and links named external studies (Lancet, UNDP) without conducting original data collection or peer review; ordinary sourcing standards but no primary records or official inquiry status.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document published in 2006 reports only on mortality data through mid-2006 and contains no information on 2007-2008 trends.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document covers mortality only through mid-2006 with no data or discussion of 2007-2008 trends.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"second lancet mortality study 2006\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"first lancet mortality study 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"undp iraq living conditions survey 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"global policy forum\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3470, "completion_tokens": 1808, "total_tokens": 5278, "reasoning_tokens": 1554 }, "cost_usd": 0.00791353, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990108Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Secondary compilation by an NGO policy site that summarizes and links named external studies (Lancet, UNDP) without conducting original data collection or peer review; ordinary sourcing standards but no primary records or official inquiry status.", "directness": 0.0, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, { "type": "study", "id": "first lancet mortality study 2004" }, { "type": "study", "id": "undp iraq living conditions survey 2004" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "global policy forum" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Secondary compilation by an NGO policy site that summarizes and links named external studies (Lancet, UNDP) without conducting original data collection or peer review; ordinary sourcing standards but no primary records or official inquiry status.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document published in 2006 reports only on mortality data through mid-2006 and contains no information on 2007-2008 trends.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document published Oct 2006 contains only pre-2007 mortality data and thus does not address changes after mid-2007.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"second lancet mortality study 2006\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"first lancet mortality study 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"study\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"undp iraq living conditions survey 2004\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"global policy forum\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1033, "completion_tokens": 334, "total_tokens": 1367, "reasoning_tokens": 284 }, "cost_usd": 0.00192465, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990108Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.9, "quality_rationale": "Peer-reviewed article in International Security (top journal from Belfer Center/Harvard) using declassified local violence data and 70 structured interviews with participants; meets criteria for reputable primary-sourced study rather than secondary journalism or advocacy.", "directness": 1.0, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.9, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Peer-reviewed article in International Security (top journal from Belfer Center/Harvard) using declassified local violence data and 70 structured interviews with participants; meets criteria for reputable primary-sourced study rather than secondary journalism or advocacy.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 1.0, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly tests the surge's causal contribution to the 2007-2008 violence drop relative to the Awakening and sectarian cleansing using local violence data and interviews.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.8, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document's data-driven assessment concludes that a synergistic surge-Awakening interaction was required for the observed rapid decline, with neither sufficient alone and little support for Awakening or cleansing theses in isolation.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"dataset\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"sigacts\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"coalition participant interviews\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3078, "completion_tokens": 3407, "total_tokens": 6485, "reasoning_tokens": 3205 }, "cost_usd": 0.01481512, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990192Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary compilation relying on secondary citations rather than primary records or peer review; publisher maintains editorial policies but no formal academic standards or original sourcing.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary compilation relying on secondary citations rather than primary records or peer review; publisher maintains editorial policies but no formal academic standards or original sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt notes the 2007 surge helped stabilize the country but does not report or test data on civilian deaths or attack levels in the specified intervals.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt notes stabilization from the 2007 surge but gives no information on civilian deaths or attack levels in the specified periods.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3478, "completion_tokens": 1886, "total_tokens": 5364, "reasoning_tokens": 1716 }, "cost_usd": 0.0074128499999999995, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990257Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.5, "quality_rationale": "Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary compilation relying on secondary citations rather than primary records or peer review; publisher maintains editorial policies but no formal academic standards or original sourcing.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.5, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Wikipedia is a collaboratively edited tertiary compilation relying on secondary citations rather than primary records or peer review; publisher maintains editorial policies but no formal academic standards or original sourcing.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt notes the 2007 surge helped stabilize parts of Iraq but does not address the specific causal claim or compare it to the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt notes the surge helped stabilize parts of Iraq but does not address the decline in violence or compare the surge's effects to those of the Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, or sectarian displacement.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"wikipedia\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3534, "completion_tokens": 1876, "total_tokens": 5410, "reasoning_tokens": 1683 }, "cost_usd": 0.00765945, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990326Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Official US Army website publishing an American Forces Press Service article that directly quotes a named brigade commander providing unit-level operational statistics and observations; constitutes reputable official reporting with primary sourcing but lacks independent verification or peer review.", "directness": 0.4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.3, "basis": "mixed", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "american forces press service" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "col jb burton 2nd brigade combat team 1st infantry division" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Official US Army website publishing an American Forces Press Service article that directly quotes a named brigade commander providing unit-level operational statistics and observations; constitutes reputable official reporting with primary sourcing but lacks independent verification or peer review.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.4, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports early 2007 Baghdad violence drops from new outpost tactics but does not isolate surge effects from Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire or displacement nor cover the full 2007-2008 period.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\n \\\"direction\\\": 1,\\n \\\"strength\\\": 0.3,\\n \\\"basis\\\": \\\"mixed\\\",\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Reports early 2007 violence drops in one Baghdad sector and attributes them to new outpost tactics plus Iraqi cooperation, but covers only initial months, one locale, and makes no reference to other factors named in the sub-claim.\\\"\\n}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"american forces press service\\\"\\n },\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"col jb burton 2nd brigade combat team 1st infantry division\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3416, "completion_tokens": 2273, "total_tokens": 5689, "reasoning_tokens": 2017 }, "cost_usd": 0.00866586, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990396Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Secondary compilation from globalsecurity.org that directly cites and summarizes official MNF-I SIGACTS reports, DOD assessments, and UN data with explicit methodology notes on attack definitions and counting. Not a primary record or peer-reviewed study but reputable sourcing of official records rather than ordinary journalism.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "mnf i significant activity reports" }, { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, { "type": "study", "id": "un april 2008 report" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Secondary compilation from globalsecurity.org that directly cites and summarizes official MNF-I SIGACTS reports, DOD assessments, and UN data with explicit methodology notes on attack definitions and counting. Not a primary record or peer-reviewed study but reputable sourcing of official records rather than ordinary journalism.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document directly reports substantial drop in overall enemy-initiated attacks (including on civilians) from June 2007 levels back to 2006/early-2007 highs, through Feb 2008, though it omits civilian deaths and extends only partially into mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports MNF-I SIGACTS data showing enemy-initiated attacks (including on civilians) fell ~70% from June 2007 levels through Feb 2008, a substantial drop from 2006/early-2007 highs, with only partial rebound by March 2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"mnf i significant activity reports\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"dod march 2008 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un april 2008 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3558, "completion_tokens": 3100, "total_tokens": 6658, "reasoning_tokens": 2824 }, "cost_usd": 0.01303459, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990457Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Secondary compilation from globalsecurity.org that directly cites and summarizes official MNF-I SIGACTS reports, DOD assessments, and UN data with explicit methodology notes on attack definitions and counting. Not a primary record or peer-reviewed study but reputable sourcing of official records rather than ordinary journalism.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "mnf i significant activity reports" }, { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, { "type": "study", "id": "un april 2008 report" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Secondary compilation from globalsecurity.org that directly cites and summarizes official MNF-I SIGACTS reports, DOD assessments, and UN data with explicit methodology notes on attack definitions and counting. Not a primary record or peer-reviewed study but reputable sourcing of official records rather than ordinary journalism.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document directly reports substantial drop in overall enemy-initiated attacks (including on civilians) from June 2007 levels back to 2006/early-2007 highs, through Feb 2008, though it omits civilian deaths and extends only partially into mid-2008.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.7, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"finding\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Document reports ~70% drop in enemy-initiated attacks from June 2007 to Feb 2008 (180/day to ~50/day) vs. 2006/early-2007 highs, with no Ramadan spike, directly showing substantial decline in attacks through early 2008.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\":[{\\\"type\\\":\\\"primary_source\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"mnf i significant activity reports\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"dod march 2008 report\\\"},{\\\"type\\\":\\\"study\\\",\\\"id\\\":\\\"un april 2008 report\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1030, "completion_tokens": 607, "total_tokens": 1637, "reasoning_tokens": 524 }, "cost_usd": 0.0026034, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990457Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "Human Rights Watch World Reports are secondary compilations by a reputable NGO with editorial standards and a track record of citing official records and field interviews; the excerpt references US military statements on detainee numbers but offers no primary data collection on violence metrics or force posture.", "directness": 0.2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "human rights watch" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "unhcr iom" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "us military" }, { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraqi government" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\\"quality\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Human Rights Watch World Reports are secondary compilations by a reputable NGO with editorial standards and a track record of citing official records and field interviews; the excerpt references US military statements on detainee numbers but offers no primary data collection on violence metrics or force posture.\\\"}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.2, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"Mentions unspecified 'security gains in 2008' as background but reports no data on civilian deaths or attack levels in the stated period.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 0, \\\"strength\\\": 0, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The excerpt notes unspecified 'security gains in 2008' and a drop in US-held detainees from late-2007 peaks but offers no data or observations on civilian deaths or attack rates.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\\"roots\\\": [{\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"human rights watch\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"unhcr iom\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"us military\\\"}, {\\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\", \\\"id\\\": \\\"iraqi government\\\"}]}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3392, "completion_tokens": 3649, "total_tokens": 7041, "reasoning_tokens": 3670 }, "cost_usd": 0.0155711, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990588Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "CSIS is a reputable nonpartisan think tank whose security analyses typically draw on official US military and Iraqi government records plus named field sources; the document is secondary analytical reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary data release.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": false, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CSIS is a reputable nonpartisan think tank whose security analyses typically draw on official US military and Iraqi government records plus named field sources; the document is secondary analytical reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary data release.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly examines the effects of the 2007 US troop buildup and posture changes on violence levels in Anbar and Baghdad while noting tribal alliances, but does not isolate those effects from the Awakening or other listed factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": 1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.4, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The 2007 report directly links the US troop buildup and posture changes to decreased violence in Anbar and improved Baghdad security, while treating tribal alliances as a related but distinct factor.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"csis\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 3388, "completion_tokens": 1733, "total_tokens": 5121, "reasoning_tokens": 1520 }, "cost_usd": 0.0076069, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990647Z" }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "quality_v1+directness_v1+direction_v2+roots_v1", "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "quality": 0.7, "quality_rationale": "CSIS is a reputable nonpartisan think tank whose security analyses typically draw on official US military and Iraqi government records plus named field sources; the document is secondary analytical reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary data release.", "directness": 0.7, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "roots": [ { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" } ], "roots_model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813", "flipped": true, "raw_response": "{\"quality\": \"{\\n \\\"quality\\\": 0.7,\\n \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"CSIS is a reputable nonpartisan think tank whose security analyses typically draw on official US military and Iraqi government records plus named field sources; the document is secondary analytical reporting rather than a peer-reviewed study or primary data release.\\\"\\n}\", \"directness\": \"{\\\"directness\\\": 0.7, \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The document directly examines the effects of the 2007 US troop buildup and posture changes on violence levels in Anbar and Baghdad while noting tribal alliances, but does not isolate those effects from the Awakening or other listed factors.\\\"}\", \"direction\": \"{\\\"direction\\\": -1, \\\"strength\\\": 0.6, \\\"basis\\\": \\\"assertion\\\", \\\"rationale\\\": \\\"The report links the 2007 US troop buildup and operations like Phantom Thunder to decreased violence in Anbar, damage to insurgents, and improved Baghdad security, while treating tribal resentment as a separate but complementary factor.\\\"}\", \"roots\": \"{\\n \\\"roots\\\": [\\n {\\n \\\"type\\\": \\\"primary_source\\\",\\n \\\"id\\\": \\\"csis\\\"\\n }\\n ]\\n}\"}", "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 1028, "completion_tokens": 641, "total_tokens": 1669, "reasoning_tokens": 573 }, "cost_usd": 0.0026859, "params_hash": "561a1a429326a491", "created_at": "2026-09-17T03:56:57.990647Z" } ], "runs": [ { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "leaf_results": [ { "leaf_id": "outcome", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": 4.474990985331952, "probability": 0.98873795356283, "evidence_mass": 4.29, "mass_for": 3.3185, "mass_against": 0.0, "mass_mixed": 0.4226249999999999, "contested_shrink": 0.8870326439239534, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.06290018337689207, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0, "clusters": [ { "id": "outcome:c1", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c2", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" }, "member_item_ids": [ "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "international mission for iraqi elections" }, "member_item_ids": [ "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c4", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "congressional research service" }, "member_item_ids": [ "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "gen david petraeus testimony september 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" }, "member_item_ids": [ "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c9", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "human rights watch" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c11", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, "member_item_ids": [ "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c12", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 1.26, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.85, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.595, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.22049999999999997, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.03125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 6, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.055999999999999994, "independence": 0.015625, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.0078125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 8, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.8819999999999999, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.8819999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.75, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.7349999999999999, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.3429999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.2744, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "cause", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": 2.042815666085854, "probability": 0.8852196664367101, "evidence_mass": 3.3964999999999996, "mass_for": 2.233, "mass_against": 0.17149999999999996, "mass_mixed": 0.7520000000000001, "contested_shrink": 0.7617614446380484, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.08487501099896066, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0, "clusters": [ { "id": "cause:c1", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" }, "member_item_ids": [ "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0" ] }, { "id": "cause:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1" ] }, { "id": "cause:c3", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7" ] }, { "id": "cause:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "american forces press service" }, "member_item_ids": [ "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e" ] }, { "id": "cause:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" }, "member_item_ids": [ "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba" ] }, { "id": "cause:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense report to congress june 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b" ] }, { "id": "cause:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e" ] }, { "id": "cause:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "pritzkermilitary org" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9" ] }, { "id": "cause:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "small wars journal 2013" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8" ] }, { "id": "cause:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bob woodward the war within 2008" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7" ] }, { "id": "cause:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768" ] }, { "id": "cause:c12", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "icasualties" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6" ] }, { "id": "cause:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.8819999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.3429999999999999, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "cause:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": -0.24009999999999992, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.44099999999999995, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.6173999999999998, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.3429999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.4115999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.3429999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.4115999999999999, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.23519999999999996, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.16799999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] } ], "node_results": [ { "node_id": "root", "probability": 0.8752502814462038, "from_children": [ "outcome", "cause" ] } ], "verdict": { "label": "supported", "probability": 0.8752502814462038, "log_odds": 1.9482004028483637, "evidence_mass": 3.3964999999999996, "insufficient": false, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null }, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "cache_hits": 0 }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "leaf_results": [ { "leaf_id": "outcome", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": 6.71673, "probability": 0.9987909734629443, "evidence_mass": 4.35475, "mass_for": 4.02025, "mass_against": 0.0, "mass_mixed": 0.0, "contested_shrink": 1.0, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.00793670678272429, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0, "clusters": [ { "id": "outcome:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c2", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" }, "member_item_ids": [ "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "congressional research service" }, "member_item_ids": [ "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "international mission for iraqi elections" }, "member_item_ids": [ "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c5", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "gen david petraeus testimony september 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" }, "member_item_ids": [ "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "human rights watch" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c10", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c11", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c12", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, "member_item_ids": [ "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.94, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 1.1844, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.504, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.252, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": true }, { "item_id": "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.07875, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.3, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.010499999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 0.03125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 6, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0018000000000000004, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": true }, { "item_id": "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 0.015625, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 0.0078125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 8, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 1.1340000000000001, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.8819999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 1.1340000000000001, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.86, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.8427999999999999, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": true }, { "item_id": "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.74, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.29007999999999995, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.2744, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.12800000000000003, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "cause", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": 2.1540303782148253, "probability": 0.8960448003346582, "evidence_mass": 2.7239999999999998, "mass_for": 2.1139999999999994, "mass_against": 0.278, "mass_mixed": 0.252, "contested_shrink": 0.9046898638426626, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.09297289260692887, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0, "clusters": [ { "id": "cause:c1", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" }, "member_item_ids": [ "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0" ] }, { "id": "cause:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1" ] }, { "id": "cause:c3", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7" ] }, { "id": "cause:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense report to congress june 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b" ] }, { "id": "cause:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "american forces press service" }, "member_item_ids": [ "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e" ] }, { "id": "cause:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" }, "member_item_ids": [ "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba" ] }, { "id": "cause:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "small wars journal 2013" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8" ] }, { "id": "cause:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768" ] }, { "id": "cause:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "pritzkermilitary org" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9" ] }, { "id": "cause:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e" ] }, { "id": "cause:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3" ] }, { "id": "cause:c12", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "icasualties" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6" ] }, { "id": "cause:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bob woodward the war within 2008" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.44099999999999995, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.86, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.7585199999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "cause:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.1568, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.44099999999999995, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.7938, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.55, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.21559999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.3, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.11759999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.62, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.24303999999999998, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.18000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.28800000000000003, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.35, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.09799999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.84, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.23519999999999996, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.16799999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.46, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.1288, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.08399999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0672, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] } ], "node_results": [ { "node_id": "root", "probability": 0.8949614583926628, "from_children": [ "outcome", "cause" ] } ], "verdict": { "label": "supported", "probability": 0.8949614583926628, "log_odds": 2.142453308365757, "evidence_mass": 2.7239999999999998, "insufficient": false, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null }, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "cache_hits": 0 }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "leaf_results": [ { "leaf_id": "outcome", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": 3.407046534901175, "probability": 0.9679240326009713, "evidence_mass": 4.7094375, "mass_for": 2.7549999999999994, "mass_against": 0.0, "mass_mixed": 1.242, "contested_shrink": 0.6892669502126594, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.10001999916475102, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0, "clusters": [ { "id": "outcome:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "international mission for iraqi elections" }, "member_item_ids": [ "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "congressional research service" }, "member_item_ids": [ "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "gen david petraeus testimony september 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c5", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c6", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" }, "member_item_ids": [ "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" }, "member_item_ids": [ "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "human rights watch" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c10", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c11", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c12", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, "member_item_ids": [ "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.7, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 1.26, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.315, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.126, "independence": 0.03125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 6, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.015625, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.0078125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 8, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 1.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 1.8, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.7839999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.7839999999999999, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": true }, { "item_id": "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.08399999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "cause", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": 1.9542965419232587, "probability": 0.8759143807272803, "evidence_mass": 4.426, "mass_for": 2.69, "mass_against": 1.02, "mass_mixed": 0.512, "contested_shrink": 0.8787304594978682, "one_sided": false, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.25089481831972993, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0, "clusters": [ { "id": "cause:c1", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" }, "member_item_ids": [ "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad" ] }, { "id": "cause:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1" ] }, { "id": "cause:c3", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "american forces press service" }, "member_item_ids": [ "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e" ] }, { "id": "cause:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" }, "member_item_ids": [ "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba" ] }, { "id": "cause:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e" ] }, { "id": "cause:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense report to congress june 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b" ] }, { "id": "cause:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768" ] }, { "id": "cause:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "pritzkermilitary org" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9" ] }, { "id": "cause:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "small wars journal 2013" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8" ] }, { "id": "cause:c10", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "icasualties" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6" ] }, { "id": "cause:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3" ] }, { "id": "cause:c12", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7" ] }, { "id": "cause:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bob woodward the war within 2008" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -1.62, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "cause:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.81, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.9, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 1.62, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.48999999999999994, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.5879999999999999, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": true }, { "item_id": "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.44799999999999995, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.12, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.12, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.192, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.08399999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.08000000000000002, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.07200000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.048, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] } ], "node_results": [ { "node_id": "root", "probability": 0.8478185796067317, "from_children": [ "outcome", "cause" ] } ], "verdict": { "label": "leans_supported", "probability": 0.8478185796067317, "log_odds": 1.717593309416276, "evidence_mass": 4.426, "insufficient": false, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null }, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "cache_hits": 0 }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "leaf_results": [ { "leaf_id": "outcome", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": 1.5957335176520628, "probability": 0.8314212404028586, "evidence_mass": 3.9445625, "mass_for": 2.0685, "mass_against": 0.0, "mass_mixed": 1.458, "contested_shrink": 0.5865589111016588, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.1927319305845574, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0, "clusters": [ { "id": "outcome:c1", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "international mission for iraqi elections" }, "member_item_ids": [ "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c3", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "congressional research service" }, "member_item_ids": [ "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c5", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" }, "member_item_ids": [ "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" }, "member_item_ids": [ "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "gen david petraeus testimony september 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c9", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "human rights watch" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c12", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c13", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, "member_item_ids": [ "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.5599999999999999, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.39199999999999996, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.12249999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.27999999999999997, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.12800000000000003, "independence": 0.03125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 6, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 0.015625, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 0.0078125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 8, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 1.4400000000000002, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.48999999999999994, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.32400000000000007, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.252, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.08000000000000002, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.055999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "cause", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": 1.525238862559242, "probability": 0.8213086346826968, "evidence_mass": 3.501, "mass_for": 2.0199999999999996, "mass_against": 0.645, "mass_mixed": 0.5, "contested_shrink": 0.8420221169036335, "one_sided": false, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.15620050242307582, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0, "clusters": [ { "id": "cause:c1", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" }, "member_item_ids": [ "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0" ] }, { "id": "cause:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1" ] }, { "id": "cause:c3", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7" ] }, { "id": "cause:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "small wars journal 2013" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8" ] }, { "id": "cause:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "american forces press service" }, "member_item_ids": [ "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e" ] }, { "id": "cause:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense report to congress june 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b" ] }, { "id": "cause:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" }, "member_item_ids": [ "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba" ] }, { "id": "cause:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "pritzkermilitary org" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9" ] }, { "id": "cause:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e" ] }, { "id": "cause:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768" ] }, { "id": "cause:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bob woodward the war within 2008" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7" ] }, { "id": "cause:c12", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3" ] }, { "id": "cause:c13", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "icasualties" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 1.4400000000000002, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.81, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "cause:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.567, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.5599999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.75, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.8399999999999999, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": true }, { "item_id": "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.24, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.288, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.1568, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.05760000000000001, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.5, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.13999999999999999, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.2, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.03200000000000001, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.03200000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] } ], "node_results": [ { "node_id": "root", "probability": 0.682853443801466, "from_children": [ "outcome", "cause" ] } ], "verdict": { "label": "leans_supported", "probability": 0.682853443801466, "log_odds": 0.7669162699563115, "evidence_mass": 3.501, "insufficient": false, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null }, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "cache_hits": 0 }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "leaf_results": [ { "leaf_id": "outcome", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": 2.012760487364621, "probability": 0.8821303506262447, "evidence_mass": 3.10275, "mass_for": 1.9815, "mass_against": 0.0, "mass_mixed": 0.7885, "contested_shrink": 0.7153429602888087, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.12438177775706649, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0, "clusters": [ { "id": "outcome:c1", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "international mission for iraqi elections" }, "member_item_ids": [ "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c3", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "dod march 2008 report" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c4", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "brookings iraq index" }, "member_item_ids": [ "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "congressional research service" }, "member_item_ids": [ "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" }, "member_item_ids": [ "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "gen david petraeus testimony september 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c9", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2006" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "human rights watch" }, "member_item_ids": [ "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense" }, "member_item_ids": [ "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c12", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9" ] }, { "id": "outcome:c13", "root": { "type": "study", "id": "lancet 2004 iraq mortality survey" }, "member_item_ids": [ "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.6859999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "5badad2f95e6f1745aedcd966c4db6ad9d3759291659e2ccfb12f83cf7ef1fa0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.35, "independence": 0.25, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 3, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.12249999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 0.125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 4, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.055999999999999994, "independence": 0.0625, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 5, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "96b4567f5be6e768370876acf49cae9688df378fee7bbd9beab29f80e427503c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 0.03125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 6, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.015625, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 7, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.0078125, "cluster_id": "outcome:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 8, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 1.008, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ed73525bcc874b3e724e63ff9c1770b3b872f91768fad59782c487cd1a34dce2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.48999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 0.6859999999999998, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.22399999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.7, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.19599999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.11520000000000002, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.11199999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c6ffdc09ec5aa3e88f5f0bc2c02fc3a120584ea9de0dbb9ef2e4b2c41c33d571", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "cd42f04e3d4331badc83b6030f9c94c99858d178a7897d58ef317404870755d8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "outcome:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "f7af1b900ae103370d4724c30da245a03c34b5f8cd06a213a81c41480034eb2f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.055999999999999994, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "9ed08747945d948dd6e16d6f1c190ee0a32bea12a07f90dce9fe6e891e228a07", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "1dfefe2afd3a8487db6dbe8c2a6a46080e8b8169add5d27c9d455e6de41297a9", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": "outcome", "weight": 0.0, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "outcome:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false } ] }, { "leaf_id": "cause", "prior": 0.5, "log_odds": 1.9826286059872997, "probability": 0.8789610942178301, "evidence_mass": 3.6910000000000003, "mass_for": 2.192, "mass_against": 0.47500000000000003, "mass_mixed": 0.64, "contested_shrink": 0.8064711218627154, "one_sided": true, "insufficient": false, "leave_one_cluster_out_spread": 0.20030197987459997, "leave_one_backend_out_spread": 0.0, "clusters": [ { "id": "cause:c1", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "sigact" }, "member_item_ids": [ "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0" ] }, { "id": "cause:c2", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "coalition participant interviews" }, "member_item_ids": [ "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1" ] }, { "id": "cause:c3", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "iraq body count" }, "member_item_ids": [ "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7" ] }, { "id": "cause:c4", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "american forces press service" }, "member_item_ids": [ "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e" ] }, { "id": "cause:c5", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "csis" }, "member_item_ids": [ "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba" ] }, { "id": "cause:c6", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "small wars journal 2013" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8" ] }, { "id": "cause:c7", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "department of defense report to congress june 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b" ] }, { "id": "cause:c8", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "george w bush 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768" ] }, { "id": "cause:c9", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "report to congress on the situation in iraq 2007" }, "member_item_ids": [ "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e" ] }, { "id": "cause:c10", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "pritzkermilitary org" }, "member_item_ids": [ "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9" ] }, { "id": "cause:c11", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "wikipedia" }, "member_item_ids": [ "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3" ] }, { "id": "cause:c12", "root": { "type": "dataset", "id": "icasualties" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6" ] }, { "id": "cause:c13", "root": { "type": "primary_source", "id": "bob woodward the war within 2008" }, "member_item_ids": [ "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7" ] } ], "items": [ { "item_id": "cf5a355adaa2a5c6a00b104a0a8e8421bbe02b00dc437664c60e604fc54558ad", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 1.4400000000000002, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "b206f96b7badc7a604223cce3e4a3404d0de70f224fb518da8365f6106679db0", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.63, "independence": 0.5, "cluster_id": "cause:c1", "rank_in_cluster": 2, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": -0.504, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "c8e275a49a90c3fc9fc342fe17fc271883e2ce4399897ae77e9a56dc4f2096a1", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.9, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c2", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.8, "basis": "finding", "basis_factor": 1.0, "llr": 1.4400000000000002, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "306ab6a1804a4540e8a5b29ee608f303ae44e363359a09edd005eb64706906e7", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.36000000000000004, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c3", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "e7b5f1f942ec420ea7c991f0b525dd3c92466a149728b4c2a8bf84053b23b31e", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c4", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.3, "basis": "mixed", "basis_factor": 0.7, "llr": 0.11759999999999998, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "fc18a4fcc834b424cee6311c86743e0b319698b8b7eb6dcdca2b257cbe3775ba", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.19599999999999998, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c5", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 1, "strength": 0.4, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.1568, "polarity_checked": true, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.16000000000000003, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c6", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": -1, "strength": 0.6, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": -0.19200000000000003, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.14400000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c7", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "2a675dd173f8eb4a5bbe60f2ccd8c9c602c848af59879fb3d0853bb0c4a01768", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c8", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.13999999999999999, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c9", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c10", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "d4060f3ea9a9f41a680fc0c2f3ba292676b040f90d3faf08e73b75200c0982a3", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.08000000000000002, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c11", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4969b49f44ad4fe0276eae942b2f847049310a0167c2a0c44444d038d1d6d8b6", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c12", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false }, { "item_id": "4e527b77d75cd844a873ee5bd4b2555265db40548e9a0485881fcfc8294fbfb7", "leaf_id": "cause", "weight": 0.04000000000000001, "independence": 1.0, "cluster_id": "cause:c13", "rank_in_cluster": 1, "direction": 0, "strength": 0.0, "basis": "assertion", "basis_factor": 0.4, "llr": 0.0, "polarity_checked": false, "inconsistent": false } ] } ], "node_results": [ { "node_id": "root", "probability": 0.7753582582292021, "from_children": [ "outcome", "cause" ] } ], "verdict": { "label": "leans_supported", "probability": 0.7753582582292021, "log_odds": 1.238818316806229, "evidence_mass": 3.10275, "insufficient": false, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null }, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "cache_hits": 0 } ], "comparison": { "models": [ "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "x-ai/grok-4.3" ], "per_model": [ { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "label": "supported", "probability": 0.8752502814462038, "log_odds": 1.9482004028483637, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "judgments": 36, "items_scored": 35, "polarity_checked": 10, "polarity_inconsistent": 0, "polarity_rate": 0.0 }, { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "label": "supported", "probability": 0.8949614583926628, "log_odds": 2.142453308365757, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "judgments": 36, "items_scored": 35, "polarity_checked": 10, "polarity_inconsistent": 3, "polarity_rate": 0.3 }, { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "label": "leans_supported", "probability": 0.8478185796067317, "log_odds": 1.717593309416276, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "judgments": 36, "items_scored": 35, "polarity_checked": 10, "polarity_inconsistent": 2, "polarity_rate": 0.2 }, { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "label": "leans_supported", "probability": 0.682853443801466, "log_odds": 0.7669162699563115, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "judgments": 36, "items_scored": 35, "polarity_checked": 10, "polarity_inconsistent": 1, "polarity_rate": 0.1 }, { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "label": "leans_supported", "probability": 0.7753582582292021, "log_odds": 1.238818316806229, "cost_usd": 0.0, "api_calls": 0, "judgments": 36, "items_scored": 35, "polarity_checked": 10, "polarity_inconsistent": 0, "polarity_rate": 0.0 } ], "leaves": [ { "leaf_id": "outcome", "log_odds": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 4.474990985331952, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 6.71673, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 3.407046534901175, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 1.5957335176520628, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 2.012760487364621 }, "probability": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.98873795356283, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.9987909734629443, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9679240326009713, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.8314212404028586, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.8821303506262447 }, "evidence_mass": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 4.29, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 4.35475, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 4.7094375, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 3.9445625, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 3.10275 }, "spread": 5.1209964823479375, "mean_pairwise_disagreement": 2.540844692532641, "consensus_log_odds": 3.407046534901175, "consensus_probability": 0.9679240326009713, "consensus_mass": 4.29, "consensus_insufficient": false }, { "leaf_id": "cause", "log_odds": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 2.042815666085854, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 2.1540303782148253, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 1.9542965419232587, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 1.525238862559242, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 1.9826286059872997 }, "probability": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.8852196664367101, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.8960448003346582, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.8759143807272803, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.8213086346826968, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.8789610942178301 }, "evidence_mass": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 3.3964999999999996, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 2.7239999999999998, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 4.426, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 3.501, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 3.6910000000000003 }, "spread": 0.6287915156555834, "mean_pairwise_disagreement": 0.26922043109475247, "consensus_log_odds": 1.9826286059872997, "consensus_probability": 0.8789610942178301, "consensus_mass": 3.501, "consensus_insufficient": false } ], "mean_pairwise_disagreement": 1.4050325618136967, "max_spread_leaf": "outcome", "labels_agree": false, "coverage_complete": true, "quality_disagreements": [ { "item_id": "8373a4b06f3d7fca0a1a6d5975b1b32ec1745ce6c3e6a2a5830157d96cd98921", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.9, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.5, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.5, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.5, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.5 }, "spread": 0.4 }, { "item_id": "b06ab3f87b13282053f8050ef962ce5cb90df4578e76dbc30e523a25fd2e7ffb", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.9, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.5, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.9, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.7 }, "spread": 0.4 }, { "item_id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.5, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.5, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.3, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.6, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.4 }, "spread": 0.3 }, { "item_id": "07c31dbd135c66fd331c116e22d423185c5ecfce3da4f936c188bbe880d587e2", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.9, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.7, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.8, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.7 }, "spread": 0.20000000000000007 }, { "item_id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.9, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.7, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.7, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.7 }, "spread": 0.20000000000000007 }, { "item_id": "4f5a5eee3e38a3107a85b97c576e092d77e9ed0839a87ec4b6492454c62e1155", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.9, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.8, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.7 }, "spread": 0.20000000000000007 }, { "item_id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.9, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.9, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.8 }, "spread": 0.20000000000000007 }, { "item_id": "72d0d56c6efc774203ab302266cfaed1cf6eb05effcb8fcbfa75c66ec4f9a51b", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.9, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.7, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.9, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.9 }, "spread": 0.20000000000000007 }, { "item_id": "8c448b3e9c7d4d98ddc7f1977eccff5248508c4bb43cf44566d13056668a93d7", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.7, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.7, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.7 }, "spread": 0.20000000000000007 }, { "item_id": "91332142b5846b13bde2a7d2535f577f09a2c5e25e74888f339ae8668932bf95", "leaf_id": null, "kind": "quality", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.9, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.9, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.9, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.9 }, "spread": 0.20000000000000007 } ], "direction_disagreements": [ { "item_id": "4838d5ad76d7e44418c38a419abec7cc76c8210460d90dd160cb53a50e6459c8", "leaf_id": "cause", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": -0.8, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": -0.8, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": -0.6, "x-ai/grok-4.3": -0.6 }, "spread": 1.5 }, { "item_id": "453db8432a1dc6b2dcb5f1136b26784b12a0728357e41816465369c89fc7120e", "leaf_id": "outcome", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.9, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.0, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.0, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.0 }, "spread": 0.9 }, { "item_id": "3b44fc3554cedccf1ff07e6328401f4212a172c890fc32c4c1037755b33df9b9", "leaf_id": "cause", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.6, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.84, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.0, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.0, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.0 }, "spread": 0.84 }, { "item_id": "18fb3de114f7a1445668964b3eb4d8f11395735044f857f1730e70b487b0444f", "leaf_id": "outcome", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.0, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.8, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.0, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.0, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.0 }, "spread": 0.8 }, { "item_id": "6847b9398aa537c96987e0cced2d9693934fed89facf21cfd618b01d133e33f2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.8, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.0, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.0, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.0 }, "spread": 0.8 }, { "item_id": "7503260ba46161950688473ec0083edb5aa055731228a8c1d647bdc0a78e259c", "leaf_id": "outcome", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.74, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.8, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.5, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.0 }, "spread": 0.8 }, { "item_id": "a51397ba668a7264d2099a442d58570e1f7d5c69064ab8366c55bc9f18f972d0", "leaf_id": "outcome", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.7, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.8, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.0, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.5, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.7 }, "spread": 0.8 }, { "item_id": "ba1039d8698b31217df9b7bb6ea7be8d9e76f3f8b62362647e2eecfec4fef69e", "leaf_id": "cause", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.6, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.6, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.8, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.5, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.0 }, "spread": 0.8 }, { "item_id": "57d745eb6959b23af4903972b137b6de42fc8c30453e16ce26ab9b8130c620c8", "leaf_id": "outcome", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.0, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.7, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.0, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.0, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.0 }, "spread": 0.7 }, { "item_id": "957fe97acdea5459501d614d796783189a081102b076e38805583cd1755bfeb2", "leaf_id": "outcome", "kind": "direction", "values": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": 0.0, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": 0.7, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": 0.0, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": 0.0, "x-ai/grok-4.3": 0.4 }, "spread": 0.7 } ], "consensus_nodes": [ { "node_id": "root", "probability": 0.8507675668146844, "from_children": [ "outcome", "cause" ] } ], "consensus_verdict": { "label": "supported", "probability": 0.8507675668146844, "log_odds": 1.7406339170447165, "evidence_mass": 3.501, "insufficient": false, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null } }, "baseline": { "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5": { "model_id": "anthropic/claude-haiku-4.5", "prompt_version": "baseline_v1", "probability": 0.45, "leaves": { "outcome": 0.85, "cause": 0.5 }, "rationale": "The outcome is well-documented: violence did decline substantially from 2007-2008 compared to 2006-2007 levels. However, the causal claim remains contested among scholars and analysts; while the surge likely contributed, isolating its effect from concurrent factors (Anbar Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, sectarian sorting) is methodologically difficult, and many experts attribute significant weight to these alternative explanations.", "cached": false, "cost_usd": 0.001005 }, "openai/gpt-5.4-mini": { "model_id": "openai/gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_version": "baseline_v1", "probability": 0.95, "leaves": { "outcome": 0.99, "cause": 0.9 }, "rationale": "Civilian deaths and attacks in Iraq did fall sharply from 2006/early-2007 to mid-2008. The surge, together with new counterinsurgency tactics, was a major contributor to that decline, though it was not the only cause and other factors like the Anbar Awakening and the Sadrist ceasefire also mattered.", "cached": false, "cost_usd": 0.00066075 }, "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite": { "model_id": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "prompt_version": "baseline_v1", "probability": 0.75, "leaves": { "outcome": 0.99, "cause": 0.75 }, "rationale": "There is overwhelming consensus that violence fell dramatically in Iraq between 2007 and 2008, though historians and analysts vigorously debate the exact degree to which the US troop surge caused this decline versus concurrent local factors like the Anbar Awakening.", "cached": false, "cost_usd": 0.0002937 }, "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash": { "model_id": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "prompt_version": "baseline_v1", "probability": 0.75, "leaves": { "outcome": 0.97, "cause": 0.7 }, "rationale": "The outcome is well-documented: violence in Iraq fell sharply from mid-2007 to mid-2008. The causal attribution is more contested, since the surge coincided with the Anbar Awakening, the Sadrist ceasefire, and sectarian displacement, though most analysts credit the surge and changed tactics with a substantial independent role.", "cached": false, "cost_usd": 0.00016176 }, "x-ai/grok-4.3": { "model_id": "x-ai/grok-4.3", "prompt_version": "baseline_v1", "probability": 0.68, "leaves": { "outcome": 0.9, "cause": 0.6 }, "rationale": "Violence indicators show a clear drop after mid-2007, but the surge's independent causal contribution beyond the Awakening, Sadrist ceasefire, and completed ethnic cleansing is contested in the historical literature.", "cached": false, "cost_usd": 0.0018084 } }, "refused": false, "refusal_reason": null, "created_at": "2026-09-17T05:13:22.557936Z", "git_sha": "unknown" }